r/macarons • • 5h ago

Macaron help - no matter how much I macaronage, my batter will not become runny enough

5 Upvotes

If you can't be bothered to read this, just skip to the bolded bit.

Hi,

I've been making macarons following this recipe: https://preppykitchen.com/french-macarons/ (see here for youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zgfdImm_VA)

This is only my second attempt ever (the first was last week). I have only been making shells so far and haven't even got to the filling stage yet.

In my first attempt, after piping my macarons I found that they had bumpy tops, and wouldn't settle into smooth domes. However, taste/consistency wise after cooking, I was happy with them. I did some research (and this is covered in the recipe I shared), and it said the likely cause is under-macaronaged batter. So this time I planned to do much more macaronaging.

Basically I get to the step where I fold in the almond flour. I then did macaronage, but no matter how much I did it, the batter just will not become smooth. I did it for almost half an hour. I then googled and some sources said it should take only a few minutes. Anyway I eventually gave up as my arm was almost dead. Please advise.

I see the recipe I was using advises cutting the amount of almond flour to address this problem, which is what I plan to do next time. However, I wanted to check here before doing so.

1 - This recipe in particular seems to use considerably more almond flour than other recipes I've found, in terms of ratio to other ingredients.

168 g blanched almond flour (about 1½ cups)

120 g powdered sugar (about 1 cup)

100 g egg whites room temperature (from 3 large eggs)

100 g granulated sugar (½ cup)

These are the basic ingredients for this recipe. As a next step, I'm going to reduce the almond flour in this recipe to 140g.

2 - I'm based in the UK, and there is some crossover between almond flour and ground almonds. I used ground almonds https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/groceries/product/sainsburys-ground-almonds-200g, which I then used a handheld blender on with the icing sugar before sieving (I don't have a food processor sadly). However, I'm concerned that maybe the pieces are still too big, and have considered purchasing almond flour from amazon directly, e.g. from here. I am wondering if perhaps these ground almonds are too coarse and I just need something much, much finer. I am a bit concerned as the individual almond pieces (even though each one is quite small) are still visible when I'm macaronaging. Should almond flour for macarons look like plain/normal flour in terms of the size of each single piece?


I would appreciate any advice or insight. Thank you.


r/macarons • • 18h ago

Pics I love the way variety boxes look!

Post image
45 Upvotes

Birthday cake, mint chocolate, strawberry, cookie butter, and crème brûlée.


r/macarons • • 19h ago

Pics My friend surprised me with these pretty macarons as a little appreciation gift and I’m obsessed

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/macarons • • 20h ago

Convection Oven

4 Upvotes

There’s no real point to my post except I’m getting a new oven (convection with an induction stovetop) in 10 days and I’m terrified to try my first batch of macarons in it. I’ve been baking them about 18 months now and while they’re never perfect, I haven’t had a failure yet. I really need to work on consistency in size. Anyway, I suppose w the convection I won’t have to switch sheets in the middle. Normally when I cooked with convection (I’ve since downsized to a senior community and couldn’t pick the oven) I drop the temp 25°f but with the convection I suppose I just set it them I’m supposed to. I already bake my macs at 290°! But now I’m wondering if I can turn the convection off? I never even thought to look.

Anyone who’s made the transition, any advice?


r/macarons • • 21h ago

Why are my macarons exploding? 🤨

Post image
6 Upvotes

This happened with my last two batches. Is it my oven? This batch is French, the one before was Swiss. It seems to be just one side of the pan so I’m wondering if maybe there’s some hot spots in my gas oven? I noticed this about 12 minutes into baking. I rotated my pan at that point and let them finish baking since the others looked fine. Has anyone else experienced this? Does it sound like an oven temp issue or could something else be causing it? My oven does run hot in general so I set it at 260F and my oven thermometer will read 275F. Any higher and they get very crispy.