r/mtgrules • u/Silly_Guarantee_7641 • 8h ago
Can I exile a creature that's about to be sacrificed?
Someone had aftermath analyst on the board, another player casted an instant to destroy it during the owner's turn, he sacrificed in response to activate it's ability, I exiled in response with path to exile.
It was agreed that, since the sacrifice is part of the activation cost, it resolves immediately and thus it cannot be exiled. I argued that since I'm exiling it on the stack before his ability activates, there won't be a creature to sacrifice.
I understand that mana abilities don't work through the stack, but I'm a little fuzzy if this also applies to other costs as part of the ability, such as "sacrifice this creature."
Update: Thank you all for clarifying!