r/mtgrules • • 8h ago

Can I exile a creature that's about to be sacrificed?

0 Upvotes

Someone had aftermath analyst on the board, another player casted an instant to destroy it during the owner's turn, he sacrificed in response to activate it's ability, I exiled in response with path to exile.

It was agreed that, since the sacrifice is part of the activation cost, it resolves immediately and thus it cannot be exiled. I argued that since I'm exiling it on the stack before his ability activates, there won't be a creature to sacrifice.

I understand that mana abilities don't work through the stack, but I'm a little fuzzy if this also applies to other costs as part of the ability, such as "sacrifice this creature."

Update: Thank you all for clarifying!


r/mtgrules • • 9h ago

Does Karn, Argent Defender prevent ETB's?

0 Upvotes

[[Karn, Argent Defender]], has the text "Artifacts and creatures entering the battlefield don’t cause abilities to trigger."

ETB effects often have the wording 'When <permanent> enters, do x'. This might be me misunderstanding the timing, but are ETB's not resolved after the permanent enters?
If so, are ETB's not abilities 'triggered' by the creature itself? Or are they not considered to be 'triggered'? The wording is quite clear for passive abilities, but the wording of ETB effects is unclear to me.


r/mtgrules • • 17h ago

"Q, stacking the deck" rules nightmare

0 Upvotes

Edit: thanks everyone, all questions answered :)

So I have a LOT of questions about [[Q, stacking the deck]]. This card reads like a rules nightmare and I can't find any rules text yet.

1) the copy: where does the copy of the exiled card go? In exile? In my hand? On the stack? Does the copy disappear if I choose not to cast it or does it stay in whatever zone it is created?

2) the casting speed: at which point am I allowed to cast the copy? Do I have to cast it when I activate the "exile a handcard" ability (as it resolves), can I wait and cast the copy later in my turn or during the next opponents turn (if it's an instant spell)?

If I have to cast it as the "create a copy" ability resolves, how does the stack work? Does the ability stay on the stack until the copy resolves or is the ability gone from the stack as I cast the copy?

3) interaction with other card effects:

A) Rebound: will rebound trigger in my next upkeep if the copy had this effect?

B) Evoke: If I evoke the copy, will it land in my graveyard or does the copy cease to exist bc it's a token?

C) Dash: same as evoke, but does the copy bounce back into my hand or cease to exist?

D) [[Clarion Conqueror]]: CC still prevents me from activating the ability of the exiled card and create a copy, right (if it's one of the named card types)? What I mean is, does CC affect cards in exile?


r/mtgrules • • 10h ago

Counterspell against a permanent with ward

0 Upvotes

Do i still gotta pay the ward cost of aauron the dark lord if i countered it before entering the battlefield?


r/mtgrules • • 47m ago

Phasing and the death of a thief.

• Upvotes

This came up in a game I recently played. I stole an opponents creature with [dragonlord silumgar] and attacked with it on the next turn. A different opponent phased it out and then killed me before it could phase back in.

As I understand it it's supposed to phase back in under my control at the beginning of my untap step and then go back to its controller immediately. But since my untap step will never come, with me being dead, does it just stay phased out forever? Does it phase back in on its owners turn? How does this work?


r/mtgrules • • 7h ago

Can I play the cards plotted by mohiam with madcap jester

0 Upvotes

I was looking over the new mohiam, imperial truthslayer and was wondering, if madcap jester is out and mohiam plots the cards from the opponents libraries would I be able to play them (if It has flash or is an instant)?


r/mtgrules • • 11h ago

Slicer, Hired Muscle and Saw in Half

0 Upvotes

I had an interesting game action the other day.

One player received [[Slicer, Hired Muscle]] from it's owner. on their turn, they used [[Saw in Half]], *destroying Slicer and creating two copies.

The legend rule applies here, but Slicer's text says that it cannot be sacrificed. How does this resolve?


r/mtgrules • • 18h ago

About Stable Wormhole

0 Upvotes

So I currently have an Emmara Soul of the Accord deck that I am considering this card for, but I have a question about how [[Stable Wormhole]] interacts with [[Reconnaissance]] from the Assassins Creed set. If I use Reconnaissance to remove my tokens from combat do I still get the Planet token?


r/mtgrules • • 14h ago

How triggered am I?

0 Upvotes

If I have Caesar, Legion's Emperor + Roaming Throne + Isshin, Two Heavens as One on the field how many triggers of Caesar would I get?


r/mtgrules • • 23h ago

Void Winnower vs Panoptic Mirror?

0 Upvotes

Some friends and I were playing a game and one of them casted Void Winnower but one of my friends had Panoptic mirror out and Blood tribute was imprinted on it. With mirror making copies and those copies being able to be “played” would that bypass Void Winnower or would it still get blocked since it’s an even mana cast?


r/mtgrules • • 5h ago

Question "becomes a copy until end of turn" on a creature with an end step trigger

2 Upvotes

Hello, just looking for some clarity on the resolution of something.

Lets say i have [[Golbez, Crystal Collector]] on the field. I use [[Shore Leave Planet]] to make a temporary copy of Golbez thats not legendary. I have 4 artifacts independent of the copy.

I move to my end step and Golbez triggers since I have 4 artifacts. Would the Shore Leave Planet copy also trigger, or does it cease being a copy of Golbez before the trigger would occur. Thanks!


r/mtgrules • • 9h ago

Any difference in adding, or not, "then" between two effects

2 Upvotes

I've been looking at different effects, like scry, draw, proliferate, etc., and I've noticed that sometimes an effect such like "scry 1" will be followed by "draw a card", but in some instances the scry effect will be written such as "scry 1, then draw...", such as in [[Jace, Unraveler of Secret]] and other times it will not, like in [[Opt]], where the two effects are separated by a period. Is there any difference between the two effects? Similarly, there are cards like [[Grim Affliction]] that have you put a -1/-1 counter on a creature and "then" proliferate. Would there have been any difference if the card had said "Put a -1/-1 counter on target creature. Proliferate."?