r/mtgrules • • 4h ago

Rocksteady and Bebop, and Avenger of the fallen.

1 Upvotes

Hello all I'm not sure how this interaction would go.

So when Avenger of the Fallen attacks he creates 1/1 red warriors.

And when Rocksteady and Bebop attack you must either sacrifice a creature or discard a card.

Would Rocksteady and Bebop be able to sacrifice one of the warriors created by Avenger of the Fallen?

Thank you,


r/mtgrules • • 4h ago

Valid targets

2 Upvotes

[[Kiari, the Swirling sky]] dies and I target an enchantment and a food token. In response my opponents sacrifices the food. Does the ability fizzle as one of the legal target is no longer valid similar to [[Decimate]]


r/mtgrules • • 5h ago

Dack Fayden, Helping Hand + Bronzebeak Foragers

1 Upvotes

I'm interested in how this interaction between [[Dack Fayden, Helping Hand]] and [[Bronzebeak Foragers]] would work. This is how I understand it, but I'm probably wrong - that's where you experts come in.

Assuming I am playing three other opponents. I cast Dack Fayden, Helping Hand and his ETB triggers. I reveal cards from the top of my library until I reveal three creature cards, one of which is Bronzebeak Foragers. Those creatures hit the battlefield. Bronzebeak Foragers ETB triggers and goes onto the stack. Dack's ETB finishes resolving so I shuffle, goad the creatures, choose a different opponent to gain control of each creature. Then Bronzebeak Foragers ETB resolves and I target all of the creatures my opponents gained control of (including Bronzebeak Foragers since my opponent controls it now). When Bronzebeak gets exiled (via its own ETB trigger), will the other two cards exiled with him return to the battlefield back under my control?


r/mtgrules • • 6h ago

Jace multiverse architect loyalty abilities on recast

1 Upvotes

If I use a loyalty ability that kills Jace and puts him back into the command zone can I recast him and use his loyalty ability again?


r/mtgrules • • 7h ago

Sphinx of second sun and second main phase?

0 Upvotes

If i have sphinx of second sun on the board do i still get my second post combat mainphase so like casting spells at sorcery speeds or do i just immidiaetly go to my beginning phase after my combat phase so i dont have a second mainphase?


r/mtgrules • • 7h ago

Proliferate twice and sagas

1 Upvotes

Just to be sure, if I would proliferate twice a Sara's lore counters like going from chapter 1 to chapter 3 w would two still go on the stack?


r/mtgrules • • 7h ago

Uldaros theorix and moonlight meditation interaction

1 Upvotes

If moonlight meditation is on uldaros from its cast trigger can the other copy of spells enter as copies of uldaros activating the cast trigger for those tokens?


r/mtgrules • • 7h ago

Question about Defense of the Heart

0 Upvotes

the card says "At the beginning of your upkeep, if an opponent controls three or more creatures, sacrifice this enchantment, search your library for up to two creature cards, put those cards onto the battlefield, then shuffle."

My interpretation was that because the sacrificing part of the text comes before the tutor part, you don't get to tutor because the card is sacrificed?

But based on people's discourse online, I'm wrong and you sacrifice it, therefore you get to tutor 2 creatures??

Edit: thank you for the quick responses!


r/mtgrules • • 8h ago

Vincent, Vengeful Atoner, Chaos Trigger

2 Upvotes

Does the last ability of [[Vincent, Vengeful Atoner]] goes on the stack even if he has less than 7 power (and just fizzle/don’t do the damage)?

The Gatherer database has a quote about this it’s in the opposite direction (from 7->6 power = fizzle) but would it work if you attack with 6 power (since he get a +1/+1)?

The quote in question:

(6/6/2025)

“Vincent's last ability doesn't care what Vincent's power is when it deals combat damage to an opponent; it only matters what its power is when the ability resolves. For example, if Vincent's power was 7 when it dealt combat damage to an opponent but is reduced to 6 just before its last ability resolves, it won't deal any additional damage when the last ability resolves.”


r/mtgrules • • 8h ago

Layering effect interaction

0 Upvotes

Its been a while since I’ve seen a post similar to this question. I’m pretty sure I know the answer already but I’d rather double check.
Colossus hammer removes a creatures pre-existing ability to fly. However that same creature can regain flight if given something that grants flying is placed upon it. Up to this point I’m good and clear.

However “Odric, Lunarch marshal” grants a bunch of key word abilities pending board state during battle phase. If equipped creature has native flying would that trigger ODRIC’S ability and it regains flight. And if so would it be a temp or permanent regain?
I’m assuming that it would trigger and then be a temp flyer


r/mtgrules • • 8h ago

Phasing and the death of a thief.

0 Upvotes

This came up in a game I recently played. I stole an opponents creature with [dragonlord silumgar] and attacked with it on the next turn. A different opponent phased it out and then killed me before it could phase back in.

As I understand it it's supposed to phase back in under my control at the beginning of my untap step and then go back to its controller immediately. But since my untap step will never come, with me being dead, does it just stay phased out forever? Does it phase back in on its owners turn? How does this work?


r/mtgrules • • 9h ago

Gwyndala, the Prodigy interaction with Leonardo Da Vinci

1 Upvotes

Hey ! I have Gwyndala, the prodigy and Leonardo da Vinci on the field, I use Leonardo's second ability to pitch a colossus hammer making a thopter token with the colossus hammer text. Would I be able to use Gywndalas ability to copy that colossus hammer onto my existing equipment tokens equipped on other creatures etc ?


r/mtgrules • • 11h ago

Question about [[Alaundo the Seer]] and zero cost cards

1 Upvotes

Question about [[Alaundo the Seer]] and zero cost cards. If you use his ability to exile the card it will no time counters because it has 0 for its cost. Does that mean that it will imminently cast, or will it sit in exile forever because there are no counters to remove and thus the trigger to cast can't activate. I tried looking around and couldn't find anyone else asking this, Any/all help is appreciated!


r/mtgrules • • 13h ago

[[Salinae, the Ocean Mother]] and Clone creatures

1 Upvotes

If I have [[Salinae, the Ocean Mother]] on the battle field and I cast a clone creature, like [[Mirrorhall Mimic]] and I have it enter as a copy of my opponent's creature, does the fish created by Salinae that is a copy of Mirrorhall Mimic, does it enter as the copy of the creature the original Mirrorhall copied?


r/mtgrules • • 13h ago

Question "becomes a copy until end of turn" on a creature with an end step trigger

2 Upvotes

Hello, just looking for some clarity on the resolution of something.

Lets say i have [[Golbez, Crystal Collector]] on the field. I use [[Shore Leave Planet]] to make a temporary copy of Golbez thats not legendary. I have 4 artifacts independent of the copy.

I move to my end step and Golbez triggers since I have 4 artifacts. Would the Shore Leave Planet copy also trigger, or does it cease being a copy of Golbez before the trigger would occur. Thanks!


r/mtgrules • • 15h ago

Massimo and Samut, Tyrant of Naktamun

1 Upvotes

Hello!
I wanted to confirm my idea of using Massimo’s Combat-Exiled One Drops to be protected by Samut’s Split Second ability.

If for example, I have both Massimo and Samut out, and have a Slither Blade with Lightning Bolt and a Invisible Stalked with Path to Exile, would the Split Second keep those spells protected from responses?

Or would the Split Second have awkward interactions with their combat damage triggers, causing one spell to not be cast-able?


r/mtgrules • • 15h ago

Can I play the cards plotted by mohiam with madcap jester

0 Upvotes

I was looking over the new mohiam, imperial truthslayer and was wondering, if madcap jester is out and mohiam plots the cards from the opponents libraries would I be able to play them (if It has flash or is an instant)?


r/mtgrules • • 16h ago

Can I exile a creature that's about to be sacrificed?

0 Upvotes

Someone had aftermath analyst on the board, another player casted an instant to destroy it during the owner's turn, he sacrificed in response to activate it's ability, I exiled in response with path to exile.

It was agreed that, since the sacrifice is part of the activation cost, it resolves immediately and thus it cannot be exiled. I argued that since I'm exiling it on the stack before his ability activates, there won't be a creature to sacrifice.

I understand that mana abilities don't work through the stack, but I'm a little fuzzy if this also applies to other costs as part of the ability, such as "sacrifice this creature."

Update: Thank you all for clarifying!


r/mtgrules • • 17h ago

Does Karn, Argent Defender prevent ETB's?

0 Upvotes

[[Karn, Argent Defender]], has the text "Artifacts and creatures entering the battlefield don’t cause abilities to trigger."

ETB effects often have the wording 'When <permanent> enters, do x'. This might be me misunderstanding the timing, but are ETB's not resolved after the permanent enters?
If so, are ETB's not abilities 'triggered' by the creature itself? Or are they not considered to be 'triggered'? The wording is quite clear for passive abilities, but the wording of ETB effects is unclear to me.


r/mtgrules • • 18h ago

Any difference in adding, or not, "then" between two effects

2 Upvotes

I've been looking at different effects, like scry, draw, proliferate, etc., and I've noticed that sometimes an effect such like "scry 1" will be followed by "draw a card", but in some instances the scry effect will be written such as "scry 1, then draw...", such as in [[Jace, Unraveler of Secret]] and other times it will not, like in [[Opt]], where the two effects are separated by a period. Is there any difference between the two effects? Similarly, there are cards like [[Grim Affliction]] that have you put a -1/-1 counter on a creature and "then" proliferate. Would there have been any difference if the card had said "Put a -1/-1 counter on target creature. Proliferate."?


r/mtgrules • • 18h ago

Counterspell against a permanent with ward

0 Upvotes

Do i still gotta pay the ward cost of aauron the dark lord if i countered it before entering the battlefield?


r/mtgrules • • 19h ago

Can I [[Narset's Reversal]] a spell from a [[Massimo, The Magician]] trigger?

1 Upvotes

If I deal combat damage with a creature and I cast a card with a [[Massimo, the Magician]] trigger, can I then cast [[Narset's Reversal]] on that card, even though it was copied from Exile?


r/mtgrules • • 19h ago

Slicer, Hired Muscle and Saw in Half

0 Upvotes

I had an interesting game action the other day.

One player received [[Slicer, Hired Muscle]] from it's owner. on their turn, they used [[Saw in Half]], *destroying Slicer and creating two copies.

The legend rule applies here, but Slicer's text says that it cannot be sacrificed. How does this resolve?


r/mtgrules • • 22h ago

How triggered am I?

0 Upvotes

If I have Caesar, Legion's Emperor + Roaming Throne + Isshin, Two Heavens as One on the field how many triggers of Caesar would I get?