Guys, i posted this theory in r/Bricelriel the other day, but I need to hear more thoughts on this so I cut the ship section to bring it here.
It's a long shot and I don’t know if it was already discussed or if it makes sense!
What if Hybern was originally part of Fionn and Theia’s Kingdom?
STAY WITH ME
Ok so when the IC goes to Hybern it is described almost as a baren land, with no resources, no animals or anything. We know their kingdon is falling apart and atributing this chaos to the lack of human slaves right? Awfull.
All right, but we're also told the courts are all sustained by their High Lords Magic. For exemple, we are told that the Calanmai in the Spring Court is essentially a fertility ritual in which the land's magic is renewed.
So Hybern's misery doesn’t actually make any sense, because why can’t the fae in Hybern also use their magic to fuel and make their island thrive? Like all the courts in Prythian and the continent?
My theory is they literally cannot because the whole of Hybern’s Island is DEAD just like the Prison.
What if, when Theia left Prythian and Selene created the Prison and hid in the NC, they left their land (Hybern) without any magic to sustain it, if that would be true it makes sense that Hybern's land would rot, their magic is stuck in another world!!!
Also there are a lot of parallels between the people of Avallen and the people of Hybern. This indicates that they were somehow connected and the people from Hybern also imigrated with the people of Prythian to Midgard!
This post brings great points about the connection between Morven and the King of Hybern:https: //www.reddit.com/r/Bryceriel/comments/1rueqjo/parallels_between_morven_and_hybern_and_why_i/
So we know the King of Hybern had many spells in his book, AND he had the cauldron and we know the cauldron was tempered with by the Daglan. So he should be able to awaken his land, shouldn't he?
Maybe he didn't even know it was possible, but these powerful objects beeing there points to the presence of the Daglan in their Island.
Then it would only make sense that when Fionn became High King, he would be High King of ALL the land the Daglan once ruled over.
OK OTHER EVIDENCES:
I know there are a lot of theories that say that Hybern is ruled by the valg, but canonically the valg go after powerfull fae and magic wielders, not humans, so I really don't believe that one.
It would make much more sense to assume that in the time the Daglan Ruled, they sucked the magic of the land. They did that with the Tribute, says Amren, but just like in Midgard, I doubt that we are aware of all the ways the daglan preyed on this world.
When Bryce eliminated the Asteri from Midgard, the Pegasus returned from the ground!!! The life was returned to the land, and the magic too.
Vesperus said that the land under the prison was a container full of magic for her to consume, maybe all the life of Hybern is hidden under somewhere aswell and only Bryce, who has the star, can be guided to this treasure and free the land. Bringing it back to life!! (Possible parallel to The crochan curse being broken in TOG aswell, by Manon, a descendant of both lines)
The creature appearing to Azriel totally brings Hybern back into the fold of this story, and as we are heading to a High King High Queen possible future, it only makes sense that all the land that was once united comes back togheter again, including Hybern.
Also, if the map is any indication, Hybern does strongly resemble Ireland. And I always found extremely weird that they were portrayed as these villains, and i've seen others agreeing with me.
But if we look at Hybern as a land who were very abused in those times (Daglan rule) and then lost its only source of sustained magic (The starborns leaving and hiding) there is no surprise in the fact that they are in a great famine situation (making them extremely vulnerable to outside influence COF COF Koschei)
Given all this, I don't really believe that their allyship proposal is a trap. They need help!!
My guess is Bryce comes back to prythian, she is a descendant of Theia and has her full powers now, it is theorized that Azriel is a descendent of Aidas, Theia's mate, togheter they make the Dusk court source of power complete to awaken the land.
This ties to the prophecy that Bryce keeps alluding to
"When knife and sword are reunited, so shall our people be"
Bryce with Gwydion, Az with Truth-Teller.
Uniting the people of not only Midgard and Prythian, but also Hybern.
Imagine the Hybern fae knowing their land was saved by a half fae, half human, this directly contradicts their prejudice and superiority against humans, they would be grateful!
(And If the people from midgard eventually cross to prythian, I imagine there would also be a great jump in technology too).
ANOTHER THING
In this whole imigration to Prythin theory, I must say that the prison is too small a land to acomodate every fae migrant from Midgard. Hybern is significantly bigger and could be a more viable option if we go in this direction.
NOW You can argue with me that Bryce doesn't WANT to rule, she left the Queen position in Midgard, and tried to install some kind of representatives chamber right? YES I agreeee
But if Hybern is a parallel to Ireland, I am thinking maybe it needs to heal, and THEN it will need independance from the kingdom of "Britain", so I see this going in this direction:
Feyre and Rhys (?) ascend to High King and Queen and unite Prythian.
Hybern/Dusk court gets its independance and Bryce, Azriel and Nesta (with Valkyries) install a democracy there, a safe haven for humans, fae and vanir.
Is this crazy? What do you guys think? Please tell me!!