TL;DR: My girlfriend has a pattern of impulsively breaking up with me during disagreements, sometimes returning a few hours later. On one occasion, she broke up with me and within five minutes contacted her ex of several years, asking him for a temporary/fake relationship because she was feeling lonely and wanted emotional closure. She later returned to me. Nothing sexual happened; my concern is entirely about the emotional aspect. I love her deeply and have never considered looking for someone else or doing something similar. However, she repeatedly tells me she can break up with me and pursue emotional connections elsewhere if she wants to. During our latest argument, I brought up the incident again because it still affects my trust. She called me delusional, said I was disrespectful, and broke up with me again. I now feel disposable and don't know whether I'm being unreasonable or whether this relationship has become unhealthy.
I'm 22M, and my girlfriend is 21F. We've been together for around a year and a half, and I'm honestly struggling to understand whether I'm being overly insecure or whether my concerns are justified.
My girlfriend has a pattern of threatening to break up or actually breaking up with me whenever we have disagreements. She has repeatedly told me that if I make small issues bigger than they need to be, she will eventually get tired and leave.
The problem is that what she considers a small issue and what I consider important are not always the same. Sometimes I want to discuss something properly, understand her perspective, or get some clarity. I'm not necessarily trying to start an argument, but I don't feel comfortable simply ignoring something that genuinely bothers me.
Her response has often been that she's done with the relationship.
What's particularly difficult is how quickly this happens. She can go from being in a relationship with me to acting as though I no longer exist. Sometimes, after a few hours, she comes back and wants to continue the relationship as if things can simply go back to normal.
This has happened multiple times, and over time, it has made me feel extremely replaceable.
However, one particular incident has made this significantly worse.
She had an ex whom she was deeply attached to for several years. Their relationship had ended a long time ago, and from what she's told me, he hadn't treated her particularly well. Nevertheless, she still seemed to have a significant emotional attachment to him because he was someone she had once loved deeply.
On one occasion, my girlfriend broke up with me during an argument. Within approximately five minutes of ending our relationship, she contacted this ex and asked him for a temporary or fake relationship.
According to her, she was feeling lonely and wanted some form of emotional closure and comfort. She spent some time with him, and eventually, after whatever she needed from that interaction was over, she contacted me again and said she wanted to be with me.
Meanwhile, I had spent that entire period crying and trying to process what had happened.
To be absolutely clear, nothing sexual happened in this entire situation. Neither my girlfriend and I nor my girlfriend and her ex have ever been sexually involved in the situations I'm describing. My concern is entirely about emotional intimacy, the attachment to her ex, and how easily she seemed able to seek that connection immediately after ending our relationship.
This wasn't even the first time something similar had happened. On another occasion, she had broken up with me and reached out to her ex seeking closure. They ended up having an extended conversation over text, after which she returned and said she wanted to continue our relationship.
There have also been other occasions where she has impulsively broken up with me and subsequently returned.
I understand that people can be confused about their feelings, and relationships aren't always straightforward. But experiencing this repeatedly has genuinely affected my sense of security.
I love this girl deeply. I've never thought about cheating on her, looking for another girl, or temporarily leaving her to seek emotional comfort elsewhere. Even during arguments, my intention has always been to resolve things and continue building our relationship.
She has told me multiple times that she could never find someone like me and that she gets emotional thinking about how much I mean to her. And I genuinely want to believe that.
But how am I supposed to reconcile those words with the fact that she can repeatedly end our relationship over disagreements and seemingly move on to someone else almost immediately?
It makes me feel like I'm worth keeping around when things are good, but completely disposable whenever things become uncomfortable.
Now, coming to what happened recently.
We had another disagreement, and during the conversation, I brought up the incident involving her ex again. I tried explaining how deeply it had affected me and why I still struggle with it.
Apparently, she really doesn't like me bringing up that situation. She considers it something that shouldn't keep being mentioned, whereas for me, it's something that has never really been resolved emotionally.
During this particular argument, I asked her a question that I genuinely wanted an answer to:
What exactly makes an issue big or small?
Because if one person has the authority to decide which issues are important and which aren't, doesn't that automatically put the other person at a disadvantage? Whenever I raise something that bothers me, it can simply be labelled an unnecessary argument or a small issue. That would mean I'm always the one supposedly making problems out of nothing. And I can assure you that this has happened a few times already, including recently.
I wasn't asking this to provoke her. I genuinely wanted to understand how we were supposed to distinguish between something worth discussing and something that should be ignored.
Her response was along the lines of, "Why are you always like this?" and "What's wrong with you?"
The conversation then escalated. She started saying that she could break up with me and go to someone else if she wanted to because, once we're no longer together, she's single and free to do whatever she wants.
I told her that, from my perspective, this behaviour feels very close to being unfaithful, even if technically it isn't cheating because the relationship has already ended.
Her response was that she had broken up with me, so technically she wasn't doing anything wrong. And that's the same reasoning she gave for the last time she did this. According to her, she was lonely.
My argument was that this technical distinction doesn't address the actual problem.
What's stopping someone from repeatedly ending a relationship whenever they want to pursue an emotional connection with someone else, doing whatever they want while the relationship is technically over, and then returning when they're ready?
I asked her how she would feel if I did exactly the same thing.
Imagine we have an argument, I break up with her, immediately approach someone else, develop an emotional connection, spend time with them, seek whatever comfort or closure I want, and then come back sometime later saying that I still love her and want to be with her.
She essentially said that I was free to do that if I wanted.
But I don't want to. I don't want to treat a relationship that way. I've never wanted to look for someone else whenever things get difficult, and I don't want to become someone who treats their partner as a temporary option.
At that point, I told her that if she genuinely chooses to do something like that, she shouldn't expect to come back to me afterwards.
I don't want to be in a relationship where someone can leave, pursue whatever emotional connection they desire, and return when they're done, expecting everything to be normal again.
And in the heat of the moment, I said, "I don't want to be like you," in response to her saying that she could do the same things because she would be single after breaking up with me.
She then considered my response disrespectful, and eventually broke up with me again.
I also asked her directly whether she would ever go back to her ex. She has repeatedly assured me that she wouldn't. However, when I once asked her to swear that she wouldn't, she refused, saying that she doesn't swear and that I should simply believe what she's telling me.
Another issue is boundaries.
I've communicated repeatedly that I don't want breaking up to become the default response to disagreements. I don't expect us to agree on everything, and I'm perfectly willing to have difficult conversations. But I want some degree of emotional security and consistency.
I've also asked her to respect certain other boundaries, but she has previously told me that boundaries can be broken depending on the circumstances.
I understand that nobody is obligated to stay in a relationship they no longer want. I'm not asking her to sacrifice her autonomy or remain with me against her wishes.
But how am I supposed to feel secure when something I've repeatedly communicated as deeply hurtful keeps happening?
This feels like constantly walking on eggshells. If I disagree with her or question something she believes, I feel like I could suddenly find myself being discarded, with her declaring herself single again.
What particularly hurts is the contradiction between what she tells me emotionally and how she behaves during disagreements. She says she could never find someone like me, gets emotional about how much I mean to her, and says she loves me. Yet, when things become uncomfortable, she seems willing to discard the relationship.
And whenever I try to discuss the incident that caused much of this insecurity, it becomes another reason for her to leave.
She has also called me delusional for thinking about the situation this way, which honestly makes me question whether I'm seeing things incorrectly.
During our latest argument, she broke up with me again. I eventually blocked her on WhatsApp because I genuinely needed to step away. I couldn't deal with another cycle of breaking up, getting hurt, and potentially getting back together as though nothing had happened.
I'm now questioning whether I have been overreacting throughout this relationship.
I know that repeatedly bringing up an old incident can become exhausting for a partner. I also understand that once someone ends a relationship, they're technically free to make their own decisions.
But I don't think wanting emotional exclusivity, consistency, and some reassurance from a committed partner is unreasonable.
I love her deeply, and that's precisely why this hurts so much. I've never wanted to look elsewhere, never considered doing something similar to her, and have always wanted to resolve our disagreements rather than abandon the relationship.
Am I being overly insecure, controlling, or unreasonable for continuing to bring up something that happened in the past?
Is it wrong to consider this kind of behaviour emotionally unfaithful, even if nothing physical or sexual happened and the relationship was technically over?
And most importantly, how do you deal with loving someone deeply while constantly feeling like you're disposable to them?
I'd genuinely appreciate some honest outside perspectives, even if you think I'm in the wrong.