r/macarons • u/Lethal-Sloth • 2h ago
Macaron help - no matter how much I macaronage, my batter will not become runny enough
If you can't be bothered to read this, just skip to the bolded bit.
Hi,
I've been making macarons following this recipe: https://preppykitchen.com/french-macarons/ (see here for youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zgfdImm_VA)
This is only my second attempt ever (the first was last week). I have only been making shells so far and haven't even got to the filling stage yet.
In my first attempt, after piping my macarons I found that they had bumpy tops, and wouldn't settle into smooth domes. However, taste/consistency wise after cooking, I was happy with them. I did some research (and this is covered in the recipe I shared), and it said the likely cause is under-macaronaged batter. So this time I planned to do much more macaronaging.
Basically I get to the step where I fold in the almond flour. I then did macaronage, but no matter how much I did it, the batter just will not become smooth. I did it for almost half an hour. I then googled and some sources said it should take only a few minutes. Anyway I eventually gave up as my arm was almost dead. Please advise.
I see the recipe I was using advises cutting the amount of almond flour to address this problem, which is what I plan to do next time. However, I wanted to check here before doing so.
1 - This recipe in particular seems to use considerably more almond flour than other recipes I've found, in terms of ratio to other ingredients.
168 g blanched almond flour (about 1½ cups)
120 g powdered sugar (about 1 cup)
100 g egg whites room temperature (from 3 large eggs)
100 g granulated sugar (½ cup)
These are the basic ingredients for this recipe. As a next step, I'm going to reduce the almond flour in this recipe to 140g.
2 - I'm based in the UK, and there is some crossover between almond flour and ground almonds. I used ground almonds https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/groceries/product/sainsburys-ground-almonds-200g, which I then used a handheld blender on with the icing sugar before sieving (I don't have a food processor sadly). However, I'm concerned that maybe the pieces are still too big, and have considered purchasing almond flour from amazon directly, e.g. from here. I am wondering if perhaps these ground almonds are too coarse and I just need something much, much finer. I am a bit concerned as the individual almond pieces (even though each one is quite small) are still visible when I'm macaronaging. Should almond flour for macarons look like plain/normal flour in terms of the size of each single piece?
I would appreciate any advice or insight. Thank you.