I find this subreddit, while prone to sometimes echoing strong opinions without flexibility, to nevertheless be very reliable. Additive free is important to me (as much as it is clearly to all of you, on the whole), and I’m also someone who enjoys tasting tequilas made traditionally, with care; as well as some less traditional tequilas, provided the craftsmanship is pure.
I’ll throw out some of the favorite tequilas I’ve tried recently, and maybe we can get into a convo about tequilas that have similar tasting notes, profiles, unique qualities.
Blanco. Tequila Ocho Plata is probably my standard bearer, always on the shelf, for mixing or neat. If mixing margaritas, I prefer Zumbador and Lalo, in that order, and depending on price. For sipping neat, I enjoyed Cascahuin plata 48, G4 Madera, and Fulano Fuerte in that order. Lost Lore’s Blanco also ranks highly for me, which I think sips like a briny dirty martini. Really enjoy it.
I’ve had Fortaleza blanco and enjoyed its minerality, citrusy agave, dewy/oily mouthfeel (think of how an oaky California white sits on the tongue). A solid 7.8/10 in my book. Not unimpressed at all; but you’d think it’s next level nectar the way it’s mentioned in some threads here.
Repo. Far less exposure here, I’ve had El Tesoro, La Gritona, and Mijenta. Mijenta is by far my favorite; maybe top 3 of any tequilas I’ve had to sip on. I know some may say that makes me a sugar bomb bourbon seeking taster; and that’s probably fair to a degree. But despite the attractive caramel, tropical fruit, and warm tasting notes, I like that the agave is very much there at the forefront.
Anejo. I’ve had Mijenta, Don Fulano, and Cazcanes (the latter at a bar). Of this group, I enjoyed the Don Fulano most, especially after it had a chance to open up. Really appreciate the barreling and the milder approach Fulano takes, particularly the French limousin oak barrels proprietary to Don Fulano.
Extra Anejo. No experience.