r/MawInstallation • u/Imaginary-Maize4675 • 3h ago
[LEGENDS] Given the actual firepower yields of blasters and turbolasers in the OT & Legends, how should Star Wars battles realistically look—and how do hulls and armor even tank that kind of damage?
I’ve been digging through old fan calcs and Legends technical manuals (Incredible Cross-Sections, Essential Guide to Weapons and Technology) regarding the energy yields of Imperial weaponry in the Original Trilogy, and it honestly makes you wonder what Star Wars combat would actually look like if it followed its own physics consistently.
Just look at two baseline on-screen examples that usually get cited: - Infantry Blasters (E-11 in Docking Bay 94, ANH): When that stormtrooper misses Han and blows a ~60–80 cm wide, 25 cm deep crater out of the Mos Eisley duracrete wall, even conservative fragmentation math puts a single bolt at roughly 2 to 10 Megajoules (about 0.5–2 kg of TNT equivalent). Compared to a modern 5.56mm or 7.62mm rifle round (~2–3.5 kilojoules), every trooper is essentially carrying a rapid-fire 30mm autocannon or light RPG in an SMG-sized frame. - Starfighter Lasers & Light Turbolasers (The Asteroid Field, ESB): TIE fighter laser cannons routinely shatter massive boulders tens of meters across (10 to 500 tons of TNT per burst), while a Star Destroyer’s light point-defense turbolasers outright vaporize iron-silicate asteroids roughly the size of the Falcon (~30 meters wide, ~50,000 tons) in a single hit—which requires anywhere from 1 to 75 kilotons of TNT per bolt, even before getting into the gigaton-level heavy batteries from the ICS guides.
With numbers like that, the usual "WWII dogfights and Napoleonic line-infantry firefights" we see on screen start feeling pretty surreal.
So, taking these yields at face value: - How should ground and space battles in Star Wars actually look? If every infantry bolt hits like a high-explosive shell, taking cover behind thin crates or trading shots across a narrow corridor should be instant death from spalling, superheated air, and overpressure alone—and fleet engagements would be blinding, long-range exchanges of multi-kiloton flashes rather than broadside slugfests at visual range. - How do hulls and armor realistically survive this? Beyond handwaving everything as "deflector shields," what’s the lore/physics explanation for stormtrooper plastoid not turning the wearer into paste from kinetic/thermal shock, or starship durasteel hulls surviving even glancing blows from weapons that casually vaporize 50,000-ton asteroids?