Am I Being Targeted by Gunbroker?
TLDR: If you accept credit cards on gunbroker, you are defenseless against chargebacks. The platform also seems to be moving towards streamlining listings and making sellers conform to their rules similar to eBay/Amazon and also allowing fraudsters onto the platform because the losses are coming out of YOUR pocket.
The deep dive:
Sorry in advance for the long post; I find it necessary to raise a new issue for sellers (especially) on gunbroker and am thankful for anyone with positive insight, potential solutions, or encouraging words.
As a general rule, it seems that credit card fraud is an increasingly common area of theft due to the ever-increasing sales volume happening online and the permissive nature of the various card issuers’ policies. I have been an eBay seller for over twenty-five years and back in the pre-PayPal days you only took payment via check or money order and a seller really had nothing to worry about so long as the check cleared prior to shipping. eBay moved to handling all credit card processing internally about 5-6 years ago, and while I can definitely complain about the number of scammers they allow on the platform, I can also say that I’ve only lost one dispute (out of thousands of transactions) since they made that change. They provide full seller protections for all purchases and backstop any chargeback that occurs whether it’s through the sight itself or the cardholder’s bank so long as tracking shows that a successful delivery was made. The fee structure is high, but the ease of use and level of confidence that you’re not going to lose money are both very high. I find these seller protections to be essential because the amount of users making fraudulent claims is insanely high! Whether it’s just claiming to have not received a box (even when you have signature confirmation on the tracking), false returns, cancelation requests after shipping, or disputing a charge with their credit card, I deal with cases every week and they are almost exclusively from zero or very low feedback users.
Unfortunately, over time, the scammers have moved more and more into the gunbroker platform. I used to extol the virtues of the GB ecosystem as I appreciated the fact that you could still leave negative feedback for buyers that abused the system and that they actually removed people even for as little as one non-paying item report (they are much quicker to pull the plug on brand new accounts, which I view as a good thing). But a glaring shortcoming of the GB approach is that they disclaim all liability from both parties to a transaction and only act as a facilitator for the sale–keeping everything at arms length when it comes to negotiating disputes or even setting terms of a sale.
A further complication comes up specifically with firearm sales. I got a dealer’s license in 2018 and moved into full-time gun sales in 2022 primarily using gunbroker as my online platform. In the past few years I’ve learned a great deal about CC chargebacks and the low success rate of fighting these cases. I have had chargebacks occur after the buyer picked up a gun from his/her dealer and submitted documentation to merlink (who handles CC disputes) that included the s/n invoice from GB with the AVS match CC receipt as well as the receiving dealer’s 4473 form with the buyers name, address, date of receipt, signature, and s/n matching the invoice from gunbroker and STILL lost the dispute with the card issuer simply because the shipping address didn’t match the cardholder’s address (and obviously, in the case of a gun, it HAS to ship to an FFL so the address will never match unless it’s the FFL holder making the purchase).
The last time that this situation came up, I got angry and decided to change my terms of sale to limit payment methods from accounts with no or low feedback. For the last two years, I have had a clause in the pictures, in the terms of sale, and also in the description stating that “If your feedback score is 5 or below, you will have to make payment via postal money order ONLY.” When buyers fail to read/adhere to that policy and pay with a credit card through gunbroker’s checkout, I have voided their payment through my processor before it ever processes and then sent a friendly email pointing out the special requirements for new users and requesting they send a money order. This has resulted in quite a few arguments with buyers over that special clause, of course, but seems to have eliminated all chargebacks (not surprisingly).
A couple of weeks ago, I received an email from gunbroker’s support team stating that they needed me to remove the picture with the special terms from my listings as it was a policy violation–as is common with their support messages, the communication was very short and unclear as to what they wanted so I asked for clarification of what policy I was violating. I thought maybe they didn’t want an image included that wasn’t of the item for sale. The support girl responded with “We do not condone requiring different methods of payment based on a buyer’s feedback score.” And then I responded with a long dissertation about why I implemented the policy and that there was no way to protect yourself against chargeback except by utilizing the feedback feature they’ve built into the sight. After several emails back and forth, and my studying of the user agreement and pointing out the clauses stating that “terms are set by the seller and the buyer, by placing a bid, is agreeing to the set terms” and also the parts about gunbroker disclaiming all liability for either party, as well as pointing out that there was no policy stating that I couldn’t require different payment methods for different buyers, I thought that I had actually made a break through when the girl told me she was taking my concerns to her superiors and asked for more documentation of what chargebacks I had experienced.
But the following Monday I got a new message now demanding I remove my terms of sale clause indicating that users would need to pay with money order (apparently, they had only seen the picture the first time and hadn’t even bothered to read my terms or description). So we were right back to square one. The next day I get a phone call from someone claiming to be gunbroker’s “head of legal” trying to coerce me into changing my terms. We spoke for 30 mins with the “lawyer” arguing that the policy was bad for the platform and that they wanted to encourage new users to join and participate. Nothing he said was focused on protecting sellers from fraud or respecting the years of sales and participation on their platform, his only aim was to convince me the policy needed to change. At one point, he actually told me, “It’s fine if you want to cancel these transactions after the fact–we’ll back to up on any credit requests you submit for those, we just need you to remove the verbiage from your listings.” This statement laid bare the crux of the issue: they don’t care about the fraud, they don’t care about your actual policies, they are only worried about offending a new user and even more worried that my policy might spread to other sellers and we’d all band together to stamp out fraud.
If I didn’t have a bad taste in my mouth previously, this crossed a line. This man was advocating for me to be deceptive in my advertisement and blindside potential buyers after the sale was completed changing the terms only because he didn’t want my terms to be public on the platform. When pressed about that, he made a retreat back to “look, it’s just bad for the platform” to which I finally said, “with all due respect sir, that’s not my problem–but the fraud sure is.” He then hung up on me. I can say with 99% certainty that this man was NOT a lawyer, was definitely NOT the head of GB’s legal team, and was likely just the first support agent’s buddy calling thinking they could pull one over on me. Alllll very unprofessional, let alone the fact that the head of legal wouldn’t waste a half hour talking to little ol me.
Fast forward one more week, I get another message from support highlighting a change to their sales policies that clearly states all payment methods must be offered equally to all users regardless of feedback rating. This was sent with the flippant message “We have taken your notes for consideration” while they are clearly telling me to go F myself and bow down. I was out of town for a gun show and didn’t have the chance to reply immediately but when I reviewed my listings I found that they had already gone in and edited the listings themselves; removing the offending image with the terms placed as well as the text in my terms of sale and description.
That was really a bridge too far… I have now removed my items from the platform and am looking for alternatives for online sales.
The purpose of this long post is really just to call attention to the liability that you all have as FFLs–if you take a card for payment, your money is not secure. And if you are selling on gunbroker, they can rug pull you whenever they want. Would love to hear your feedback: Do you think my policy was out of line? Do you agree with gunbroker’s handling of the situation? What online platforms have you had good success with selling on? TYIA