r/dndnext • • 4d ago

Discussion Weekly Question Thread: Ask questions here – November 16, 2026

5 Upvotes

Ask any simple questions here that aren't in the FAQ, but don't warrant their own post.

Good question for this page: "Do I add my proficiency bonus to attack rolls with unarmed strikes?"

Question that should have its own post: "What are the best feats to take for a Grappler?

For any questions about the One D&D playtest, head over to /r/OneDnD


r/dndnext • • 6m ago

Resource D&D Beyond Content Sharing Thread - November 20, 2026

• Upvotes

Whether you're requesting or offering content please feel free to post here.

If you're requesting content remember that no one is required to provide you access to their content and to be polite to those that do.


r/dndnext • • 10h ago

Discussion Fixing martials with magic item abundance doesn't sit well with me. Anyone else?

90 Upvotes

Disclaimer: let's try keeping things civil and refrain from devolving into a full-on "martial-caster gap" discussion, even though what I'm about to say has to do with that entirely.

It's no secret that one the most oft suggested fixes \ band-aids (iirc, even some WotC members themselves have said in tweets or else that this is what they do) to martial characters feeling underwhelming is giving them more magic items.

I'd say that the Enspelled weapons and armors that got introduced in 5.5e, as well as the Evolving magic items that got introduced with Arcana Unleashed, are evidence that modern WotC's solution to the "Gap" is giving martial characters access to spellcasting (here, have this sword that can cast Fireball. Now you're a real hero, not some martial impostor!)

I have my own gripes with said approach, but that's besides the point. What I really want to discuss is the following:

Does anyone else feel like a martial character's strength being improved with magic items is very cheap and not at all rewarding? My point is, the character themselves isn't getting any better or stronger at what they do, they just get toys that do the cool stuff.

Yes, you can give your Rogue a magic blade that allows them to teleport behind the enemy and deal increased Sneak Attack damage. But what is the Rogue without said dagger? A basic 5.5e Rogue.

You can give your Barbarian a greataxe that allows them to cleave inanimate objects in half. But what is the Barbarian without that axe? A basic 5.5e Barbarian that is, again, kinda pathetic.

But if you undress your Warlock or Sorcerer, they still have the vast majority of their spellcasting present (without a focus some spells aren't castable, but a quick skim through spell lists shows us that maybe 30% of spells even need a material component). A naked Sorcerer can still cast most of their arsenal, use Metamagic, learn new spells on level-up and use subclass features.

So to me the fix of "give your martials cool magic items" just feels very cheap, even if I'm the player being given cool stuff. I mean yeah, I will still use it, but it feels wrong. It makes me feel like a comic relief character that tries to solve all their problems with money. Even Batman can still throw hands without his gadgets or money, but a naked Fighter will still be dealing 1+STR per successful punch.

That's why I personally believe that martial classes' power should first and foremost be improved via changes to base classes, not through magic trinkets.

One notable exception could be some sort of training manuals, which push on the "your martial character has learnt how to be better via learning and training" button even more: let's say I give my Rogue some sort of a book called "Cloak and Dagger and You: How to Deal A lot of Damage" written by Bigby of all people. And now my Rogue PC has doubled their Sneak Attack dice forever (or until, I guess, someone erases their memories?... but that's way too mean). It's still an item (which you can reward them with or let them buy for gold), but one that makes you better inherently.


r/dndnext • • 18h ago

Poll On average, how often do your characters fail their skill checks?

37 Upvotes
2000 votes, 4d left
Practically never fail a skill check
Succeed much more often than you fail
Succeed slightly more than you fail
About 50/50
Fail more than you succeed
Results

r/dndnext • • 7h ago

Discussion Running a Magic-Focused Artificer?

3 Upvotes

This is more a question of flair than actual build optimization, but I'm really struggling with a character design. DM approved Artificer for an upcoming campaign, and I had in mind a great concept. Fleshed out the backstory, feats, did concept arts, really got into it when I normally have a hard time doing that for a prospective character.

Anyway, this has been in discussion for weeks, talks of party composition, seating the place the party would take in the world, After all of that is set and we plan Session 0, DM adds on that there will be no technology, clockwork, blackpowder, or anything similar, full high fantasy. Bear in mind, I've shared every step of creation and verified with them up to this point, from the heavily machine-based turrets (Artillerist) and flintlock pistols, to the clockwork Homunculus designs.

So while I'm still on board, it felt awful, like everything I was building wasn't even glanced at. I'm gutted on the designs, I'm not sure how to run a character built around mechanical invention without mechanical gear. How do I flavor the cannon in a way that feels high fantasy? What kind of All Purpose Tool fits without wrenches and such?

CLARIFICATION; This has been discussed with the DM already, and amounted to "it didn't occur to me, I don't really look at characters until session 0" which is fair, the party does a lot of conceptual design.


r/dndnext • • 5h ago

Running a single-player DnD. Wondering about homebrew rules, and mechanics ideas

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 7h ago

Character Building Drow Blood Hunter Backstory (Short)

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 9h ago

Speaking about WoW D&D

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Other D&D Beyond Hit With Massive Malware Attack

202 Upvotes

https://dungeonsanddragonsfan.com/dnd-beyond-malware-attack/

D&D Beyond was one of hundreds of websites serving malicious code to visitors on November 16th. I put together this article about what happened and how to tell if you may have been impacted.


r/dndnext • • 17h ago

Does a druid with Pack Tactics get a bonus to his spells Attack rolls?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 5h ago

Discussion Are wizard not allowed to get specialist subclasses?

0 Upvotes

I've never really enjoyed playing a Wizard. I understand why people like the class: the fantasy of having an answer to virtually every situation is appealing. However, I prefer being a specialist, particularly in an RPG game where everyone is supposedly meant to have a distinct role to fill.

It's like every Wizard has a major in a very broad subject, such as physics or biology, but never really specializes in any particular branch of it.

The only subclass that I feel genuinely offers specialization is the Illusion Wizard. Its features grant capabilities that no other Wizard can replicate through spell selection or feats, such as modifying existing illusions, creating both sound and image with Minor Illusion, and temporarily making illusions real. These aren't just improvements to existing spells; they fundamentally change how you interact with illusion magic.

Unfortunately, despite being the best example of what I'm looking for, Illusion Wizard doesn't work particularly well at many tables, judging by the number of complaints about how illusions are handled. The rules leave too much to DM interpretation, and their effectiveness can vary wildly depending on the creatures and NPCs you're dealing with.

Most concepts I've tried to build as a Wizard have eventually ended up as Sorcerers instead, purely because of their more distinct subclasses, even when I don't particularly want to play a Charisma caster or care about Metamagic.

I've found one interesting exception in partnered content: the Magic Missile Mage from Valda's Spire of Secrets.

Regardless of whether it's balanced or not, I genuinely like the concept. It's a Wizard specialized in Magic Missile, and the subclass actually changes what the spell can do. It can bypass Shield, apply conditions to targets, and generally introduce new tactical applications for the spell that other Wizards cannot replicate simply by learning it or upcasting it.

That's what I consider specialization. It isn't just making an existing ability more efficient or powerful. It's introducing mechanics and capabilities that give the character a distinct identity.

Recently, I also took a look at the Warcraft content and its Mage class, which has three subclasses: Arcane, Fire, and Frost.

My first reaction was that finally, some actual magical specializations! Unfortunately, I was disappointed when I realized they're essentially all Evocation Wizards, with a framework that guides you into "making your own specialization." Which, frankly, defeats the point for me. Simply choosing which spells to use is barely a specialization when virtually every Wizard can eventually learn those same spells.

This is also my main criticism of the existing Wizard subclasses. Most of them offer a feature or two that is mechanically unique, but don't really establish a distinct magical discipline.

For example:

  • Abjuration: Essentially a tougher Wizard. Being tankier isn't a particularly distinct magical identity when there are numerous ways to build a durable Wizard.
  • Bladesinging: A more nimble Wizard who can use one-handed weapons more effectively. But other Wizards can already use weapons, and Bladesingers will often find that casting spells is simply more effective anyway.
  • Conjuration: Better at summoning and teleportation, but other Wizards can already summon creatures and teleport.
  • Divination: Portent is genuinely unique, and probably the most interesting Wizard subclass feature. However, the rest mostly revolves around spell efficiency, additional spell recovery, and utility that can largely be replicated through other means.
  • Enchantment: Alter Memories is probably its most distinctive feature. The other features improve charm and manipulation, but other Wizards can achieve much of the same functionality through spells and upcasting.
  • Evocation: Sculpt Spells is genuinely unique, but the rest is largely about making your existing blasting spells stronger.
  • Necromancy: Better undead and improved survivability. It makes you a tougher Wizard with a tougher undead familiar, but doesn't offer particularly distinctive mechanics for interacting with necromancy itself to make you different than a wizard that picks necromancy spells.
  • Transmutation: Probably the strangest one for me. Most of its features provide effects that can already be achieved through spells, except you get them for free or more conveniently. That's efficiency, not specialization.
  • Illusion: The closest to what I'm looking for. Its features actually allow you to manipulate and interact with illusions in ways other Wizards cannot. Unfortunately, the subclass suffers from the general problems with illusion mechanics, particularly inconsistent DM rulings and how easily many creatures can overcome or invalidate illusions.

To clarify, I'm not saying subclasses shouldn't improve existing abilities. I'm saying that improving an ability isn't necessarily the same as specializing in it.

For example, making your undead stronger is an improvement to an existing capability. Having unique mechanics for controlling, commanding, or interacting with undead that other Wizards cannot replicate would be a specialization.

Likewise, giving a Wizard more spell slots or allowing them to reproduce certain spell effects for free doesn't make them a specialist. It makes them more efficient.

What I'm hoping for is a subclass that fundamentally changes how you interact with a particular discipline of magic, introducing unique mechanics and capabilities that another Wizard cannot simply replicate by selecting the same spells.

So, is there a particular reason Wizards don't get more mechanically specialized subclasses? Is it a balance concern, is it against the class's identity as a generalist, or is it smth else i missed?

I'd genuinely like to understand the reasoning behind it.

Edit: I don't want to sacrifice mechanical effectiveness just to maintain a character concept. If I choose to associate with certain beasts as a Druid, for example, I shouldn't have to accept being less effective than someone who simply picks the optimal beast for every situation. I want that specialization to offer something in return, whether unique abilities or mechanical advantages that make it worthwhile.

That's why I like the Illusion Wizard. I dont feel bad when i don't pick Fireball to maintain my identity as an illusionist. Instead, my subclass gives me unique tools and alternative ways to contribute in a way as valuable, making specialization a mechanically supported choice rather than a self-imposed handicap.

Edit2: I am not looking for extra power, i know wizards are strong enough, i am looking for uniqueness, something that defines wizards from one another aside from just spells picked, because all wizards can eventually learn all spells, so what differentiate between them? for example, a necromancer should interact mechanically different with necromancy spell, so that other wizards who pick necromancy spells can't just mimic them.

Just like how no other wizards can mimic Illusion wizards by just picking illusion spells.


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

5e (2024) What can i do about party imbalance?

12 Upvotes

We recently started a campaign with 6 people at lvl 3 where some of us take turns DMing short adventures (because none has time to prep alone for 1 session per week).

And when I DMed the first session you could instantly see a party imbalance. 3 of the players are rather invested in DND and after some time building characters they gravitated to full casters(obviously) so that they choose to be wizard,sorcerer and druid. They didn't min maxed to break the game but still have strong builds. (Tortle Abjuration wizard)

The other two players are not as invested in combat and optimizing and stook to theyr first builds of fighter and rougue (the rogue being very very unoptimized).

Theyr first encoumter was to show of in a show and the casters used levitate and other spells + wild magic.

The martials were disapointed as the rogue was dragon born solemly for the flight but everyone else in the party could fly better than him and the fighter had although he is a echo knight more limited options than spells.

So what can I do to give more options to the fighter and overall help the rogue? As I'm not the only DM I can't just add random stuff and have to work with magic items (with The risk of someone else getting them


r/dndnext • • 5h ago

Discussion Should Opportunity Attacks be a class feature unlocked at a certain level?

0 Upvotes

I’m both a DM and a player. I usually play Tier 1–2 characters, and I’ve found Opportunity Attacks annoying.

Opportunity Attacks effectively discourage characters with low HP or AC from moving around the battlefield. This limits tactical movement, often leaving characters standing still and spamming spells or attacks.

I understand that higher-level characters can withstand Opportunity Attacks better, and that melee characters can use them to protect ranged allies. Those are good aspects of the mechanic that I’d like to preserve.

So here’s my proposal: Opportunity Attacks should only be available to certain classes, unlocked as a class feature at a certain level.

My questions are:
- Which classes should get it?
- At what level should they unlock it?

Thanks in advance!!!

——

[edit]
I also mean that some low CR monsters will not have opportunity attack.

I also think that disengage as an action is wasteful. There should be a cheaper (not free) way to do so.

When I said about “battle movement”, I am also talking about the situation where “I need the melee character to move out of the way, so I can cast ranged magic without hurting them. But I really hate to ask them to just disengage and do nothing”


r/dndnext • • 2d ago

D&D Beyond got infected with malware

Thumbnail
blog.report-uri.com
1.5k Upvotes

Yesterday, Optimizely, an ad company, distributed ads compromitted with malicious JavaScript code across a multitude of websites including D&D Beyond.

The malicious code installed iOS exploit shells, skimmed payment cards and stole crypto, among other things.

The infection got cleaned up already, D&D Beyond is safe again. Moreover, adblocker users were most likely unaffected by this attack as Optimizely's domains are blocked by most adblockers by default.


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

5e (2024) Toxicologist v 1.3: A tactical martial support debuffer for 5.5E

0 Upvotes

https://docs.google.com/document/d/10gaz6I-nZrnhm2Q2SDiUUdvH2SuvVtOwCOtr4CSA_gE/edit?usp=drivesdk

Hey guys, thank you for the feedback on Toxicologist v1.2. Here is another substantive rework of the toxicologist. Here is the updated version. Also added a roleplay guide for playing a Toxiciologist, having a Toxicologist in your party, and DMing for a Toxicologist at the beginning and a reworked Poisoner ASI feat. As usual, feedback is welcome and encouraged. Enjoy playing this at your table.

“A barbarian trusts in brute strength to shatter a monster’s ribs. A ranger trusts the wind and the wild to track its footsteps. I trust the three drops of nightshade-silver distillate on my blade—and the anatomical chart in my pocket that tells me exactly where its heart beats.”

— Vespera Vance, Master Toxicologist

A Toxicologist is a scholar of biological weaknesses, chemical reactions, and calculated lethality. Where other warriors rely on strength and reflex, Toxicologists rely on preparation, observation, and precision.

They study their enemies through anatomical charts, dissected specimens, and detailed field observations. They prepare unstable chemical agents tailored to the physiology of their quarry, then deliver those compounds through blades, projectiles, or pressurized aerosols. Rather than being physically strong or athletic, they understand how to exploit the biochemical defenses of their enemies—leaving opportunities for their allies to deal more damage or attack them more precisely.

Their expertise is not magical in origin. It is the product of rigorous study, dangerous experimentation, and an almost obsessive understanding of how living things function.

Some Toxicologists are royal physicians who have learned to weaponize their medical knowledge. Others are covert operatives trained to eliminate political threats. Still others are monster hunters who travel beyond civilization, cataloging the weaknesses of creatures that ordinary soldiers cannot defeat. What kind of Toxicologist will you be?


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Discussion Dms, will you be using the warcraft spells in your non-warcraft campaigns?

25 Upvotes

I'm not very well versed in warcraft, just wondering if you will be letting your players take spells from this book if you're not running a warcraft campaign. Is there anything very setting specific that you think would be out of place? Curious what people think of this sort of thing.
Thanks for your thoughts!


r/dndnext • • 13h ago

Self-Promotion I made a free dice roller for D&D with real-feeling dice, advantage/disadvantage and roll history

0 Upvotes

Hi all! I've just released my first Android app, DM Dice Roller, and I'd love some feedback from people who actually play.

I wanted a dice roller that feels like throwing real dice, not just a random number, so the dice tumble and bounce across a felt table. You can tap Roll, swipe to throw them in any direction, or shake your phone.

What it does:

- d4, d6, d8, d10, d12, d20 and d100, up to 20 dice at once

- Advantage and disadvantage (rolls each d20 twice, keeps the higher or lower)

- d20s are totalled separately from your other dice, so attack and damage come out apart, each with its own modifier

- Calls out natural 20s and 1s

- Keeps your last 50 rolls in history, tap one to roll the same dice again

- Light and dark mode, different dice and table colours

- Works offline, no account or sign-up

Every result uses a cryptographically secure random number generator, so the rolls are fair; the bouncing is just for show.

It's free, with a small banner ad at the top. It won't get in the way.

Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jacx808.dmdiceroller.app

Any feedback, bugs or feature ideas are really welcome. I'm planning updates based on feedback


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Question aquatic race in non-aquatic campaign?

4 Upvotes

hello all! i am currently building a character for a campaign based on a set of dice i have! they are dark blue with gold numbers.

because they are blue, i wanted to have an ocean/deep sea theme to the character, but his aquatic background won’t have any bearing on the story as it is a land based campaign.

i also have never played an artificer and have always wanted to, so i would like this character to be one.

now onto the question. i was thinking of making my character a triton, but would making him such hinder his character because it is a land based campaign? are there any other aquatic races that would make more sense not only as an artificer, but as a land dweller?

thanks :D


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Question One shot time length?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone I’m Running a one shot soon. And I’m just curious on how long it should be.


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Question Mind Controlling / Manipulative creature that is not extremely OP?

3 Upvotes

I need a quasi-stationary creature that is capable of manipulating a relatively large number of creatures to do its bidding, stuff like the elder brain and aboleth could do the trick and are what I am currently going for, but I want to know if there is any other monster that could do that... I guess is also worth mentioning that I am looking for a more magical manipulation style instead of a political influence style.

The context of said creature would be at the center of a rapid growing kenku camp that is starting to show abnormal extractivism of its environment, to help the mastermind increase its power and wealth. We are very early in-game.


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Question About swordlock "gameplay"

0 Upvotes

It's been years since my last campaign and I was wondering.. what does a swordlock do better then another class? In a battle of more than 2 rounds what can they do that does not burn their spell slots istantly?

I figured with smites and short rest recover they could be strong but I'm not sure.

Round 1 maybe some concentration spell to capitalize on the duration, then you have to get close to the enemy.

Round 2 you can already risk loosing you concentration by staying in melee range of the enemy or use some smite or another spell and now you're a fighter? Help me understand pls


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Question Persistent Scanning for Artificer Crafting Components - Suggestions?

2 Upvotes

I'm playing a campaign set in Colorado in 2007, following a global invasion of demons that basically resulted in a partial "end of the world" apocalypse. In said campaign, I'm playing a Hive Lady Artificer with a fleet of small drones that assist me both in and out of combat.

Just recently, I've decided that I want to take better advantage of an ability my drones have that allows them to carry and drop any object that weighs less than 10lbs. More specifically, I'm thinking that I could use them to deploy smoke grenades and alchemist fires for some effective area control.

Problem is... I need to find material components to be able to craft those things. The obvious solution, of course, is to just ask "can I look for components" when I enter a room. However, I'm painfully aware that asking that question every single time I enter a new room is gonna get old quick. I asked the DM (my wife) whether she would be willing to just tell me if I could see components in an area, but she said no.

I could use spells like Locate Item, but that burns a spell slot and the cost to reward ratio is pretty terrible overall. What I really need is something, whether it be a spell or item, that allows for persistent scanning of the area around me and alerts me when it detects viable components nearby, without having to constantly waste spell slots on renewing the effect.

Any suggestions?


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Homebrew Balancing Advantage/Disadvantage Stacking

0 Upvotes

I've seen thrown around a lot online the opinion that Advantage and Disadvantage should work more like in Nimble, where you can stack more instances of Advantage/Disadvantage by throwing more dice and eliminating lower/higher ones, and all instances cancel each other one at a time.

I agree with rewarding players for their decisions and giving them opportunities to make teamwork matter more, but doesn't this have the potential to unbalance the game by creating certain easily repeatable combos between players that make the whole team overpowered against one or more enemies?

I know there's also the variants of making Advantage and Disadvantage flat modifiers or smaller dice to add to the main roll, but if I would to adopt this homebrew rule in my games, I would want for 5e Advantage and Disadvantage to remain recognisable.


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Discussion About bladelock pt2

0 Upvotes

Following the previous post (which I am thankfull for your partecipation and exhaustive answers):

I have a question for those who played or wish to play as one -> what do you like more between using your pact weapon (the one you conjure and can change form) and a weapom your master gives you


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

What’s a good Xmas gift for a DnD fan?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes