r/mlb • u/rbambara • 11h ago
| Discussion My 2027 Hypothetical Hall of Fame Ballot
With the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot officially out, I wanted to put together my own ballot and explain how I would approach Hall of Fame voting.
My philosophy is pretty straightforward: The Hall of Fame should be reserved for the best of the best. I’m evaluating what players accomplished on the field, not whether they were universally liked, had spotless personal lives, or fit some arbitrary standard of what a Hall of Famer should look like.
I look at the entire body of work:
Career value and longevity
Peak performance and sustained excellence
Offensive and defensive contributions
Positional value
Rate statistics and counting statistics
Historical context and how a player compared to his contemporaries
I don’t believe any single statistic should determine a player’s Hall of Fame worthiness. Context matters.
My ballot 👇🏻
Buster Posey
Chase Utley
Alex Rodriguez
Bobby Abreu
Andy Pettitte
Dustin Pedroia
David Wright
Francisco Rodríguez
Jon Lester
Félix Hernández
There are some unconventional choices here, particularly Pedroia, Wright, K-Rod, and King Félix. I understand the arguments against some of these players, especially when it comes to longevity and traditional counting statistics. But I believe their peaks, overall contributions, and accomplishments deserve serious consideration.
I considered them, but didn’t make the cut
Mark Buehrle
Jimmy Rollins
Cole Hamels
Brett Gardner
My NO votes
Torii Hunter
Omar Vizquel
Jake Arrieta
Jay Bruce
Asdrúbal Cabrera
Starlin Castro
Wade Davis
Andrew Miller
Pablo Sandoval
Ervin Santana
Kyle Seager
Joakim Soria
I respect what many of these players accomplished, but being a very good player isn’t the same thing as being a Hall of Fame caliber player
The PED question
I also want to address something that has become a major part of Hall of Fame discussions.
I believe Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Alex Rodriguez, and other historically great players who were connected to PED use should be in the Hall of Fame.
That doesn’t mean I condone PED use or think those players were perfect. It means I don’t believe their on-field accomplishments should be erased from baseball history.
Bonds and Clemens were among the defining players of their generation. A-Rod was one of the greatest players to ever step on a baseball field. The Hall of Fame should recognize baseball greatness, not become a morality tribunal.
You can acknowledge a player’s shortcomings while still recognizing an extraordinary baseball career.
I’m interested in hearing how other people approach the ballot.
Who are your 10 votes? Which players am I overlooking? Which of my selections do you disagree with most?
And most importantly, what should the standard for a Hall of Famer actually be?