r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/[deleted] • Aug 19 '20
Important Article When Surgeons Fail Their Trans Patients on Gender Confirming Surgery NSFW
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/HiddenStill • Feb 07 '25
Mod Post The future of this sub NSFW
After this sub was "accidentally" banned 2 days ago there's been a lot of discussion about the future of the sub.
Whether it was an accident to not, the possibility exists that this sub and others will be banned from reddit in the near future. In the event that happens what do we do?
I started as a mod here when the sub had only 3k members and my intention was to grow it to where it is today, and more. I last wrote about how the sub is moderated in 2022.
In principle, it would be better to have an trans resource site independent of reddit and corporate control. In practice its very difficult to achieve for a number of reasons
There's no point in moving to another site like Discord which is susceptible to the same risks as reddit. i.e. based in the USA. But what other sites are there, and where else is safe in the long run? Not just safe from hostile governments, but whoever runs the community losing interest, or data (susans.org lost years of it with a hard drive crash), selling out, etc.
Neither Discord and Facebook are indexed by search engines making it difficult for people to discover the resources in the first place, or finding information once you're there. It's like a black hole for knowledge; you put it in and it disappears. Personally, I'd never waste my time on building this kind of community on sites like that.
Reddit also provides, or did, legal protection. If a surgeon doesn't like what's posted here they can't easily censor it. And especially important, they can't attack me personally as its not my responsibility. Good luck going after reddit corporate.
As one of the largest social media sites in the world reddit makes it easy to build community, there's so many of us already here. People have mentioned sites like Lemmy as alternatives, but as far as I can tell they have tiny membership and few people have even heard of them.
A major advantage for me was reddit's wiki's. Few subs take advantage of them, but I believe its a great way to build and spread knowledge, and it has helped build this sub and raise the general level of knowledge. People have asked that it be copied off site, but if this sub disappears many of the links in the wiki will also disappear. Its not nearly so useful at that point. I don't think anyone else will build or maintain a wiki either, as it seems to interest very few people.
Regardless if reddit banning this sub or not, I'd like to see another site even better than this one, but I'm not sure its possible. Even more so while reddit hosts trans content as 99% of people will just come here anyway. Reddit basically killed old style forums years ago and nothing's changed since then.
It's even more difficult to build a trans surgery surgery community on another site while this sub exists because its so big and useful that almost no one would bother going there. And I'm not shutting the sub down to force everyone to move to another site. That would cause immediate harm to people who use the sub.
If this sub does get shut down I personally won't be trying to rebuild elsewhere. I'm burned out with this and don't have the energy.
If anyone wants to discuss how to build a successful trans surgery community I'm willing to offer my advice. I'd like to see it happen and it would be great if people had a place to go, and knew about it ahead of time. My main aim is to help people, and it doesn't matter to me where that comes from.
Edit
If you set up any external resources for surgery, hrt, etc please add them in the comments here. And I suggest people save the links in case this sub, or worse, all trans content on reddit disappears.
There’s a number of people talking about off site projects they are considering or actually doing. Persons you could get together and discuss if you could work together.
This looks interesting r/RedditAlternatives
There's some cisgender people wanting to comment here in support of Lemmy and other reddit alternatives. Rule 5 limits cis people on this sub, but I'll allow it on this post only and give them a flair "cisgender reddit alternatives". If you're one of them please don't comment elsewhere.
Other reddit posts
- https://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/1ii61jm/so_transgender_surgeries_subreddit_just_got_nuked
- https://www.reddit.com/r/MtF/comments/1ii6qfw/rtransgender_surgeries_was_banned_an_hour_ago
- https://www.reddit.com/r/germantrans/comments/1ii6y7y/reddit_purge_beginnt_voran_transgender_surgeries
Media
- 2025-02-05 - https://www.newsweek.com/transgender-surgery-subreddit-disappearing-bug-2026965 by Rachel Dobkin
- 2025-02-06 - https://www.engadget.com/social-media/reddit-blames-bug-after-banning-more-than-90-nsfw-subreddits-221908069.html by Karissa Bell -- "The nature of the affected subreddits has alarmed some users and moderators who worry the company may be getting ready for a bigger crackdown. In r/transgender_surgeries, where users discuss their medical care, members began to discuss ways to “back up” the content of the subreddit. ""
Lemmy Discussion
Lemmy keeps getting mentioned. I don't know much about it yet. Its pitched as Fediverse reddit replacement.
According to the statistics here Lemmy has 477,049 total users and 45,194 monthly active users. The trans instance https://lemmy.blahaj.zone has 8671 total users and 971 monthly active users.
This sub alone has 93,419 members, and in the last 30 days 4.6M views, an average of 20.2k daily unique visits, 4.0 subscribed, and 1.2k unsubscribed. The main FTM surgery subs in total have about that again, and the HRT subs are a bit larger in total.
This sub is then 10 times the size of the main trans Lemmy instance, and the total with the subs I mentioned is approaching the entire size of Lemmy. This doesn't include all the very main trans subs which are individually many times larger as I only included the important medical subs.
I have a few reservations about Lemmy, partly because I know so little at this point
Can Lemmy can scale to the size required if trans content was banned on reddit.
I couldn't find much information on Lemmy's moderation tools. Currently this sub attracts a lot of hate and chasers, which moderation easily takes care of. In the past the have been excessive amounts, but reddit has cracked down on it, and provides tools to limit it (not very good ones). Lemmy would be unusable without this.
Lemmy works by sharing data across multiple instances (computers) and it appears there seem to be privacy concerns about the amount of data on users that is shared.
What is to stop the owners of the instance shutting it down, or the data being lost for any other reason? Although not a corporate it makes no difference. There would be a massive loss of knowledge and history.
If anyone has expert knowledge on Lemmy I'd be interested in learning more.
The author of the Engadget article on the sub's ban made a YouTube video on the Fediverse
- The future of decentralized social media by Engadget (Karissa Bell)
Discussion on Lemmy
- https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/post/21815813
- https://mlmym.lemmy.blahaj.zone/post/21815813 if you like old reddit
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/One_Odd_Egg • 3h ago
My FFS experience with Dr Shih and Dr Kleinberger in Norcal Kaiser (Before and After) NSFW
So I think there is a lack of kaiser posts here, especially when it comes to Nor Cal so I wanted to share my experience. I am currently 7 weeks post op. The only results about these surgeons I could find in the past were not so positive.
Waiting time:
From the first message to receiving the surgery it took around 3 years. This was partly due to the fact I was diagnosed with a mental illness, and they said I was not in the right mind to consent to major surgery. That delay however only added around 6 months. The copay blew me away and was only 150 dollars.
The surgeons:
I only met Dr Shih twice, one for the consult where he showed me a collection of results, and the second time at the operating bed. His bedside manner was very calming and reassuring. He went over my concerns and even showed me how far my brow lift would be with markers since that was one of my biggest concerns. I never met Dr Kleinberger, even though I was aware he would be operating on me from the consult.
The experience:
I immediately had cold feet and was panicking, even after the surgeon reassured me. They sedated me with some medication and I was out before I was even wheeled into the operating room. It was a 9 hour surgery with no complications. The hospital at San Leandro was a completely different hospital experience than anything I have experienced before. I had one nice nurse and the rest were very blunt, and not very trans friendly. I had my own room, however there was lots of screaming throughout the night through the hallways. I slept for maybe three hours at max. I was not discharged until late in the afternoon the next day.
The results:
Scalp advancement: Just wow, it is completely rounded off and I no longer have signs of the stereotypical male hairline. I am not afraid of my bangs blowing up in the wind other than it revealing my scar line. However, it might be due to my aftercare or just a general complication, I lost a concerning amount of hair, especially around the incision site. (Also from someone who has seen a lot of shoddy suture, stitch, and staple work, my hairline was a work of art.)
Brow Lift:
Let me tell you how worried I was when I first saw the results. They were plastered up and I looked perpetually shocked. After a few weeks they settled down, and the biggest change is the arch is more defined, other than that they are a tiny bit raised from their original spot.
Brow bone shave and orbital rim contouring:
This is my favorite result from these surgeons, it is so incredible to look directly up and have a view not blocked by a brow bone. My side profile is infinitely better and I don't mind looking at photos when I am caught off guard. Before the surgery I had drooping on my right side that was corrected and is now even. The rim contouring is my favorite, I used to avoid using eye shadow since it would highlight my orbital bone, that fear is gone and I am actually having to relearn eye shadow for my new eye shape.
Mandibuloplasty:
This is what I am the least happy with at the moment, they really rounded out my chin, and now my jaw has a more square appearance. I am praying that it is just the swelling still going down. I have recovered almost all feeling in my jaw, and my lower lip has completely recovered from the nerve damage.
Tracheal Shave:
This is my second favorite result, its like I never even had an Adams apple. The incision is well placed and I'm sure as it heals further will be unnoticeable. It however has made voice training a bit harder as I really cant feel where my larynx is at but I would rather that then how dysphoric it made me
How I feel and my general experience:
My facial dysphoria is mostly gone(thanks jawline), and I feel more comfortable in my skin. By no means is my face passable without makeup, but the important part is I feel at ease. I am unsure if I have been gendered correctly more often, but when I do get clocked it hurts a bit worse now. I have noticed more when I get gendered male, but I think that is just availability heuristics. My friends, partners, and family all told me something along the lines of "I look the same, but its like a switch was flipped and I get viewed as more feminine."
If I could pay out of pocket for a more aggressive surgeon I would, but I am perfectly fine with these results, although subtle they make me extremely happy. These surgeons did a wonderful job reversing the bone growth from puberty, and I could not be more pleased. They are very subtle but they know what they are doing.
Side note:
Sorry for the before and after this is the best I can find in the relatively same pose!
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Electronic_Set4043 • 1h ago
HEY YALL 🎉 I have exactly 6 months until my Bigg day. I can’t believe it’s finally gonna happen. NSFW
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/anavocadoothaaanks • 22h ago
1 year post op. Suggestions for revision? NSFW
I‘m some months over one year post op. Photos are all from around 8-14 months post op. When i‘m standing or have my legs not spread i think its pretty, but as soon as i spread my legs (like as for missionary) i think it looks weird and ugly. I booked a revision for yhe top scar at the anterior commisure and to reduce some left over erectile tissue.
Any other suggestions? is it possible to make the vulva appear slimmer when legs are spread without making dilation more of a hassle? i‘m currently dilating one a week just fine with the intimate rose size 8 and have around 14 cm of depth. I dont want to loose any function.
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/roseMothGirl • 9h ago
My srs surgery is next Monday, I'm freaking out in the good way! NSFW
I'm so nervous now and I have 4 days until the hospitalization on Sunday. Surgery is 6 am I don't think I will be able to sleep properly that night...
Everything is ready, all itens bought... There's only my bag to pack but that is only Saturday
I know there's still time for something to go wrong but I'm just so happy now. And nervous.
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Evoidit • 6h ago
How should my expectations be and could FFS make me pass in the future?? NSFW
Ok so for context, I(24mtf) started hormones two weeks ago, which I'm very happy about, but I am also a bit worried about my starting point.
I definitely got a big dose of testosterone through puberty and I feel like my face screams "MAN"💔. It does get better with makeup and now with laser hair removal, but I feel very dysphoric over my face.
Now I am expecting HRT to fill out and round out my face, but it feels unrealistic to expect me to look that different really. I'll still look like me you know... I do like parts of my face, and I would call myself conventionally attractive by guy standards, but will that carry over?? Atleast my body will likely look pretty good.
Could I get some of your wisdom/experience? Would FFS, browbone, nose, adams apple and maybe chin, be able to take me far? Would I maybe need a further surgery? What do you recommend?
Also just how bad do I have it? Like relatively speaking? I mean this is a pre hrt body/face but still, will I be able to turn this around? Will I get clocked forever?
Thank you for your time ❤️ Looking through other people FFS results in this sub has given me a little hope.
(Oh btw, will be buying a better wig soon lol, instead of that 20 dollar one, so hairwise that is my solution, not gonna do hair transplants or expect regrowth, been losing hair for around 8-9 years)
Edit: On a positive note, since this post is a bit depressing and showcasing a lowpoint, I am very hopeful for my happiness going forward and I am quite mentally healthy now! It's only gonna get better from now on, I'm gonna get more comfortable presenting feminine and I will only get closer to my goal from now on. ❤️ My appearance right now is a bit of a car wreck, but also this is the most masculine I will ever look thanks to HRT! Life is going in a very good direction!! 🫶
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/viuhe_gaming • 2h ago
i hate the idea of dilating. NSFW
MTF, 2.5 yrs HRT, demisexual / asexual, Pan, 19 yrs old
haven't had bottom surgery yet and I really hate the idea of having to dilate or have sex just to maintain depth. I've also heard that having sex can replace dilating depending on frequency and like how long it's been from your surgery.
Anyways, I'm like fine with sex and it feels nice yea but like I don't have the urge to do stuff. And that kinda includes dilating because well you get aroused and stuff its just, i would really hate how frequently I would have to do it and I feel so ashamed to even masturbate. And like I would be fine with sex if i just didnt have to have it so often as I dilate. Also I would probably STILL have to dilate if said person and I only finger me yknow??? and also that relying on having said person in the first place AND WHAT IF THEY ARE ASEXUAL OR LIKE WEVE ONLY DATING FOR A YEAR AND I DONT FEEL COMFORTABLE DOING THAT STUFF YET! ugh
Maybe I'm crazy but I just wish I was born a girl and didn't have to deal with all the complications of a trans person.
I'm proud of my identity, but i really hate being trans.
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Decape_Gahlu_1015 • 9h ago
Girls who get shallow depth or limited depth --- please think it as "full depth lite", not "zero depth plus" NSFW
Disclaimer
I mean shallow depth as in ones with depth more than 3 cm but less than 10 cm, sometimes referred to as "limited depth". It's different from those with only 1-2cm dimple but no real canal.
Body text
I got shallow-depth vulvoplasty at Dr. Kyulhee Kim 5 weeks ago and the recovery has been generally smooth, and the aesthetics have been great. I have made 2 posts and will take another photo at 2 months and make another post.
However, during my recovery, I have realised that shallow or limited depth, I mean specifically those are not used interchangably with zero depth, is much better understood as a lighter version of full depth non-PI skin graft technique rather than "zero depth with a bonus".
There is dilation. Lighter than full depth (for me it isn't painful, and the duration is shorter, discomfort lighter), and usually temporary (a few months), but still. Without dilation it will close up.
My vaginal canal was 5.5 cm at first and now it's only reaching 5.5cm with size 1 and 4-4.5 cm with size 4 dilator.
It can and does bleed. It can and does have discharge. Just like a full depth skin grafted vagina.
You'll need to douche it, once a day, for a few months.
Recovery is faster than full depth, but comparable to or slower than zero depth.
Theoretically you can have all the complications specific to full depth such as fistulas, granulation etc, just that the risk is substantially lower.
I picked shallow depth because I mainly wanted the existence of a vaginal canal for self-image reasons, not the penetrative sexual function of it; ideally it would be full depth but any depth would have done 90% of the job; I am aroace, somewhat slightly lesbian so not interested in penetrative sex; I might want some fingering; I am scared of the more severe complications associated with full depth; I wanted to "end the battle", not stuck with dilation and maintenance for life.
But it helps to think minimum or limited or shallow depth as a reduced version of full depth non-PI, not zero depth. Recovery can involve a lot of things irrelevant in zero-depth.
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/greengav • 21h ago
Not sure what to think NSFW
8 months post op. 1 month post op revision (not cosmetic) loveeee my vagina so much but ive started to look at her sideways since I crossed the 8 month mark. I don’t know if it’s just anxiety. I know my clit is large and theres not rlly a hood. I suppose I could seek a revision. Let me know what you think
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Anonymyne353 • 3h ago
1 Year Post-Op. Ask me anything! NSFW
The actual 1 year anniversary was a few days ago, but I figured I’d offer to answer any questions some of you might have about vaginoplasty in regards to anything surgery related, aftercare, feeling, sensations, among other things.
This won’t be in proper AMA format, but I’ll reply to any post on here, and if you have follow-up questions, just tag me on the reply!
Looking forward to talking with you guys!
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/LonelyArxa • 2h ago
How useful are those 1-3 cm with pushing the dilator in? NSFW
Hi, I'm currently 7 months post op normal PI with urethral graft and I wanted to ask people who had the surgery a while back, how useful is the extra space you can push with your dilator with extra force? When having penetrative sex with a partner, is it actually possible to use that extra length or is it just for "stretching purpose" for medical care? Thank youuu
In my theory, while the tissue softens over the years, it could be used for more comfortable penetration in the future?
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/ItsTooLate_LostSheep • 21h ago
About 4 months post-op with Dr Stiller. NSFW
These results are part of the first stage, which is a zero-depth procedure. I’m doing the second stage, which uses the right ascending colon, in the summer of next year. But even with only half a pussy I feel SO good. I can orgasm safely, I create a teeny teeny bit of self-lubrication, my thighs touch higher up (thank godddddd) and I feel like…1,000,000x better. I’m so glad I did this. I know this isn’t like…the platonic vulva, but she’s mine and I adore her.
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/FREYA_4 • 10h ago
NHS vs Suporn vs other vaginoplasty options — how do I make an informed decision? NSFW
I’m UK-based, currently on the NHS pathway for vaginoplasty, and trying to work out which surgeon and technique would best meet my needs.
Anecdotally, I’ve heard that NHS penile inversion results aren’t as good as those from places like Suporn Clinic. However, I’m conscious that this may be biased, as the only trans women I personally know who’ve had surgery went to Suporn.
My main priorities are:
- Natural-looking aesthetics
- Self-lubrication during arousal, ideally enough for penetration without additional lubricant
- Good sexual sensation and adequate depth
I don’t have loads of money, but I also don’t want to compromise on these priorities. My options are essentially to go through the NHS, spend several years saving for private surgery, or potentially find an employer whose health insurance covers gender-affirming surgery.
I’m aware of the different vaginoplasty techniques, including PIV, Suporn/Chonburi, peritoneal and intestinal approaches, but I’m struggling to establish which actually offers the best outcomes for what I want.
I also don’t want to pigeonhole myself into choosing Suporn simply because it’s what I’m familiar with.
Does anyone know of good comparative resources, studies or patient outcome data that could help me weigh up the options?
I’d love to hear personal experiences too, but I’m conscious that most people can only speak to the technique they’ve personally had, making objective comparisons difficult.
Please excuse any ignorance or incorrect info!
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/rainmouse • 14m ago
Flying overseas for bottom surgery soon. What should I not forget to pack? NSFW
For reference, I will be travelling alone to Thailand (Wansiri). As I have pretty high level ADHD and I always forget essentials. So, for the first time in my life I will make a checklist.
Do you have any suggestions for things other than the basics that I should include?
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Due_Imagination_3681 • 6h ago
Pain when touching eye socket at a certain point after FFS NSFW
I had FFS with a brow shave a long time ago and when I accidentally touch a kind of a small hole in my eye socket above my eye I feel like a jolt of pain.
Its not something that happens often so it doesn't bother me that much but I wonder if this could be a serious problem worth getting checked out?
The location is roughly central above my right eye on the height of my eyebrow maybe a bit more to my nose and inwards if that makes sense.
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/ava_harper • 11h ago
Decision making: Peritoneal pull vs penile inversion & dilation regime question. Please help. 😀 NSFW
I am keen to ask a question about bottom surgery.
For years I was thinking that one day I would like to have a peritoneal pull vaginoplasty because I prefer how the inside of the vagina feels less like skin and more like vaginal mucosa, and the lack of need for dilating. I’ve now found that the peritoneal technique does require dilating. I’m now just really keen to know whether it is worth it just for the difference in feeling inside.
I have always been concerned about dilating. I am an RN that works long hours and I just don’t know how easy it is to fit in the dilating schedule. My work days are 7:30am till 9pm three days a week. I leave home for work about 6:15 am and I get home about 9:30pm. I wouldn’t want to be stuck not having time to dilate and lose depth. I really don’t mind dilating but worried about working such antisocial hours.
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/swaghotmothman • 10h ago
Massachusetts surgeons for FFS GRS NSFW
Has anyone had any surgeries in Massachusetts and what was your experience plus results?
I'm moving from Florida to mass finally and don't know any trans women there or who to ask about surgeons in the area
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Sherwin_1997 • 1d ago
I regretted my SRS I missed the ex version of myself NSFW
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/elliewilliams1092 • 13h ago
Choosing an FFS Surgeon in the US NSFW
I live in new england and have mostly been looking at ffs clinics near there, such as dr spiegel, but I also am probably going to pay out of pocket and I have about 47 thousand dollars available.
I mostly wanted to get work done on my jaw and chin, i have a pretty feminine face and I'm open to other minor things but the only things that really cause me significant dysphoria is my jaw/chin.
I've also been considering deschamps braly, but they're more expensive in consults and surgery, and I don't want to pay a lot for something I could get for less that's basically the same thing since I'm not doing full service FFS
Does anyone have any advice on where to look with my budget?
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Interesting_You2843 • 11h ago
Srs in 3 weeks in Belgium tips or advice? NSFW
Hi everyone,
I have my operation in 3 weeks in Belgium with Dr Sommeling I have been looking for any advice and tips for my package and what i need to buy when I get home. Are there any tips or advice from the girls who have the feeling “oh I wish I know this” so I can be 100% prepared. Otherwise I live by myself do I need to meal prep? And what should I make? Thankyou so much. There is not much information in this group about Belgium Surgery so I’am thinking about posting my general here. 💗
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/itsjustmepixie • 18h ago
Is it normal for a surgeon to want to reposition your nipples during breast augmentation/revision? NSFW
Hey, I’m planning a revision and my surgeon said one of my nipples sits higher than the other and he wants to surgically move/recenter them at the same time as fixing the implants. i’m kind of scared about the extra scarring and possible loss of sensation. Is this a pretty normal thing surgeons recommend, or does it usually only happen in certain cases and has anyone had their nipples repositioned during an augmentation or revision, and if so, How did the scars and sensation end up?
Would appreciate any honest experiences.
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Madison_Devereux • 20h ago
I just got approved for my consult with a urologist! Questions in comments. NSFW
Okay, so I am starting with full gender reassignment after 4 years of hormones. It is covered by my insurance and thought they were going to start me out with FFS, but the referral that came back was from my urologist!!
faint
So now I have a lot to think about. I want PPV. I was hoping that any of you ladies who had gone with PPV might tell me about the pain scale for the healing process, and your experience with your kitty after it was all healed? Im excited because I have wanted a vagina since before puberty, and also scared because I have never had surgery or been put under anesthesia before.
Thank you and Im so fricking excited, Im so fricking excited, IM SO FRICKING EXCITED!!!!!
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/Jar_of_lameness • 13h ago
Deschamps Discord NSFW
I have an upcoming consultation and was wondering if anyone had the link to his Discord? I'd be really grateful!
r/Transgender_Surgeries • u/roseMothGirl • 1d ago
Terrified of spilling out secrets because of anesthesia NSFW
So I'm talking with the anesthetist who's explaining to me how it works.
I have a situation. My mom will be there with me. And there are some pretty traumatic things that I went through as a child that I don't want her to discover.
I'm working with my therapist, but regardless I don't want her to know.
Is there any way for me to not talk about these things while under the effect of anesthesia, when I'm going in or waking up? Maybe it's an irrational fear, but still.