I'm curious whether anyone here has made the transition from teaching high school to a full-time community college position and, looking back, whether you think it was the right decision.
For some background, I'm in my early 30s and currently teach high school science in a red state. With my master's degree and supplements, I make around $70k annually. I also adjunct at several colleges, bringing my total income to approximately $110k–$120k per year.
I've been an adjunct at a local community college for several years, and there's a good possibility that a full-time position will become available this spring. I'm seriously considering it, but the financial side has me second-guessing the move.
The starting salary would be around $55k, increasing to approximately $60k once I finish my doctorate (quite the raise, I know). There are opportunities to teach overload courses in the fall and spring, along with summer courses, which could bring my college income to around $75k if everything works out. I could also continue adjuncting at other institutions. Based on my calculations, I'd probably take an overall annual pay cut of around $5k–$10k, depending on how many additional courses I can pick up. That's a difference I can comfortably manage, although the uncertainty of those extra courses concerns me.
One of the biggest reasons I'm considering leaving K–12 is job security. I'm currently on an annual contract, and my district has been cutting positions and tightening budgets year after year. Being in a red state, I don't have the kind of tenure protections that teachers in some other states enjoy. At the community college, there's a pathway to a continuing contract after five years, which seems like it could provide more long-term stability. I realize colleges have their own enrollment and budget problems, though.
There's also the issue of losing my current adjunct income at that institution. I typically teach four courses in the fall and four in the spring, earning about $10k each semester. Moving into a full-time position would mean giving that up and hoping overloads, summer courses, and work at other colleges would make up the difference. Those opportunities are available, but obviously nothing is guaranteed.
I'm also wondering how much my day-to-day life would actually change. Currently, I teach high school all day and then spend my evenings and weekends teaching college courses, grading, answering emails, and keeping up with everything else. Between classroom management, administrative expectations, meetings, and the usual K–12 responsibilities, it feels like I'm always working.
I know full-time college faculty have plenty of responsibilities outside the classroom, especially with a five-course teaching load, office hours, advising, committees, and institutional service. I'm not expecting an easy job, but I wonder whether having more autonomy over my schedule and working primarily with college students would make the workload feel more manageable.
Benefits are another factor. Both positions participate in the same state retirement system, so I wouldn't be starting over in that regard. The college offers somewhat better health insurance, although both provide access to an HSA, so that's not a major deciding factor for me. One downside is that I've accumulated nearly 600 hours of sick leave at my current district, and under the contract, I'd lose that if I resigned.
Professionally, higher education is where I see myself long-term. I'm finishing my doctorate, enjoy conducting research and publishing, and genuinely like teaching college students. I'm not particularly interested in administration or climbing the academic ladder. I'd be perfectly happy spending my career teaching science, staying involved in research, and eventually earning a continuing contract.
I realize community colleges are primarily teaching institutions, and research generally isn't part of the formal workload. That's fine with me, as I've already been doing research independently while maintaining my current teaching responsibilities.
I suppose my biggest concern is whether I'm romanticizing the idea of being a full-time professor. I've enjoyed adjuncting, but I also recognize that being a full-time faculty member comes with responsibilities adjuncts don't necessarily experience.
For those of you who have taught at both the secondary and postsecondary levels, did you notice a meaningful improvement in your work-life balance? Did you actually gain more flexibility, or did the additional institutional responsibilities cancel that out? How secure do you feel in a full-time community college position, particularly after receiving a continuing contract?
And perhaps most importantly, would you take a $5k–$10k annual pay cut to make this transition?
I'm trying to think about this as a 20–25-year career decision rather than just comparing next year's salary. If the position is offered this spring, I'd like to have a clear answer rather than make an emotional decision because I'm frustrated with K–12.
I'd particularly appreciate hearing from full-time community college faculty who previously taught high school, but I'm interested in perspectives from anyone familiar with the realities of teaching a 5/5 load.