Some people on Twitter have been complaining that the Authority of Gluttony keeps changing and that Tappei doesn't know how to handle it. However, I think many of these complaints stem from a misunderstanding of how Witch Factors and Authorities actually work, as well as a lack of understanding of Gluttony's almost limitless potential.
First, what exactly is a Witch Factor?
Witch Factors are the antithesis of Od Lagna and have existed for an extremely long time. They possess the ability to interfere with and alter the laws of the world established by Od Lagna.
It's also important to understand the distinction between Witch Factors and Authorities. A Witch Factor is not an Authority itself. Rather, you could think of Witch Factors as keys and Authorities as the doors they unlock. Once that door has been opened, it doesn't simply close again, even after its user dies.
There are also exceptions to the usual rules surrounding Witch Factors. For instance, someone can potentially develop an Authority through an exceptionally close connection to another person who possesses one, such as a family member or close relative.
Another important aspect is that Authorities can evolve alongside their users.
Aldebaran and Spica are interesting examples of this. When someone experiences an extremely significant psychological shock, it can affect how their Authority manifests.
In Aldebaran's case, his defeat against Satella seems to have had a profound impact on him, leading to the development of what can be described as his Territory Aggressor mode. Similarly, Spica's experience with Subaru appears to have changed her Authority, allowing her to use it without consuming her victims' memories in the same way as before.
Now, let's talk about Gluttony.
Many people underestimate just how absurdly versatile this Authority is. Its most well-known abilities allow its users to consume someone's name or memories. However, that's only the beginning.
Through Solar and Lunar Eclipse, Gluttony users can reproduce another person's abilities or even assume their entire identity.
But there are several other applications that people tend to overlook. Gluttony users can create copies of themselves, produce and control Mabeasts, and even manipulate memories in more unconventional ways. Roy, for example, demonstrated the ability to combine memories and turn them into an attack, forcing his opponent to relive painful experiences from their past.
In other words, Gluttony isn't simply an Authority that allows someone to steal names and memories. Its applications extend far beyond that, and we've already seen several different ways its users can exploit it.
Finally, there's one major question that remains unanswered: what happens to the people consumed by a Gluttony user when that user dies?
More specifically, what happens if one of the three siblings dies without first regurgitating the names and memories they consumed?
In Lye's case, the people whose names and memories he had consumed were eventually restored after he regurgitated them during his final confrontation with Ram.
Louis, on the other hand, hadn't consumed nearly as many people, so we have considerably less information about what would have happened had she died without returning what she had taken.
As for Roy, he consumed a considerable number of people. However, we still don't know whether his death would automatically restore the names and memories he consumed, assuming he is indeed dead.
There's also the particular case of people like Crusch and Rem, who regained consciousness but remained unable to remember their identities.
Ram actually proposed a possible explanation for this phenomenon. According to her theory, the people consumed by Gluttony are gradually digested over time. If that's the case, recovering their names and memories might eventually become impossible unless the Gluttony user willingly returns them.
This would also explain why simply killing a Gluttony user is pointless to save their victims. If Ram's theory is correct, the only reliable solution would be to force the Gluttony user to regurgitate everything before it's too late.