r/XSomalian • u/Glass_Inspector_9729 • 7h ago
Discussion Advice Needed: I Can’t Help Feeling Anti-Hijab
Disclaimer: I’m looking for an honest discussion and I am not supporting islamophobic or hateful rhetoric. I just want a safe space to discuss this because I find myself really against the hijab, and it started when I was still a Muslim. I feel like this is the only subreddit that can speak about Islam without being Islamophobic. So please give me your advice. I’m a woman btw.
I don’t want to be someone who holds hateful opinions. I want to be loving and accepting of all people. However, by doing this I find myself unable to reconcile how I can fight for women while simultaneously fighting for hijab.
The way I see it, the hijab is inherently anti-women. It is only worn by women around men who may sexualize or be attracted to her. Men are not required to cover their entire body around women.
I find it interesting that both Muslims and non-Muslims can critique other aspects of Islam such as child marriage, slavery, and harsh punishments. They will all say it was a practice of the time and it cannot fit in modern society. Well, why is the hijab any different? I find it just as appalling. The hijab creates so many issues for women such as reduced participation in sports, travel, discrimination, and ironically sexualization. It also leads to heat exhaustion, therefore, many Muslim women don’t spend much time outdoors during summer. So why is it acceptable to ban child marriage and slavery, but any ban against hijab is met with such disdain? Is it wrong to ban actions that separates and others individuals based on gender? From what I’ve seen, such laws would be a relief to the majority of women who cannot just remove it. It gives an easy way to take it off without losing your entire community.
The hijab was only allowed for free Muslim women. Enslaved women couldn’t wear it.
The hijab requires a woman to cover everything but her hands and face. It also leads to other opinions on “hijab in character” where some believe women shouldn’t free mix or speak loudly in public.
Lastly, removing the hijab often leads to horrific outcomes such as excommunication, bullying, abuse, and even death. We cannot lie to ourselves and say the same outcomes occur from putting the hijab on.
When I see the hijab I don’t just see a cloth, I see a gender-based apartheid system.
These are my thoughts, and it’s difficult to sit with. I felt this way since I was a Muslim and I had to cover up during summer while the Muslim men didn’t. Am I wrong?