Before getting into the review, I recently started an Instagram Account where I’ll be sharing shorter versions of my reviews. While I mainly do whiskey, I am slowly starting to dabble in rum as well (this being my first “official” rum review).
This bottle was purchased by me with my own funds. I have no association with Circle Hook or its associated brands
Background: Circle Hook was founded in 2018 by Eli Underhill. A commercial fisherman by trade, he got his first exposure to rum when an old fishing partner would mix Meyers with orange juice after a long day working off the California coastline. Fast-forwarding to 2012, Eli and his wife Amy moved from Sitka, Alaska, to Gulfport, Mississippi. However, Eli was still spending 6 months out of the year in Alaska fishing, growing tired of being separated from his family and the strenuous work. After some thought and much research, Eli decided to build a craft distillery from the ground up. Choosing to produce his take on a rum, partly due to his position around sugarcane farmland. Taking the name Circle Hook as a reference to his extensive fishing career.
The Distiller’s Reserve line is a bit of a Mississippi brand collaboration. Taking their rum and maturing it in a blend of new American oak casks and ex-bourbon barrels from Crittenden’s in Kiln, Mississippi.
Circle Hook Distiller’s Reserve Batch 2
Aged 2 Years 6 Months
125 Proof (62.5% Alc./Vol.)
I paid ~$65 (after tax) for 750mL
Nose: Starting strong with dark brown sugar, vanilla bean, overripe banana peels, and maybe even a bit of guava. Faint sweet cinnamon, mace, marzipan, and cacao nibs too. A heavily reduced fruit note ties everything together. No real proofy notes are jumping up; yes, the alcohol is present, but it's well integrated.
Palate: Overall, not as sweet as the nose would suggest. Opens up with a bit of shortbread cookie before transitioning to plentiful vanilla along with some dried coconut and brown sugar. Wisps of banana. A tropical fruit cocktail bridges the gap to the finish.
Finish: The finish is reminiscent of banana foster. Cooked overripe bananas, dark brown sugar, dry cinnamon. Also, the tropical fruit cocktail note is persisting. As it progresses, flecks of dry black pepper, toasted oak, and the transition of brown sugar to a more earthy molasses start to happen. That cooked banana and tropical fruit cocktail lingers, with the oily mouthfeel and grippy tannin. Even getting a bit of pineapple rind on the exhale.
Conclusion and Thoughts: This might just be the bourbon drinker in me, but I love this rum. With some oxidation, this bottle began to really shine, having enough subtle changes between each session that I wanted to keep coming back. I appreciate the organic growth idea that Circle Hook is taking, and I am looking forward to future projects. Apparently, some more experimental finishes are coming down the pipeline, which has my attention.
I want to keep on exploring rum, so if anyone has some other recommendations, please drop them below! As always, if you made it this far, thank you! Cheers!