r/OpenChristian • • 40m ago

The abortion doctor who leads with her faith: ‘God is forgiving’

Thumbnail theguardian.com
10 Upvotes

r/OpenChristian • • 1h ago

Support Thread Prayers for my displaced family

5 Upvotes

Please pray for my cousin and his partner, Ernesto and Daniela. Their apartment burned down last night due to a neighbor’s patio fire. We know they are alive, but do not know their whereabouts at this time.

Please pray that they are safe and their immigration documents made it through the fire safely.


r/OpenChristian • • 12h ago Heartwarming

Discussion - LGBTQ+ Issues “Being gay isn’t a sin as long as you don’t act upon it” NSFW

39 Upvotes

Is the most ridiculous thing I’ve heard. Essentially you are saying that, that person has to go without love for the rest of their lives. I think it’s a way of that person trying to seem less homophobic and on your side but it just doesn’t work. It’s also rooted in the idea of being gay is a choice. Which I’m honestly sick of hearing. It’s a way to stay calloused and lack empathy for the LGBTQ community. It’s easier to abuse someone if their “choices” are sinful. It’s hard to admit that it’s not a sin because that would mean you’ve been abusing lgbtq people for nothing. And you are


r/OpenChristian • • 15h ago Regret

Support Thread TW: I had a stillbirth of a son I didn’t even know I had

35 Upvotes

Hi everyone. This is really traumatic and heartbreaking and I am still reeling.

We weren’t trying for a baby. But I had a cryptic pregnancy. I wasn’t showing, I had a period or periods during this, I had zero symptoms and any I did have other reasons I was having them that either coincidentally lined up perfectly or something? But then, Sunday, I was working my brand new job and work with my husband. I went to the bathroom with period cramps, and my water broke, it exploded everywhere.

Blood poured down my legs when I ran to tell him and I was rushed to the hospital where I gave birth in the hospital parking lot to my baby boy, who already passed away. We have been grieving awful. I mean, horrifically hard. If we knew he existed? We would’ve done anything. But the doctors said it wasn’t me, or my body at all. I just wish I knew my baby boy. But I didn’t even grow and I am not considered a big woman. But he was big enough he should’ve shown.

I struggle with a lot of issues. I’m very very religiously traumatized and so is my husband. For so long, even when we were teenagers I’ve had fears God would say I can’t be with him or take him away. And it comes from my parents when I was growing up took anything I felt safe with away— including my husband when we were teenagers. But honestly, it feels like God aligned everything perfect. Because everything fell through last minute, and then perfectly went together when I ran away. My husband was my safety net, he stayed with me every single day through my parents abusing me from 16-18 even though we were both young. He’s my best friend and even with us both being so religiously traumatized, we have spent so long working together to heal. We pray morning and night and we even finally went to church together after years of being afraid. God holds us so close and we both feel God around us.

I’m reeling from the loss of my son. I know that. So I’m terrified of losing my best friend too. It’s just scary. I don’t know if anyone can help. I also was crying a lot in the hospital. I don’t believe I stopped praying the whole night. But I was so scared I was going to die. And I was scared begging God because I didn’t want to leave my husband. I was so scared, I begged God and I know God held me so tightly during that. My husband did too. I always pray that God will help guide His love through us to each other. The only way I could sleep that night was my husband holding my hand and brushing my hair. He stayed up all night, even though we had gotten up so early, just caring for me in the er until they finally got me to labor and delivery and he knew I was safe.

I know God doesn’t control us. I know God gave us free will to love and with every day God forgives and reconciles with us so idk why my brain thinks if I mess up or my husband does we have to be separated and punished. My husband is so good to me and I am good to him, we barely fight and when we do it’s healthy and stable and we make up. We’ve of course made mistakes, we’ve hurt each other horribly before, but we have worked through it all. I don’t hold it and he doesn’t either. We pray for forgiveness and always for God to guide us to be the best to each other. He cares for me and I care for him. When we have issues we talk it out and we both go to a religious therapist. And that therapist said he believes God wants us to flourish and he even knowing our entire backstory every pain, our bad moments and good, he says we flourish together. And I can’t remember exact wording but that I’m my best self with him.

But I’m scared. I’m so scared. This trauma is awful. And losing my baby, of course I tossed and turned asking myself, is God punishing me? Did I deserve this? My heart is broken. But we are both leaning on God and each other so much.


r/OpenChristian • • 23h ago

Inspirational Just as Mary says: He has done great things through us and holy is His name.

Post image
97 Upvotes

r/OpenChristian • • 15h ago

Wednesday Meat Fasts have turned into Soup day 😍

Post image
19 Upvotes

I've been cooking my way through this book now that we are into soup season. Since I've returned back to the faith, I've been abstaining from meat on Wednesday and Friday each week. This book has helped tremendously as most of the recipes are meatless (some seafood). The most of the ones I have made are amazing! Except one beet soup which was low key horrid 😅

A pot of soup Wednesday night for my husband and I. And then it's my lunch the rest of the week too!


r/OpenChristian • • 11m ago

Discussion - Sex & Relationships Thoughs on polyamorous relationships?

1 Upvotes

IN Genesis there's actually Polyamorous relationships in Genesis, while It Was tollerate by God, though then ,in mosaic laws and second testment Is seen as a sin, personally, i don't really like the idea of sharing a relationships with a third weel.... though i don 't judged obviusly.... what's your thoughs about It? Is It a sin for you?


r/OpenChristian • • 20h ago

Is anyone else here bloody sick of hearing how Russell brand is soooo innocent, and the simps like Megan Kelly who defend his grimy behind??

34 Upvotes

Personally this is the final nail in the coffin for evangelicalism for me, I hate that CULT and NO I will NOT TAKE THAT BACK EVER!! Honestly Christianity itself seems like a crock right now too and I’m
Becoming agnostic more and more


r/OpenChristian • • 21h ago

Support Thread Christian men who would date a trans woman and not be a creep about it or best of both worlds, do you exist?

34 Upvotes

Hi, i am a christian and im pretty traditional other than being trans. im really lonely and trying to find a boyfriend. what sort of spaces do guys like that frequent? how do i attract them? do they exist?


r/OpenChristian • • 20h ago

Discussion - General Can I be a Christian if I don’t necessarily care if God is “real” or not?

25 Upvotes

For some context—I was raised Catholic, stepped away from religion, and now, seemingly out of the blue, I feel like I am being called back to God.

However, I feel as if my views on Christianity are different than most, and I’m not sure if they prevent me from becoming a “real Christian.”

The thing is, I don’t care much about whether God or Jesus is “real”, in the sense that, when I read the Bible (which I have slowly been starting to do), I feel like even if they don’t “exist” in the literal sense, choosing to believe in them is what makes them real. I still feel their presence regardless of whether the things that are written in the bible are “real” or not, and that, to me, is faith. The written word can be interpreted in so many different ways. Which makes one interpretation more true than another?

Like, I believe in science. I believe in evolution. I don’t believe the world was created in seven days, but I believe that when I read that story, literal or not, I still hold the core belief that God, in whatever way, created the world. And isn’t that enough?

Does that make sense at all? I don’t know. My relationship with religion is so complicated, and I’m not sure how to explore it or if it is even worth trying to find a church to attend if my views are, like, heretical. The most accurate depiction of how I am beginning to understand religion is closest to how John Green talks about his faith in his video “My Religion.”

Thoughts? Where do I go from here?


r/OpenChristian • • 18h ago

Discussion - LGBTQ+ Issues I'm really struggling to reconcile my beliefs about homosexuality with Christianity, and I'd love some advice.

15 Upvotes

I'm a 27-year-old girl who has been incredibly agnostic for pretty much my entire life, but, if I'm honest, I've always felt a real desperate longing to find God. I've spent years trying to find my way towards faith, exploring religion and trying to build some sort of connection with God, but I always seem to hit the same stumbling block.

I think one of the biggest things holding me back is the views on homosexuality within the Bible and within Christian communities.

For a little context, I have a lesbian mum and stepmum, as well as lesbian and bisexual friends. More than anything, I believe in equality, kindness and loving people for exactly who they are. I genuinely cannot get my head around the idea that someone's sexuality could make them any less deserving of love, acceptance or happiness.

Every time I start going down the rabbit hole of exploring Christianity, I inevitably come across discussions about homosexuality being a sin, and it leaves me feeling so disheartened. It really puts me off pursuing something that, deep down, I desperately want to believe in.

I just find myself thinking... surely an all-loving God wouldn't discriminate against anyone? Surely He wouldn't love someone any less, or condemn an otherwise good, kind-hearted person to hell simply because they happen to be gay? Doesn't that fundamentally contradict the idea of a God who is supposed to be the embodiment of unconditional love?

And something else I really struggle with is how difficult it seems to be to find Christians who are genuinely accepting of the LGBTQ+ community. I know they exist, but sometimes it feels like finding them is the exception rather than the rule. I'd love to understand why that is.

But then I come back to another question which I really can't get my head around. If the Bible genuinely does say that being gay is wrong or sinful, how can I become a Christian while disagreeing with that? How can I embrace the rest of the Bible but question or interpret certain passages differently because they don't align with my values? Is that even something you can do?

Does being a Christian mean believing and accepting every single thing in the Bible, without question? And if so, how do I reconcile that with something I feel so strongly about?

I suppose I'm just hoping to find a way to have faith without having to compromise on something that feels so fundamental to who I am and what I believe in, and more importantly I am not willing to be a part of something that ultimately says my mum and other people around me are any less than anyone else for their sexuality, let alone the suggestion they will go to hell!! My mum is a literal angel and I love her so much that I'm not willing to align myself with anything that rejects her existence (funnily enough she is a devout Christian herself and doesn't need the same kind of reassurance I guess I am looking for)


r/OpenChristian • • 18h ago

Discussion - Church & Spiritual Practices Going through OCIA and having to defend an impermissible prompt, is this normal?

12 Upvotes

I’m a college student looking at trying to enter the faith through the OCIA process, and as part of that class, I was instructed to write a short essay about 5 questions. Most of them are asking to answer basic questions about theology and clergy, and those I had no issue with, but then this prompt came up:

Question #4: Explain in no less than 100 words each the following:

  1. Why sex before and outside the confines of marriage is immoral.
  2. Why divorce is immoral.
  3. Why Marriage can only be between one man and one woman.
  4. Why contraception is immoral.
  5. Why trying to change your gender using science is wrong.
  6. Each response to the following five questions must be persuasive to a non-Christian
  7. audience. This means that all arguments from authority must be avoided. In this section,
  8. you need to be able to demonstrate the goodness of God’s moral law. For example, whenresponding to the question on divorce, you should not say: “Divorce is bad because God
  9. said it is bad.” Instead, you should say something like “divorce is bad because it has
  10. numerous negative consequences such as _______________________________.”

Bigotry of most church dogma aside these are just culture war points being asked here, and having to defend these disgusting viewpoints secularly is a fundamentally defunct idea. Especially as an ace Christian, I do not want to defend these points as they are blatantly harmful to countless individuals. To anyone who’s been in my shoes before, is this normal, and if so, how do I handle this?

Edit to rant: I’ve known quite a few people who went through the process at this parish, which means they had to answer these too. None of them know I’m queer, and I have reason to suspect that they wouldn’t be all that welcoming to anyone not cishet. I don’t think I’ll be able to stay at this parish for long, as it’s incredibly likely that I’ll be scorned the moment someone finds out.

Edit to not rant: I appreciate the feedback folks, seriously. It seems that while these beliefs are prevalent in the church, unfortunately, this practice required for catechumens is not. I’m gonna talk to the director but unfortunately I think that this is probably going to be the end of this chapter, or at least this parish, unless things drastically change. Appreciate y’all’s help.


r/OpenChristian • • 22h ago

Medical Prayer Request Pt 2

8 Upvotes

I posted a prayer request about a week ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenChristian/s/ozDQEifT8d

Just got back from getting a sonogram and they found an ovarian cyst and a uterine polyp. They did a biopsy and bloodwork and I’m waiting on results.

I had a cyst in ‘11 and a polyp in ‘14 that were benign. Please pray all current growths are benign as well. Thank you.


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

‘I know I sound crazy’: the creep of demons into American evangelical churches

Thumbnail theguardian.com
42 Upvotes

r/OpenChristian • • 14h ago

What If We’ve Misunderstood the Purpose of Sin, Religion, and Accountability? A Generation Trying to Choose Love Over Judgment

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about religion, God, American history, morality, our justice system, and the direction my generation is taking society. The more I think about these things, the more I wonder whether we’ve built entire institutions around a fundamental misunderstanding of what it means to be human.

I genuinely believe my generation is doing something culturally significant. We are increasingly vocal about love, kindness, mental health, acceptance, and inclusivity. We are questioning traditions, challenging institutions, and becoming more willing to have conversations that previous generations often avoided.

And I wonder whether some religious institutions see this cultural shift as a threat. They see a generation that is increasingly willing to question traditional interpretations of scripture, accept people who don’t necessarily live according to conventional religious standards, and challenge established ideas about morality. Some interpret this as evidence that our nation is moving away from God.

But have we forgotten the people God showed us in the Bible? Have we forgotten how flawed some of His greatest servants were?

I believe we are a generation full of sin, but also full of love. And perhaps those two things are not as incompatible as we’ve been taught to believe.

I want to explain why I think we need to reconsider almost everything about how we approach religion, morality, and the way we treat one another.

  1. America is a 250-year-old experiment. Why do we treat its traditions as unquestionable?

Sometimes I think we forget just how short 250 years really is. In the grand scope of human history, America is an incredibly young country. It is an experiment in self-government, a relatively new political system, and a nation still trying to determine what it stands for.

Yet we often treat its traditions, institutions, political foundations, and cultural expectations as though they are ancient, unquestionable truths.

I think we need to examine our roots.

Who were the people who established these institutions? What were their values? What motivated their decisions? And how much of what we consider American morality today comes from genuine moral principles versus the interests and interpretations of people who originally held power?

America’s founders were not one unified group of Christian men. They held different religious and philosophical beliefs. The Constitution itself was not written as a biblical document. It does not establish Christianity as the national religion.

There are two particularly important constitutional provisions that I think Americans should understand.

Article VI of the Constitution explicitly states that no religious test can ever be required as a qualification for federal public office.

The First Amendment, ratified in 1791, states:

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”

These provisions are important because they establish two principles: the government cannot establish an official religion, and people must be free to practice their religion.

That doesn’t mean religious people should be excluded from politics. It means the government should not impose one particular religious interpretation on an entire population.

And there is a difference between a country having a population with strong Christian influences and a country being constitutionally founded as a Christian government.

I think that distinction gets lost in many modern political and religious conversations.

Sources: U.S. Senate, Constitution of the United States; National Archives, Bill of Rights.

2. Christianity has been used to justify both slavery and abolition

This is one of the most important contradictions in American religious history.

Throughout American history, Christianity has been used both to defend injustice and to fight against it.

Slaveholders and religious leaders used biblical passages to justify slavery. Some pointed to Leviticus 25:44–46, Ephesians 6:5–6, and 1 Timothy 6:1–2 as evidence that slavery was permitted or that enslaved people were expected to obey their masters.

Pro-slavery theologians, including Presbyterian minister James Henley Thornwell, developed religious arguments defending the institution of slavery. Southern religious leaders used interpretations of scripture to argue that slavery was compatible with Christianity.

But there was another side of this history.

Christian abolitionists used their faith and their interpretations of scripture to fight slavery.

Consider a few examples:

Benjamin Lay: An eighteenth-century Quaker who publicly condemned slaveholding as a violation of God’s will.
John Woolman: A Quaker minister who devoted much of his life to challenging slavery among fellow Christians.
Angelina and Sarah Grimké: Sisters raised in a slaveholding South Carolina family who became Christian abolitionists. Angelina published An Appeal to the Christian Women of the South in 1836, arguing that slavery contradicted Christian morality.
Frederick Douglass: A formerly enslaved abolitionist who criticized the Christianity practiced by slaveholders while drawing on Christian principles to challenge slavery.

Think about that.

The same religious tradition was interpreted in dramatically different ways depending on who was interpreting it and what they believed society should look like.

The Bible was used to defend the institution of slavery, while other Christians believed their faith required them to dismantle it.

I don’t think we can look at that history without asking how much human interpretation influences what we consider religious morality.

I’m not saying every religious teaching is manipulated or that every interpretation is equally valid. I’m saying that religious authority has historically been used to defend the interests of people who held power.

That should make us cautious about treating any institution’s interpretation of scripture as unquestionable.

If people can use the same religious text to defend opposite moral positions, shouldn’t we examine how and why those interpretations developed?

Historical sources:

National Humanities Center: The Religious Roots of Abolition
National Humanities Center: American Abolitionism and Religion
University of Virginia: James Henley Thornwell and the Pro-Slavery Argument

3. Why would I serve a God just to go to heaven if everyone I love is going to hell?

There was a time in my life when I asked myself a question that completely changed my relationship with God:

Why would I want to serve a God just so I could go to heaven if all my friends were going to hell?

That thought process made me separate myself from God and even hate Him for years.

I couldn’t understand how a God described as infinitely loving, merciful, and forgiving could allow so much suffering.

Why does God let terrible things happen to good people? If He has the power to prevent suffering, why doesn’t He? Does that make Him responsible? And if God created humanity knowing we would make mistakes, why would those mistakes determine whether we deserve eternal punishment?

Eventually, my questions became even deeper.

What actually makes something a sin? Who decided what sin meant? Who interpreted the scriptures we follow today? Whose understanding of the Bible are we listening to, preaching, and building our lives around?

How much of what we have been taught about God actually comes from God, and how much comes from human beings interpreting His words through their own beliefs, cultures, fears, and agendas?

I don’t pretend to have the answers to these questions. But I think they deserve to be asked.

I also think questioning what we’ve been taught about God doesn’t necessarily mean rejecting God.

Sometimes, I wonder whether my anger was directed less at God Himself and more at the version of God I had been taught to believe in.

A version shaped by fear, punishment, exclusion, and human interpretations presented as unquestionable truth.

4. Have we confused sin with failure?

This is probably the biggest part of my entire argument.

I don’t believe making a mistake automatically makes someone a failure. I believe mistakes can become opportunities to learn, recognize our shortcomings, understand the consequences of our actions, and develop into better human beings.

When I look at the Bible, I don’t see a collection of perfect people.

Moses killed an Egyptian. David committed adultery and arranged for a man’s death. Peter denied knowing Jesus. Paul persecuted Christians before becoming one of Christianity’s most influential apostles.

These were deeply flawed human beings. Their stories included wrongdoing, consequences, repentance, and transformation.

Their mistakes did not have to be the end of their stories.

That doesn’t mean their actions were justified. It means their humanity wasn’t erased by their worst decisions.

I think we’ve become so focused on preventing people from sinning that we’ve forgotten to teach them what to do after they sin.

Sin is not necessarily the end of someone’s story. It can be the beginning of their growth.

I don’t believe we should excuse wrongdoing. I believe we should teach accountability, repentance, forgiveness, and transformation.

There is a difference between excusing someone’s actions and believing they are capable of becoming better than the worst thing they’ve ever done.

What if we have misunderstood the purpose of making mistakes?

What if the human experience is not about achieving perfection, but about learning to respond to our imperfections with humility, accountability, wisdom, and love?

5. What does the Bible actually say about how we treat sinners?

I think one of the biggest problems is that we sometimes spend more time identifying other people’s sins than examining our own behavior.

There are several passages in the Bible that I think deserve more attention in these conversations.

Matthew 7:1–5 — Judging others

Jesus teaches about the hypocrisy of focusing on someone else’s shortcomings while ignoring our own.

The lesson isn’t that wrongdoing never matters. It’s that we should examine ourselves before placing ourselves above others.

John 8:1–11 — The woman accused of adultery

In this passage, religious leaders bring a woman accused of adultery before Jesus, intending to condemn her. Jesus challenges those accusing her and ultimately tells her to leave her life of sin.

What stands out to me is the combination of mercy and accountability.

He doesn’t tell her that her actions don’t matter. But He also doesn’t reduce her entire identity to her wrongdoing.

One historical-textual note: scholars recognize that this passage appears in later manuscripts of John and is absent from some of the earliest surviving Greek manuscripts. Its textual history is worth acknowledging, even though it has played an enormous role in Christian teaching.

Luke 15:11–32 — The prodigal son

This parable tells the story of a son who makes destructive decisions, leaves his family, and eventually returns.

His father welcomes him home.

To me, this is one of the most powerful illustrations of redemption. The son doesn’t return as someone who has never made mistakes. He returns as someone who has learned from them.

Galatians 6:1–2 — Restoring someone gently

This passage specifically discusses restoring someone caught in wrongdoing with gentleness and carrying one another’s burdens.

I think that is an important distinction.

The instruction is not simply to identify wrongdoing and condemn the person. It speaks about restoration, humility, and mutual responsibility.

These passages are some of the reasons I believe we should reconsider how we approach people who struggle.

Read the passages together here.

6. Religion has become a popularity contest in some communities

I think we’ve created religious environments where the goal seems to be making no mistakes.

Being a good Christian can become measured by how successfully you avoid sin, how closely you follow a particular set of rules, how you present yourself to others, and how well you fit into a religious community.

And when someone makes a mistake, instead of helping them understand it, learn from it, and become a better person, we sometimes isolate them.

We label them sinners. We treat them as though they are beneath us, unworthy of belonging, or less deserving of love.

Religion, in many environments, has become a popularity contest built around appearing righteous rather than practicing compassion.

I think we’ve confused three things:

Having a personal relationship with God.
Belonging to a religious institution.
Following a particular institution’s interpretation of scripture.

Those are not necessarily the same thing.

You can believe in God and question religious leadership. You can value Christianity and disagree with certain churches. You can believe in morality without believing that every religious interpretation should determine how everyone else lives.

And you can disagree with someone’s decisions without treating them as though they are less human.

If Christianity teaches forgiveness, mercy, redemption, and love, why do some religious communities place so much emphasis on shame, exclusion, and condemnation?

7. Our generation is full of sin, but also full of love

I genuinely believe my generation is doing something important.

We are talking about mental health. We are talking about trauma, addiction, acceptance, and emotional well-being.

We are becoming more willing to acknowledge that people are complicated.

Someone’s upbringing, environment, psychological struggles, experiences, and circumstances can influence their behavior.

That doesn’t mean people aren’t responsible for their actions. It means understanding human behavior requires more than simply labeling someone good or bad.

I sometimes wonder whether our generation is actually rediscovering some of the values we believe Christianity was supposed to represent.

Love. Mercy. Forgiveness. Humility. Compassion. Patience. Redemption.

We are a generation that is increasingly willing to say that people deserve love even when they don’t fit traditional expectations.

I think that’s beautiful.

I don’t believe the goal should be to force everyone to live according to our individual interpretations of morality.

Our job should not be to control every person’s spiritual journey.

We can share what we believe, offer guidance, demonstrate compassion, and plant seeds.

Then we have to allow people the freedom to grow.

Our job is to plant seeds. God’s job is not ours to control.

Sometimes planting a seed is nothing more than showing someone kindness when everyone else has rejected them.

Sometimes it is listening without judgment.

Sometimes it is loving someone even when you disagree with their decisions.

There is something profoundly powerful about knowing that someone sees your imperfections and still treats you with dignity.

I want us to be patient. I want us to be kind. I want us to trust that genuine love can accomplish things that shame and condemnation never will.

8. What if we applied the same philosophy to our justice system?

This is where I think the conversation needs to extend beyond religion.

I wish we lived in a society where people could admit their mistakes, seek help, accept accountability, and work toward rehabilitation without automatically believing their entire lives would be destroyed.

Think about what happens when someone makes a mistake and believes there is no way back from it.

When admitting wrongdoing means potentially losing employment, family relationships, reputation, and their entire future, people may become more concerned with hiding what they’ve done than addressing the underlying problem.

That creates a culture of secrecy rather than growth.

Look at how we approach crime and punishment in America.

We frequently define people by the worst decisions they have made. We label them criminals, place them in prisons, and often create barriers that follow them long after they have served their sentences.

Of course, victims deserve justice. People who harm others must be held accountable. Society has a responsibility to protect vulnerable people.

But accountability and rehabilitation should not be opposing ideas.

I want a system where consequences have a purpose beyond suffering.

For nonviolent offenses, addiction-related crimes, and other situations where treatment can meaningfully reduce future harm, I think we should place much greater emphasis on rehabilitation.

That could include:

Addiction treatment and specialized therapy.
Mental health services.
Cognitive behavioral therapy.
Education and vocational training.
Restorative justice where appropriate.
Restitution to victims where legally and practically appropriate.
Structured supervision and monitoring.
Reentry support and long-term follow-up.

There is actual research supporting the importance of rehabilitation.

The U.S. Department of Justice’s National Institute of Justice has published a review of adult rehabilitation programs examining hundreds of research effect sizes. The review found that rehabilitation programs were associated with reductions in reoffending, although outcomes varied by intervention.

Programs involving structured counseling, cognitive behavioral approaches, and certain specialized courts showed evidence of reducing recidivism.

This doesn’t mean every rehabilitation program works. It means rehabilitation deserves to be treated as an evidence-based part of public safety rather than an alternative to accountability.

Source: National Institute of Justice — Rehabilitation Programs for Adults Convicted of a Crime

9. Rehabilitation must never come at the expense of victims

I also want to make an important distinction because I know this part of my argument can be misunderstood.

I am not suggesting that every offender should avoid prison, that every crime is an addiction, or that treatment alone is enough to make someone safe.

Victims must come first.

Their safety, dignity, privacy, financial recovery, and emotional well-being matter. They should not be pressured into forgiveness, reconciliation, or participating in restorative justice programs.

Restitution should be considered when appropriate. Victims should have access to support and meaningful opportunities to participate in decisions that affect their safety.

Rehabilitation should also be based on an individual’s actual risk, behavior, circumstances, and treatment needs.

For example:

Addiction-related and nonviolent offenses: Many people may benefit from treatment programs, diversion, counseling, supervision, and opportunities to rebuild their lives. The goal should be to address the factors contributing to the offending behavior.

Property crimes and repeat offenses: Treatment may be combined with restitution, community service, supervision, and restrictions designed to reduce further harm.

Sexual offenses, including child sexual abuse material offenses: These are serious offenses involving real victims and exploitation. Specialized treatment, psychiatric and psychological assessment where appropriate, strict restrictions on access to potential victims, digital safeguards, and long-term supervision may all be necessary. Treatment does not erase criminal responsibility or guarantee that someone will not reoffend.

Rape, murder, and serious violent offenses: Victim protection, public safety, proportionate legal consequences, and secure confinement when necessary must remain priorities. Rehabilitation can still be part of the correctional process, but it cannot substitute for protecting society.

I think this distinction is important.

We can believe in redemption without minimizing the harm someone has caused.

We can believe people deserve opportunities to change without giving everyone unrestricted access to the people they have harmed.

We can believe in forgiveness without demanding that victims forgive.

Love does not mean removing boundaries. Rehabilitation does not mean removing consequences. And accountability does not have to mean abandoning someone’s humanity.

10. We teach children to fear mistakes instead of teaching them how to grow

I think this same mentality begins in childhood.

Too often, we teach children that making mistakes is something to fear.

We punish them for being wrong without always taking the time to explain why their choices were harmful, what consequences those choices created, and how they can make better decisions.

We focus on controlling behavior instead of developing understanding.

But a child who never learns how to recover from a mistake may grow into an adult who is terrified of failure, ashamed of imperfection, and unable to take accountability without feeling worthless.

I don’t want a society where people are taught that mistakes don’t matter.

I want a society where mistakes become opportunities for learning.

Where accountability leads to understanding.

Where consequences teach something.

Where people are given the tools to grow.

We cannot realistically expect human beings to live without ever making mistakes. So why do we spend so much time teaching people to fear them instead of teaching them how to respond to them?

11. Religion and government should not become instruments of one another

I also think we need to examine the relationship between religion and American politics.

The Constitution protects religious freedom and prohibits the government from establishing a national religion.

It is important to clarify that the Bible itself does not contain a constitutional separation-of-church-and-state provision. That is an American constitutional principle, not a direct biblical quotation.

But I believe the principle is important.

People should be free to practice their faith, express their beliefs, and allow those beliefs to influence their personal decisions.

But no particular religious interpretation should automatically become the moral authority governing an entire population.

Throughout American history, religious arguments have been used to justify slavery and discrimination, while other religious voices have fought against those same injustices.

That history should make us more thoughtful about who interprets religious teachings, how those interpretations influence legislation, and whose interests are served when religious authority becomes political authority.

We should be able to question religious leadership without being accused of hating God.

We should be able to question government without being accused of hating America.

And we should be able to question the systems we inherited without believing that doing so makes us immoral.

I also think transparency matters.

When powerful institutions hide wrongdoing, protect their reputations, or prioritize themselves over the people they are supposed to serve, they undermine public trust.

Whether we’re talking about churches, corporations, political organizations, or government agencies, accountability should apply to everyone.

No one should be above the standards they demand of others.

12. We are creating a culture where hiding sin feels safer than admitting it

This might be one of the most damaging consequences of the way we approach morality.

When people believe that admitting their mistakes will permanently destroy their lives, they learn to hide them.

When institutions believe admitting wrongdoing will damage their reputation, they learn to conceal it.

When political leaders believe honesty will cost them power, they have incentives to avoid accountability.

And when religious communities prioritize appearances over genuine transformation, people learn to pretend they are doing better than they actually are.

We end up with a culture that rewards looking righteous rather than being honest.

I think that is dangerous.

We should want people to come forward, ask for help, acknowledge their wrongdoing, and take responsibility.

We should create pathways for rehabilitation while maintaining appropriate consequences and protecting the people who have been harmed.

I don’t want a society without standards. I want a society where standards actually serve a purpose.

A society where honesty is encouraged, accountability is expected, and growth is possible.

13. What if America is another lesson in human history?

America is still a relatively young experiment in self-government.

We have spent centuries preaching freedom while denying it to entire populations. We have spoken about equality while maintaining systems of inequality. We have invoked Christianity while using religious arguments to justify things that contradict the compassion and human dignity many Christians believe Jesus taught.

I sometimes wonder whether America is a test of what humanity can build when given freedom, power, and the opportunity to govern itself.

If so, perhaps the test isn’t whether we can preserve the institutions we inherited.

Perhaps it is whether we have the courage to recognize their failures, confront the harm they have caused, and build something more just.

Someday, our generation’s decisions, contradictions, and cultural changes will become part of the history books.

I hope future generations recognize that we were willing to question systems that needed improvement.

I hope they recognize that we tried to build something that valued human dignity over appearances, rehabilitation over vengeance, compassion over condemnation, and genuine accountability over institutional protection.

14. What I actually want for our future

I want a generation that is brave enough to admit its mistakes, compassionate enough to help others through theirs, and humble enough to recognize that none of us has perfected the human experience.

I want a society where people can struggle without being permanently labeled by their struggles.

I want churches that prioritize helping people grow rather than making people feel inferior.

I want a justice system that recognizes rehabilitation as an essential part of public safety.

I want children who learn that mistakes are opportunities to develop wisdom, not reasons to believe they are worthless.

I want religious people who understand that they don’t have to control someone else’s relationship with God.

And I want a government that understands the importance of protecting individual freedoms rather than imposing one religious interpretation of morality.

I don’t believe we should abandon morality, religion, or personal responsibility.

I believe we should reconsider what those things are supposed to accomplish.

I don’t want a society without consequences. I want consequences that actually help prevent future harm.

I don’t want a society that ignores sin. I want a society that understands the difference between recognizing wrongdoing and permanently defining a human being by it.

And I don’t want a generation that abandons God. I want a generation that feels comfortable questioning what it has been taught about Him while searching for a genuine relationship with Him.

Perhaps our generation isn’t necessarily rejecting the values of Christianity. Perhaps some of us are trying to rediscover the values we believe Christianity was supposed to represent.

Maybe we have spent too much time trying to prevent people from falling and not enough time teaching them how to get back up.

Maybe we have confused condemnation with accountability, fear with faith, and religious conformity with genuine morality.

Maybe the greatest failure of our religious culture is not that people continue to make mistakes, but that we have sometimes forgotten how to love people through their struggles without abandoning accountability.

I don’t have all the answers. I don’t expect everyone to agree with me. And I don’t believe my interpretation of God is automatically the correct one.

But I think these conversations are important.

I want us to question what we’ve inherited, examine what we believe, and consider whether the systems we’ve built actually reflect the values we claim to hold.

We cannot force people into goodness. We can demonstrate it.

We cannot demand that people grow. We can create environments where growth is possible.

We cannot make people love God through fear. We can show them what love looks like through the way we treat one another.

I genuinely believe our generation has an opportunity to change how we approach religion, morality, mental health, and justice.

And I think that’s beautiful.

Perhaps the greatest thing we can teach the next generation is that being imperfect does not mean being incapable of becoming something beautiful.

We focus so much on preventing people from falling that we forget to teach them how to get back up.

We focus so much on condemning sinners that we forget we are sinners ourselves.

And we focus so much on hell that we forget the walk to heaven.

I’d genuinely like to hear other people’s perspectives, especially from Christians, former Christians, people questioning their faith, and people who believe in rehabilitation over punishment.

What do you think we’ve misunderstood about sin, forgiveness, accountability, and the purpose of religion?


r/OpenChristian • • 18h ago

Support Thread I don't feel a connection to Christianity. Is something wrong with me?

2 Upvotes

I was raised Christian, but I never felt a connection to God or Jesus. I'm also autistic and a lesbian, so I often feel excluded in Christian circles. I read the Bible, but it doesn't make any sense to me. I pray for a relationship with God, but I haven't felt it yet. Am I just not meant to be a Christian?


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

Vent Anyone else annoyed by the argument that heaven is worse than hell?

28 Upvotes

A lot of this comes from Athiests who are scared of eternity, which I can understand. But it feels like their understanding of the afterlife is very shallow: “when you die you can do anything forever.” The natural response to this is, “what do you do when you’ve done everything?”

I consider myself a universalist and personally believe that the purpose of the afterlife is not to retain your human wants and grudges. But when you argue that, or something similar, you get met with “so you’re just gonna get turned into a lobotomized version of yourself?”

Granted, I understand that this is kind of the version of heaven that is sold to people by evangelical Christians. I also know that a lot of media depicts this view of the afterlife which may serve as their primary reference for how it operates. I also want to clarify that it’s not all Athiests, mainly just the toxic ones. And of course, the internet is gonna be the internet. But I don’t know, I’m just kinda tired of seeing the same old argument


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

Discussion - Sex & Relationships How did you find your partners?

13 Upvotes

Blessings,

I have never dated before, and I am very new to the faith -- I am a Jew and very proud to be so, but have fallen in love with Anglicanism and am quite devoted to both traditions. I have no idea how to date, or even begin to date, especially because I'm quite progressive but very theologically conservative (in the sense that I believe very strongly in little-o orthodoxy, biblical inerrancy/infallibility, the creeds, the value of tradition, etc). To be clear, this doesn't mean that I'm anti-LGBT, just very serious about my theology.

For those of you who are partnered, and especially those of you with my theological inclinations, how did you find your partners? I'm not really sure how to even make friends in church (I've always been socially awkward) so finding a partner is even more daunting. Obviously I'm praying about it and entrusting it to the Lord, but I would also like some advice from others.

Thank you so much in advance!


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

Alternative ways to approach faith for neuro-divergent people

9 Upvotes

I live with ADHD. The dopamine rush of discovering the faith has long worn off and I'm bored. I'll straight up say it - I'm bored. Bored of the scripture, bored of the hymns, bored of the worship, bored of the debates. This has led me to look at other spiritual paths, despite my more logical, rational, and moral sides being loyal to Jesus Christ. I believe, I'm just bored.

If I jump ship to, say, paganism, I'll get bored of that too. Then who knows what's next. I want out of this cycle.

Can anyone relate?


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

Discussion - General Do you believe in signs from god? (trigger warning) NSFW

33 Upvotes

something strange happened today. i have a flock of doves that i feed. theres probably two dozen of them in total, i feed a lot of birds altogether of different kinds. they chill on the other side of the house, by the feeder, at the opposite side yard. never once has the flock chilled by the breezeway and patio next to my garage door, right out my backdoor on the opposite of the house. i was feeling suicidal, and i confess i wanted to walk to the garage to see if there was a objectin the garage i could use to come up with a plan about ending in.

i was in a very bad and hopeless emotional state feeling like i cant continue to live with my current reality. when i unlocked the door i heard doves, i opened it wider and heard more. I opened the door completely and a ton of them flew away to a higher spot. it was like the entire flock at one time was right outside my door. i like to respect and share their habitat, my home is theres, so i went back inside so they could feel comfortable sitting on the breezeway. they blocked my path to the garage door and i no longer wanted to kill myself, seeing my happy little bird buddies i love so much. i forgot about it completely. i love birds.


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

What would you call my theology? Progressive Christian, religious pluralist, or something else?

5 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking a lot about my beliefs lately, especially after some interesting discussions at my church. I’m baptized and still feel connected to Christianity, but I realize that a lot of my beliefs don’t necessarily fit traditional Christian theology.
Here’s where I stand:

My understanding of God:
I believe there is one universal God or divine reality.
I don’t necessarily see God as a separate being outside of creation. I see divinity as something present throughout humanity, nature, consciousness, and existence.
I believe different religions are interpreting and experiencing this same divine reality in different ways.

My understanding of Jesus and other religions:
I believe Jesus is the Son of God and an important spiritual teacher, but I don’t believe he is the exclusive expression of divinity.
I believe other spiritual teachers, such as Buddha and the Sikh Gurus, can also reveal divine truths.
I struggle with the Christian belief that someone must accept Jesus to be saved or enter heaven.
I don’t believe a good Jewish, Muslim, Buddhist, Sikh, or nonreligious person should be excluded from heaven simply because they aren’t Christian.

My understanding of heaven, hell, and sin:
I don’t necessarily believe heaven and hell are literal places we go after death. I see them more as metaphors for the human experience.
To me, hell is the suffering humanity creates through war, greed, hatred, oppression, exploitation, and cruelty.
I see sin as the ways we hurt one another and perpetuate unnecessary suffering, rather than simply breaking a set of divine rules.
Heaven represents compassion, peace, justice, and a world where people genuinely care for one another.
I think our focus should be on making Earth a better place rather than spending our lives worrying about getting into heaven after we die.

My understanding of suffering and the afterlife:
I recognize that not all suffering is within human control. Death, disease, aging, and grief are still part of existence, and I honestly don’t have answers for why.
I believe the soul or consciousness may continue after physical death, and I’m open to possibilities like reincarnation.
I don’t claim to know what happens after we die. I think it’s one of the great mysteries of existence.

Ultimately:
I believe in one God, many spiritual paths, and the interconnectedness of humanity. I think our purpose should be to love one another, reduce suffering, challenge injustice, and make this lifetime meaningful.
I realize some of this probably falls outside traditional Christian orthodoxy, but I still appreciate Jesus, Christian teachings, and being part of a church community.
What would you call this? Religious pluralism? Perennial philosophy? Pantheism? Progressive Christianity? Some combination of all of the above? I’m curious if anyone else has similar beliefs, particularly people who still identify with Christianity.


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

Discussion - LGBTQ+ Issues What was your experience growing up transgender?

10 Upvotes

This is long winded, but I'll do my best. I wouldn't say this is an "issue", but it's LGBT related. I'm trans mtf (25), and I came out to my worship leader of my membered church, who is one of my best friends. I'm a very avid worship volunteer, and have been at this church for probably close to 15 years. The church is relatively conservative in the south, though we don't often talk about politics. Since I came out to her a couple months ago, we've put me being on stage on pause, and we regularly meet and talk about it.

She is trying to understand where I'm coming from, and we're trying to engage in theological conversation. Where we've kind of left off is her asking, "Do you think this is really a belief that you have had since you were born? Or could it have been something you thought about once or twice and it's kind of 'spiraled' from there?" Along with that, "Do you think things would be different if you had a mentor growing up (such as parents) leading you in the direction of 'here's what the Bible says about male/female/sexuality?"

As far as I know, from the earliest I can remember (4-5 years old) I was felt like I wasn't in the right body, but I have NEVER seen that as a mistake that God has made. But I honestly don't know if it's always been a true belief that I've had, or if it was a thought that just grew. And I guess I'm asking... what was your experience? Was it always a belief for you? Did you have a mentor at a young age to have those sexuality/gender conversations with you? Did you just have a desire to wear clothes/makeup/whatever of the opposite sex?

Her other concern/question is how do I fit in to the reproduction purpose that God gave us? I personally do believe that He gave us that purpose to have kids and gave families and raise god-fearing children, and I don't plan on altering that, for more reasons than just that, too. I'll probably never get on hormones or have anything "permanent". I'm happily married to my wife, and we want to/plan to have kids together.

Be gentle on my worship leader friend. She's still one of my best friends, and she's asking all the right questions so she can understand where I'm coming from, because with her being cis female, it's all she's ever known.

TLDR: Did you always know that something was different? What was that thing that made you feel different? Did you have a mentor that potentially could have pointed you to the bible? Did that change anything?


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

Discussion - General Has anyone else had to leave a church community that hurt them? How did you find your way back to God?

5 Upvotes

I won't go into details, partly because some of it still isn't easy to talk about, and I don't want to blame anyone. About a year ago I stepped away from a church community I had served for many years, and it left a hurt I didn't know what to do with. I've since found a new church and I'm doing okay, but it took this whole year before I could even talk about it.

What helped me was writing a song about it. Not to point fingers, just to be honest before God. Somehow putting it into words and melody became a kind of painkiller.

I'm curious whether others have been through something similar. If you've been hurt in a church, or you're still looking for a spiritual home, what helped you heal? Did it change how you know God? You don't have to share anything you're not ready to. I just think it might help to have a place where we can listen to each other.


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

Support Thread I think my church is dying

13 Upvotes

Using an alt account for reasons.

I don't know that I have a question or really want anything out of this post other than to just rant and process a bit. This sub has been great in terms of support so I guess that led me to want to post here.

A while back our minister left. He had been with us for a decade and a half or so and played a large role in shaping our church by really challenging us and pushing back on harmful dogma and tradition. As life circumstances changed with aging parents and kids going to college, it made sense for him to move when an opportunity came up that would put his family in a better spot geographically. The hard part for me is that he was probably my closest friend nearby. We still talk and text each other stupid stuff we find online but it's still a loss to not be able to just go grab lunch or something together when I have a day off during the week.

Still, I saw this as an opportunity for growth and change. We, as a church, had this time to reexamine things and think about what to do with this new chapter.

To back up a bit we've lost members over the years. This area has a bit of churn due to Military families and other federal jobs in the area. The problem is that as we became a more progressive congregation fewer people tended to stay. It seemed for a while that if we had two families visit, one would usually decide we weren't for them. With COVID we lost a few people because we stopped meeting in person for a while. And while there was never any political endorsement from the pulpit or church leadership, calls for being Christian first led to some people leaving because they saw those as attacks on their preferred political position.

So here we were with a small church where one family could be the difference between our budget being in the black. Not having a full time employee made things better but we still needed money coming in if we're going to consider offering someone a position in the future. Then we have someone announce they're leaving for some reason. Well, not an immediate problem. Then back to back two other families are moving away.

Last Sunday maybe a dozen people showed up. Even if we had someone we wanted to hire as a new minister it wouldn't be sustainable. I know the church isn't a place and we could easily shut down the building and become a home church but I don't think that is for everyone. There is something about going to the place and coming together as a group. What's frustrating is the mega-church literally across the street that uses our parking lot as overflow. They've added on to their buildings and seen explosive growth while we've been dwindling. We'll just say that one would feel more comfortable wearing a red hat over there.

I guess the TL;DR is that our church has been on the decline for a while but I think we're at a real tangible point right now where we have to face the reality of closing our doors.


r/OpenChristian • • 1d ago

"We may not control how easily faith comes to us, but we can choose to seek God...this is more of a struggle for some of us than others."

6 Upvotes

UPLIFT: Easier for Some
I received some nice feedback about the last Uplift message—about the practice of praying not for what we want but for what God wants.

But here’s what I didn’t mention: living this way requires a good deal of faith and trust.

This is one of the most familiar passages of Scripture in the Bible:

“Faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.” (Hebrews 11:1)

One way to understand faith is as trusting beyond what we can prove or see.

This is more of a struggle for some of us than others.

I’ve been thinking about that.

Some people, like me, seem more naturally inclined toward faith, comfortable believing in a God we cannot see or fully understand.

I wasn’t particularly interested in God for many years, mind you. But once the spark of childhood faith was reignited, the path began to open up.

Others wrestle with the very idea of God, even when they might wish they could believe.

Perhaps it’s a little like maintaining a healthy weight. For some people, it seems almost effortless. For others, it’s a lifelong struggle, influenced in part by their genetic makeup.

And perhaps faith is a little like that. We’re not all made the same way. Our experiences, training, and natural predispositions shape how we approach the world, what we can believe, and how easily we trust.

But whatever our starting point, we can choose to seek God.
And even when it’s difficult, seeking a loving, trusting relationship with Him is worth the effort.

It’s why we’re here.

The good news is that God wants a relationship with us. Jesus invites us to seek Him. In Matthew 7, Jesus says:
“Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.”

And even if it takes time, the effort is not wasted. Seeking God can strengthen our faith. It can even awaken it.

This is what I suggest: spend time with God’s Word, the Bible, and with others who are walking the same path, perhaps in a church community. And ask God for his presence.

The more we do, the more the puzzle pieces begin to fit together and the more complete the picture becomes.

We begin to recognize things we couldn’t see before, and view familiar things in a new light.

As Paul writes in 2 Corinthians 3:16:
“But whenever anyone turns to the Lord, the veil is taken away.”

Until next time, keep walking toward the light.