r/thomasthetankengine • • 2d ago

Episode Thread 📺 Episode Discussion: S14E05 - Toby and the Whistling Woods

7 Upvotes

Welcome to our subreddit's weekly Episode Discussion Thread! Today's episode is:

Toby and the Whistling Woods

Synopsis

Toby is given the job of delivering coal to the Duke and Duchess of Boxford’s summerhouse. However, his usual route is blocked by a fallen tree, so he must travel through the Whistling Woods instead. Nervous about the mysterious sounds coming from the woods, Toby refuses Thomas and James’s offers to accompany him, believing he is too old to ask younger engines for help. Each time Toby enters the woods, he hears another frightening noise and reverses back to the junction, accidentally crashing into the trucks Thomas and James are shunting.

After derailing the trucks for a third time and realizing he is now late with his delivery, Toby finally accepts their help. Together, they discover that the frightening sounds were simply an owl, a waterfall and the wind blowing through the trees. Toby successfully completes his delivery and learns that he is never too old to ask his friends for help.

Episode Credits:

  • Written by: Louise Kramskoy
  • Directed by: Greg Tiernan
  • UK Narrator: Michael Angelis
  • US Narrator: Michael Brandon
  • Original UK airdate: October 15, 2010
  • Original US airdate: November 21, 2010

Your Thoughts!

What are your thoughts on the episode? Any favourite moments or moments you wish were different?

Please tell us your thoughts AND more in the comment section below!

Useful Links & Resources

🔵 Read more about the episode: https://ttte.fandom.com/wiki/Toby_and_the_Whistling_Woods

🔴 Watch Thomas S14 on the Internet Archive:

🟢 Past Episode Discussions on Reddit:

New 'Episode Discussion' threads are posted every Monday & Thursday. See you there! Thanks for participating! 👋


r/thomasthetankengine • • Sep 30 '26

Movie Thread 🔴 DISCUSSION THREAD - Thomas & Friends: Really Helpful Engines (Netflix release - 9/30)

14 Upvotes

⚠️ SPOILERS AHEAD:

------------------------------------

This megathread contains spoilers for Really Helpful Engines. Enter at your own risk.

"Around every bend on Sodor, there's someone who needs help and a problem to solve. And no one is more excited to help than Thomas! Join Thomas and his friends for exciting adventures, unexpected surprises, and songs you'll be singing long after the journey ends. Because every delivery, every challenge, and every adventure is better when friends work together."

Leave your thoughts and comments down below! 💙


r/thomasthetankengine • • 6h ago

My Original Fanwork Had a dream last night, so I made some edits of it

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

Basically, Henry gets jealous of Douglas for his pet duck, so Henry gets a pet AT-AT


r/thomasthetankengine • • 8h ago

Question Including Thomas, who would you consider the main four of the entire franchise?

Post image
80 Upvotes

Books, tv show, etc.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 6h ago

Fanwork (not by OP) I've kind of noticed this too.

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 8h ago

Question What is the thing James almost fell into in TATMR

Post image
38 Upvotes

Is it just a pit of molten metal? Is it a blast furnace? Is it something that exists in real life?


r/thomasthetankengine • • 15h ago

Television Series Why is Duck's number 8 a different design from all the other engines' numbers?

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 10h ago

My Original Fanwork Reposting my customs since my account got hacked.

Thumbnail
gallery
50 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 13h ago

Funny He's got no face! Never trust faceless engines, they're not respectable!

Post image
89 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 8h ago

Railway Series In the story crossed, it’s explicitly stated the trucks say words “oh oh oh oh” and “stop!” Despite not having faces, which is strange

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 8h ago

Funny Where is this from? (UPDATE)

22 Upvotes

I FOUND IT OMG NOW YOU ALL CAN ENJOY IT IN ITS FULL GLORY
(I didn’t make btw)


r/thomasthetankengine • • 12h ago

Fanwork (not by OP) Desloppifed art

Thumbnail gallery
40 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 12h ago

Merchandise Peak just came to the mail

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

I haven't held a bachman in literally years


r/thomasthetankengine • • 8h ago

Television Series Oliver appreciation post

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

The NWRS number 11 and the great western top


r/thomasthetankengine • • 6h ago

My Original Fanwork Art I did :3

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 5h ago

Funny he found his way in politics be very afraid

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 8h ago

Question So what is the general fan consensus on Railways of crotoonia?

Post image
18 Upvotes

I'm asking this because i'm working on a video essay about the railways of crotoonia, and i just wanted to know what the fandom thinks of it because i dont really see it mentioned much in spaces like these. Infact it is kinda time consuming doing proper research as you could imagine due to this! if anyone has any facts or additional info about it that you might know please do tell.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 3h ago

Funny Doom ain’t surviving TS

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 21h ago

Question Who do you think had the funniest insult nickname?

Thumbnail
gallery
151 Upvotes

Thomas - Blue puffball

Edward - Old iron

Henry - Old square wheels

Gordon - Galloping sausage

James - Rusty red scrap iron

Percy - Green caterpillar

Toby - Old teapot


r/thomasthetankengine • • 6h ago

Funny Some random shenanigans with Thomas the Tank Engine in draw bricks.

10 Upvotes

I do not own this model. It's made by u/NNminations.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 15m ago

Funny Aura farming on Henry's aquaphobia ass

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 9h ago

Character Discussion What was your first reaction upon seeing this scene?

Post image
16 Upvotes

I mean, they had surely already seen thomas and magic railroad, so they must have been scared to see Diesel 10 again... so, tell me your thoughts


r/thomasthetankengine • • 12h ago

General Chat Anyone know what happened to this site?

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

There's a (British, I think, but unsure) TTTE website online that I stumbled across whilst looking for something, and it appears to be completely frozen in time.

It appears to have ceased operation on an intended temporary basis around 2012 but seems to never have started up again.

Does anyone here know why or know anything about the site?

It just got me curious as it struck me as being like an abandoned house urban explorers find where everything has been left as it was😂


r/thomasthetankengine • • 7h ago

Television Series reminder henrietta has been acknowledged more then annie and clarabel in the hit and (i think?) nitrogen eras

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 3h ago

Question Anyone Got ideas for Engine classes or TV Series characters to use for a Railway Series Based Au

5 Upvotes

My TTTE Au is based mostly on the Railway Series

Roles:

North Western Railway:

Engines

Thomas NWR No. 1 - First Bought in 1920 but arrived after Edward

Edward NWR No. 2 - Second Bought in 1921 but arrived first

Henry NWR No. 3 - Third bought in 1922 was blue until after his rebuild at Crew following his Flying Kipper Crash

Gordon NWR No. 4 Fourth Bought in 1923

James NWR No. 5 Fifth Bought in 1925 black livery until after his first crash on his first day

Percy NWR No. 6 Sixth Bought in 1926

Toby NWR No. 7 Seventh Bought in 1951 alongside Henrietta

Montague/Duck NWR No. 8 Eighth Bought in 1955

Donald NWR No. 9 Ninth Bought in 1959

Douglas NWR No. 10 Bought soon after Donald arrived with him saved from scrap by Donald & their crews

Oliver NWR No. 11 Bought after Douglas was saved from scrap by Douglas alongside Isabel & Toad. Specifically bought in 1967

( ) NWR No. 12

Barry NWR No. 13 - rescued from scrap by Sir Stephen Topham Hatt in 1986 works on Mainline

Daisy NWR No. D1 bought in 1960

Boco NWR No. D2 bought in 1965

Bear NWR No. D3 bought in 1967

The Pannier Tank Engine - They arrived before 1987, but after Duck

Bloomer - Bought in 1975

Pip & Emma - New main Express Engines from 2011 onwards

Walter - Arrived in 1995

Sodor Chain Load Undercut/Sodor Railway Repair bought before 1987

Tidmouth Harbor Stunter (Rosie) bought before 1987

Other Mainline Engines (about 7)

Brendam Push-pulls (2) (Arthur is one)

Other Brendam Engine (

Brendam Harbor Shunter (Salty) - bought before 1987

The Peel Godred Engines (at least 4)

Cronk-Killdane Engine (

Kirk Ronan Branch Engines (Less than 4)

Kirk Ronan Harbor Stunter (

Norramby Branch Engines (3)

Vicarstown Station Pilot (

Barrow Station Pilot Engine (

Goods Engines (5)

Extra Engines (6)

(Everything after the Sodor Chain Load Undercut is what I'm asking for ideas about)