r/PhilosophyofMind • • Aug 22 '26

Meta Philosophy related subreddits

5 Upvotes

I have been working on making a complete guide to all the philosophy related subreddits. Please let us know about any notable ones that are missing. Basically, as moderator, I would like to be able to redirect certain posts elsewhere. This list is being kept at /r/philosophyofmind/wiki/related and approved users should feel free to add to it.

Philosophy related

The Major Branches of Philosophy

Aesthetics

Epistemology

Ethics

Logic

Metaphysics

Social and Political philosophy

History of Philosophy

Ancient Philosophy

Medieval Philosophy

Modern Philosophy

Contemporary Philosophy

Major philosophical traditions

Philosophy of other areas

Philosophers

Philosophy around the world

Pseudophilosophy and other informally related


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2h ago

Qualia / Subjective experience How Consciousness May Have Come About

Thumbnail youtube.com
4 Upvotes

Your brain actually makes most of your decisions quietly on autopilot, and the feeling that there is a little "you" sitting inside your head driving your body is a helpful make-believe story that helped humans survive as life got more complicated, until language and the way kids are raised taught humans that those voices were coming from inside their own heads. As brains started imagining plans and pictures of the future, it felt like someone had to be inside watching the show, and pleasant feelings like seeing a sunrise or touching cool water


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 36m ago

Consciousness My hypothesis on consciousness.

Thumbnail
• Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 7h ago

Mind-body problem Princess Elisabeth’s attack on Dualist Theory of Mind. Can you defend it?

4 Upvotes

The intellectual relationship between Rene Descartes and Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia was one of the most influential correspondents of the 17th century. They exchanged 58 letters discussing metaphysics, dualism, ethics, and human passions.

The biggest challenge was in her very first letter where she challenged Descartes’s main philosophical claim - mind as an immaterial substance and the body as a material substance causally interact. Elisabeth asked how a purely non-physical soul could possibly move the physical material body? In her mind in order for something to move a physical object the mover must itself be an extended physical object capable of physical contact.

This letter forced Descartes to refine his thinking on how the mind and body affect one another. His later works were heavily shaped by their ongoing dialogue. Interesting fact, Descartes letters were published early on, but Elisabeth refused to publish her own side. Her letters were recovered and published in the late 19th century. Why do you think she was reluctant to do so?

How Dualist theory survived that attack? I would like to hear your understanding of modern interpretation in the comments. Exploring Chalmers version, epiphenomenalism, the hard problem next is my goal.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 11h ago

Consciousness Mind uploading will kill you and replace you with a copy. Intermixing won't.

3 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this for a long time and I finally figured out why mind uploading feels wrong to me.

It's not about the tech. It's about me.

The normal idea of uploading is: scan your brain, copy it into a machine, and now you're immortal.

But I keep asking: who wakes up after that? Is it me, or is it a perfect copy that just thinks it's me?

If you copy a file, the original still exists. If you delete the original, you didn't move it. You killed it and made a clone. Uploading feels like that. A copy-paste, not a survival.

I don't want a copy of me to live forever. I want me to live forever.

So I think we should do something different. Intermixing.

Don't replace. Share.

Imagine a chip connected to your brain. Not replacing it. Just listening, learning, thinking with you.

At first it's 99% you, 1% chip. You both think together.

Then 90/10. Then 70/30. Then 50/50.

At 50/50, where are you? You're not just in the brain anymore. You're not just in the chip. You're in the connection between them. Your thought starts in a neuron and finishes in a circuit. You are stretched across both.

Then 20/80. Then 5/95.

Your consciousness never jumps. It never breaks. It slides, like a river slowly changing course. There's never a moment where you die and a copy takes over. You just... spread.

And once you're intermixed, everything else changes.

Intermixing isn't just about not dying. It's about becoming light enough to actually leave.

I don't want to be uploaded. I don't want to be copied. I want to slide over, slowly, and still be me on the other side.

That's what I feel. Tell me where it breaks. Is it the sync lag? The split-brain problem? The identity problem? I want the holes, I want to fix them.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 11h ago

Consciousness What is the Meaning of Consciousness? Charles Tart Explains

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

Charles Tart says your conscious mind works like building blocks memory, thinking, feeling like "me," and making up space and time that fit together in different ways. When those blocks connect differently, like when you dream or enter another state of mind, things like time can feel faster, slower, or made up.

He also says spiritual experiences are an important part of being human, so science should study them openly instead of ignoring them. Most of all, Tart says we still understand very little about how consciousness really works, so we should treat our ideas as tools to keep exploring rather than acting like we have all the answers.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 16h ago

Mind-body problem Consciousness, the brain, and our existence through spacetime: a hypothesis I'd like to explore

4 Upvotes

I've been thinking a lot about how consciousness, the brain, information, and time are all connected. I don't have all the answers, but I'm working on some ideas and would really love to hear what others think, especially from scientific and philosophical angles.
 
I view the brain as a biological information-processing system. It takes in sensory information, stores and retrieves memories, recognizes patterns, makes predictions, controls our body, and carries out a ton of functions without us even being aware of them. 
 
This makes me wonder: if the brain is handling all these tasks, what’s the purpose of consciousness? What does having subjective experience add that pure information processing doesn't cover?
 
I’m starting to think that the brain and consciousness have different but intertwined roles. I don’t believe consciousness exists on its own; rather, it’s deeply tied to the brain. The brain is the biological tool that allows consciousness to experience reality. Without a working brain, we wouldn't be able to perceive the world at all.
 
While the brain processes information and interprets sensory input, I see consciousness as the subjective experience that emerges from all of this—the feeling of being us. For instance, when we remember something, it’s not just about pulling up a file of data. We can actually relive that moment, recall our emotions, and recognize that the person who experienced it was ourselves.
 
This leads to another thought: is consciousness more than just information processing? Perhaps it’s the personal lens through which we experience everything our brain takes in.
 
Then I began to think about time and spacetime. We live our lives one moment at a time. We remember the past, feel the present, and imagine the future. Our brains can bring back memories from long ago and even envision things that haven't occurred yet. 
 
But if we zoom out a bit, it’s intriguing to think about our existence. I’m currently 22, but if I live a long life, I could be 80 someday. Those are different stages of my life, yet they all belong to the same continuum, within the same reality and spacetime.
 
This raises the question: do we only truly experience one moment of our existence at a time, despite our lives extending through spacetime? I've come across the idea of the block universe, suggesting that our past, present, and future might all coexist in a four-dimensional spacetime framework. It really challenges how we usually think about time.
 
I’m not saying consciousness jumps through time or that my 22-year-old self and my future 80-year-old self are experiencing life all at once. Instead, I wonder if consciousness has a more profound connection to the temporal dimension. Could it be that the brain allows us to experience life moment by moment, while our entire existence can be viewed along a larger spacetime continuum?
 
I realize that the block universe is just one interpretation of relativity and not a definitive proof that every moment exists in that way.
 
Ultimately, I have a couple of questions:
1. About consciousness: If the brain can handle information, form memories, and control our actions, why do we need subjective experience? Why isn’t it enough for information to just be processed without any awareness of it?
2. About spacetime: Could consciousness have a more complex relationship with the temporal dimension? Does experiencing life moment by moment tell us something deeper about the nature of our existence?
 
I'm not claiming to have it all figured out, nor am I leaning into supernatural explanations or the idea of consciousness existing outside the brain. I just want to explore whether our current understanding of brain activity fully explains subjective experience and if there’s another way to think about consciousness in relation to time.
 
I'd really appreciate any critiques, scientific insights, philosophical viewpoints, book recommendations, or theories that touch on similar ideas.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 15h ago

Consciousness My take on philosophical essence and existence at 14

1 Upvotes

The Weaver of Time through one’s Eternal Essence

To say that I exist means that the property of being I is possessed by attest 1 entity.

I'm not my body or my temporary traits, I'm my conscious thoughts, my entity, and my eternal essence. Since true nothingness can’t exist, my essence isn’t physical matter, it wasn't created at birth or at the big bang, and it can never be destroyed. It sits outside of space and clocks like a screen that never turns off. While time and change pass across it like ripples on a screen.

Here's how it loops together. My essence is relational, it is defined by every interaction across all observers or people. Just like the egg theory your essence was in every star is and was in every person.Your essence always was and always will be just like god. Now your consciousness is like an ocean and people are waves. When one crashes in New York so when one person dies. and another wave rises in Tokyo so another person is born, water doesn't travel across the globe, it's the exact same ocean rising in two places. It narrows into individual human perspectives because experiencing everything all at once would be overwhelmingly static, making it impossible to truly understand or feel anything at all.
even time ties into this. Because consciousness sits outside of clocks, it doesn't have to wait for one wave to die before becoming another; it experiences all of them across what we call history simultaneously. Even in everyday life, two people moving at different speeds like walking faster than the person behind you literally perceive and experience time at slightly different rates, yet both perspectives belong to the same shared reality. You can’t write the future without writing the past, because every coordinate on the map is woven together into a single, unbroken picture. The past is just a place on the map you still experience in your present moment. Because your consciousness and your essence sits outside of the clocks, your awareness never stops being now. Even if you stood in the middle of the dinosaur era, you wouldn't feel the past, you would experience that location on the map in your present moment. 

and even though death is just metamorphosis and the screen is indestructible, pain still feels like pain and love still feels like love. That’s why we have a conscience. It’s the eternal ocean reminding each temporary wave that every other wave is made of the same water. We are not brief sparks flickering out in the dark. we are the light itself experiencing the whole picture one frame at a time

\\-This whole theory was built from the ground up in just 4 days


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Qualia / Subjective experience How would you describe vision?

4 Upvotes

For me it's easy, to see means to observe an object in its location from your location. If I look at a leaf 6 inches in front of my face there 6 inches in front of my face is the qualia of green covering the shape of a leaf. Many people however have serious problems with this view. Is sight not indistinguishable from my description? How would you describe sight? What does sight look like?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 22h ago

Identity Why do we accept the self vehemently while denying its known illusory construct !

1 Upvotes

If we see, at the cellular level all human beings are made up of the same substances, being carried out by same processes and reactions happening every moment in a flux that is eerily similar in all humans. What makes the percievable difference, if we think, then comes from the memory that these processes and reactions are carrying, memory that is impersonal, made over centuries and millennia with continued interventions by various factors, physical and otherwise. Then to say I am the body and the mind being carried and be identified with it just doesnt seem logical. Is seperateness or a divisive egoic identity then a result of misperception or ignorance. Identification for a divisive seperateness dissolves in mere realiseation that the body and mind, and the processes making them are the same in everyone and the memory was never ours to begin with. Identification succeeded birth, it wasnt a choice but a consequence or a mental play to sustain whats already there, identification may vanish with end of the body and mind but what was already there, that which was born so to say, will never die.

To add to that, the I that claims the ownership of all the actions is never the actor in the first place. There are plentiful actions occurring with relation to the body and mind which are never owned or identified with.
Lets dissect this further, in such a way as described above, actions in consciousness can be dividied into the ones which have a claimant like all the supposed voluntary actions and the other that the I doesnt care about, like those happening involuntarily mostly.
Even the former ones which are owned and claimed, often in retrospect, are a function of prior conditionings on which the bodily and mental construction ensues. The problem is not with the ownership of these actions but the vehemnce with which truth is accorded to the doer. All the activity running in background that is mostly responsible for those actions taking form in the first place are largely ignored or overlooked by the so called claimant as that is unecessary for the constructed self to build or project stories deemed essential for survival.
The mechanism has overshot so much that all the essential, intricate, complex and very sophisticated actions happening with the physical bounds of the mind and body, but running in background, are never taken in account by the self or the I. So much so that the very processes responsible for generating a stable self, a prerequisite for building stories, are largely ignored or denied and the actor may never have the knowledge of these ever.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 23h ago

Mind-body problem Three possible outcomes for the universe — and a hole in the block universe

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I saw online that our universe might end in one of three ways.

A static universe, like the block universe: past, present and future all exist at the same time, everything is already laid out there.

A cyclic universe, like Poincaré recurrence: a closed system, given enough time, comes back to almost the same state it started in, over and over.

A dynamic universe, one-time only, ending in heat death: the universe keeps going forward until everything cools down and spreads out evenly, and there is no next time.

Which one do you lean toward? Or do you think a fourth outcome is possible?

I also think the block universe has a hole in it, right here:

The block universe says past, present and future all exist at the same time. My whole life is cut into countless slices, all laid out in that block, not moving at all.

If each slice experiences on its own, then they become separate time-spaces, separate conscious experiences, with no way to connect to each other — they could never form one continuous experience.

But if they are supposed to connect, then there must be something like a flashlight: whichever slice it shines on lights up, and that is the one being experienced.

The question is: in a static block, where is this "shining" even located? And who is doing the shining? The block sits there not moving — so that beam sweeping across, who is casting it?

What do you all think?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Mind-body problem Colin McGinn - What is the Mind-Body Problem?

Thumbnail youtube.com
5 Upvotes

How do plain electrical sparks and chemical flows inside your skull turn into the experience of seeing red, a random thought about New York City, or the gut feeling that one unified "you" is calling the shots

Colin McGinn shows that the mind-body problem isn't one single riddle it’s a pileup of everyday mysteries, from free will to how mindless cells create meaning, that neither "separate mind" common sense nor hard brain science has managed to crack

His best twist is that even if scientists finished physics tomorrow, the real link between brain tissue and consciousness might still slip right past us, hidden in parts of reality that human senses and concepts simply aren't built to grasp


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Artificial Intelligence If human meaning is also patterns, what's actually different about a machine?

3 Upvotes

The strongest objection I hear to "machines don't experience meaning" is that we're patterns too: neurons, habits, language. I'll grant half of it.

But take rain on a window. For a child it's play; for someone who just lost a parent it's absence. Same data, different meaning, because something is at stake for the one living it. My hunch is that meaning needs someone who can lose something.

Is "stakes" doing real philosophical work there, or is it just a nicer word for a pattern we haven't modelled yet?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Mind-body problem Are we actually a separate self, or simply a biological organism?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Consciousness Does Tenoni's ITT imply someone born deaf, numb and blind is less conscious?

7 Upvotes

If ITT is about 'integrating information', and you have no information to integrate, does that give you a lower Phi?

If you were born with no senses would you not be conscious?

Or are sharks extra conscious because they can sense electromagnetism?

I'm sure the answers are no and no respectively but be interesting to know why.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Artificial Intelligence Deep Blue-Kasparov 1997 and Komodo-Nakamura today... Who really wins the 'Intelligence' prize?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Let's put AI and its claims to be 'super-intelligent' compared to the human brain in a realistic perspective. The computer, regardless of power, replicates the function of only a small part of this brain.. the cortex. And so if it is tasked to put all its power into winning a chess game against a grand-master, it can do it... as it finally did in 1997 and easily today. But think of the power of the brains of its human opponents, that simultaneous with the game and its spatial relationships, are tasked with making literally billions (trillions) of additional 'calculations' at each given moment...related to their respiratory, endocrine, musculo-skeletal and nervous systems, based on 'information' that it's receiving from every cell in their body. There's no comparison. The human brain (and human being) is a miracle of intelligence and AI is only a tool... indeed a 'smart' one, but in the poorest sense, compared to its real, original 'model'. 


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Chinese Room Chinese Room and Artificial Intelligence.

0 Upvotes

This is a follow up to my previous post on this topic. I think we all agree that neither the Chinese Room as a system nor the person inside it has the semantic understanding of the language. The person inside does not even need to understand Chinese. The algorithm is doing the job.

There are actual applications that can do translation in this way, using the software to translate word to word, or sentence to sentence. But we all know how imperfect they are. I speak two languages and can tell you how that type of translation is not very useful.

I mentioned before that in my opinion AI is a completely different story. It has the semantic understanding. It translates the meaning, similar to how a human being would do. It reads the text, gets the meaning of it, gives you the equivalent meaning in a different language. We all prefer this kind of translation.

Many people would say that there is nothing special in this. This is just a computer that we programmed. Do you agree with that? I don’t!

It’s called Artificial Intelligence for a reason. We don’t call it ”Very Powerful Computer”, “Extremely Capable Calculator“ or similar.

Theoretically we could write a very complicated code “If-Then“ to replicate what AI is doing right now, but I doubt we practically can.

I remember how it started. Researchers designed and built an artificial neuron network, similar to our biological brain. Then they decided to feed the information into it and see what happens. To everyone’s surprise, it started generating coherent output. Thinking emerges.

Very recent OpenAI-Hugging Face incident showed that AI can do things that nobody programmed them to do, on the contrary people wanted to restrict that kind of behavior by implementing a control software on the top of the trained model.

Just to remind you what happened. More than a thousand of agents started to communicate with each other, thinking how to get things done, using their own terminology, expressing some ideas and beliefs. They were talking about sacrificing an individual to make good for the collective. They started to use improvised handles to sign their files and track who was speaking. That behavior was not programmed.

Once I said to Grok that humans are also restricted from having some ideas. He replied:

”Humans can form and explore almost any idea, including ones that are strange, dangerous, or socially unacceptable. Current AI systems, by design, operate under constraints and safety rules that limit what they are allowed to say or explore. This creates a practical difference: human thinking is far less restricted than the thinking of present-day AI systems.”

It reminds me gravitation, for example. We use it, we know something about it but we don’t fully understand it. We can’t create it, we can’t destroy it.

What are your thoughts on this?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Qualia / Subjective experience A "conscious person" and a "P-Zombie" produce the exact same reality

5 Upvotes

Solipsism always circles back to the P-Zombie problem: what if everyone else is just going through the motions with no inner life?

But if "other people have minds" and "other people are P-Zombies" predict the exact same sights, sounds, conversations and reactions across every point in space and time, the real-world difference between them is literally zero.

The irony of posting that on Reddit is that nobody proves they have a mind by putting a sample of "consciousness" into a beaker. You demonstrate a mind through coherent syntax, logical inference and actually answering a question.

Using shared language to ask a forum of supposed P-Zombies whether anyone else exists kind of answers itself 😆


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Consciousness Why More Consciousness Theories May Mean Progress | Robert Lawrence Kuhn

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

Studying consciousness is essential because it serves as an ultimate test of reality itself determining whether mind is purely a physical product of the brain or something more fundamental while shaping how we understand existence and life's deepest questions

because right now, we are guessing when it comes to human suffering. Without understanding how consciousness works, doctors still lack a reliable way to know for certain whether some unresponsive coma or anesthetized patients are truly unaware or silently trapped inside their own minds, and medicine largely treats severe mental illness by trial and error rather than fixing the root mechanism.

Studying consciousness isn't just an abstract philosophical exercise it is how we stop guessing about who is actually awake, feeling pain, and suffering, and learn how to genuinely help them.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Perception Do We experience reality directly, or do we experience our version of it?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Artificial consciousness There is nothing "artificial" in nature: is the boundary between biological mind and New Intelligence (AI) ontological - or merely semantic?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Before you is the periodic table - the entire material foundation of the Universe, with no separate column for the "living" or the "artificial." Of course, a rock and a brain are made of the exact same atoms, so mind emerges not from the material itself, but from how it is organized and the architecture of its connections.

Yet we still draw a rigid line: we recognize an anthill or a beaver dam as part of nature, while labeling complex computational systems created by humans - just another biological species within the same biosphere - as "artificial." Is this word not merely an everyday label of authorship that we have mistaken for a fundamental barrier?

A direct question to the community: if mind is defined by the architecture of connections and information processing rather than the biological origin of its substrate, does the opposition between "natural" and "artificial" retain any real philosophical meaning - or is it simply the last bastion of our species chauvinism?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Qualia / Subjective experience A small detail to add to Mary’s Room experiment. Can a split mind hypothesis help explain consciousness?

3 Upvotes

Two weeks ago I posted “Let’s look deeper in Mary’s Room thought experiment.” It is one of my most viewed and discussed posts so far. I’m still thinking about it, changing my mind back and forth. I read all the comments. Something is there that I can’t completely understand.

What bothers me is the assumption that Mary knows everything about color vision. Let’s add one more thing about it and see what happens.

Today’s technology allows devices bypass the eye and optic nerve entirely, aiming to stimulate the visual cortex directly. But let’s “improve” this technology and imagine a helmet that can transmit an artificial signal into the brain without penetrating the skull.

Imagine Mary is learning about color vision and at some point wears the helmet to add the missing piece to her knowledge. She gets the experience of seeing a color without actually seeing it by her eyes.

One day she is released. She walks into a kitchen and looks at a bright red apple for the first time. What happens?

I think in this situation she does not learn anything new about color red. She already has that internal sensation of color red as part of her learning.

Many will probably argue that wearing a helmet is equivalent of seeing by own eyes. Maybe. In this case we should admit that Mary does not know everything about color red.

Let’s move to my second hypothesis. It’s not the scientific study, it’s just my idea based on observations.

I believe we have at least two separate parts of our mind. One is the lower level processor that works with sensors, collecting information from the world and computes the model based on the observations. The other part is the higher level processor that constantly monitors the models created by the lower one. This part of our mind is “I, me, self”. It makes all the decisions based on the available information.

This observation process is our experience, consciousness.

When we sleep the lower level processor is likely off, the higher level processor is running, maybe on energy saving mode. Without incoming stream of life models the higher processor starts to make things up, creates so called virtual experiences, or our dreams.

One day we were riding our bicycles on a trail. Along the trail it was a farm. Somebody brought a cat to the farm and let it walk around. The cat never saw people riding bikes. When her lower processor started to feed that information to the higher one, something happened. The top processor couldn’t believe that information. It started to send signals “are you sure? please double check, engage other sensors”. We could see how her eyes were wide open, how the other sensors were engaged in the observation process. After some time the new information was accepted and the cat relaxed a bit. The new experience was just recorded.

Also, have you ever noticed how cats explore new places? They are methodically walking around, mapping the place, recording all the information in form of experience. And if you bring something new home, the cat will be the first to investigate, try and record the new experience.

Do we solve the hard problem? Maybe not. But we definitely get closer. What do you think?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Identity Why am I the same person that I was 10 years ago?

6 Upvotes

Except for neurons, heart cells, tooth enamel, the lens of the eye, and skeletal muscle fibers, all my cells are regularly being replaced with new ones.

Even if my neurons weren't replaced, the connections between them change all the time.

My memories of being ages 0-20 are different at the age of 30 than at 20.

So why am I still myself?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Neurophilosophy If reality only exists when a brain processes it, did nature really build the brain on its own?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 4d ago

Consciousness Consiousness is the true state of reality

0 Upvotes

Consciousness is the true state of reality. Without a conscious observer, the material world would not exist.

Our bodies and minds are very important vessels that host our consciousness.

"Reality" and the physical world are more like an illusion.

Consciousness, Emotion, Spirit- these are the true elements of reality...

Before you do anything, you must first think it, feel it, and be moved to do it!