r/overclocking • u/the_ict_bb • 15h ago
Ryzen 9 9950X3D + MSI X870E Tomahawk: reliable 128GB → 256GB DDR5 upgrade? Conflicting MSI/Kingston answers
Hi everyone,
I'm building a high-memory workstation for intensive financial backtesting (Python, NumPy, pandas, heavily parallelized CPU workloads running continuously for days or weeks).
My planned configuration:
- CPU: AMD Ryzen 9 9950X3D
- Motherboard: MSI MAG X870E TOMAHAWK WIFI (7E59-004R)
- Initial RAM: 2 × 64GB Kingston ValueRAM KVR56U46BD8-64, DDR5-5600 CL46, 2Rx8
- Future upgrade: 4 × 64GB (256GB total)
- OS: Windows 11 Pro
The problem: MSI and Kingston have given me conflicting information.
MSI support says this exact Kingston part number is absent from their X870E memory QVL and therefore cannot be officially validated in a 4 × 64GB configuration.
Kingston's Technical Resource Group says the module appears in their X870E configurator and refers to motherboard QVL validation of 4 × 64GB configurations up to 5600 MT/s. However, Kingston has not independently tested this exact combination.
Kingston also warns that the ValueRAM series is multi-BOM, meaning identically labelled modules may contain different internal components.
My questions:
- Has anyone actually tested 4 × 64GB DDR5 (2DPC 2R) on this exact MSI motherboard, ideally with a Ryzen 9950X3D?
- Which exact RAM part numbers, BIOS versions and memory speeds were stable?
- Has anyone successfully combined two separately purchased 2 × 64GB pairs?
- Does anyone have documentation confirming or contradicting MSI's QVL response?
- Would you recommend a different officially validated 4 × 64GB kit for maximum reliability?
DDR5-3600 with 256GB would be perfectly acceptable to me if it provides better stability. I'm not trying to maximize benchmark scores.
My priority is long-term computational reliability and reproducible results, not peak memory overclocking.
I'm especially interested in actual test results (y-cruncher, TestMem5, OCCT, MemTest86, extended workloads), BIOS versions and exact module references.
Thanks for any technical insights or firsthand experiences!

