r/bourbon • • 3d ago

Weekly Recommendations and Discussion Thread

4 Upvotes

This is the weekly recommendations and discussion thread, for all of your questions or comments: what pour to buy at a bar, what bottle to try next, or what gift to get; and for some banter and discussions that don't fit as standalone posts.

While the "low-effort" rules are relaxed for this thread, please note that the rules for standalone posts haven't changed, and there is absolutely no buying, selling, or trading here or anywhere else on the sub.

This post will be refreshed every Sunday afternoon. Previous threads can be seen here.


r/bourbon • • 6h ago

The 2026 Buffalo Trace Antique Collection Debuts 12-Year-Old Thomas H. Handy

Thumbnail
forbes.com
47 Upvotes

I am not usually one to get too excited about the annual BTAC announcements, but the change to Thomas H. Handy is definitely noteworthy.

What does everyone think?


r/bourbon • • 7h ago

Review #25: Southern Collective - "MODERN LIQUOR" Single Barrel

Post image
25 Upvotes

Picked by: Modern Liquor OKC
Type: Wheated Bourbon
Yield: 84 Bottles
Age: 5 Years - Rear Label Age stated
Source: Old Glory Distillery (TN)
Proof: 126.3 proof
Paid - $85
Rested: 15 minutes
Drank: Neat
Glass: Glencairn

As always - unbiased, unprofessional, and unpaid!

Nose -
The nose starts off with some Sweet and funky oak, a mix of Blackberry, Cherry, and Raspberry - made into a compote and some vanilla cake icing. Further nosing reveals what I can describe as unmistakably pancake syrup, there is a fresh cinnamon spice that is interlaced with a note of fresh baked wheat bread.

Palate -
First sip I am hit with a wave of warm Cinnamon rolls, funky charred oak, and raspberry jam. The second sip shows an underlying tone throughout of sweet pipe tobacco and baking spices of cinnamon, nutmeg, cracked black pepper. The third sip doesn't bring on anything new - but intertwines the sweet and savory flavors nicely.

Mouthfeel -
The mouthfeel is Medium Density. It has above average viscosity as well. Comes across as "slippery" on the palate and very saturating as well.

Finish -
The finish is medium length and lead with flavors of more Raspberry jam, some cigar box, and funky charred oak. The finish is medium length with a spice warmth that builds every sip, goes down into chest, and stays with you. I do note that it is slightly drying as well.

Overall - 79/100

JT23 Scale:
1-49: Drain Pour, absolute drain cleaner, donate to the sink.
50-59: average - standard, boring, but gets the job done.
60-69: solid - reliable, but nothing to write home about.
70-79: great whiskey, well above the average pour.
80-89: excellent whiskey, top notch, well done.
90-95: exceptional top tier whiskey - very memorable.
96-98: Unreal pour - some of the best ever.
99-100: Pinnacle Lifetime whiskey - perfection in a glass.


r/bourbon • • 3h ago

REVIEW #41: Black Ledger "Founders Collection" 11yr single barrel (Barrel 3)(128.3 proof)

Post image
11 Upvotes

Nose: sweet oak, a little carmel, toasted sugars, "baking spice" notes. Nothing unique here, but just pleasant bourbon

Palate: medium, oak, dark sugars, nutty, slight pepper

Finish: pretty long, gets a bit spicy, oak tannins kick in, subtle sugars hang around

My thoughs: this is good. It's got good flavor all around with a proof that feels good. The oak tannins, while they typically turn me off, feels nice in this winter-esk weather. No real issues. Just nice, good classic bourbon. Worth a purchase for sure.

Rating: 7.8/10

puchase here

[Find me on all socials at @plentyofbottles for video reviews and all that]


r/bourbon • • 3h ago

Review: Private Stock Whiskey Co. Batch No. 1 10 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Post image
11 Upvotes

Private Stock Whiskey Co. Batch No. 1 10 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Distilled by Jacob Call in Owensboro, KY

Produced & bottled by Western Kentucky Distilling (DSP-KY-20193) in Beaver Dam, KY

Release date: November 14, 2026

JD Edwards is the owner of Private Stock… along with being the co-owner & business partner of Jacob Call at Western KY Distilling. These barrels are technically sourced by Private Stock, but it’s a case of JD Edwards & Jacob Call working with some of the earliest barrels that were laid down when they were together at O.Z. Tyler Distillery (now Green River Distilling)

To my knowledge, this is the first 10 year Owensboro bourbon to be released

Barreled dates: October 26, 2016

Dump date: October 27, 2026

Mashbill: 78% corn, 13% rye, 9% malted barley (Beam mashbill, but not Beam)

Jacob Call’s dad is Ron Call… who worked at Beam for 16 years and played a large roll in developing Beam Black

Still type: 54” Vendome column

Barrels: Kelvin Cooperage, Char No. 4

Proof: 105

Batch size: 10 barrels

Cases produced: 166

MSRP: $100 (750 ml) and/or $299 (3 L)

Nose: Butterscotch pudding skin. Cinnamon sugar blend. Dried orange peel. Post Honeycomb breakfast cereal.

Extremely nice! The butterscotch crust is really strong at first, but then fades away. The cinnamon sugar blend feels like one of the combined shakers you can buy at the grocery. Oak feels extremely balanced.

Palate: Butterscotch candy discs. Sweet pipe tobacco. Nutmeg. Cornbread. Medium-thick mouthfeel.

I absolutely love the butterscotch and tobacco! The tobacco never gets too dry. The cornbread adds a little bit of bite at the end.

Finish: Black pepper. Dried orange peel. Cinnamon gum. Tobacco.

I’m extremely happy with this bottle. The overarching combo of butterscotch and tobacco works extremely well for me. I appreciate that the oak influence isn’t too strong. The oak definitely shows up, but it maintains plenty of sweetness to go with it.

More 10 year bourbon from Owensboro will follow, but I feel like this is a great start! I have absolutely zero regrets about my purchase.

I paid for $100 this bottle

Rating: 8 | Excellent | Really quite exceptional


r/bourbon • • 22h ago

Jim Beam will not resume distilling at its flagship distillery in 2027

Thumbnail msn.com
315 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 3h ago

Review: Starlight Distillery Carl T. Huber's Cigar Batch Barrel Pick - Barrel Pick - "Central Store"

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Barrel pick: "Central Store"
Barrel: 23-2360

Picked this up in the quad cities during a soccer tournament for the kids. It was tasted and enjoyed using a paper cup from the Hampton Inn and Suites, but that didn't seem to impact the flavor much. For a four year, the Amburana finish really added a ton of color, sweetness, cinnamon, and spice - to the point of overpowering to where that's all there was. I would say it was like eating a cinnamon roll at the Hampton Inn continental breakfast.

Appearance: Mahogany (7/10)
Nose: (6/10)
Palate: Molasses, Brown sugar, Vanilla, Cinnamon (5/10)
Mouthfeel: Hot, Ethanol (4/10)
Finish: (4/10)

Value: 5/10
At $100 out the door, there are much better values, but I'm a big fan of at least trying a store pick if I can from a store I haven't before just to see if I should go back for more.

Score: 5/10 Good


r/bourbon • • 22h ago

Review: Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Heritage Barrel (Toasted), Barrel 26-02765, 100 proof, 8/10 Pull Over

Thumbnail
gallery
72 Upvotes

Tennessee Tuesday. This is the bottle I grab when I don’t know what I’m in mood for. Tennessee whiskey, single barrel, 100 proof. Toasted, low-char barrels. Barrel 26-02765, entered July 30, 2018. Picked up at Buster's in Memphis for $69.99, right at MSRP. Shelf release, not a store pick.

One of my favorite releases of 2025. Jack is putting out some phenomenal barrels, and now this one is pretty much on the shelf to stay. I've had about six different barrels. Being single barrels there's some difference bottle to bottle, but all in all I've found them incredibly consistent. It's close to a daily drinker for me, it's that easy.

**Nose:** Sugar, then that classic Jack banana Foster, with light chocolate, toffee, a little baking spice and light toasted oak. Very little alcohol. Just a really nice nose.

**Palate:** If you like sweet, this is up your alley. S'mores, vanilla custard and graham cracker, with a little banana and light charred sugar. A banana Foster campfire s'more, right in my flavor profile.

**Mouthfeel:** Medium, and sweet right away. It lacks the oil to coat the palate and give a full, creamy taste. The only thing keeping it from a higher score.

**Finish:** A little light. Not a high proofer, so it doesn't linger as long or bring the warmth. I generally prefer higher proof, but this is just an easy sipper.

**Verdict: 8/10, Pull Over.** I keep a couple of bottles at both houses. When I don't want anything too complex, just a nice, easy drink, this is the one I reach for. If you see one and don't have it, go get it. They're easy to find now, and it belongs on your shelf.

---
**Route Score:** [Pull Over (8-10)](https://www.reddit.com/search/?q=author%3AProfessionalDealer32%20title%3A%22Pull%20Over%22&sort=new) | [On Your Way (7)](https://www.reddit.com/search/?q=author%3AProfessionalDealer32%20title%3A%22On%20Your%20Way%22&sort=new) | [Next Exit (5-6)](https://www.reddit.com/search/?q=author%3AProfessionalDealer32%20title%3A%22Next%20Exit%22&sort=new) | [Keep Driving (0-4)](https://www.reddit.com/search/?q=author%3AProfessionalDealer32%20title%3A%22Keep%20Driving%22&sort=new)


r/bourbon • • 21h ago

Review #107 - Heaven Hill 90th Anniversary Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Post image
57 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 19h ago

REVIEW – 1792 Full Proof (Virginia ABC Single Barrel, 2024)

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

This was my high proof bourbon (above 50% ABV).  Produced by Barton 1792 Distillery and bottled at 125 proof (62.5% ABV), this has no age statement but is at least 4 years old and non-chill filtered.  The mash bill is undisclosed but is thought to be 15-25% rye.  This specific bottle is a VA ABC Sazerac Barrel Select single barrel released in 2024; the label doesn’t have a specific barrel number.

This review is based on multiple separate notes-taking sessions over 9½ months using Glencairn and Denver & Liely Bourbon glasses with varying resting/aeration times in the glass.

COLOR: Dark copper

AROMA PROFILE: Significant ethanol that dissipates somewhat the longer the bottle is open – Aroma profile defined by dark caramel & burnt brown sugar, vanilla, dark chocolate, bananas caramelized in brown sugar, prominent baking spices (cinnamon, nutmeg, cardamom, cloves), oak, & a smoky note.  This has opened up significantly the longer the bottle has aerated.

PALATE: Hot initially before rich, deep flavors pop (matching the aromas).

FINISH: 7-10 seconds (medium-long)

MOUTHFEEL/VISCOSITY: Incredibly viscous & coats the glass with very slow-forming tears; Creamy/oily mouthfeel


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review: pappy van winkle 20 year (2025)

Post image
143 Upvotes

Pappy Van Winkle 20yr Bourbon

Age: 20 years; released in 2025

Proof: 90.4° (45.2% ABV)

Price: ($400)

Nose: Caramel, some earthy herby notes

Taste: strong on the vanilla, sweet, some oaky afterbirth - more than I expected and in a good way

Finish: Mid finish, no alcohol burn

Notes: I’ve had the 15 year before a couple times and wasn’t impressed. This is a bit better than the 15 imo. I wish they’d put it out at cask strength, it’d be way better, though this is a fine sipper. Maybe I’m a proof hound, as wlw and gts and larceny barrel proof are some of my favorites. But as a historical thing that helped propel bourbon into the spotlight this certainly does deserve recognition

8/10.


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review #995 - Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Batch Y1223 (Heaven Hill 'You Do Bourbon' Experience)

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 21h ago

Review # 61: Nashtucky Whiskey Company Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey - Trevor’s Liquor Private Select

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 1d ago

REVIEW #40: Ezra Brooks 12yr Single Barrel 2026 (99 proof)

Post image
21 Upvotes

Nose: oak, cherry, cinnamon, that malted barley punching through...which for my preferences isn't really appealing, a little perfumy, some sugar sweetness

Palate: soft, a little bitter, cocao chocolate note, proofy for only 99, no complexity

Finish: soft, short, acidity, citrus, bitter

My thoughts: Nope. Not a lot of complexity or depth. Drinks more like a Japanese whiskey than American. Not my thing. Cool looking bottle though.

Rating: 2.9/10

[Find my on at @plentyofbottles on all socials for video content and reviews]


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review: Green River Distillery Select Series Clay Tile Blend Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

Green River Distillery Select Series Clay Tile Blend Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Release date: November 27, 2026

Second release in the Distillery Select Series

Distilled in Owensboro, KY

Age: 7-8 years

Blend of 4 lots of barrels pulled from the upper floors of 5 clay tile rickhouses located at the distillery campus in Owensboro

The hollow clay tiles have large inner pockets that hold hot & cold extremely well. Green River’s Owensboro campus is one of two distilleries to have rickhouses built from these mid-1930s-style clay tiles. Woodford Reserve also has one of these style clay tile rickhouses, but it’s not currently being used.

The blend:
2 lots of 8 year: 70% corn, 21% rye, 9% malted barley

2 lots of 7 year: 74% corn, 16% rye, 10% malted barley

Proof: 118

Bottle size: 375 ml

MSRP: $49.99

Nose: Mango. Coconut water. Bazooka Gum. Dark brown sugar.

It’s pretty rare that I pick up mango. The coconut definitely feels more like coconut water versus a more pronounced coconut. The combination of mango and coconut gives it a bit of a tropical feel… much like a rum. The Bazooka scent comes on pretty strong and I like it.

Palate: Orange creamsicle. Raspberry lollipop. Toasted marshmallow. Buckwheat honey. Medium viscosity.

I’ve tasted a lot of Green River bourbon…and this is immediately different! There’s a much brighter character that works for me… no doubt coming from the 16% rye bourbon component.

Finish: Cinnamon toothpicks. Dr. Pepper syrup. Concord grape skin.

The brighter aspect of the palate shifts hard on the finish… as the spice suddenly kicks in… followed by a pleasing amount of tannins.

This is an excellent bottle that offers something different in multiple stages. Definitely complex. I fully appreciate the evolution from initial palate to finish.

I received this 200 ml media sample, but I’ll definitely be tracking down a 375 ml bottle… I need more of this.

Sample provided for review by Green River Distilling

Rating: 7 | Great | Well above average


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review #43 - Still Austin Distillery Reserve Series - Monster Mash 2026

Thumbnail
gallery
173 Upvotes

This past week, while traveling in Texas for work, I was able to sneak away for a few hours and visit Still Austin's distillery and the Quarter. What a great experience! While the quarter had a great vibe, and the drinks were great, the tour AND Monster Mash bottle pickup were my favorite parts. I was able to do the base distillery tour (wasn't around long enough for the grain to glass or master distiller tour), try a bunch of the base products back to back to back, and get a taste of the Distillery Exclusive. I highly recommend the tour to anyone in Austin, as they take you through all the distillation tanks and the still, as well as some of the bottling lines. Very cool stuff. I actually ended up trying all the Distillery Exclusives they had, the Armagnac finished rye, the blue corn finished rye, and the blue corn/rye blend. All were phenomenal.

The big reason for going however, was to pick up Monster Mash 2026. This is an entry in their distillery reserve series, which is highly coveted, and can only be picked up at the distillery. Being from PA, I never even try to pick these up, knowing I can't just up and leave for Austin every time I find a bottle I want to try to get.. Fortunately, I knew I would be in Austin when this bottle was announced, so I knew I had to try. Sure enough, I was lucky enough to get this!!!

While on the tour, our tour guide (I forget her name but she was great!) told us that the distillers take two weeks in the beginning of the year to experiment with mash bills and blends to just see what good, random mash and blend they could come up with as their next big product. That seems like a great time, and it sounds like products like the Monster Mash are born during this innovative time! Now, onto the bottle...

MSRP: ~$125.00. This does have a secondary presence, not sure the prices on it there, but I'm sure it's way too much. Way too much to spend on a bottle, haha.

Age: 3 years. This should drink more like a 5 or 6 year if everything I've read about Texas whiskey is true... It also sounds like it may be a blend? So there may be older stuff in here? The way the tour guide was talking, I was led to believe so. I'd love to hear someone else's thoughts on that.

ABV: 58.25% (116.5 proof).

Mashbill: 63% Blue Corn, 17% Winter Hawk Wheat, 10% Malted Rye, 8% Rye, 2% Malted Barley

Nose: Very very sweet! Lot of gummy, plain old sugar, and very very sweet caramel on the nose. Almost an artificially sweet caramel apple? I did see a tasting note from the distillery of candy corn, I definitely could see that on the nose.

Palate: I get much less sweetness on the palate, something warming, but not ethanol. There's a little nutty note, and a little of a bready note. I also get some citrus on the palate. Not quite a meringue like the tasting notes, but definitely some orange instead. Red fruit rounds out the end of the palate, mostly some kind of raspberry and strawberry (and blueberry - not red fruit I know) in there.

Finish: Long, and very warming. Again, not ethanol, but very warming. I love it to be honest. The tasting notes don't really change from the palate, but the finish is long and does let the rye shine through a lot more. Some type of peppery note does increase throughout the finish. Great pour.

Overall, this is different, and very good. I think that the mash bill contains differences between the nose and palate, and incredible complexity within the nose and the palate. It's like there's so many flavors going on here, and it does work. I would not call it flavor overload if that makes any sense. I would probably rate this as a 8, honestly on the T8KE scale. Quite exceptional! If you can find a friend with this bottle, a bar that is selling pours, etc... I highly recommend! Just please don't spend like a grand on this bottle, secondary is never worth it lol.

Let me know in the comments if you've had this one, how it compares to the previous years' Monster Mashes, and if there are any future Still Austin releases that you're excited about. Drink responsibly, and cheers!

1 | Disgusting | So bad I poured it out.

2 | Poor | I wouldn’t consume by choice.

3 | Bad | Multiple flaws.

4 | Sub-par | Not bad, but better exists.

5 | Good | Good, just fine.

6 | Very Good | A cut above.

7 | Great | Well above average

8 | Excellent | Really quite exceptional.

9 | Incredible | An all time favorite

10 | Perfect | Perfect


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review #2 Larceny Barrel Proof B523

Post image
72 Upvotes

A bottle I’ve had for at least 3 years. I wish I opened it sooner had I known it’d be this good. I didn’t think much of Larceny Barrel Proof releases til I tried this one. I’ve only tried 2 so far and the last one I didn’t care much for. This one was much different than the first one I had and this one specifically made a good impression on me.

Though I may not pick up another because I’m afraid they won’t live up to what this one is, it’s still a good buy at the price. If you find this one in store by chance, I suggest buying it. Anyways, here we go.

Larceny Barrel Proof B523

Nose: Cherry, Oak, Cinnamon, Moss, Petrichor, Damp Oak, Vanilla, Cherry Syrup, Cotton Candy

Taste: Cherry, Cinnamon, Clove, Herbal, Cherry Cough Syrup, Cedar, Smoky

Finish: Strong lingering Damp Oak, Musty, Vanilla, Smoky, Cherry Cough Syrup

Very Striking Contrast to the one I previously drank I believe it was C922 or C921 which was more nutty and not as pleasant as this one. I hesitated to open this one because I really didn’t care for the last Larceny Barrel Proof I had but I’m glad I opened it. It was a pleasant surprise. With that being said I’d give it a solid 8/10. If you happen to find it, buy it. It’s a worthwhile release.


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review: New England Barrel Company “French Rye-viera”

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 2d ago

REVIEW #39: Very Olde St. Nick "Straight Outta Bardstown" 11yr

Post image
97 Upvotes

Price: $270 OTD

Nose: pretty big, earthy, damp oak, toasted sugar, cinnamon, that oak funk all in it

Palate: sweetness galore backed by oak, vanilla, toffee, almost tastes like it's got a high rye mashbill, cinnamon and pepper, more of that damp or earthy feel on the palate that I get from the nose, an espresso bite in there, lastly a stout feel to this

Finish: long, sweetness disappates and barrel char is introduced, oak also along for the ride, those palate spices linger around and transitions back to a sweeter, but faint sweetness. Very intereating.

My thoughts: this is fire. It tastes like Christmas in a glass. I'm not one suggest pairings, but man would I love a warm berry pie with a scoop of ice cream with this. This is worth the coin.

Rating: 8.7/10

[Hey! You can find me on all socials at @plentyofbottles for video reviews and content]


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Review # 044 — Parker’s Heritage American Kentucky Straight Whiskey Aged 11 Years (19th Edition)

Post image
59 Upvotes

Fun Fact: a portion of the proceeds from purchasing this bottle supports ALS research and patient care in honor of Heaven Hill Distillery’s Master Distiller Emeritus Parker Beam.

My expectation is that highly sought-after annual releases will pass me by unless I’m willing to pay a large markup. Last Black Friday, though, I was visiting my parents near the Virginia border for Thanksgiving and thought to myself “maybe they were nice and released some stuff to the ABC store for the holidays.” Sure enough, I walked into the store and immediately spotted this sitting on the shelf with everything else. If not for the large price tag, this would have gone unnoticed by the average (or even moderately-informed) consumer. A year later and its turn in the queue is upon us. This is my first experience with Parker’s, let’s see how we like it.

Price Paid: $179.99 before tax

Score: 8.5/10

The Background
Distillery: Heaven Hill

ABV: 61.25% (122.5 proof)

Age: 11 years

Mash Bill: unknown

Other: comprised of 15-year-old wheated bourbon, 11-year-old corn whiskey, and 12-year-old whiskey made from only rye and malted barley; barrel proof; not chill filtered.

The Experience
Nose: vanilla bean, caramel, pecan brittle. This has a syrupy sweet aroma.

Palate: cherry cordial, vanilla, brownie, plain raw pecan, charred oak. An earthy nuttiness meets a sweetness that makes this addictive.

Finish: cola, spice. The heat is strong in this one, but it does not pass without leaving behind an addictive savory quality.

The Summary
This started off odd but grew on me as I finished the glass. The odd mash bill is immediately apparent and makes it easy to write this off as being just a wacky experiment. The blenders were able to step in and create some magic, though, and the sweetness shows up in layers and gives this a dessert-like quality. I haven’t had anything else like it. That’s an experience worth $180 to me, but beware of secondary pricing.

T8KE Scoring System Used for Relevancy and Consistency:

0 | Unscored | New Make Spirit or Personal Selection.
1 | Disgusting | So bad I poured it out.
2 | Poor | I wouldn't consume by choice.
3 | Bad | Multiple flaws.
4 | Sub-par | Not bad, but many things I'd rather have.
5 | Good | Good; just fine.
6 | Very Good | One cut above.
7 | Great | Well above average.
8 | Excellent | Exceptional.
9 | Incredible | An all-time favorite.
10 | Perfect | Perfection.


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Review #12: Fierce Whiskers Texas Straight Rye Whiskey Single Barrel (Barrel 282)

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 3d ago

Bourbz Review #253: Jack Daniel’s SiB Heritage Barrel

Thumbnail
gallery
131 Upvotes

Bourbz Review #253: Jack Daniel’s SiB Heritage Barrel

MASH BILL: 80% corn, 8% rye, 12% malted barley

AGE: 8 yr 9 mo

PROOF: 100

COST: $60 for 750mL bottle (Costco, South Carolina)

In 2018 and 2019, Jack Daniel’s had a special release that featured a distinct barrel toasting technique to create a richer character. In August of 2025, that special barrel toasting process became part of a new year-round offering in their single barrel collection.

Jack Daniel’s Heritage Barrel features whiskey from the classic JD mash bill that is filtered through sugar maple charcoal (Lincoln County Process) and is then barreled into unique barrels prepared using a high-toast, low-char process that was inspired by barrel-making traditions used in the early days of Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey. The whiskey is then aged for a minimum of 7 years and finally bottled at 100 proof.

While “toasted barrel” expressions have seemed to increase in popularity in recent years, this Heritage Barrel release is both Jack Daniel’s attempt to capitalize on that market momentum as well as make a statement that this is something they were doing “before it was popular.” In general, almost all expressions from the Jack Daniel’s single barrel collection tend to impress me, but as with all single barrels, milage may vary. I feel like this particular release has received a lot of positive attention since it dropped, with a few poor reviews that I chalk up to SiB variance. My friend picked up this bottle from Costco and we agreed to split it. After he split the bottle and tried it, he texted me and said he was thinking about keeping my half after all… I assume this is going to be a win.

This bottle is from barrel #26-03585, barreled on July 12, 2017 and bottled on April 4, 2026. Reviewed neat in a Glencairn.

APPEARANCE: A dark, caramelized oak color (1.6), a mild oiliness.

NOSE: Sugary sweetness with a touch of woody spice. Big brown sugar notes right away with a hint of maple syrup. A softer sweetness of toasted marshmallow starts to show up along with rich vanilla. Dipping my nose a bit deeper into the glen I some nice gingerbread spice, spicy oak, and graham cracker.

PALATE: Nice viscosity on the palate that is very coating. The nose transfers to the palate extremely well. I would say the notes on the nose were more simple while they’ve evolved to be more complex on the palate. The brown sugar remains consistent while the toasted marshmallow, graham cracker, and spicy oak meld into a nice sugary wood spice. The vanilla has more of a toastiness to it on that palate. There’s a mild tannic profile that starts to show up as I hold it on the palate that becomes slightly drying.

FINISH: Medium length finish. The brown sugar continues its consistent dominant presence. Graham cracker, tannic, charred oak, and a touch of cinnamon. There is a light spearmint note that creeps in. As time marches on, the spice notes start to drop off and I’m left with brown sugar, marshmallow, and vanilla. Santa dropped off some craft vanilla flavored marshmallows for Christmas a few years ago and this reminds me of those with a dusting of brown sugar caramelized on top.

RATING: 8.1/10

OVERALL: Easily one of the top value whiskies I’ve purchased this year! The use of the toasted barrel really shows up in this pour with tons of vanilla and wood sugars. The light char of the barrels is evident as well. I’ve seen the use of toasted barrels be counteracted by putting too heavy of a char on the barrels and getting too much bitter influence than the sweet wood sugars, but this is perfect. There’s a light char note and some tannic oak, but it still lets the thick red layer of the toasted barrels steal the spotlight with bold notes of brown sugar, marshmallow, and vanilla. While it’s delicious and very well executed, the only thing holding it back from a higher score is simply the lack further complexity. In particular, I personally wish the nose was a bit more robust and a few other notes sprinkled in along the way. But that’s just me being nit-picky.

 

1 | Disgusting | see my 1/10 ratings

2 | Poor | see my 2/10 ratings

3 | Bad | see my 3/10 ratings

4 | Sub-par | see my 4/10 ratings

5 | Good | see my 5/10 ratings

6 | Very Good | see my 6/10 ratings

7 | Great | see my 7/10 ratings

8 | Excellent | see my 8/10 ratings

9 | Incredible | see my 9/10 ratings

10 | Perfect | see my 10/10 ratings

 

If you enjoyed this review, check out all my reviews at Woodgrain & Whiskey.


r/bourbon • • 3d ago

Just the Sip: Heaven Hill Unity Review

Post image
30 Upvotes

Verdicts Explained

  • Special Occasions: Rare, special pours that go well and above. Something you pour to celebrate.
  • Treat Yourself: Obligatory weekend pour. Worth having on hand at all times if possible.
  • Daily Drinker: Affordable, available and tasty. Could have every day and be perfectly content.
  • Penseur Pour: Puzzling pours that won’t be to everyone’s liking.
  • Trophy Bottle: Something to show off more than anything. Likely allocated and overpriced.
  • Cocktail Request: Shines best in a cocktail, as opposed to neat or on the rocks.
  • Good If Affordable: Only worth buying if the price comfortably fits within the budget.
  • Serve to Guests: Something accessible that you don’t mind sharing or parting ways with. Likely belongs in a decanter.
  • Couch Pour: Something enjoyable enough, but ideal for drinking while doing another activity (movies, TV, games, etc.).
  • Find a Mixer: Grab the Coke or Sprite and relax.
  • Drain Pour: No. You deserve better.

Link to blog post: https://thewhiskeyramble.com/2026/11/01/makers-mark-cask-strength-26-01-scoresheet-review/

More scoresheets available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpiritScoresheets/

A common experience in life is the sense of “they don’t make it like they used to,” a sentiment that’s far from exclusive to whiskey. There’s a layer of truth to it, but that truth is also more nuanced than I think many people realize. From what I’ve gathered, much of what this comes down to is a combination of lower barrel entry proof, older stocks, and older trees. Other than that first aspect, the actual process of creating whiskey hasn’t changed all that much, but the market certainly has. And with popularity comes a faster replacement cycle, meaning older whiskey made from older trees simply isn’t as feasible (if at all) compared to the days when most people would turn their noses up at bourbons priced anywhere near three figures.

So, what would happen if the two eras converged?

This is the hypothetical that Heaven Hill Unity seems built to answer. Released as a way to commemorate the opening of the new Heaven Hill Springs Distillery in Bardstown, Unity features a curious bourbon blend of 27 barrels, one of which was apparently the last remaining barrel from the Old Heaven Hill Springs Distillery. This is the same distillery that fell during the famous fire of 1996, an event that saw Heaven Hill move production to Louisville at the current Bernheim Distillery. 2025 saw a new Heaven Hill Springs distillery open up, ostensibly as a return-to-roots transition (pardon the pun). Production is meant to scale up so that it can match (or exceed) that of the Bernheim Distillery, which will almost certainly have people itching to compare future stocks after they come of age.

As for Heaven Hill Unity, 26 of the total 27 barrels were aged 6 to 14 years, with that final barrel from the Old Heaven Hill Springs distillery being an impressive 34 years old. Was it held that long because the whiskey was that good, or because Heaven Hill felt it’d work best in a blend? We’ll never know, but I have my suspicions. Let’s see if the product we did get is any good. Heaven Hill Unity was limited to around 4,000 bottles and carried an MSRP of $225.

Nose: Brown Sugar, Custard, Almond Butter, Dried Apple

Standard, Balanced, Creamy

Palate: Brown Sugar, Pepper, Nutmeg, Tobacco

Soft, Creamy, Tannic

Finish: Tobacco, Custard, Pepper, Burnt Orange

Mild, Warm, Tingly

There’s plenty to enjoy in Heaven Hill Unity. Everything feels nicely balanced and integrated, giving us a pour that epitomizes many of the distillery’s hallmarks, particularly from the standard bourbon mash bill. The sweet nuttiness is well developed, complemented by robust tobacco and oak notes. Altogether, it’s a rounded and accessible drinking experience that feels catered to bourbon fans who want something that’s a noticeable step above the distillery’s shelfers, albeit without hitting like a potent cask strength product, such as Elijah Craig Barrel Proof or Parker’s Heritage.

And yet, it’s difficult to see this bourbon as much more than a competently made limited release that struggles to justify its price or positioning. The novelty of including a barrel of 34-year pre-fire bourbon in a blend that, just based on specs, would otherwise read like a future Elijah Craig Barrel Proof, feels like just that: a novelty. Everything about Heaven Hill Unity screams competent; almost nothing about it screams impressive.


r/bourbon • • 3d ago

Do you like Wild Turkey 101 or Rare Breed tastes better and why ?

38 Upvotes

I’ve been expanding my bourbon collection and trying to better understand my palate. Recently, I picked up a bottle of Wild Turkey 101 after hearing so many people praise it as one of the best everyday bourbons.
Unfortunately, something about it just tastes off to me.
From the initial smell all the way through the finish, I get a strange medicinal, almost chemical or artificial taste. Somewhere between rubbing alcohol, antiseptic, and plastic. I even tried making an Old Fashioned with it, thinking the bitters and other ingredients might balance it out. Nope. That same flavor was still there.
Here’s where it gets interesting.
I poured myself some Wild Turkey Rare Breed afterward, and that unpleasant flavor completely disappeared. Rare Breed is significantly higher proof, yet I find it much more enjoyable. The flavors seem richer, better balanced, and more natural to my palate.
I also really enjoy Buffalo Trace, so I’m beginning to realize that proof isn’t necessarily what determines whether I enjoy a bourbon.
I’m not saying 101 is bad whiskey. Obviously, plenty of people love it. I’m just curious why two bourbons from the same distillery, with the same mash bill, can taste so dramatically different to me.
Has anyone else experienced this with Wild Turkey 101? Is there a particular flavor characteristic I’m picking up on, or could I have gotten an unusual bottle?
I’m interested in hearing what others notice when comparing the two. I’m learning that developing a palate isn’t just about discovering what you like, but understanding why you don’t like something.


r/bourbon • • 3d ago

Review: Single Barrel Saturday: Larrikin Single Barrel 9 Year, Saint Goose store pick (barrel E14)

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

122 proof | 9 years | low rye (75/21/4) | $109 | Saint Goose, Franklin TN

**Nose:** Some oak and some light fruit. Baking spices, almost a yeast smell like a good southern roll. Hint of fig. Ethanol isn't overpowering.

**Palate:** No dark fruit for me. More of a green apple, slightly sweet, fading to a little clove and baking spices. Medium complexity and a good mouthfeel. There is complexity there, it's all just subtle and goes by quickly.

**Finish:** Oaky. A little short and not overly sweet.

All in all this is a solid bourbon, easy to drink. It does everything well but nothing special. It would make a great everyday drinker if you wanted to sip on something and not think about it. It just doesn't do enough interesting things to justify the price point. Better everyday drinkers at half the price.

**Score: 6.5/10, Next Exit.** I wouldn't buy this one again, but I'm glad I tried it.

This is a veteran owned distillery, and although my personal palate doesn't like finished bourbons, I hear good things about their finished products. This bottle came up a little short for me, but it had enough promise for me to give them another shot.