r/opera • • Sep 19 '25

Hello /r/opera-philes! So, we've lasted 15 years without an official set of rules, is it time to make some?

85 Upvotes

I'm getting tired of bad actors that we have to ban or mute complaining that they had no idea their obnoxiousness wouldn't be allowed in a nice place like this.

Do we need a policy on politics in opera? Or, what I think is starting to appear more often, political soapboxing with a tenuous opera angle? And, more generally, do we want to be specific about what is ad isn't on topic?

What's too clickbaity?

Where should we draws the line between debate and abuse?

What degree of self-promotion (by artists, composers, etc.) or promotion of events and companies in which the OP has an interest, is acceptable?

Please share your thoughts, thanks! <3

Edit: One thing that's come up in the conversation is that because we don't have an actual rules page, in the new (shreddit) desktop interface, the option to enter custom report reasons in the reporting interface is unavailable. (This does still work on the OG desktop and in the app.) That's one motivator to create at least a minimal set of rules to refer to.

N.B. I've changed the default sort to 'New' so change it if you want to see the popular comments


r/opera • • 11h ago

New to Opera - Help me find out why I can't appreciate Puccini (but like Verdi)

22 Upvotes

TLDR at the bottom

I'm in love with Verdis La Traviata for about 15 years (since I was in my teens), it really means a lot to me. Aside from that one, I only listened to two other operas over those years, I like both: Heinrich Marschner's "Der Vampyr" and Bizet's Carmen.

I wanted try out other operas and subscribed to MetOnDemand for a month. I started with Puccini: Tosca and La Boheme. The singers were awesome, I liked the story, but not a single song or melody got stuck in my head. I couldn't even remember one if I tried (except for Vissi d'arte maybe)..and I tried while listening to some songs multiple times afterwards. It's like nothing really stood out which is kind of weird because I heard people say Puccini was 'opera for the masses' (as a negative thing).

I thought maybe opera's not for me then (except La Traviata) but decided to at least listen to some other works of Verdi to check if it's a composer issue. So far I've listened to multiple recordings of Il Trovatore and Rigoletto and I like these SO much more already and definitely will watch them too. (You can tell for sure but I have zero clue about music theory and composing.)

Any idea what could be the cause? What's the main difference between Verdi and Puccini? I heard Puccinis songs were more approachable and memorable, but to me it's exactly the other way round?

Bonus question: Is there another composer or specific opera that I should try that's similar to the operas I like?

TLDR: After adoring La Traviata for 15 years I tried to get into other operas. Puccinis works sounded strangely boring and unmemorable for me - but I do seem to like other operas by (1850s) Verdi. Any idea why or am I just an idiot? What should I try next?


r/opera • • 15h ago

Just needed to rave about Saoia Hernandez's Tosca

29 Upvotes

What more can I say? I loved it. The friend I brought with me also loved it.

On a more detailed note, I loved the acting choices that the entire cast made. There are definitely times where the cast plays up some of the potentially lighter and comedic moments, such as Tosca's jealousy and Cavaradossi fixing his appearance before he sees Tosca. It feels great to see a production where everything in the drama really gets attention alongside the vocalism.

Hernandez was absolutely fantastic. We didn't sit too high up, so I'm sure we missed out on some of the acoustics, but it was amazing to hear her with an incredible command of dynamics and control. There are a lot of genuinely quiet, lyrical moments, alongside all the outbursts and extremely piercing and exciting high notes. Her acting was also incredibly detailed and I think there were a lot of times that she really did things in a way that read well from within the house and absolutely emphasized the drama. I'm really speaking from a very detailed singer point of view and breaking many things down because I think there's a lot to learn, but I think that she is simply moving and someone who truly has everything that the art form needs. Her acting was absolutely as naturalistic or as intense as needed, depending on the scene and context. She got applause on every entrance which was more than deserved.

Seokjong Baek was even better in house as Cavaradossi. His singing was extremely secure and he delivered all of the high notes even better than on the excerpts the Met released. The dramatic detail was once again impeccable and I am typing this a couple hours post performance, but he was incredibly convincing in the second act and really sold it, with a very good vittoria that got so much applause that his next lines were basically inaudible due to the entire house clapping. I wish I could accurately describe it, but the best I have is that he probably held a huge b-flat for 10s, and then immediately launched in to his next lines with no reserve. Both of his arias were also beautifully delivered. If the Met did encores, I think most of us would've called for bis after e lucevan. The moments where he shared with Tosca were also incredible and they really sold the idea that Tosca and Cavaradossi are young and intensely in love with each other, with lots of flirtatious moments.

Quinn Kelsey definitely fit my idea of Scarpia, someone who is pious and terrifyingly respectful but genuinely depraved, and I would really say that his voice has much more color in house, which gets lost in recording. His first entrance is menacing, but he switches easily when Tosca comes on, and I think if any of us were Tosca, we would've been fooled. The way he handles the scene right after Cavardossi gets pulled for execution and gia mi dicon venal is honestly one of the most chilling and visceral experiences ever in house, and he sings and acts the undercurrent of menace extremely well despite how mundane and genial the text would make him seem. There's always a little bit of him where he's acting nice, but forcing someone else to do what he wants (such as when he invites Tosca to dine, but essentially forces her into sitting at his table), and that really helps sell the idea of Scarpia as someone who is respectable on the outside, but utterly evil and uses whatever at his disposal to acheive his selfish goals.

I'm sure that I've left things out, but I really loved this cast. Would recommend all of the cast when they come back to the Met and it's so worth all the trouble getting to the city this week.


r/opera • • 5h ago

Asmik Grigorian Met Opera Recital

3 Upvotes

Anyone else find it odd that she’s doing nine arias and no art song? I like attending recitals because I get to hear works I wouldn’t necessarily be able to buy tickets to during the full season. I will be listening in house but this is the most disappointing recital program I’ve seen so far at the met. So far I have previously attended Sonya Yoncheva, Lise Davidsen and Anna Netrebko in recital at the met - all of which had a heavy art song program.


r/opera • • 2h ago

Prague opera?

2 Upvotes

It looks like I'm going to be in Prague in December. I can see Dvorak's Rusalka and/or Purcell's Dido and Aeneas. Any thoughts / recommendations from the crowd? Both on prioritization and what I should expect? E.g. should I expect regietheater or something more traditional? Rusalka is at the National Theater while Dido and Aeneas is at the Estates Theater- any thoughts on the venues? I'm not familiar with the cast for either- but is there anyone who is especially compelling in either production?

A Czech opera in Prague sounds more compelling but requires a longer stay; while Dido and Aeneas would be good for my opera education. So I'm definitely open to both...


r/opera • • 16h ago

The Magic Flute (Die Zauberflöte), K. 620, Act II: Der Hölle Rache kocht in meinem Herzen (Hell's Vengeance Boils In My Heart)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

In honour of Voyager 1’s one light day mark today!


r/opera • • 1d ago

NY Philharmonic and Met Opera Duel With Back-to-Back ‘Toscas’

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
15 Upvotes

r/opera • • 19h ago

Opera vinyl records for sale US only

2 Upvotes

$1 per record. $2 for box sets. $6 flat shipping...US only . I have more similar batches.. will share a video if there's interest.


r/opera • • 1d ago

Can you stand listening to your own recordings?

14 Upvotes

Recently added this to my practice routine as a student of classical singing, and at first I was suffering, but then I found comfort in the thought of potentially abandoning singing completely.

Both normies and professionals encourage me in person but I can't take them seriously after learning how I sound to them.


r/opera • • 1d ago

Jenůfa 11/16: Grigorian and Stemme triumph at The Met

Post image
95 Upvotes

HOLY SHIT! Jenůfa tonight was a revelation. I haven’t felt such catharsis at The Met since Die Frau ohne Schatten a few seasons back. Why is this only the 52nd performance of Jenůfa in the Met’s history? I love my Janáček recordings, but nothing prepared me for finally seeing this live. The orchestrations are simply sublime. The score is radical in every sense of the word, and yet still full of melody and beauty. I had goosebumps all over my body at several points in the evening.

Grigorian and Stemme are giving masterclasses in how to be an object of gay diva worship. These weren’t just stand-there-and-sing-pretty performances; neither were merely “singers,” but rather red-blooded, ferocious actresses who happen to sing as well. Kostelnička must be one of the most difficult characters to play in the whole repertoire, and yet I, like Jenůfa, felt pity for this woman driven to carry out such a heinous act. You really feel the weight of these women’s place in society and the rules they must abide by. It’s telling when at the wedding scene, a townsperson asks Jenůfa if she feels like crying knowing that once she gets married, she will give up any freedom she had. This townsperson cried profusely at her own wedding, and she was marrying a “decent” man to boot. Our two leads have the world closing in on them, and I found it difficult to judge either of them for their actions or reactions to the plot.

I think we should just let Grigorian go through the whole Janáček cycle. Put on Káta Kabanová next and then just let her glide through the other operas.

Do NOT miss seeing this live in the house. I will try to squeeze in another performance or two before the run finishes.


r/opera • • 1d ago

Angela Gheorghiu

Post image
42 Upvotes

I wanted to come here and ask everyone if they happen to actually like Angela Gheorghiu’s voice?

When I first got into opera she had a beautiful voice in my opinion, although nothing special (all sopranos sounded the same to me). I kept hearing her name & decided to try and listen to her more often. That’s how I’ve come to hear her in Tosca, and loved her in it.

However, as my musicality developed and my ear grew sharper, I’ve come to the realisation that her singing is intolerable for me, which is ironic, considering she was my favourite Tosca for a while.

I don’t know why I don’t like her singing anymore. She sounds a lot like Zeani, whom I love, but for some reason something isn’t clicking.

Any thoughts?


r/opera • • 2d ago

Mission to experience all 20 productions at The Met in the 2026-27 season

Thumbnail
gallery
106 Upvotes

5 new productions, 12 revivals, and 3 concerts. Still have to arrange Silent Night, La Boheme, The Magic Flute, Laffont Grand Finals, Asmik Grigorian in concert, and the Diamond Jubilee. Not pictured is Tosca, which I got off the digital rush on November 1, but I added a picture from the talkback after the show.

Of the 5 I’ve seen so far I adored all but one... in fact I despised the very fiber of its being. See if anyone can guess which opera. Very much looking forward to the rest!


r/opera • • 1d ago

Rameau’s Les Surprises de L’Amour in Washington DC: recap

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Opera Lafayette unearthed this Rameau opera, which has not been staged since 1748, and presented it to audiences in NYC and DC last week.
The DC show I saw was an excellent performance of a decidedly second tier Rameau effort. Not sure if that’s why it was forgotten but there’s not that much memorable music or interesting harmonies, maybe outside few choral movements and one or two arias. This is all set to a lightweight story, if you can call it, the typical Baroque “she loves me / she loves me not” tussle of assorted gods and mortals. There’s no danger of this opera unseating Platee or any other justly famous Rameau’s works but Opera Lafayette elevated this rather basic libretto and pedestrian music to absolutely charming and delightful production. It was a tongue in cheek play within play, with the king watching and Madame Pompadour, who commissioned the opera, watching along with him before joining the action on stage. It looked beautiful, it had sparkle and wit, and small details - like the singers and dancers competing for attention, plus one of the dancers putting the moves on Madame Pompadour- saved this from being a long evening of rather monotonous music. I say it as someone who loves Rameau and would rate him as one of my most favourite composers, but I had come home happy that I saw this performance and also wanting to immediately put on Grand Motets to listen to Rameau at the height of his powers.
The cast was very good, especially Kayleigh Sprouse as Cupid and Emilie Kealani as Astrea / Diana as were two basses, Hadleigh Adams and Phillip Lopez. I was not entirely sold on Elizabeth Sutphen who sang Madame Pompadour / Uranie and Venus, her vibrato too heavy to my liking, but she was very good actress and really went for it in her last bravura aria. The chorus was excellent, and so were the dancers who had to carry the story and in many cases, the funny props around the stage. The orchestra was tiny bit shaky at the beginning but settled in quickly. Artistic director Patrick Dupre Quigley had his back to the singers at all times but the coordination between the players and singers was top notch, with long breathing lines and these nicely pulled up French style ornamentations all shining through.
If this was available on video, I would happily watch it again and recommend it to anyone interested in delightful productions of rare Baroque operas. If it was available as a music only recording, I would recommend it to anyone interested in Baroque music - Rameau on his day off is still better than vast majority of other composers - but I would prefer to listen to another Rameau piece instead.
And one minor quibble: there are two acts and a perfect spot for an intermission in the middle but the orchestra started tuning after the conclusion of Act 1 and launched into Act 2 right away. If you were there, as I was, with somewhat fidgety ten year old in tow, that made for rather tiring experience.
Curious if anyone else saw it and what you thought of it..!


r/opera • • 2d ago

How to know when the lead soprano is out

23 Upvotes

I went to Medea at the MET, for November 10th performance. My mom and I expected Sonya Yoncheva, but ended up with Chiara Isotton. We didn't know it until we got the playbill right before we sat down. This production was suppose to have Sonya Yoncheva starring in all performance except except one, which I think is Nov 21st. Although Isotton was great, my mom was slightly disappointed because she wanted to see Yoncheva. So, we bought tickets again for 13th.

I understand that there could be last minute change, but is there way to know the announcement? Because we bought ticket on the day of the performance, which was the 10th, and still didn't know.


r/opera • • 1d ago

Grazie Luciano

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Hi does anyone know if this is worth anything in Australia?


r/opera • • 1d ago

Moving Met Opera Seats

4 Upvotes

I'm more of a Broadway-goer but looking to expand my palette. Can you move seats at the Met Opera if they not occupied after the first act? I've seen that happen at Broadway after intermission but don't know the rules here


r/opera • • 2d ago

Most out-of-pocket review you've ever read?

28 Upvotes

Years ago I was reading the (dearly departed) Opera News. A significant part of the magazine was dedicated to criticism/reviews, of both recently released albums and live performances around the world.

In this case, they were discussing a recent production of Cosi. Their assessment was decidedly mixed, and of the soprano singing Dorabella, wrote "[Name] seems to have been cast primarily for her breasts. Lovely as they are, they sound uncomfortable singing 'Smanie implacabili.'"

I have never forgotten that. Anything similar we want to share?


r/opera • • 2d ago

The singer who got you into opera: how do you feel about them now?

52 Upvotes

Who is a singer you were obsessed with when you first got into opera and are you still obsessed with them today?

Mine is Joyce DiDonato, I listened to everything she recorded and watched endless videos. Today, sadly, her voice is like nails on a chalkboard to me.


r/opera • • 2d ago

Review | They left the Kennedy Center to survive. It was an artistic rebirth. (Gift link)

Thumbnail
wapo.st
12 Upvotes

r/opera • • 2d ago

Shanghai Opera stages L’elisir d’amore

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

It has been far too long since I last revisited a Gaetano Donizetti opera on a domestic stage—the previous occasion was all the way back at the New National Theatre in Tokyo. Operas representing the very roots and original spirit of Italian bel canto live and die by one quality: stylistic authenticity.

Yesterday afternoon at the Shangyin Opera House, the Shanghai Opera House presented Donizetti’s beloved L’elisir d’amore (The Elixir of Love), led by Italian conductor Paolo Carignani.

As one of the leading bel canto tenors of his generation, seeing Yijie Shi perform a complete Donizetti role live on a Chinese stage is no longer a distant wish. His bright, agile, and ringing timbre remains virtually unrivaled—a rare voice in today’s operatic landscape. That seemingly effortless projection is certainly backed by extraordinary natural gifts, yet it is equally sustained by supreme vocal technique.

Equally impressive in terms of craft was Doctor Dulcamara, who stood out as the highlight of yesterday afternoon’s international cast including Nino Machaidze as Adina. While the voice itself shows signs of age—most noticeably during his duet with Nemorino, where he was nearly covered—he brought this notoriously difficult, portly comic role to vivid life through sheer stagecraft and theatrical command. His subtle micro-expressions and physical comedy were nothing short of a masterclass.

Watch and read more
https://klassikom.substack.com/p/china-needs-both-bel-canto-mastery


r/opera • • 2d ago

The history behind role distributions?

8 Upvotes

So what are the leading roles giving to a soprano and a tenor most of the time? and why is the villain usually a baritone?
What’s the history behind the phenomenon? And are there national opera traditions that deviate from this?


r/opera • • 2d ago

A Tale of Two Toscas in NYC

46 Upvotes

Did anyone happen to catch both the Carnegie Hall and Met Toscas in NYC this weekend?

My take, for what it's worth.

Better Tosca: Marina Rebeka and it's no contest here. I read all of the PR hype about Saioa Hernandez but The Met really waited far too late in her career to employ her. Very chesty sound and she is now having problems moving from her chest to her head voice and also with sustaining on a breath. On her very last note before jumping, she literally cheated on Saturday, initiating the note then taking a quick breath before resuming and finishing it. There were other times during the performance when she was obviously unable to sustain passages on a breath. I can find absolutely no fault with Rebeka's Tosca. Her sound is youthful with squillo for days. Nearly flawless IMO.

Better Cavaradossi: SeokJong Baek. Kaufmann doesn't have the strength in the high notes anymore but it was a very, very respectable showing for someone who is nearly 60. His use of pianissimi is a skilled singer's brilliant use of his remaining resources, which are still considerable. Baek is considerably thinner than when I last saw him as Cavaradossi at Tanglewood two summers ago. Since then, he's smoothed out his sound. His acting was also much better than previous staged performances I've seen him in. A notable flaw for Baek is agility with his part of the act III duet somewhat muddled. A remarkably talented singer though.

Better Scarpia: tie. The part isn't right for either Tézier or Kelsey IMO. Scarpia favors baritones with more dramatic qualities vocally than these singers, who used to singing lyrically in Verdi roles, display. Absolutely loved - and I mean loved - Kelsey's Macbeth. He's worked out Scarpia dramatically versus his Met Tosca showings with Davidsen, who is a cruel guy with no suaveness whatsoever. Still, he lacks the incisiveness in the middle register instead leaning more towards the lyricism of a Verdi baritone. There was little dramatic effort by Tézier IMO, who I had more difficulty hearing due to the orchestra's volume.

Better conductor: Dudamel although definitely a respectable showing by Lyniv. With Lyniv, there were some obvious problems with cuing, including the brass in Act I, but she appeared to work better with her singers, which separates the opera conductor from the orchestral conductor.

Overall better show: Unfair comparison, or perhaps not, but Met Opera. Some of the semi-staging choices at Carnegie came off as weird. For example, Rebeka stabbed the air and then Tezier simply turned for the rest of act II. Also, there was paying $200 a seat to sit in the balcony at Carnegie with the madness that goes on there, like listening to what sounded like a loud door alarm for nearly 20 minutes during the performance - it was feedback from someone's hearing aid that the entire hall heard as a buzzing sound. (No shade to that person btw but the ushers should have helped you much sooner.) Tech bros claiming someone must have given (my black ass) my ticket, and then sincerely asking each other after act I if the performance was over. NY Phil should really be ashamed they are pricing many opera lovers out. I heard they chose to sell the $25 limited view tickets that Carnegie reserves for its own performances, for $85 each - true? In any case, don't expect to enjoy the NY Phil while The Dude is in town...


r/opera • • 2d ago

Can someone help me identify this 5-note progression from La Traviata?

5 Upvotes

Question for you music brains (alas I am only a worker bee with no musical training at all, so please be gentle with my ignorance here). I am trying to identify a 5-note progression toward the end of 'Addio del passato.' At exactly 8:48 of the linked video (It's time-stamped), Lisette Oropesa repeats a series of five notes three times. Could you tell me what those notes are? Also, in this particular video, are these considered pianissimi?

https://youtu.be/2ldOBson0vw?t=526&is=nbvdczx7iUf9O0IT


r/opera • • 2d ago

Hello ! How often do you actually go to the opera and how often do you watch videos of them at home/at the cinema ? And why ?

4 Upvotes

r/opera • • 3d ago

Thanks a lot, kid

Thumbnail
gallery
179 Upvotes

I’ve never cried at an opera before last night. Like, UGLY cried.

I hope you’re happy. Who could be more deserving?

I’ve since found out I actually saw him on Broadway a couple years ago in Appropriate starring Sarah Paulson. Imagine being what, 11-12 years old and you already made it to Broadway and the Metropolitan Opera. Rather humbling.

I’m so immensely thankful to have been alive to witness this opera in person, even (especially) in the family circle boxes, and shout out to the Met for streaming it on YouTube. Between Lincoln In The Bardo, last year’s Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, and Ainadamar the year before that (among others) it’s clear opera is alive and well.

Obligatory special shout out to the only living god walking among us, Anthony Roth Costanzo. It’s hard to stand out in the middle of all that brilliance but he did it. What a hauntingly dynamite feature.