On the evening of July 26, 1976, Nathan Brown, then 19, along with 19-year-old Jose High and 23-year-old Judson Ruffin, held up a gas station in Crawfordville. When the operator, Henry Phillips, told said there was no more money, Ruffin grabbed Henry and his 11-year-old stepson, Bonnie Bulloch, and told Henry to get in the car trunk or Henry and the boy would be murdered. Bonnie rode in the passenger compartment of the car. Henry got in the trunk of the car. High, who was the leader of the gang, felt that Bulloch, who was begged for his life, was too young to die, but nevertheless told him, "Are you ready to die? Do you want to die? Well, you're going to die." Henry and his stepson were marched around to the front of the car and ordered to lie on the ground. Henry then heard shots fired.
When Henry regained consciousness, he discovered that Bulloch was dead. Henry himself had been shot in the head and wrist, but survived. He would later identify the trio in court.
On August 20, 1976, Brown, High, and Ruffin, along with 17-year-old Alphonso Morgan, kidnapped 36-year-old Willina Hall and 30-year-old Leroy Linwood. Linwood was shot and killed immediately. Hall was gang raped and shot. The gang threw both bodies into the Savannah River. Two days later, Morgan, High, and Ruffin kidnapped 54-year-old James Gray from South Carolina and drove him to a then-remote spot near the airport. Morgan and his companions pulled Gray out of the truck, took ninety dollars from his wallet and told him that they were going to kill him. They took off the victim's shirt and tied it around his head like a blindfold. While Gray was begging for his life, Morgan pulled a sawed-off shotgun to his face and pulled the trigger.
The gang was arrested less than a week later and made full confessions. According to Brown's confession, after they shot Phillips and his stepson execution-style, Brown slept on the way back to Augusta. "Could you sleep after you had just shot a man and his 11 year old son?" Phillips said.
Brown, High, and Ruffin were all convicted of Bulloch's murder and sentenced to death. Morgan was convicted of the murders of Hall, Linwood, and Gray and also sentenced to death. On appeal, the death sentences of Brown, Ruffin, and Morgan were overturned due to procedural errors. Brown and Morgan were later resentenced to life in prison and Ruffin was resentenced to life in prison without parole. Life without parole was not a sentencing option at the time, although Ruffin evidently agreed to waive his right to be eligible for parole to avoid another death sentence.
Now 73, Ruffin is serving his sentence at Macon State Prison.
Now 68, Morgan is serving his sentence at Wheeler Correctional Facility.
The leader of their gang would not be so fortunate. After exhausting his appeals, Jose High, 45, was executed by lethal injection at Georgia Diagnostic and Classification State Prison on November 6, 2001. His last meal consisted of two three cheeseburgers, two fried chicken breasts, one large order of french fries, two slices of white bread, two soft drinks, and a slice of bean pie.
I could not find High's full final statement, so I stitched together excerpts of his last words.
"Poor people are on death row, and the death penalty is racist to the core. That's it. I did not kill that little boy. I could not hurt a child. Never. That lie is going to follow me now. I'm ready to die. I'm sorry about your kid, Ms. Phillips. I wanted to meet you. I wrote you a letter but you never got it. My life is a poor substitute for your son. I know how it is. Death is a universal process."
Bulloch's mother, Hazel Phillips, was on prison grounds but did not witness the execution. Speaking with reporters afterwards, she said High was lying when he denied firing the fatal shot: "I really hope that God forgave him. I really hope someday that I will have the strength to do that."
Mother pleads to keep son's murderer up for parole in prison
During an interview in 2018, Hazel Phillips begged the state parole board to not release Nathan Brown. As for her desire to forgive them, she said she couldn't: "The closest I can come in my 76 years is I don’t hate them. They told them if you just lay down on the ground and put your hands behind you we 'gon let you and your son live." Phillips said she feared that since Brown became a born-again Christian behind bars, he would get out and return to Augusta. Phillips said she did not feel like Brown could change, calling him a psychopath who laughed after the crime was done, took a nap, and wasn't under the influence of any drugs.
A key difference this time around is that Phillips died in 2025.
Under his parole plan, Brown will reside at an Atlanta-based transitional housing program in Fulton County under supervision of the Atlanta Circuit, according to the board. Special conditions of his parole include no contact with family members of one of the victims, complying with Georgia sex offender notification law, undergoing substance abuse assessments at his own cost and paying $30 per month to the Georgia crime victim's compensation fund. Standard conditions bar Brown from possessing firearms or deadly weapons, leaving the state or changing residence without permission.
Brown must also participate in a rehabilitation plan, submit to drug testing and warrantless searches, maintain employment or pursue education and report to his community supervision officer within 24 hours of release.