When I look at a lot of modern voting in the US and elsewhere, one thing that bugs me is that 51% of the vote is no different than 80% of the vote. Additionally, there is no real benefit between losing with 49% or 20% of the vote. This is essentially the root of the gerrymandering problem.
I think proportional systems that prevent that are interesting, but I believe in voting for people and not parties.
So, I came up with, from what I understand, would be a voting/congressional/parliamentary system that would allow you to (1) vote for individuals, (2) prevents gerrymandering, and (3) makes every vote count in the legislative process.
I call my system Proportional Representatives.
The way the system works is as follows: Suppose you have two candidates in an election, Candidate A and Candidate B. Candidate A gets 60% of the vote and Candidate B gets 40% of the votes. Both candidates go to the legislative body and share the one vote assigned to the one seat, such that Candidate A gets 0.6 votes and Candidate B gets 0.4 votes because that is how much each respective candidate got in the election.
This system can have more than two candidates, with more than two people getting in, but a real-world system would probably put a minimum vote threshold for actually being seated and/or a maximum number of people per seat.
In my view, this would have a few major benefits. First of all, the strength and power of the winning candidate scales with the proportion of the vote they got, meaning getting more votes is always good. Second, and conversely, the minority of voters that failed to win the majority would still be represented by what ever proportion they can muster. This would make gerrymandering impossible, as packing candidates in to a supermajority just gives the opposition a more powerful legislator.
The way I see it, this would encourage parties to try to select the candidates that are the most popular candidates and to ditch relatively unpopular candidates, as running less popular candidates would lose power based on their lack of popularity, even if they are capable of attracting the majority of the voters.
It would also, as far as I can tell, not have to fall in to a two party system.
The major downsides I can think of is that it would be very difficult or impossible to actually fully remove truly problematic people from the legislative body through voting and would fail to prevent dangerous parties that seek to attack the democratic institutions from getting a voice through elected positions. Also, it could be hard to have proper procedures for the actual legislative body while in session.
There are a bunch of other details that would need to be worked out, like how the actual legislative floor would work, (e.g. each legislator would get an amount of speaking time proportional to the number of votes they got), but I've had this idea for a while, and I'm wondering what other people might think of it.