r/dndnext • u/Old_Sample_1756 • 13h ago
Homebrew Balancing Advantage/Disadvantage Stacking
I've seen thrown around a lot online the opinion that Advantage and Disadvantage should work more like in Nimble, where you can stack more instances of Advantage/Disadvantage by throwing more dice and eliminating lower/higher ones, and all instances cancel each other one at a time.
I agree with rewarding players for their decisions and giving them opportunities to make teamwork matter more, but doesn't this have the potential to unbalance the game by creating certain easily repeatable combos between players that make the whole team overpowered against one or more enemies?
I know there's also the variants of making Advantage and Disadvantage flat modifiers or smaller dice to add to the main roll, but if I would to adopt this homebrew rule in my games, I would want for 5e Advantage and Disadvantage to remain recognisable.