r/opera • u/_SamGuevenne • 11h ago
New to Opera - Help me find out why I can't appreciate Puccini (but like Verdi)
TLDR at the bottom
I'm in love with Verdis La Traviata for about 15 years (since I was in my teens), it really means a lot to me. Aside from that one, I only listened to two other operas over those years, I like both: Heinrich Marschner's "Der Vampyr" and Bizet's Carmen.
I wanted try out other operas and subscribed to MetOnDemand for a month. I started with Puccini: Tosca and La Boheme. The singers were awesome, I liked the story, but not a single song or melody got stuck in my head. I couldn't even remember one if I tried (except for Vissi d'arte maybe)..and I tried while listening to some songs multiple times afterwards. It's like nothing really stood out which is kind of weird because I heard people say Puccini was 'opera for the masses' (as a negative thing).
I thought maybe opera's not for me then (except La Traviata) but decided to at least listen to some other works of Verdi to check if it's a composer issue. So far I've listened to multiple recordings of Il Trovatore and Rigoletto and I like these SO much more already and definitely will watch them too. (You can tell for sure but I have zero clue about music theory and composing.)
Any idea what could be the cause? What's the main difference between Verdi and Puccini? I heard Puccinis songs were more approachable and memorable, but to me it's exactly the other way round?
Bonus question: Is there another composer or specific opera that I should try that's similar to the operas I like?
TLDR: After adoring La Traviata for 15 years I tried to get into other operas. Puccinis works sounded strangely boring and unmemorable for me - but I do seem to like other operas by (1850s) Verdi. Any idea why or am I just an idiot? What should I try next?