r/thomasthetankengine • • 10h ago

General Chat Why I Don't like Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure

0 Upvotes

Now before anyone gets mad at me

Let me just say this is purely my opinion and my opinion only.

Now, Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure

The film many consider the peak of Thomas

in my opinion

Before we jump into the negative

Lets start with the positives

The animation is at it's all time highest

I LOVE the soundtrack, you can really tell Peter and Robert Hartshone knew this was their last time composing for Thomas and wanted to go out on a high note

The small railway engines, while they may not look like their real life basis are a treat to see

The action is really epic

But the greatest thing about this film

is Sailor John

He is the only human villan that is an actual threat, he literally whacks Thomas with an Oar and tries to blow him up with dynamite

He's ruthless and they do NOT sugarcoat it at all and I LOVE the fact they do not redeem him and he rightfully gets arrested

Now

onto the bad stuff

Ryan, He is a very weak character as he just exists to drive home a "thomas is jealous of the new engine" trope we've seen before

But the real issue is that Ryan has very little to him

I wish they had kept his original personality as overconfident and dismissive, it would have aided the mystery of the story on who is the real villain

I also kinda wish they had cut out some of the other subplots

Now onto the 3 characters I find the most problematic

Thomas, Sir Topham Hatt and Gordon

first off with Gordon

I simply just find his scene at the start to be a plot device

like you could have easily cut this scene and just have a different reason as to why Thomas is needed on the Harwick Extension project?

Next onto Topham

Don't think I am going to act as if Topham is some villanous monster

he isn't, he's a man trying to build a branch line but one of his engines won't take accountability

I just wish we SAW Ryan doing more instead of being another Stanley

Now

Lets get to the main character himself

Thomas The Tank Engine

My biggest issues with Thomas are that he is such an idiot in this film

No seriously he's honestly WORSE than Nitrogen Era Thomas

I despise the fact we are supposed to be on HIS side despite all the terrible things he does

He intentionally gave Ryan bad coal and denies accountability, not one, not two but THREE TIMES!!!

What angers me even more is that Thomas’ lying IS SOMETHING THOMAS WOULD NEVER DO.

Even in S1-2 when Thomas was a prick, he NEVER once denied or lied about his actions.

Take for example Thomas and the trucks, Down the mine or Thomas comes to breakfast, Thomas screwed up yet he always apologized to TFC and admitted his actions.

Here, he just straight up lies in a selfish egotistical manner, something not even Gordon would do! I can see James doing this but Thomas…NEVER! even in his lowest low, he never lied before!

There are other problems

Like how or why did Sailor John know about the treasure

How did Sailor John get that huge pirate ship up the hill?

The less said about Henry in this film the better since he does literally nothing

So yeah

Those are my issues with Lost Treasure

This film has ALOT of issues that just confuse me

I just find this film overrated and uninteresting

There is potential

But it just needs some rewrites


r/thomasthetankengine • • 18h ago

General Chat All Thomas Twitter accounts have the right to remain public no excuses

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Social Media is not disposable you know I implore all Twitter, Bluesky, Threads, Instagram, Facebook and even YouTube Thomas users to archive and save all of the content that they ever posted publicly so those things remain public for future generations it’s for the sake of transparency Everything posted online deserves to remain public not matter what. If we delete things the public will just lose access to history. Resultingly opening the door up for revisionism and denialism deleting and withholding only damages our knowledgebase and media literacy I really do care deeply about public accessibility, historical transparency, clarity and seeking the truth why can't Thomas twitter accounts be publicly archived in the same way that Jiro Mifune's was https://archive.org/details/jiro-mifune-1acf-6519baf-34a-7fbed-21dca-2ba-35044


r/thomasthetankengine • • 12h ago

My Original Fanwork Thomas Leaves Sodor through The Magic Buffers

Post image
0 Upvotes

What if Thomas ran away from Sodor to the Magic Railroad after the dynamite incident in Sodor's legend of the Lost Treasure?


r/thomasthetankengine • • 12h ago

Fanwork (not by OP) Made an ttte character base of the adult swim trend hope you like it or don't we don't care

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 6h ago

Funny if u were Awdry in 1946 how would u react to this

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

HOW DARE U INSULT ME U DREW HIM AS A E2 WHAT ARE YOU BRAINDEAD HES A J50


r/thomasthetankengine • • 6h ago

Question Why do so many people hate SodorProductions?

0 Upvotes

Nothing more than an innocent question ... besides destroying the Colin prop, why is he so hated?


r/thomasthetankengine • • 15h ago

My Original Fanwork Thomas leaves Sodor to Bridlington Part 1

0 Upvotes

In this story, Thomas decided to run away from Sodor and find a new railway to work and live at, instead of facing the consequences for nothing.

It all started when Ryan accidentally lit the dynamite, because he took on bad coal. Then, Thomas came to the rescue to save everyone by getting rid of the dynamite before it explodes, and he did. After Thomas saved everyone, Sir Topham Hatt scolded him furiously. He thought Thomas was trying to hurt Ryan, but he wasn’t. Thomas tried to tell Sir Topham Hatt what actually happened, but he won’t let him explain, so he punished him, by sending him to the shed where he is temporarily staying for the rest of the day and told everyone else to get back to work. Then, he stormed away. After getting punished for nothing, Thomas puffed sadly to his temporary shed. While Thomas is settling in his shed, he was very sad and hurt.

Thomas: (shouted sadly) It’s not fair! I didn’t do anything wrong this time!

At the end of the day, the engines and the Pack started to leave the construction site. They felt very sorry for Thomas, including Ryan.

Oliver (excavator): Come on everyone, let’s go home.

Thomas began to cry. He felt that his life was completely ruined. He remembered the time when he found Great Waterton and meet Stanley, when he felt that the silver engine was ruining his life and thought that nobody wanted him anymore and the time at the Blue Mountain Quarry where he tried to tell what happened with Luke and Victor to the narrow gauge engines as they would listen to him. He felt like there were happening again, but combined in a much horrible way. He thought that this time, nobody wanted him anymore and no one would listen to him.  Back in the construction site, the diggers could not dig anymore without the dynamite and none of them were in a good mood to do it. They all felt sorry for Thomas. Especially Ryan. He felt terrible about what happened.

Thomas: (sadly) I was Sodor’s number 1 engine, but after what happened at the construction site, I guess I’m not anymore. I guess I’m not useful anymore either.

Ryan is puffing back to his shed too. He is slowly passing Thomas’ shed. Then, Thomas began to cry.

Thomas: (sobbing)

Ryan stopped when he heard Thomas crying, he felt worse.

Ryan: (sadly) Oh Thomas, I’m so sorry.

Then Ryan continued to puff to his shed. When Diesel, Arry, and Bert came by with more supplies and rails on flatbeds.

Diesel: Well well well. If it isn't the blue naughty troublesome tank engine himself.

Ryan: Can we not upset him?

Diesel: Come on Ryan. What he did was bad, he completely should be sold for scrap! Sir Topham Hatt will make sure of that!

Arry: Why doesn't he do so before it's too late.

Bert: Yeah.

Ryan: Hey! You three cut that out right now! It wasn't intentional. He was just trying to prevent a certain disaster. And Sir Topham Hatt will not sell him no matter what.

Diesel: Who care about him anyway.

This made Thomas more upset.

At the Sodor Construction Company Yard, Jack, Alfie and Oliver have been talking about Thomas getting in trouble for nothing.

Jack: (sighs sadly) Poor Thomas.

Alfie: I can’t believe he got punished for nothing.

Oliver: Yeah, Thomas didn’t do anything wrong, he saved us from the dynamite. It’s totally unfair. What did Sir Topham Hatt think Thomas did?

Jack: I don’t know, got rid of the dynamite for nothing?

Alfie: Maybe.

Oliver: Well guys let’s get some sleep. Good night.

Jack and Alfie: Good night, Oliver.

They felt very bad for Thomas. And so does Marion who also temporarily staying near the construction site.

Marion: Man it’s so unfair to Thomas. He didn’t deserve to be punished, what he did was heroic.

When nighttime came, Thomas is still alone in his shed, then he stopped crying. Then he thought of doing something he had never done in his life.

Thomas: If Sir Topham Hatt won’t listen to me anymore, … then I… I…. (sobs) I DON’T WANT TO WORK ON THIS RAILWAY ANYMORE!!

Then he puffed out of his shed and headed to the Steamworks. When Thomas arrived at the Steamworks, it was about to close for tonight.

Victor: Thomas, hello my friend, isn’t it kinda late for you to be here?

Thomas: Yes, Victor.

Victor: Ok, then what can I do for you tonight?

Thomas: Well, I was wondering if you can give me my original livery back.

Victor: Your original livery?

Thomas: Yes. Is that ok?

Victor: Well, uh… sure.

Thomas: Thanks, Victor.

Victor: No problem, my friend. By the way, what does your original livery look like?

Thomas: Well, when I first came to Sodor, I was painted tealish green, my previous number is 70, which is on the sides of my bunker, and the letters LBSC on the sides of my tank, it stands for London Brighton and South Coast Railway.

Victor: Got it.

Then Thomas started getting repainted. First, the painters scraped off Thomas’ Sodor livery. Next, he was being painted tealish green. And finally, he got his previous number and letters of his former railway back.

Thomas: Thanks again, Victor.

Victor: You’re welcome, my friend. Well, while you’re waiting for the paint to dry, why do you want your original livery back anyway?

Thomas: Because I don't feel like Sodor’s Number 1 Engine anymore.

Victor and Kevin: What?!

Kevin: How come?

Then, Thomas told Victor and Kevin what happened at the construction site earlier, when the dynamite was accidentally lit, and saved everyone there, and how Sir Topham Hatt had treated him after it happened.

Victor and Kevin were shocked, they cannot believe what Thomas had just been through.

Victor: How awful. I can’t believe Sir Topham Hatt did that to you.

Kevin: We’re really sorry that just happened to you, Thomas. That must be totally unfair, mostly when you did something heroic.

Thomas: Thank you, Kevin. After what just happened to me, I had decided to do something I had never thought of my whole life.

Victor: And what’s that?

Thomas: I have decided to leave Sodor and not return until I feel like it or Sir Topham comes to say sorry because he owes me an apology.

Victor and Kevin: (Gasps in shock) What?!

Kevin: You wanted to leave Sodor?!

Thomas: Yes. I had been trying to useful since the accident at Knapford. Every time I tried to make up for that accident, I ended up making more. I have had enough working on Sodor, so I decided to not live or work here. I’m going to find a some other place on the Mainland to work and live at.

Victor: Ok, I hope you find a great new home, we’re gonna miss you.

Thomas: I’m gonna miss you guys too.

Kevin: We will never forget you.

Thomas: I will never forget you guys too. Goodbye, Victor, Goodbye, Kevin.

Victor and Kevin: Goodbye, Thomas.

Victor: Hope you come back soon.

Thomas had left the Steamworks. He decided to tour his favorite places one last time before he leaves, starting with Knapford. All of the engines were already asleep. Thomas noticed that the yard is unorganized, so he had decided to do some shunting. He shunted the coaches onto the platforms and organized the yard as he lef to do the same to the other yards and stations. After that, he left Knapford and headed to all his other favorite places like, Tidmouth, Ffarquhar, Farmer Trotter’s farm, Farmer McColl’s farm, Brendam Docks, Kirk Ronan, Kellsthorpe Road, Callan Castle, Bluff’s Cove, Crovan’s Gate, The Wharf, Great Waterton, Tidmouth Town Square, The Magic Buffers, Misty Island, The Search and Rescue Center, Blue Mountain Quarry and Ulfstead Castle.

Then Thomas arrived at Vicarstown, he got his tank and bunker filled up with coal and water after shunting and arranging some trains. When Thomas got to the bridge, it was rolled up, because a ship is passing by. While Thomas is waiting for the ship to pass, he looked back as he was about to leave Sodor, he did have a lot of great times here. When the bridge rolled down, he started to head to the Mainland.

Thomas: (sadly) Goodbye, Sodor.

(I’m Not a Useful Engine Anymore song plays)

(To be continued)


r/thomasthetankengine • • 16h ago

Question what is your guilty pleasure epsoide

5 Upvotes

so commet down below what epsoide you find that is generaly considered medicor at best to bad at wrost that you love for multiple reasons like rose tinted glasses nostolga or maybe even unironicaly maybe you were like me and got dvds as a kid[i lived and grew up in the us during the late 200s early 2010s and got a lot of dvds back in the day of thomas]


r/thomasthetankengine • • 17h ago

Question My 2026 Metal Emily’s front left tender wheel has scratched paint. Is it common, or was I just unlucky?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 17h ago

Question How does autism manifest in locomotives?

Post image
6 Upvotes

I’ve been wondering how autism works in engines—how it manifests, how it’s diagnosed, how it’s managed, and so on. Keep in mind that engines function differently than we do, so how does it actually work?


r/thomasthetankengine • • 21h ago

Character Discussion What's your headcanons for Sam?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Another odd character... Considering how big he is. He'd destroy any bridge or tunnel or rail he'd travel on


r/thomasthetankengine • • 7h ago

Television Series reminder henrietta has been acknowledged more then annie and clarabel in the hit and (i think?) nitrogen eras

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 20h ago

Funny Caption this image/meme challenge, submit your captions in the comments

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 9h ago

Question Am I the only one who thinks this

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I do support engines forming relationships with each other. But I don't know why people are so against it? If an engine is sentient and feels emotions like anger or happiness and clearly have best friends, then why can't they also experience love? And if they can, why are people so against it? (And yes, I did use Ai for the graph)🤓🤓🤓🤓


r/thomasthetankengine • • 21h ago

General Chat Do you think Nia and Rebecca would be more accepted if they just kept Edward and Henry in the Steam Team?

Post image
29 Upvotes

Cause personally it always hurt when they called it the steam team with out Henry and Edward.

I also put duck here cause everyone wanted Duck to be in the steam team.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 14h ago

Funny Holy Misprint Batman! Nia grew a Mustatche lol

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 18h ago

General Chat Is this a good starter set?

Post image
14 Upvotes

I don't have any plarail blue track at the moment


r/thomasthetankengine • • 8h ago

Question Including Thomas, who would you consider the main four of the entire franchise?

Post image
80 Upvotes

Books, tv show, etc.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 14h ago

Question Which British tank engine looks closest to Porter’s basis?

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 20h ago

My Original Fanwork I gave the engines american whistles again

86 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 12h ago

Fanwork (not by OP) Desloppifed art

Thumbnail gallery
40 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 15h ago

Television Series Why is Duck's number 8 a different design from all the other engines' numbers?

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 9m ago

Funny Aura farming on Henry's aquaphobia ass

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 3h ago

Funny Doom ain’t surviving TS

Post image
6 Upvotes