r/mormon • u/Strong_Attorney_8646 • 14h ago
Cultural Why Shouldn’t This Be the Church’s Standard for Reporting Abuse?
This Saturday, Meggan Hayes, Radio Free Mormon and I are combining forces to discuss Kate Lauck’s recent Keystone interview (our channel names combine to the Generally Disagreeable Mormons). We will compare her representations of how the helpline works to the facts of the Bisbee Arizona case recently decided in the Church’s favor by the Arizona Supreme Court.
I intend to demonstrate that both she and the attorney responsible for the result in that case, Merill Nelson, both demonstrate the same misunderstanding or misrepresentation of clergy reporting statutes.
I have a sincere suggestion for an addition to a handbook and I’m hoping to stress test it here. Why should this not be a new section of the LDS General Handbook? Wouldn’t this prioritize the interests of victims more while also providing doctrinal reasons for the positions taken?
“Confessions Regarding Ongoing Abuse
The Savior warned of the seriousness of harming “little ones” (see Matthew 18:6). All leaders within the Church, including Bishops and stake presidents have a sacred duty to protect children from abusive situations. As the Church has long explained, there is no tolerance for abuse within
God’s Kingdom.
When a member confesses ongoing abuse of a child, the bishop or stake president does not promise confidentiality but helps them understand their need to take accountability to adequately repent. The Church does not consider withholding such ongoing cases of abuse from civil authorities reasonable or necessary under its religious teachings. Instead, any leader receiving such a report, promptly reports suspected abuse, even when reporting is not required. He also calls the abuse help line (see 38.6.2.1) and acts to protect the child.
The Lord taught that repentance requires confessing and forsaking ours sins, which includes taking legal accountability for those sins when required by the law (see Doctrine and Covenants 58:43; Article of Faith 12). Bishops and stake presidents help members who have abused children accept responsibility by report their conduct, and cooperating with civil authorities. A member’s self-report does not replace the leader’s responsibility to report.”
Please catch the episode on YouTube this Saturday evening. It will be a respectful and measured critique that recognizes Kate’s overall good intentions but also demonstrates many of the things she states in this interview are belied by the facts of actual cases.