Oh boy, here we go. This is going to be a very long one, fair warning. I (18yo m) have a beautiful loving and amazing gf (17yo f) who we'll call Anne. We've been together for 6 months now and its going great. We are a great match. We're both in theatre, we both like a lot of the same shows and movies, we both are kind of losers, etc. Now, im not the most attractive guy period. My best features are my long jet black wavy hair and my height at around 6'1" and maybe my glasses if someone finds that attractive. And my "cute nose" according to my best friend. Let's call her Brittany. But other than that im pretty ugly. Ive got a very square jaw and a round face cause im fat (around 285lbs). Im a decently intimidating dude tho, im no slouch, im strong enough, ive got some broad shoulders, but im not winning any races.
Me and Brittany have been friends since the summer after 9th grade. She's about 3 months older than me, her being born in November and I in January. And her newest bf, let's call him Jackoby, was born 11 days after me. Anne was born about 1 year and 2 months after me. Me, Brittany, and Jackoby are all seniors in High School. Anne is a Junior. We all live in a small town in Oregon. Now, for the situation with Brittany. I had a group back in 9th that was only held together because the cliques we looked like we'd be a part of didnt accept us. Brittany came along, she dated a few guys in that group, but ultimately none of those worked out. That summer i saw someone on Snapchat who I thought was my buddy Fred, but Brittany's display name on snap was just "Not Frederick". So I added her, and she explained it was her and I was like "oh, shit, alr cool" and we started snapping. It was during this time that she told me i "have one of those cute noses" I kept saying she was hot too because she kept saying she was ugly and i of course found her kind of attractive and i hadnt had a good friend like that for a while. Come 10th grade, we started hanging out a lot, some of the people from that group moved/dropped out/got homeschooled/got their GEDs etc. She had gotten her driver's license that year and me and her would eat in her car on lunch talking about drama going on between our friends. That's when I really started falling for her. The talking, sometimes serious talks, sometimes funny talks, sometimes no talking, just sitting in silence. Sometimes she'd cry to me. I started attempting to flirt but I was locked up for all my puberty years (COVID lockdown) so I never learned how to flirt or how to read someone's body language around my age or how to present myself. I was a little skinnier around this time, so I didnt look quite as bad. So eventually, on halloween, I decided to ask her out. Turns out, this other guy (a senior in her band class, we'll call him Jerry) had asked her out the day before. Total bs, right? Anyway, i was basically like "aw damn, alright" and we stayed cool after that. We kept talking, having sleepovers, skipping our math class, eating together during lunch, all that shit. But the whole time I still wanted to be with her. I ignored my feelings as much as I could. She started talking to me about her relationship with Jerry, and turns out, he was a total dick. Couldn't handle confrontation at ALL. He would whine and cry and give her the silent treatment for a week at a time. And the whole time I stuck with her through it because at the end of the day regardless of how i feel about her she's my best friend. I kept saying that she should leave him. Now somewhere in the back of my mind im sure I was hoping she'd leave him for me. But I was mostly meaning it as a friend trying to get my friend out of a shitty relationship. We went to a concert together while she was with Jerry. Mind you, i didnt have my license, i live 20 minutes from the nearest town where we go to school, and her dad (the house she was at) lives 40 minutes from our schools town. She came to pick me up, and then we drove an hour and a half to Portland at 5 o'clock on a Thursday to go to this concert. I was never able to convince her to leave him until he decided to break up with her during lunch one day (we had math right after lunch) so she comes into math and tells me Jerry broke up with her. I console her a little but inside im fucking ecstatic. I wait until the school year ends to start "flirting" which was awful. Then one day me, her, and a few of my friends got together to go swimming. I had told a buddy of mine I was into her and while I was in the water he told me he was gonna go tell her then he goes and whispers something in her ear but he tells me it was some random bullshit. The day continues on fine, then a bunch of my other friends tagged along and hung out. We got some pizza then went to a big open field near my buddy Fred's house. We were all laying down in the field, the couples were cuddling, and Brittany ended up laying right against me, and eventually turning to her side to face me with her hand on my cheat. Also, she smokes cigarettes so when she got up to go smoke away from the rest of the group she yelled at me to come along with her cause I didnt mind cause my mom used to smoke and by this point the smell of cigarettes reminded me of Brittany. Later on when we were all heading home, we packed a bunch of us into my friend Mary's car, her bf Will got the front seat, me, Brittany, and my buddy that told her I was into her earlier that day, Jason, got the back seat, and our friend Anton had to sit in the back trunk area of the SUV. I sat in the middle between Brittany and Jason and Brittany was laying her head on my shoulder as we dropped the other 2 off. Then when we dropped her off she told me to text her when I got home, which I did. Then she told me Jason told her I was into her and then I got pissed at Jason and didn't follow up with Brittany.
Now, it was very early in my Junior year i met Anne at board game club. I had joined our alternative learning prgram that year because i was severely behind on credits so i didnt see her that much since the program was in a seperate building (a bus came to bring us to the school for electives). But also because she was in theatre which happens at the same time as game club so i didnt see her there much either. Brittany and her current bf Jackoby also joined the program that year. I was excited cause i would get to hang out with brittany more. I started seeing Anne more because i got recruited to do crew for our spring play that year because someone left and i had to take over their jobs. When Anne and her brother (a year older than me) joined our HS theatre department, she would give me this look which is what I think made me start to fall for her. It actually got to the point where every time I hear the song "Like Nobody Else" by My Darkest Days I think of her. She's absolutely amazing and I love her so so so much. There maybe has been a little lacking in communication and she hits me when I do stupid shit but its never hard, or mean, or actually abusive. Other than that, she's amazing, and this is genuinely my healthiest relationship ever. We both love Supernatural, we both do theatre (im actually trying out acting for our spring play), we both like similar foods despite how picky I am, we like similar music. A bunch of stuff, like I said, we've been together for 6 months and its been great.
Now for the conflict. What me and Anne call our first date is a concert which I was originally going to take Brittany to, to repay the favor of taking me to that one so long ago and to make a move officially, but she recently had her hair dyed and she started having an allergic reaction to the dye and she told me to give her ticket to someone else. I gave it to Anne. It was an amazing time. That previous summer we had been hanging out a lot because I was trying to convinve myself I wasnt into Anne. And I had been coming to Anne for advice on Brittany. Then she told me she liked me and I had to think about it for about a week but obviously we ended up getting together. The problems me and Anne have are the communication and that she hits me. She says its my job to figure out whats wrong when i piss her off. The other day i apparently pissed her off so bad that she actively avoided me during rehearsal and our bingo night fundraiser and whenever I got near her she suddenly looked all pissed off but whenever I got away and she was over with her other friends she was fine. I was so confused about what I did that i started crying. She apologized but i still dont know what i did. The hitting! Its usually just like a sock to the shoulder because i said or did something stupid without realizing it, which i dont mind. But sometimes she kicks me in the leg (which recently has been a big issue cause i have a healing tattoo on my right leg), punches my stomach, or slaps the back of my head too hard. I wanna bring it up to her but i dont like confronting people abiut this stuff because my dad was abusive for years and whenever i try it just reminds me of him. Also, Brittany and Jackoby have been arguing a bit and its over some pretty serious stuff, he cannot remember that she allergic to strawberries for the life of him. The three of us all got stranded because mine and Brittany's cars broke down and when my dad came to rescue us he brought strawberry shortcake roles (we were in the middle of nowhere with no service necause we were going to check out a campsite and hadnt had food all day and hiked to the ranger station to call our parents) and Jackoby goes "Babe, you want some?" Me and Brittany just look at him and hes so confused. We all give him shit for it but it is a serious thing between them. He also asks really stupid questions and Brittany jokes about channeling her inner Anne if Jackoby doesn't stfu.
So, my point is sometimes i still get that same feeling when i talk with Brittany as i did back in 10th grade even though i love Anne and this is my first healthy relationship. She came with me and my dad to get my first tattoo for fuck sakes. Im just really lost on what i should do in this situation. I really need advice. Please.
TL:DR I think I might still be in love with my best friend even though I am dating a great girl and she's pretty happy with her bf too.