THIS IS A LONG POST. NO ONE IS FORCED TO READ LOL
Hi all! First-time Reddit poster here. I’ve been listening to the show for quite a while now and thought this audience might be able to help me out. I’m not sure if I’m looking for an AITAH response or just some advice. Maybe both?
Like the title says, my best friend of five years uninvited me from her baby shower for spoiling her proposal. I know that, based solely on the title, I probably look like a complete asshole. In this situation, I know I’m not 100% innocent and could have gone about things a little differently, but I’m still struggling to accept how everything played out.
Please let me know your thoughts and what I should do, if there’s anything left to do. We’ll call my ex-best friend Nicole and her boyfriend, Jerry.
Nicole and I became friends five years ago. Before she and Jerry got together, we had never really fought. We thought very similarly and never ran into situations that caused disagreements. She had more of a party lifestyle, while I’ve been in a long-term relationship and have a child, so our lives were pretty different. Despite that, we got along incredibly well.
She also lived almost an hour away, so most of our communication was over FaceTime. She moved back to her home state shortly after my son was born, and we maintained our friendship that way. Honestly, that’s when our friendship really started to blossom. She had a falling-out with most of her party friends and didn’t really have anybody. I went out to visit her, and we would FaceTime while working since we both work alone.
When she moved back, she was really wanting to find a partner. That’s when she met Jerry. They had been dating for about two months before I met him.
At first, Nicole had nothing but great things to say about him. She would call me and our mutual friend, who we’ll call Ellie, and tell us about all the sweet and romantic things he would do for her. He never let her pay for anything, planned every date, bought her flowers, etc. Both Ellie and I were so happy for her.
Things seemed to be going great until Nicole and I had our first argument.
Jerry wanted to throw a Halloween party the weekend before Halloween. She brought it up to me at the beginning of the month, and I told her I would love to meet him and that we would try our best to attend. I also mentioned that I wanted to take my son to a Halloween event at the zoo that my aunt used to take my sister and me to when we were younger.
At the time, I didn’t realize the zoo event was only happening on the exact same day as Jerry’s party. I thought it was going on throughout the month.
About two weeks before the party, I let Nicole know what was going on and explained that we were really bummed we wouldn’t be able to make it. However, that was the only day the zoo was hosting the event.
Nicole had always been an understanding person, so I didn’t think it would be a huge deal. She responded, “Okay, so we’ll see you after?”
I explained that we would love to, but the zoo was over an hour from my house. We would have to drive an hour back to drop my son off with my parents and then drive another hour in the opposite direction to get to Jerry’s party. By that point, the party would already be over since they had only rented the apartment clubhouse for a few hours.
She ghosted me for a while. When I eventually asked if everything was okay, she explained that she felt like I wasn’t making an effort to meet Jerry.
I felt pretty bad, but that genuinely wasn’t the case. We had simply chosen to take my son to an event he was excited about. She didn’t seem to understand that, and I ended up apologizing just to let it go and move on.
After that, I started feeling like our friendship was changing. It seemed like more and more problems were coming up, and they all seemed to revolve around Jerry.
We were still very close and FaceTimed almost every day while we worked. Shortly after Halloween, Nicole started expressing concerns about her relationship that raised a lot of red flags for Ellie and me.
We both started noticing narcissistic tendencies. Nicole would even acknowledge that he was toxic and call him a narcissist herself.
For example, if she posted a selfie, he would question who she was posting it for, which would turn into a huge argument. If she wanted to hang out with some of her old party friends, he would get upset. Eventually, she cut those people off because of him.
Those are just a couple of examples.
Even though Nicole recognized that his behavior wasn’t healthy, she continued the relationship. They had only been together for a couple of months at that point, and there were already constant fights.
Fast-forward to February of this year. Nicole found out she was pregnant. Jerry was actually out of town on a business trip when she found out. I was on the phone with her when she took the test, and he was upset about that. He said he wanted to be there, which is fair, but she had also chosen to test before he got back because she wasn’t sure how she would react to the news. She had told me the pregnancy wasn’t planned.
I was so excited for her. I was genuinely looking forward to being the village I didn’t have when I had my son.
After her first doctor’s appointment, she asked me to be her gender keeper, and I was ECSTATIC. We immediately started brainstorming ideas. Jerry wanted a huge, extravagant gender reveal, while Nicole wanted something more private and intimate because all of her family lived out of state and wouldn’t realistically be able to come down for a gender reveal and then a separate baby shower.
We talked about different ideas for both options, and I even planned on including some little surprises that I knew she would love.
Shortly after that, Jerry reached out to me. He told me he wanted to propose to Nicole and asked if, as her best friend, I would help him put everything together.
Honestly, I had mixed feelings about it. However, Nicole was still with him and having his baby, and I wanted to help make the proposal as special as possible for her.
I helped him pick out the ring. Nicole had been talking to me about her dream proposal for YEARS at this point. She had even told Jerry that if he ever planned on proposing, he should run everything by me because I knew exactly what she wanted.
The biggest things for her were:
Having her family and friends there, or at least being aware of the proposal.
Having her nails done.
Ideally waiting until after the baby was born so she could look and feel her best.
Despite the pregnancy and the upcoming proposal, Jerry’s behavior didn’t seem to change. If anything, it seemed to be getting worse.
I noticed Nicole becoming more distant, especially when it came to plans we made together. We still FaceTimed, but since she lived about an hour away, we didn’t get much face-to-face time to begin with.
I started feeling like Jerry was slowly isolating her.
At this point, she had already stopped hanging out with her other friends and was really only maintaining friendships with Ellie and me over FaceTime. For Ellie, that made sense because she lived in Nicole’s home state. But Nicole and I really weren’t that far apart, and I noticed I was seeing her in person less and less.
Jerry would start arguments with her if we were on the phone while she was home. Eventually, she was only allowed to talk on the phone if she was at work.
There was one occasion when my family and I invited Nicole and Jerry to an F1 event near their side of town. Nicole texted me that morning and said she and Jerry had been arguing all morning and wouldn’t be able to make it.
I later found out that their argument started because they had gone to get coffee that morning. While in the drive-through, another car cut in front of them. Jerry became extremely angry. Nicole told him to relax and just get behind the car, but Jerry blew up. He swerved the car out of line and started screaming at Nicole, telling her that she needed to trust him and let him make the calls.
It didn’t make much sense to me, and I’m sorry if I’m not explaining it very well.
Nicole knew this wasn’t appropriate behavior for a grown man, but she brushed it off.
I was disappointed they couldn’t make it, but I was more concerned about Nicole.
The following weekend, we had plans with them again to attend a food event, also near their side of town. Keep in mind, both of these events had been planned by my husband and me, and we drove over an hour to spend time with them.
That morning, Nicole texted me saying her aunt and uncle were in town and they were going to get breakfast. She wasn’t sure if she would be able to make it.
I was confused because our plans weren’t until later that evening. I’m not going to lie, I was a little annoyed. This would be the second weekend in a row that our plans were potentially falling through.
I responded, “You’re all good.”
She asked if I was upset, and I explained that I was just a little bummed that our plans might fall through again. She responded that she wanted to prioritize our plans and would let me know if she could make it.
Well, later that evening, she never showed up or communicated with me.
My family still went and had a great time.
When I got home, I noticed I had a missed call from my sister. I wanted to check her location before calling her back in case she was out with friends.
When I opened Find My Friends, I noticed Nicole was right next to me. I clicked on her location and saw she was less than five minutes from my house.
I texted her and asked what she was doing on my side of town. She told me Jerry had made last-minute plans with a buddy, and they were visiting him.
I was honestly really hurt and upset.
I didn’t even respond. I wanted to give myself some time to process why she would do that. Why would she tell me she might not make it because she had breakfast plans with her family, then tell me she would let me know if she could come, never communicate with me, and ultimately go to last-minute plans Jerry made?
I was also confused about why, knowing where I lived, she wouldn’t have at least tried to get together if she couldn’t make it to the event.
When I eventually brought it up, she didn’t apologize. She tried explaining that the plans were last-minute.
I explained that was exactly where my confusion was coming from. Last-minute plans? When you already had plans?
I never got a real answer.
Instead, she started deflecting and said that I, of all people, should understand canceling plans at the last minute because I had canceled on her for Jerry’s Halloween party to take my son to the zoo.
I didn’t think those two situations were comparable at all, and I was taken aback that she would even relate them.
She then told me she would reach back out when she was ready to talk about it.
This wasn’t the first time she had decided when we were allowed to talk about something, although I didn’t recognize that pattern until right before our friendship ended.
We eventually talked again, and she essentially said the same things. I can’t remember every detail of that conversation, but long story short, I never got a real explanation for why she bailed on our plans, and somehow I ended up apologizing.
I just wanted to keep the peace and move on because this was my closest friend. After having my son, I didn’t have many friends, and I didn’t want to lose her. So I brushed it off and moved forward.
We continued planning her baby shower. They still hadn’t decided whether they wanted something big or small and intimate. They were also going back and forth about the venue and date because of scheduling conflicts with everyone. Everything was still up in the air.
In April, she called me sobbing.
She told me that she and Jerry had barely spoken all day because he had been extremely busy with work. Jerry had told her he was going to have a late night, so Nicole came home, cleaned her apartment, made herself dinner, and eventually fell asleep.
Jerry got home around 9:30 p.m. and, according to Nicole, slammed the door open and started screaming at her because she hadn’t even offered to make him dinner. He told her he had such a long day and she hadn’t considered him.
She started yelling back, and then he told her to stop yelling.
Nicole told me Jerry said, “I’m not your ex. You don’t need to yell at me.”
She lost it.
She called me asking if she could stay at my house, and without hesitation, I told her absolutely.
She was also on the phone with Ellie while heading over, and Ellie was telling her to pack her things and leave immediately. She was livid. She told Nicole this wasn’t a situation she wanted to bring her baby into.
I figured Nicole had already heard all of that from Ellie and didn’t need to hear it again from me.
Nicole told me she wanted to leave, and if it weren’t for the baby, she would. But she felt stuck and scared. I felt absolutely horrible for her.
I wanted to help so badly, but I didn’t know what else I could do.
I tried encouraging her and reminding her that she had support. No matter how scary everything seemed at the moment, she would find a way through it.
We stayed up for hours talking. I told her that ultimately it was her decision, but if she chose to stay, I strongly encouraged them both to go to therapy.
She expressed concerns about her child growing up around someone who behaved that way, and we all thought she was going to leave.
Well… she stayed.
And we continued hearing about how emotionally abusive he was. She never even mentioned therapy to him.
I had heard that you shouldn’t push someone to leave an abusive relationship because it can sometimes cause them to cut everyone off, and the situation could become worse. So I NEVER told her she needed to leave, and I never expressed how I personally felt about him.
I just listened to her vent over and over again.
Honestly, I was becoming incredibly drained and emotionally exhausted, but I never wanted her to feel like she couldn’t escape or that she didn’t have someone to turn to. So I continued being that person for her.
After that incident, Jerry really started isolating her from me.
At one point, Nicole wanted to plan a double date, but Jerry said he wasn’t comfortable being around me because I was the person she had run to after their argument.
At that point, I knew she needed to get away from this man, or our friendship was slowly going to fade.
I also started becoming concerned about the upcoming proposal. She had made it very clear to Jerry that she wanted me involved, but now he wasn’t even comfortable being around me.
I decided to break the ice and try to get over that hurdle, so I reached out to him and asked how the proposal planning was going.
He told me he was planning to propose that upcoming weekend when they went to California to visit some of his friends.
I asked if her family knew, and he said no.
That was something she had specifically said she wanted.
He then asked if I could help prepare her by getting our nails done together. I agreed because I felt like that was a way for me to still be involved.
Well, only a few days later, Nicole, Ellie, and I were on the phone.
Nicole mentioned that she had a feeling Jerry was going to propose soon. We asked why she thought that, and she explained that he had been talking about getting matching outfits for California and asking about what nail design she was going to get.
We asked how she felt about that.
She told us she wouldn’t love it because she was pregnant and felt like shit, her family and friends wouldn’t be there, and she had just broken off her entire nail and wouldn’t even be able to get her nails done.
She then said, “So if you guys know anything, maybe say something.”
Once Nicole got off the phone, Ellie and I discussed what to do. Ellie suggested we tell Jerry and said I should be the one to call him.
I also reached out to Nicole’s sister-in-law, who we’ll call Bethany. Bethany agreed that someone should tell him.
Since Jerry had only told me about the proposal, we all figured I should be the one to say something.
Now, this may have been my mistake, but I chose to text him rather than call.
He works in sales and is on the phone with clients all day. I was nervous he wouldn’t find the time to talk to me before they left, so I sent him a message.
I said something along the lines of:
“Hey Jerry. I’m really sorry to tell you this, but Nicole was just on the phone with Ellie and me, and she mentioned that she has a feeling you may be proposing in California. She said she wouldn’t love that because she would rather have you wait until after the baby is here, her friends and family won’t be there, and she’s unable to get her nails done at the moment. We obviously didn’t say anything to her, but I felt like I should at least let you know.”
He responded with, “WTF.”
I apologized, and he just gave the message a thumbs-up.
About an hour later, Nicole called me.
Before I could even say hello, she said, “Tell me what’s going on.”
She sounded confused and a little angry.
I asked what she meant.
She explained that Jerry had texted her saying they needed to talk about their future and whether they were on the same page.
I continued playing dumb until she finally said, “I know he’s going to propose. Just tell me what happened.”
She sounded upset and confused about why she had received that message from him, so I told her the truth. Yes, he was planning on proposing.
She asked if her family knew, and I told her no.
She was LIVID that he was planning to propose without considering what she actually wanted.
She kept asking me questions, and I answered honestly. We stayed on the phone for hours talking about everything. She was incredibly upset with him.
I felt horrible and kept apologizing. She told me she wasn’t mad at me because she had asked us to say something if we knew anything.
She told me she would keep me updated and let me know how their conversation went.
The next day, I reached out to see how she was doing. Her entire demeanor toward me had changed.
Her responses were short, and she wasn’t really saying much. I figured this was a pretty shitty situation, and she probably needed some space to process everything, so I gave her that.
I continued checking in and making sure she was okay, but our normal FaceTime calls stopped completely. She stopped answering, and when I did hear from her, she would just say she wasn’t feeling conversational.
This went on for weeks until she eventually asked if we could talk.
During that conversation, she expressed how upset she was about the entire situation. I understood that. It was a shitty situation.
But then she said, “Had I known that what I was telling you and Ellie about not wanting him to propose right now was going to be taken back to him, I wouldn’t have said anything.”
That stopped me right in my tracks.
She had literally told us that if we knew anything, we should say something to him.
But I didn’t even defend myself.
I knew she was dealing with a lot, and I was just happy that she was finally talking to me again. So I apologized for my part in everything.
Looking back, I wish I had stood up for myself, but at that moment, it wasn’t about being right. It was about being there for her.
We talked a little more, and I continued apologizing. We eventually wrapped up the conversation by talking about our Mother’s Day plans.
I told her my husband had plans for me on Mother’s Day, and the following weekend we were going to do something with our moms.
I asked if she had any plans.
She responded, “Jerry and I are going to find out the gender.”
In that moment, I just told her how exciting that was.
But I was extremely hurt.
After Jerry had become uncomfortable being around me, Nicole continued telling me that I was still going to be her gender keeper. She had even briefly reassured me that I was still involved in everything right before she left for California and shortly after I told her about the proposal.
I was hurt that I wasn’t even given a conversation about it.
I had already planned everything out and was so excited to do this for her.
I sat with those feelings for a while. I felt stuck because it seemed like there was always another problem, and she was already going through such a difficult situation. I didn’t want to bring up another issue when she had finally started talking to me again.
The following week, she messaged me asking if my family was attending her gender reveal.
I was confused because I had never been given a confirmed date or time.
I asked when it was, and she told me it was that upcoming weekend.
I explained that we were planning on getting together with our moms for Mother’s Day, my sister was graduating, and I had family coming in from out of town.
I told her I could try to move some things around and would let her know once all of our plans were figured out.
She responded by saying that these plans seemed last-minute and asked if I didn’t want to go because of our last conversation.
I swear, this girl was giving me whiplash.
Last-minute?
She had barely spoken to me, so how would she even know what was going on in my life?
I also thought our last conversation had gone well.
I explained that the plans weren’t last-minute and that we just hadn’t confirmed times for everything yet. However, I also told her honestly that I didn’t feel comfortable attending because she had completely cut me out of something I had been so excited to be part of.
Her response was essentially that I should have known the date of her reveal, that I wasn’t actually being cut out of anything, and that they just wanted to do something intimate.
But we had already discussed me being involved in putting that together.
She ended by telling me to just let her know if I was coming so she could plan accordingly.
I felt defeated.
I was in the middle of doing learning activities with my son and making my dogs’ food. I felt like I needed to calm down before responding.
About an hour later, she messaged me again.
She told me it would be best if I didn’t come.
Once again, I felt defeated.
I genuinely didn’t know what to say.
Did she want me to beg? Did she want me to just respond with “Okay” and accept that?
It felt like our friendship was over.
I had a family vacation coming up, and I thought maybe we could talk again once some time had passed.
Well, while I was on vacation, she removed me from Instagram and made her account private, but continued following my mom, which I thought was weird.
She also unfollowed me on TikTok but kept me as a follower. Honestly, I think she just wanted me to see her reposts.
I left it alone for a while because it felt like she was playing some sort of game to see when I would notice.
A couple of months went by before I finally accepted that the friendship was over. I eventually removed her and all remaining connections from my social media.
Her last messages to me were back in May.
I can’t lie. I still think about her.
I know her baby is here now, and I genuinely hope she’s doing well. I hope she has support, and I hope things are okay.
I still don’t know how to feel about everything.
Sometimes I’m angry. Other times, I feel bad for her and blame Jerry. And then there are moments when I question whether I’m actually the villain in this situation.
If I hadn’t listened to her and had never told Jerry about what she said, would she have been upset when he proposed and it wasn’t what she wanted? Who knows.
I think about reaching out, but she’s the one who ultimately cut me off.
Should I have responded to her last message? What could I have said that might have changed the outcome? Do I even want to be her friend again?
I honestly don’t know. I’m still processing everything.
I’ve never had a friendship like this before. Before all of this happened, things were so different, and it’s hard to accept that someone who was once such a big part of my life is now essentially a stranger.
So, Reddit, where did I go wrong? Am I the asshole? And is there anything I should do at this point?
Any advice is appreciated.