r/logic • • 6h ago

Question Why Logic people can't spot the mass deception and fallacy in the way the scientific community presents the evolution theory?

0 Upvotes

They commit an outrageous bait and switch and equivocation fallacy, they give evolution two separate definitions. One is just any inherited mutations in the DNA, the other is the idea that accumulation of those mutations leads to new species.

Now notice those two ideas are not the same thing, but by labeling them by same name, they smuggle the latter by showing the first, "see mutations occur, that mean evolution is true, that means we evolved from simple cells".

Why the Logic experts don't see through this shell game and bait and switch?

Also please notice, this is not an invitation to debate evolution. I don't care whether or not you believe in evolution, and i don't intend to debate it here with you.

What I want is to point to an obvious logical fallacy in the fundamental definitions of evolution, which leads to distorted perception of the theory by the population and the narratives surrounding it.

Edit: If you want a simple example how dumb it is, here you go: Let's say I make a claim that 1+1=2, and call it "addition theory". Then i make another claim, that 1+1=3, and also add it to "addition theory". Then i say that since 1+1=2 is true that means the addition theory is true, and since 1+1=3 is also part of the same theory, that means 1+1=3 is true. Do you see how dumb it is? That's exactly what they are doing.

Edit2: also its very important to note that there is no one single official definition for evolution, it's a shifting definition that they pick depending on the moment.


r/logic • • 3h ago

Paradoxes Paraconsistent Logical Monism?

5 Upvotes

What's your assessment of paraconsistent constructions?

I have been deep-diving into Belnap, Shramko and Wansing, de Costa, Priest, etc. and am particularly engrossed by how parsimonious they are.

It seems that a critical mistake made by myself and many approaching the discipline is

  1. thinking you can get B from gluing T and F, when B instead incloses T and F, and
  2. that T and F are verdicts on realness, when they are merely shapes of information

lmk!