r/mormon • u/questingpossum • 2h ago
Cultural Critical threshold for staying or leaving
The other day as I was driving to sacrament meeting, I was thinking about how, depending on how you inventory the doctrinal content of the LDS Church, I still agree with something like 25–75% of the doctrine. It got me thinking: at what percentage is full participation untenable?
There is a world in which a person like me (an 8th-generation Mormon who has many beliefs in common with Mormons) could be a lifelong member of the LDS Church. And yet I cannot imagine ever going back to meaningful participation in the church.
"This is my doctrine"; "this one does not spark joy."
The 25–75% figure I gave is a broad range, but part of the difficulty is discerning what is the "dogma" of the church. For the past 20ish years, I narrowed what I considered to be the Doctrine so that I could maintain full participation. Early on in my long deconstruction, I jettisoned the idea that prophets could not teach false doctrine. I also rejected all the doctrinal arguments for polygamy and the race bans, attributing them to error. But my assessment of the LDS Church's doctrinal content will surely be different than, say, Clark Gilbert's.
If you go just by the Articles of Faith, I only take issue with 4, 6, 8, and 10 (and those to varying degrees). But the Articles of Faith contain, in my opinion, neither the full set of necessary or sufficient doctrinal statements to be a member of the LDS Church in good standing. None of the commandments are in the AoF, and that's what you get quizzed on in worthiness interviews. Also, very few of the distinctly Mormon beliefs are in the AoF.
I believe we should try to be healthy, but I do not believe the "Word of Wisdom" as it's practiced today. I do not believe in temples or temple work. I do not believe in eternal marriage in the sense that heterosexual couples will ceaselessly produce spiritual offspring ad infinitum. I do not believe that tithing is necessary or even beneficial the way it's mandated now. I think that Joseph Smith and his successors pushed against some errors in mainstream Christianity, but that they also sprinted headfirst into other and worse errors. I think the Book of Mormon has some good sermons, but I totally reject its historical claims. I think Mormon baptisms are valid, but I do not believe that the LDS Church has exclusive sacramental authority.
"There is no middle ground."
This quote by Hinckley gets bandied about both devotionally and critically:
Each of us has to face the matter—either the Church is true, or it is a fraud. There is no middle ground. It is the Church and kingdom of God, or it is nothing.
Now, I absolutely reject this dichotomy. (I don't even know what it means for an organization to be "true.") But the problem is that the LDS Church behaves as if it's all true or if it's a fraud. They enforce the dichotomy to compel loyalty and to silence criticism. Hence the infamous remark by Dallin Oaks that it's wrong to criticize church leaders, even (perhaps especially) when that criticism is correct.
I humbly suggest that this mindset is bad on the individual and institutional level. Unless you truly believe that the LDS Church is perfect and that its leadership never has nor ever will make mistakes, then internal criticism is important. Paul rebuked Peter publicly and then wrote about it to the Galatians:
But when Cephas [Peter] came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face because he stood self-condemned, for until certain people came from James, he used to eat with the gentiles. But after they came, he drew back and kept himself separate for fear of the circumcision faction. And the other Jews joined him in this hypocrisy, so that even Barnabas was led astray by their hypocrisy. But when I saw that they were not acting consistently with the truth of the gospel, I said to Cephas before them all, “If you, though a Jew, live like a gentile and not like a Jew, how can you compel the gentiles to live like Jews?”
There is no such thing as a perfect or "true" institution. All institutions and individuals need internal checks.
But back to the main point of this post: I think there is, or ought to be, a capacious "middle ground." But the way the LDS Church currently operates, I don't know that you can subscribe to even 90% of the capital-D Doctrine and still get a temple recommend, depending on how you inventory the Doctrine.
Where do you personally draw the line?