r/opera • u/standard-sp • 13h ago
Just needed to rave about Saoia Hernandez's Tosca
What more can I say? I loved it. The friend I brought with me also loved it.
On a more detailed note, I loved the acting choices that the entire cast made. There are definitely times where the cast plays up some of the potentially lighter and comedic moments, such as Tosca's jealousy and Cavaradossi fixing his appearance before he sees Tosca. It feels great to see a production where everything in the drama really gets attention alongside the vocalism.
Hernandez was absolutely fantastic. We didn't sit too high up, so I'm sure we missed out on some of the acoustics, but it was amazing to hear her with an incredible command of dynamics and control. There are a lot of genuinely quiet, lyrical moments, alongside all the outbursts and extremely piercing and exciting high notes. Her acting was also incredibly detailed and I think there were a lot of times that she really did things in a way that read well from within the house and absolutely emphasized the drama. I'm really speaking from a very detailed singer point of view and breaking many things down because I think there's a lot to learn, but I think that she is simply moving and someone who truly has everything that the art form needs. Her acting was absolutely as naturalistic or as intense as needed, depending on the scene and context. She got applause on every entrance which was more than deserved.
Seokjong Baek was even better in house as Cavaradossi. His singing was extremely secure and he delivered all of the high notes even better than on the excerpts the Met released. The dramatic detail was once again impeccable and I am typing this a couple hours post performance, but he was incredibly convincing in the second act and really sold it, with a very good vittoria that got so much applause that his next lines were basically inaudible due to the entire house clapping. I wish I could accurately describe it, but the best I have is that he probably held a huge b-flat for 10s, and then immediately launched in to his next lines with no reserve. Both of his arias were also beautifully delivered. If the Met did encores, I think most of us would've called for bis after e lucevan. The moments where he shared with Tosca were also incredible and they really sold the idea that Tosca and Cavaradossi are young and intensely in love with each other, with lots of flirtatious moments.
Quinn Kelsey definitely fit my idea of Scarpia, someone who is pious and terrifyingly respectful but genuinely depraved, and I would really say that his voice has much more color in house, which gets lost in recording. His first entrance is menacing, but he switches easily when Tosca comes on, and I think if any of us were Tosca, we would've been fooled. The way he handles the scene right after Cavardossi gets pulled for execution and gia mi dicon venal is honestly one of the most chilling and visceral experiences ever in house, and he sings and acts the undercurrent of menace extremely well despite how mundane and genial the text would make him seem. There's always a little bit of him where he's acting nice, but forcing someone else to do what he wants (such as when he invites Tosca to dine, but essentially forces her into sitting at his table), and that really helps sell the idea of Scarpia as someone who is respectable on the outside, but utterly evil and uses whatever at his disposal to acheive his selfish goals.
I'm sure that I've left things out, but I really loved this cast. Would recommend all of the cast when they come back to the Met and it's so worth all the trouble getting to the city this week.