r/PhilosophyofMath • • 22h ago

History of Imaginary Numbers: Invented or Discovered?

15 Upvotes

Imaginary numbers trace as back as the 1st century, when Hero of Alexandria, an ancient Greek mathematician and engineer, ran into the problem of negative numbers inside square roots. But at the time, there wasn't an imaginary unit or a complex plane. An expression like √(-1) was undefined.

That started to change in the 16th century when mathematician Girolamo Cardano was working with cubic equations. Even if all solutions for a cubic equation were real, Cardano was sometimes forced to take the square root of negative numbers to find the real roots. He called these numbers "mental torture". He could do math with them, but he considered them fictious and useless.

Then, Rafael Bombelli, an Italian engineer decided to look closely at the numbers Cardano called a "mental torture". He realised they were a consistent number system, just like the reals. Bombelli did manage to extract real roots out of Cardano's formulas, even though he didn't know what to do with them in the real world.

René Descartes hated these numbers so much that he used "imaginary" as a derogatory term. You can't have a line segment √(-1) meters long, you can't divide a circle into i equal slices, but this insult became the term we still use today to describe these numbers.

Euler and Gauss (18th and 19th century)

Leonhard Euler introduced the letter i to denote the imaginary unit (i² = -1) and his famous identity has that unit right in the exponent: e^iπ + 1 = 0

Carl Friedrich Gauss & Caspar Wessel independently realised these numbers live in a second dimension (horizontal axis for the reals and vertical axis for imaginary numbers) which is called the complex plane. Adding the real and imaginary parts together gives a complex number (a + bi)

Where imaginary numbers are used today

What started as a torture back in the 1500s is today used in electrical engineering, fluid dynamics, and signal processing. Schrödinger's equation has the imaginary unit i right in front. Complex plane waves (electromagnetism, optics) have the unit i in their exponent. Physicists use Euler's formula (e^iθ = cos(θ) + i sin(θ)) to represent travelling waves (light, sound, or radio waves)

So, do you think these numbers were invented, or discovered?


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 22h ago

The Nouve Constant-What do you think of it?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 5h ago

Dark Natural Numbers (IX): The doubled interval (0, ω]

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 13h ago

Pie hypothesis

0 Upvotes

Imagine an abstract entity that I call the Pie, inspired by the idea of π. The purpose of the Pie is not necessarily to be π itself, but to use the properties we associate with π—its infinite, non-repeating sequence of digits and its deep connection to circles—as a starting point for imagining an infinite space of information. The central idea is that perhaps every possible pattern, answer, arrangement, or piece of information already exists somewhere within this infinite structure. We normally think of an answer as something that comes into existence when we solve a problem, but the Pie hypothesis proposes a different way of looking at it: perhaps we do not create answers; we discover them. If a mathematical problem has an exact solution, that solution could already exist as a pattern within the Pie even though nobody has yet discovered how to reach it. When a mathematician finally solves the problem, they are not necessarily creating the answer from nothing—they are finding a pattern that was already possible.

This idea can be extended beyond mathematics. Imagine a person giving their child a completely original name, such as a strange combination of symbols that nobody has ever intentionally used as a name before. The exact sequence of symbols could nevertheless already exist somewhere within an infinite collection of possible patterns. What is new is not necessarily the pattern itself, but the meaning humans assign to it. Before the decision, it is simply a possible arrangement of symbols; afterward, it becomes the name of a particular person. This creates a distinction between existence as a pattern and existence as meaning. The Pie could contain the pattern before anyone gives it meaning, while human beings create the relationship between that pattern and something in reality.

The hypothesis can then be extended toward the universe itself. Space is expanding, and countless events occur within it continuously. Humans observe only an extremely small portion of everything that happens. There may be stars, particles, interactions, events, and patterns that we will never observe. The Pie hypothesis imagines that the information or patterns corresponding to these possibilities could already exist within the infinite structure of the Pie, even if humanity never discovers them. In this interpretation, reality produces events while the Pie represents an abstract space of possible information, and human knowledge is the process of discovering relationships between patterns and reality.

However, this does not mean that π has been scientifically demonstrated to contain every possible answer. π is certainly infinite, but mathematics has not established that every possible finite sequence of digits occurs somewhere in its decimal expansion. Likewise, there is currently no scientific evidence that π literally records everything that happens in the universe. These are the speculative parts of the hypothesis. The connection to π is therefore better understood as the foundation or metaphor for the Pie rather than a claim that ordinary π has already been proven to contain the universe.

Another important question is whether the Pie itself could expand. If it already contains every possible pattern, then what could possibly be added to it? Perhaps nothing can be added because every possibility was already present. In that case, the Pie would not need to expand even if the universe does. Alternatively, perhaps the Pie is not a collection of completed answers but an infinite structure from which increasingly complex patterns can be discovered. This creates a deeper problem: if an answer already exists inside the Pie, what exactly does it mean to discover it? Is discovering an answer fundamentally different from creating one?

The idea also raises a question about infinity itself. A circle can have a finite size while containing infinitely many points, and π has infinitely many digits without itself becoming physically larger. Therefore, something being infinite does not necessarily mean that it is physically expanding. This distinction becomes important when thinking about the universe. We cannot currently say with certainty that all of space is infinite, nor can we simply say that the universe is a sphere. Space could have different global geometries, including possibilities that are finite but have no ordinary boundary. Therefore, the Pie hypothesis does not need the universe to be infinite or spherical. It only requires us to imagine a relationship between physical reality and an abstract infinite structure of possible information.

Ultimately, the Pie hypothesis asks a fundamental philosophical question: When we discover something, are we bringing new information into existence, or are we uncovering information that was already possible? Perhaps every equation has its solution before we solve it, every possible pattern exists before we recognize it, and countless truths remain hidden simply because nobody has yet found the path leading to them. If this were true in the strongest possible sense, human knowledge would not be the creation of reality but the gradual exploration of an enormous space of possibilities. We would not be inventing the answers; we would be learning how to find them.