r/librarians • u/Pretend-Chest-6779 • 21h ago
Job Advice First year Librarian on a PIP…I’m scared
Title: First-year teacher at a private school put on a PIP. Am I being set up to fail, or am I overthinking this?
I am genuinely at a loss right now and could really use some advice from educators who have been through something similar.
I am in my first year at a private school as the All-School Library Media Specialist. I teach library classes to multiple elementary grade levels and also teach middle school technology classes.
When I accepted this position, I was essentially handed a library and told to figure it out. There was no established curriculum, no lesson plans, and very little guidance about what the administration actually expected from me. I have spent the past several months building a curriculum from scratch, creating engaging lessons for multiple grade levels, organizing and improving the library, and trying to establish a program that students genuinely enjoy.
And here’s the thing: I LOVE my job.
I love my students. I love teaching. I love being a librarian. I have poured so much of myself into this position.
In fact, during my THIRD MONTH at this school, I was voted Teacher of the Month by my fellow teachers. Not administration, my actual colleagues. That meant so much to me because I felt like the people working alongside me could see how hard I was trying.
But apparently, administration sees something completely different.
Since starting, I feel like I have been under a microscope. I have received constant criticism about how I do things, but the expectations seem to change every single week.
For example, I will be told to do something a specific way. I do exactly what I was asked. Then, at the next meeting, I’m told that what I did was incorrect or that I should have approached it differently.
So I adjust.
Then the next week, something else is wrong.
It feels like I am constantly moving toward a finish line that keeps getting pushed farther away.
I also feel like I have been given almost no autonomy to actually grow as an educator. I understand that administrators need to provide guidance, especially to someone new to a position, but there is a difference between mentoring someone and controlling every little thing they do.
One incident that really bothered me involved a lesson I taught using one of my supervisor’s previous lesson plans. She criticized the lesson and how I had approached it. However, when I explained that I had actually used HER lesson, her attitude toward it completely changed.
That moment really stuck with me.
It made me start questioning whether I was actually doing things wrong or whether the criticism was becoming more about me than my teaching.
Now, I have officially been placed on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).
And I am terrified.
What confuses me most is that several things listed on my PIP are things I am ALREADY doing or areas where I have made significant improvements.
I am absolutely not claiming to be a perfect teacher. I know I have areas where I need to improve. I am new to this school, new to this particular role, and still learning. I welcome constructive criticism, and I genuinely want to become a better educator.
But how am I supposed to improve when I feel like I am never given the opportunity to succeed?
I feel like I spend more time worrying about whether administration will find something wrong with my work than actually enjoying the job I was hired to do.
What makes this even harder is that I feel like the administration making these decisions doesn’t necessarily see the positive things happening in my classroom. They hear about the mistakes, but do they hear about the students who are excited to come to library? The relationships I’ve built? The programs I’ve created? The improvements I’ve made?
I don’t know.
And now I’m questioning everything.
I understand that PIPs are supposed to be tools for professional growth, but I have also read countless stories about them being used to document reasons to terminate an employee.
I am trying to remain optimistic, but I can’t shake the feeling that no matter how hard I work, it will never be enough.
So I have a few questions for anyone who has experienced this:
Has anyone actually survived a PIP and gone on to have a positive relationship with their administration?
How do you navigate a PIP when some of the expectations are things you’re already doing?
Has anyone experienced constantly changing expectations or feeling micromanaged to the point that you couldn’t develop your own teaching style?
Is being placed on a PIP this early in a new position a sign that administration has already made up its mind?
How do you advocate for yourself without being labeled defensive or unwilling to accept feedback?
I don’t want to quit. I don’t want to give up. And I certainly don’t want to lose a job that I genuinely love.
But I also don’t want to spend every day feeling like I’m waiting to be fired.
I just want to teach, grow, and be given a fair opportunity to succeed.
If you’ve been through something similar, I would really appreciate hearing your experience, even if it’s not what I want to hear.
Thank you for reading. ❤️