I've had a history of being a people pleaser. Eventually, I got so sick of people that I started avoiding them altogether because I constantly felt like I had to chase people, seek their approval, and please them. Maybe I'm a dick, and perhaps I've become one now, but I'm genuinely struggling to understand a particular friendship.
I have this friend who, on the surface, is incredibly charming and kind towards me. He went through a period of depression when he had nobody to talk to, and I was there for him during that phase. I helped him get through it, motivated him, and supported him when he was lonely. He seems to genuinely appreciate that. He checks on me every three days or so, tries to motivate me, and repeatedly tells me that he loves me.
But here's the catch: he's no angel.
A few years ago, he assaulted his girlfriend and broke her nose. During school, he was known as someone who couldn't control his anger. People were generally afraid to mess with him. Even now, he seems to carry this attitude of "I'll lose control if you mess with me." At the same time, he can be genuinely kind, affectionate, and charming.
Fast-forward to the present. When I try to contact him, he isn't particularly responsive. However, when he texts me, he seems to expect me to respond immediately, even though he never explicitly says so. During our phone calls, he tells me he loves me, calls me his best friend, and even blows me kisses.
I sometimes feel that because I haven't shown him my other side, he has grown attached to the version of me that is always nice, helpful, and accommodating. I almost feel like he's indirectly pressuring me to maintain that version of myself because of how much I've helped him.
Over the last few weeks, I've started avoiding him because I'm getting increasingly uncomfortable with the smothering nature of this friendship.
One of the things I'm struggling with is whether I'm being fair to him. He has genuinely been there for me in his own way, and I don't want to become someone who abandons people simply because I no longer feel comfortable being emotionally available to them.
During our last two phone calls, we had some rather uncomfortable conversations. He would check on me and ask whether I was feeling okay. He also mentioned that he felt I wasn't as emotionally attached to him as he was to me.
I told him that I wasn't in the right place mentally and that I needed some space. I also told him that I don't like feeling controlled by people and mentioned that I'd recently had an argument with another friend who was trying to control me, which was true.
He then said he was scared that he might have done something wrong. He even offered me some money to go somewhere, mentioning that he had recently got a new job. I declined and told him I didn't want his money and that he should just relax.
But despite all this, I still feel torn. Am I betraying someone who was genuinely there for me and who seems to love me? Or am I simply doing what I should have done a long time ago: setting boundaries and distancing myself from a friendship that makes me feel emotionally trapped?
I also wonder whether my history of people-pleasing has pushed me to the opposite extreme. Have I gone from constantly seeking people's approval to avoiding emotional closeness altogether because I'm afraid of being controlled?
I don't want to become a pushover, but I don't want to become unnecessarily cold, selfish or avoidant either.
How do you distinguish between healthy boundaries and simply running away from people?
I'd genuinely appreciate some outside perspectives on this. š