r/dndnext • • 13h ago

Homebrew Balancing Advantage/Disadvantage Stacking

1 Upvotes

I've seen thrown around a lot online the opinion that Advantage and Disadvantage should work more like in Nimble, where you can stack more instances of Advantage/Disadvantage by throwing more dice and eliminating lower/higher ones, and all instances cancel each other one at a time.

I agree with rewarding players for their decisions and giving them opportunities to make teamwork matter more, but doesn't this have the potential to unbalance the game by creating certain easily repeatable combos between players that make the whole team overpowered against one or more enemies?

I know there's also the variants of making Advantage and Disadvantage flat modifiers or smaller dice to add to the main roll, but if I would to adopt this homebrew rule in my games, I would want for 5e Advantage and Disadvantage to remain recognisable.


r/dndnext • • 23h ago

5e (2024) How likely are you to interact with gambling mechanics in a campaign?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 6h ago

Question About swordlock "gameplay"

0 Upvotes

It's been years since my last campaign and I was wondering.. what does a swordlock do better then another class? In a battle of more than 2 rounds what can they do that does not burn their spell slots istantly?

I figured with smites and short rest recover they could be strong but I'm not sure.

Round 1 maybe some concentration spell to capitalize on the duration, then you have to get close to the enemy.

Round 2 you can already risk loosing you concentration by staying in melee range of the enemy or use some smite or another spell and now you're a fighter? Help me understand pls


r/dndnext • • 17h ago

5e (2024) How Plant Growth (2024) Overgrowth Works

0 Upvotes

Just got into a conversation about how this spell works. I looked it up and it seems most people online don't get it either. Since no post came up with a clear correct answer when i searched it i decided to post one. I just have to start off by pointing out that spells do what they do not what you imagine they do based on the name. Spells that don't say they do damage don't do damage even if you imagine they would, etc. Sounds obvious but some don't understand this.

Overgrowth. Choose a point within range. All normal plants in a 100-foot-radius Sphere centered on that point become thick and overgrown. A creature moving through that area must spend 4 feet of movement for every 1 foot it moves. You can exclude one or more areas of any size within the spell’s area from being affected.

This spell has three effects.

  1. All normal plants in a 100-foot-radius Sphere centered on that point become thick and overgrown.
  2. A creature moving through that area (the 100-foot-radius Sphere) must spend 4 feet of movement for every 1 foot it moves.
  3. You can exclude one or more areas of any size within the spell’s area from being affected.

The spell does not say that you have to be in an area affected by the first effect for the second effect to work. It doesn't say there have to be any plants what-so-ever for effect 2 to work. There are plenty of other spells with multiple effects that work the same way. I get that people imagine that it's the overgrown plants that slow the players movement but the spell doesn't say that. Lots of spells have limitations listed but this one does not.

A lot of the comments i've seen focus on the fact that there are plants almost everywhere in reality, especially in 5e settings that are generally not paved over. They point out that generally if there are no plants it's more of a failure of the DM's imagination than a realistic limitation, especially given that plants in 5e is more broad a category than it is IRL. The problem is this misses the bigger picture, that it doesn't matter at all how many plants are in the spell effect other than the fact that the spell is MORE effective in a desert because there are no visual signs telling them which way to move to get out of it.

I get that some tables will want to homebrew it because it's a very powerful spell, but now you need not be confused about how it works RAW.

Personally I find the idea of randomly having it not work when the DM feels like just nullifying your spell by saying 'no plants' as an anti-fun way to nerf it so I would just ban it or rework it if you find it too strong.


r/dndnext • • 9h ago

Question How can I get people interested in my setting?

0 Upvotes

Hi, everyone. Lately, I’ve been trying to be active on social media (TikTok) and Instagram to share my adventures with people, this is the D&D book of my dreams, and we’ve already set up a page on Kickstarter.

I don’t want to post a link or promote it here in any way. I’m reaching out to you for advice because things have been going really, really tough so far. And I’m afraid that because of this, our Kickstarter might not happen. The only thing I can say is that the game is based on authentic Romanian mythology and a world ruled by Vlad Dracula. Maybe this will give me some ideas on how I can promote it.

So far, I've been posting and experimenting with different types of content, including posts as well as short videos on Instagram and TikTok, and I've also asked all my friends who play D&D to follow the project.

People say, “Just make a good, interesting, and unique product, share it, and everything will work out.” But it seems that without a lot of money for marketing, that’s unlikely.


r/dndnext • • 17h ago

5e (2024) What can i do about party imbalance?

9 Upvotes

We recently started a campaign with 6 people at lvl 3 where some of us take turns DMing short adventures (because none has time to prep alone for 1 session per week).

And when I DMed the first session you could instantly see a party imbalance. 3 of the players are rather invested in DND and after some time building characters they gravitated to full casters(obviously) so that they choose to be wizard,sorcerer and druid. They didn't min maxed to break the game but still have strong builds. (Tortle Abjuration wizard)

The other two players are not as invested in combat and optimizing and stook to theyr first builds of fighter and rougue (the rogue being very very unoptimized).

Theyr first encoumter was to show of in a show and the casters used levitate and other spells + wild magic.

The martials were disapointed as the rogue was dragon born solemly for the flight but everyone else in the party could fly better than him and the fighter had although he is a echo knight more limited options than spells.

So what can I do to give more options to the fighter and overall help the rogue? As I'm not the only DM I can't just add random stuff and have to work with magic items (with The risk of someone else getting them


r/dndnext • • 17h ago

5e (2024) Possible simple solutions to the ASI / feat debate

0 Upvotes

I'm a bit confused on the whole argument of ASIs competing with feats, because the 5.5e concept of "all feats are half-feats" seems like a near-perfect solution to me. Yeah, I know they give you an ASI in a specific stat not of your choosing, so in this case wouldn't the simplest solution be to choose between:

  1. gaining 2 points of ASI to give to one or two different stats;
  2. choosing a feat and in any case gaining just 1 point to give to any stat?

I also heard that half-feats hurt the math of the game, but I wasn't told in what way exactly. So is it that this solution still doesn't hold up, and any player should have only ASIs of 2 along with feats at the predetermined levels?

Thanks in advance to all who respond.


r/dndnext • • 11h ago

Self-Promotion Puzzle of the Week — The Sealed Door: four elements, one order opens it

0 Upvotes

Brindlehex, the raven priestess, sets a puzzle for your table.

A sealed door. Four elemental sigils carved above it: FLAME, WAVE, STONE, WIND. The door opens for only one order — touch the sigils in the wrong sequence and it stays shut.

In the video on my profile (u/Brindlehexoriginal), the priestess walks through the clues and the reveal. But the puzzle is fully playable right here: what order do you try first, and why?

Drop your order in the comments. The full video, new puzzles every week, and ready-to-run one-shots for DMs live at brindlehex-2.polsia.io


r/dndnext • • 6h ago

Discussion About bladelock pt2

0 Upvotes

Following the previous post (which I am thankfull for your partecipation and exhaustive answers):

I have a question for those who played or wish to play as one -> what do you like more between using your pact weapon (the one you conjure and can change form) and a weapom your master gives you


r/dndnext • • 11h ago

Character Building Character help!

0 Upvotes

I'll be playing in a oneshot soon with some of my friends. The current character idea i have is a Rogue 2, bard 3 (eloquence) changingling with the rewarded background (lucky feat- because i already have 3 skills with expertise) who is a gold digger and a seducer

My main issue is i have absolutely no idea how roleplay as a gold digger (my only relevant knowledge is Risa from winter moon) do you guys have any recommendations for things to read or suggestions on how to roleplay them?

Additionally my usual table tends to have rolls against each other and what not, should i decline to involve my character in that?


r/dndnext • • 6h ago

5e (2024) Toxicologist v 1.3: A tactical martial support debuffer for 5.5E

0 Upvotes

https://docs.google.com/document/d/10gaz6I-nZrnhm2Q2SDiUUdvH2SuvVtOwCOtr4CSA_gE/edit?usp=drivesdk

Hey guys, thank you for the feedback on Toxicologist v1.2. Here is another substantive rework of the toxicologist. Here is the updated version. Also added a roleplay guide for playing a Toxiciologist, having a Toxicologist in your party, and DMing for a Toxicologist at the beginning and a reworked Poisoner ASI feat. As usual, feedback is welcome and encouraged. Enjoy playing this at your table.

“A barbarian trusts in brute strength to shatter a monster’s ribs. A ranger trusts the wind and the wild to track its footsteps. I trust the three drops of nightshade-silver distillate on my blade—and the anatomical chart in my pocket that tells me exactly where its heart beats.”

— Vespera Vance, Master Toxicologist

A Toxicologist is a scholar of biological weaknesses, chemical reactions, and calculated lethality. Where other warriors rely on strength and reflex, Toxicologists rely on preparation, observation, and precision.

They study their enemies through anatomical charts, dissected specimens, and detailed field observations. They prepare unstable chemical agents tailored to the physiology of their quarry, then deliver those compounds through blades, projectiles, or pressurized aerosols. Rather than being physically strong or athletic, they understand how to exploit the biochemical defenses of their enemies—leaving opportunities for their allies to deal more damage or attack them more precisely.

Their expertise is not magical in origin. It is the product of rigorous study, dangerous experimentation, and an almost obsessive understanding of how living things function.

Some Toxicologists are royal physicians who have learned to weaponize their medical knowledge. Others are covert operatives trained to eliminate political threats. Still others are monster hunters who travel beyond civilization, cataloging the weaknesses of creatures that ordinary soldiers cannot defeat. What kind of Toxicologist will you be?


r/dndnext • • 9h ago

Question One shot time length?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone I’m Running a one shot soon. And I’m just curious on how long it should be.


r/dndnext • • 19h ago

Question Persistent Scanning for Artificer Crafting Components - Suggestions?

2 Upvotes

I'm playing a campaign set in Colorado in 2007, following a global invasion of demons that basically resulted in a partial "end of the world" apocalypse. In said campaign, I'm playing a Hive Lady Artificer with a fleet of small drones that assist me both in and out of combat.

Just recently, I've decided that I want to take better advantage of an ability my drones have that allows them to carry and drop any object that weighs less than 10lbs. More specifically, I'm thinking that I could use them to deploy smoke grenades and alchemist fires for some effective area control.

Problem is... I need to find material components to be able to craft those things. The obvious solution, of course, is to just ask "can I look for components" when I enter a room. However, I'm painfully aware that asking that question every single time I enter a new room is gonna get old quick. I asked the DM (my wife) whether she would be willing to just tell me if I could see components in an area, but she said no.

I could use spells like Locate Item, but that burns a spell slot and the cost to reward ratio is pretty terrible overall. What I really need is something, whether it be a spell or item, that allows for persistent scanning of the area around me and alerts me when it detects viable components nearby, without having to constantly waste spell slots on renewing the effect.

Any suggestions?


r/dndnext • • 8h ago

Toxicologist v 1.3: A tactical martial support debuffer for 5.5E

0 Upvotes

https://docs.google.com/document/d/10gaz6I-nZrnhm2Q2SDiUUdvH2SuvVtOwCOtr4CSA_gE/edit?usp=drivesdk

Hey guys, thank you for the feedback on Toxicologist v1.2. Here is another substantive rework of the toxicologist. Here is the updated version. Also added a roleplay guide for playing a Toxiciologist, having a Toxicologist in your party, and DMing for a Toxicologist at the beginning and a reworked Poisoner ASI feat. As usual, feedback is welcome and encouraged. Enjoy playing this at your table.

“A barbarian trusts in brute strength to shatter a monster’s ribs. A ranger trusts the wind and the wild to track its footsteps. I trust the three drops of nightshade-silver distillate on my blade—and the anatomical chart in my pocket that tells me exactly where its heart beats.”

— Vespera Vance, Master Toxicologist

A Toxicologist is a scholar of biological weaknesses, chemical reactions, and calculated lethality. Where other warriors rely on strength and reflex, Toxicologists rely on preparation, observation, and precision.

They study their enemies through anatomical charts, dissected specimens, and detailed field observations. They prepare unstable chemical agents tailored to the physiology of their quarry, then deliver those compounds through blades, projectiles, or pressurized aerosols. Rather than being physically strong or athletic, they understand how to exploit the biochemical defenses of their enemies—leaving opportunities for their allies to deal more damage or attack them more precisely.

Their expertise is not magical in origin. It is the product of rigorous study, dangerous experimentation, and an almost obsessive understanding of how living things function.

Some Toxicologists are royal physicians who have learned to weaponize their medical knowledge. Others are covert operatives trained to eliminate political threats. Still others are monster hunters who travel beyond civilization, cataloging the weaknesses of creatures that ordinary soldiers cannot defeat. What kind of Toxicologist will you be?


r/dndnext • • 15h ago

Question Mind Controlling / Manipulative creature that is not extremely OP?

2 Upvotes

I need a quasi-stationary creature that is capable of manipulating a relatively large number of creatures to do its bidding, stuff like the elder brain and aboleth could do the trick and are what I am currently going for, but I want to know if there is any other monster that could do that... I guess is also worth mentioning that I am looking for a more magical manipulation style instead of a political influence style.

The context of said creature would be at the center of a rapid growing kenku camp that is starting to show abnormal extractivism of its environment, to help the mastermind increase its power and wealth. We are very early in-game.


r/dndnext • • 9h ago

5e (2024) Class and Subclass Adjustments

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 17h ago

Question aquatic race in non-aquatic campaign?

3 Upvotes

hello all! i am currently building a character for a campaign based on a set of dice i have! they are dark blue with gold numbers.

because they are blue, i wanted to have an ocean/deep sea theme to the character, but his aquatic background won’t have any bearing on the story as it is a land based campaign.

i also have never played an artificer and have always wanted to, so i would like this character to be one.

now onto the question. i was thinking of making my character a triton, but would making him such hinder his character because it is a land based campaign? are there any other aquatic races that would make more sense not only as an artificer, but as a land dweller?

thanks :D


r/dndnext • • 13h ago

What’s a good Xmas gift for a DnD fan?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 9h ago

Question [World of Warcraft] Anyone else with this issue?

0 Upvotes

I preordered the ultimate bundle, got everything working etc on D&D Beyond but recently it started asking me to buy the Icecrown Citadel pack?? Even though I literally have the Icecrown Dice... Just a bug?


r/dndnext • • 11h ago

Your best D&D table disputes and questionable DM decisions!

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

Hoping to pick a few brains here!

A friend and I run a D&D podcast called Welcome 2 Rule of Cool. We chat about D&D, geek culture, nostalgia and generally try to show that D&D players come from all walks of life.

At the end of each episode, we do a little segment called Rule of Cool Rule of the Week, where we share a homebrew rule we've either stumbled across online or used at our own tables. It's actually become quite a popular part of the show amongst our listeners.

We're now thinking about introducing another segment, a bit like AITA, but for D&D!

Basically, those moments at the table where everyone has a different opinion on what should happen, who's in the right, or whether the DM made the correct call.

For example, we've got a long-running debate at our table involving two Tortles. One retreats into his shell, and the other launches him from a height, Super Mario style, straight at an enemy.

The question: Who gets credit for the kill? The Tortle who launched him, or the one who became a living cannonball?

It's the sort of ridiculous argument we absolutely love getting into, especially when neither of us is willing to back down!

So I thought I'd ask, what are some of the funniest, most controversial or downright ridiculous rulings you've had at your tables?

Would anyone be interested in a segment where we debate these sorts of situations and give our completely unofficial verdicts?

And if you've got a good story you'd be happy for us to discuss on the podcast, please share it! We'd obviously give you a shoutout if we featured it.


r/dndnext • • 15h ago

5e (2024) Best individual magic item price guide?

0 Upvotes

I'm looking for a price guide for magic items. Something like "Sane magic item prices" but up to date.

Any recommendations?


r/dndnext • • 15h ago

5e (2024) D&D 5.5 Eldritch Knight spell list at tier 3

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 20h ago

Question How to make an interesting encounter about capturing a Water Weird? (5e 14)

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 9h ago

Question How do you know if your Charcter should Turn enemy on the party.

0 Upvotes

Hi, me and my party have been going on a quest together on invading enemy kingdoms and what nought since one of your teammates is the king of our kingdom. The problem is my character is a noble, and hates to kill. He already was doubting the way the Kingdom was be running was good or not. Due to this fact, under the pretext of being a noble he made an underground criminal organization. Right now we are going through an enemy fort right now. I believe my character would not want this to continue.

So I believe that my character should betray the party.

I read online that it’s not a good idea for it to happen, but like let’s say it were to happen, how do you know it’s a good time to do it.