AITA for not being able to forgive my boyfriend for something he apologised for over a year ago?
I (24F) have been with my boyfriend (27M) for just shy of three years. We live together, and for the most part, our relationship has been pretty steady. However, there are a couple of incidents from earlier in our relationship that I've never been able to fully move past, despite him apologising.
For some context, the first year of our relationship was incredible. I had genuinely never been so in love with someone. It was the kind of love that's difficult to even put into words. I thought he was my person.
Things changed around a year into our relationship when we went on a camping trip with some friends.
One evening, we'd all been drinking and playing games. My boyfriend and I were being a bit frisky with each other throughout the evening, and when we eventually went to bed, he assumed we'd have sex. However, I was really drunk and told him no. I generally don't like having sex when I've been drinking, with the occasional exception.
He didn't take it well. He rolled over, turned his back to me and ignored me for the rest of the night.
The following morning, I asked him if everything was okay and why he was being so cold towards me. His response was, and I quote:
"Don't f*cking wind me up like that if you're not going to follow through."
I can't really explain how much that sentence hurt me. It genuinely felt like something inside me broke. Up until that moment, I'd never questioned how much he loved or respected me.
We barely spoke for the rest of the day, including a two-hour drive home where he didn't say a single word to me.
Eventually, I told him we needed to talk. I explained how hurtful his reaction had been and that just because we'd been flirting and getting intimate didn't mean he was entitled to sex. I was allowed to change my mind, and saying no shouldn't result in me being punished with silence.
He struggled to understand my perspective. To him, he'd been excited about having sex, and my rejection had made him feel unwanted and unattractive.
Eventually, he acknowledged that I was right and asked if we could move on. I agreed, but I never really forgot how he'd made me feel.
Unfortunately, it wasn't an isolated incident.
After that, whenever I wasn't in the mood for sex, he'd often withdraw emotionally. He'd roll over in bed, turn his back to me and sometimes remain distant into the following day.
We had numerous conversations about my low libido. Around this time, we'd moved across the country together for my job, and I was struggling quite badly with my mental health. I was incredibly homesick, isolated from my family and dealing with a supervisor at work who was bullying me.
I tried explaining that my lack of interest in sex wasn't about him or my attraction to him. I was just struggling emotionally and needed support.
Then another incident happened.
We had the same friends from the camping trip staying at our house. We were drinking and playing games, although I'd only had a few ciders. My boyfriend, on the other hand, had drunk an entire crate of beer.
One of the game prompts was to blindfold me and have someone put an item in my mouth for me to guess.
The last time we'd played, we'd put a piece of raw onion in someone's mouth, so I assumed it would be something equally silly.
My boyfriend and his friend went into the kitchen giggling and returned with some baby cucumbers. I could smell them, so I opened my mouth, expecting one of the cucumbers.
Instead, my boyfriend put his penis in my mouth.
In front of his friend and his friend's girlfriend, who was also my friend.
I was absolutely mortified. I felt humiliated, violated and completely disrespected. I didn't know how to react in the moment, so I carried on playing for a little while before making an excuse that I was tired and going to bed.
About a week later, I finally told him how deeply it had affected me. I explained that I was seriously considering going back home to my family and questioning whether I wanted to continue our relationship.
I went home to visit my family that week, and while I was away, he sent me a very long apology.
In it, he acknowledged that his reactions to me rejecting sex had been unacceptable, admitted that what he'd done during the drinking game had completely crossed the line, and promised it would never happen again.
He explained that when I rejected sex, he interpreted it as me no longer finding him attractive or loving him as much. He also acknowledged that he hadn't been emotionally supportive while I was struggling.
He promised to work on his emotional availability, be more understanding, make more effort to help me see my family and stop drinking because he recognised alcohol had contributed to some of his behaviour.
He said he loved me, was terrified of losing me and wanted the opportunity to prove he could change.
I accepted his apology and agreed to give him another chance.
And, to his credit, he genuinely did change for a while.
Things improved, we became closer again, and for a few months, it felt like we were getting our relationship back.
Then I was involved in a car accident.
The night after the accident, he tried to initiate sex. I wasn't in the mood, understandably, and told him no.
He withdrew from me again, just like he used to.
And from that point onwards, the old pattern gradually returned.
Since then, our relationship has felt like a cycle. Things will be good, we'll have fun together, and I'll feel close to him again. But then I'll turn down sex, he'll become distant, and we'll end up having the same argument.
I've since been involved in a second car accident, eight months after the first, alongside dealing with several other difficult things in my personal life. My mental health has been incredibly poor, and I've repeatedly tried to explain how much it's affecting my libido.
He tells me he's now scared to even initiate sex because he doesn't know how to turn me on anymore, and he's worried about being rejected.
I understand that rejection can hurt, and I don't expect him to never feel disappointed. But I do expect him to respect my decision without withdrawing affection or making me feel guilty for it.
I've also explained that I don't feel emotionally supported by him, and that sometimes it feels as though sex is the only way he knows how to express love or feel connected to me.
The problem is that every time this happens, it brings back everything from those earlier incidents.
When I try to explain that I still haven't fully healed from how he treated me, he gets frustrated and tells me we've already discussed it, he's already apologised, and I need to move on.
And that's where I'm struggling.
I know he apologised. I know he meant it at the time, and I acknowledge that he made a genuine effort to change for a while.
But how am I supposed to move on from something when the behaviour that hurt me in the first place keeps happening?
I don't want to spend the rest of our relationship holding his past mistakes over his head. I genuinely want to forgive him. But I feel like I've never had the opportunity to properly rebuild that trust because every time I start feeling secure again, something happens that reminds me why it was broken.
Part of me wonders whether I'm being unfair by continuing to bring up things that happened over a year ago, especially when he's already apologised and believes we've dealt with them.
But another part of me feels like accepting an apology shouldn't mean I'm obligated to forget what happened, particularly when the underlying behaviour hasn't really changed.
So, AITA for not being able to forgive my boyfriend and move on, despite him apologising over a year ago?