r/windsynth • • 2h ago

Complete comparison of current EWI available models

2 Upvotes

Wanted to share this doc that I created with AI to compare my current own EWI's and the rest in the market thought it was going to be useful for the community.

I compared the current EWIs on completeness, portability, and cost — including my Clarii PRO C20 vs. Aerophone Pro AE-30

This version uses only Reddit-compatible Markdown: no HTML, no images, and no table wider than five columns, so it should render on desktop, mobile, and old Reddit.

I own a Robkoo Clarii PRO C20 and a Roland Aerophone Pro AE-30, so I compared them against the rest of the current EWI market on three things: completeness, portability, and cost.

Prices are US prices checked on 18 Nov 2026, mostly on Sweetwater. Specs are from manufacturer and retailer listings — where sources disagreed, I flagged it at the bottom instead of picking one quietly.

TL;DR

  • Most complete: Roland Aerophone Pro AE-30 — $1,799.99. 300+ scenes, 600 user scenes, ZEN-Core + SuperNATURAL, 5-pin MIDI IN/OUT, motion sensor and thumb pad.
  • Most portable: Odisei Travel Sax 2 — $699 on sale / $789 list. 23 cm long, about 335 g, real sax keys and mouthpiece, built-in speaker, 6 hours on USB-C.
  • Best value: Robkoo Clarii PRO C20 — $699 at Patchman Music / $799 direct. 100 sounds, 1,000 user sounds, 650 g, USB-C rechargeable, at about 39% of the AE-30's price.
  • Nothing I found is both more complete AND more portable than the two I already own. Everything more portable gives up a lot of sounds and features. Everything more synth-deep is heavier or needs extra batteries.

My two, head-to-head: Clarii PRO C20 vs. AE-30

AreaClarii PRO C20Aerophone Pro AE-30
Price$699–$799$1,799.99
Presets100 sounds300+ scenes
User storage1,000 sounds600 scenes
Weight650 g1,140 g
Length66.5 cm68.7 cm
BatteryLi-ion, USB-C, 5–8 hrs6x AA Ni-MH, ~6 hrs
SpeakerDual, 98 dB peak1.5 W x 2
5-pin MIDINo — needs USB hostYes, IN/OUT
KeysTouch pads, Boehm layoutMoving sax keys
Extra expressionBend plates, 3D Glide, gyroMotion sensor, thumb pad

Where the AE-30 wins: preset breadth (300+ vs. 100), 4-part layering, full effects (multi-effects, chorus, delay, reverb), moving sax keys, motion sensor + thumb pad, and pro connectivity. It is the only one of the two that talks to hardware synths without a computer or USB host in between.

Where the C20 wins: user storage (1,000 vs. 600), weight (490 g lighter), battery (rechargeable Li-ion over USB-C — the AE-30 cannot charge or run off USB-C and its AAs are not included), speaker loudness on paper, and price. It also has more dedicated bend/glide surfaces: an analog portamento plate, dual bend plates, and 3D Glide on ClariiOS 4.0, though 3D Glide needs a $14 keycap kit.

The honest gap on the C20: no native 5-pin MIDI, a smaller preset library, and touch pads instead of moving keys. Whether touch pads are a downside is a feel preference, not a spec win for either side.

Completeness at a glance

ModelSoundsUser storage5-pin MIDI
Aerophone Pro AE-30300+ scenes600 scenesYes
ASM Diosynth384 factory768 totalYes
Aerophone AE-20 / AE-20W250+ sounds600 scenesNo
Akai EWI Solo200 soundsNot publishedNo
Aerophone AE-10*128 tones100 tonesNo
Clarii PRO C20100 sounds1,000 soundsNo
Aerophone Brisa100 tonesVia appNo
Akai EWI 5000100 patchesEditor-basedOut only
Yamaha YDS-15289 voicesVia appNo
Yamaha YDS-15073 voicesVia appNo
Travel Sax 250+ soundsVia appNo
Clarii Mini50+ sounds10 favouritesNo
Sylphyo Phoenix30+ universesVia softwareNo
Aerophone AE-01 Mini6 tonesNoneNo
Akai EWI USB0 onboardNoneNo

* Discontinued — see status notes below.

Notes on completeness:

  • Deepest synth: ASM Diosynth ($1,099) — Hydrasynth-based engine, 384 factory / 768 total patches, mechanical keys, joystick and pressure pads, full editor. Fewer ready-to-play acoustic presets than the AE-30, and no Roland Cloud.
  • Best expansion ecosystem: AE-30 and AE-20 — Roland Cloud, Sound Packs, and a desktop editor.
  • EWI USB is a controller only. No onboard sounds, no speaker, no battery. It only works with a computer or iPad running software instruments.

Portability at a glance

ModelWeightLengthBatterySpeaker
Travel Sax 2~335 g23 cmUSB-C, ~6 hrsYes
Clarii Mini263 g46 cmUSB-C, ~12 hrsYes
Sylphyo Phoenix395 g43 cmUSB, ~6 hrsNo
Aerophone AE-01 Mini500 g44.4 cm4x AA, ~10 hrsYes
Aerophone Brisa437 g75.2 cmLi-ion, ~8–9 hrsNo*
Clarii PRO C20650 g66.5 cmUSB-C, 5–8 hrsYes
EWI Solo820 g76.5 cmLi-ion, 12+ hrsYes
Diosynth900 g69.8 cm2x 18650**Yes, 2 W
Aerophone AE-20~1,100 g63.2 cm6x AA, ~6 hrsYes
Aerophone Pro AE-301,140 g68.7 cm6x AA, ~6 hrsYes
Yamaha YDS-1501,000 g69.9 cm4x AAA, ~3 hrsYes, in bell

* No built-in speaker was listed in any source checked for the Brisa.

** 18650 batteries not included, and no battery-life figure is published for the Diosynth.

Portability takeaways:

  • The Travel Sax 2 is in a different size class from everything else — less than half the length of the next shortest full instrument — and it still has real moving keys, a real alto mouthpiece, and a speaker.
  • The Clarii Mini is lighter and lasts longer, but it is twice as long, uses touch pads only, and has about 50 sounds.
  • The Sylphyo is short and light with 40+ fingerings, but with no speaker you always need headphones.
  • The Yamaha YDS line feels the most like a real sax, but the YDS-150 gets only about 3 hours from 4x AAA batteries.

Prices — US, checked 18 Nov 2026

ModelUS priceStatus
Clarii Mini$299 + shippingPatchman Music
Akai EWI USB$349Controller only
Aerophone AE-01 Mini$407.99Current
Akai EWI Solo$549Stock fragile
Yamaha YDS-120$599.99Discontinued
Aerophone AE-05 GO$611.99Current
Yamaha YDS-122$659.99Pre-order, Jan 2027
Travel Sax 2$699Sale, $789 list
Clarii PRO C20$699–$799Patchman / Robkoo direct
Yamaha YDS-150$799.99Current
Akai EWI 5000$899No longer at Sweetwater
Aerophone AE-20W$899.99White AE-20 variant
Yamaha YDS-152$1,049.99New, Oct 2026
ASM Diosynth$1,099New, Jan 2026
Aerophone AE-20$1,149.99Current
Aerophone Pro AE-30$1,799.99Current
Aerophone Brisa$1,799.99New, Nov 2025, flute-style

Value ranking

This is features + portability per dollar, not a "you should buy this" list:

  1. Clarii PRO C20 ($699) — Near-flagship features and the most user storage in the field, at about 39% of the AE-30's price.
  2. Aerophone AE-20W ($899.99) — The AE-20's 250+ sounds and 600 user scenes for $250 less than the black AE-20. You lose the AE-30's motion sensor, thumb pad, and 5-pin MIDI.
  3. Akai EWI Solo ($549) — 200 sounds, 12+ hour battery, and a speaker at the lowest standalone price. Touch-key EWI fingering, and stock is fragile.
  4. ASM Diosynth ($1,099) — Deepest synth and mechanical keys, $700 less than the AE-30. Batteries not included, battery life unpublished.
  5. Travel Sax 2 ($699) — Best portability per dollar, but the onboard sounds are basic. The depth lives in the app.
  6. Aerophone Pro AE-30 ($1,799.99) — Most complete, but the premium over the AE-20W and C20 mostly buys 5-pin MIDI, the motion sensor, thumb pad, and about 50 extra scenes.
  7. Yamaha YDS-150 / YDS-152 ($799.99 / $1,049.99) — Best if sax feel for practice is the priority. Only 73–89 sax-centred voices.
  8. Akai EWI USB ($349) — Cheapest way in, but only as a DAW controller. Not a standalone instrument.

If you only care about one thing

Most complete — AE-30. Largest preset library, largest mainstream expansion ecosystem, and the only full pro I/O set in this comparison: 5-pin MIDI IN/OUT + USB-C audio/MIDI + Bluetooth audio/MIDI + 1/4" line out. Trade-offs are weight, AA batteries with no USB-C power, and price. Closest challenger: Diosynth, if synth editing matters more than preset breadth.

Most portable — Travel Sax 2. Pocket-scale, real sax keys and mouthpiece, self-contained with a speaker and a 6-hour USB-C battery, and still a full USB-C + Bluetooth MIDI controller. Trade-offs are basic onboard sounds, no listed bite sensor or dedicated bend plate, and a full-size price for a travel instrument. Closest challenger: Clarii Mini — lighter, cheaper, longer battery, but longer, touch pads only.

Caveats — where the sources disagreed

  • Travel Sax 2 weight: 335 g (Thomann / Dawkes) vs. 279 g (Odisei's own Instagram, 18 Nov 2026). I used 335 g above.
  • EWI 5000 battery: About 6 hours in Akai's spec vs. 12 hours on one dealer page. I used 6 hours.
  • Brisa battery and speaker: About 8 hours (Sam Ash) vs. about 9 hours (B&H). No speaker was listed in any source checked.
  • Diosynth battery life: Not published anywhere I checked.
  • YDS-122 / YDS-152: Weight, dimensions, and battery life were not published in the sources checked. Prices were verified.
  • Speaker specs are not comparable across brands. Some publish watts, the C20 publishes 98 dB peak, and several publish nothing. Do not rank speakers off these numbers alone.

Discontinued / superseded as of Nov 2026: Roland AE-10 (2022), Yamaha YDS-120 (replaced by the YDS-122), Akai EWI 5000 (no longer available at Sweetwater).

New in 2025–2026: ASM Diosynth, Roland Aerophone Brisa, Yamaha YDS-122 / YDS-152, Roland AE-20W, Sylphyo Phoenix, and the Clarii PRO C20 on ClariiOS 4.0.

Happy to be corrected on any spec — especially from anyone who owns the Diosynth, Brisa, or Sylphyo, since those were the hardest to verify from listings alone.

Sources


r/windsynth • • 15h ago

Aerophone AE-10 vs Yamaha YDS-120?

2 Upvotes

Hey all. I am (was) an avid sax player of about 5 years, (bari, alto, tenor and sop) who recently moved out of home into a tiny TINY apartment where I haven't played one for over a year now.

I'm seriously looking into buying a digital saxophone or wind synth to give me something to do. I don't plan on gigging or studying seriously any more, rather scratching a depressing itch my brain gets when it hears its favourite piece and knows it no longer can just pick up and play them.

My two candidates have even the Yamaha YDS-120 or Aerophone AE-10. These are due to my tighter budget and am happy to hear out other suggestions if there's truely aren't great, but there's reasons and my dilemma for not being able to pick below.

The Yamaha looks sleeker and like it mimics more of a natural 'acoustic' playstyle with raised buttons and a nice shape. However one major issue was brought up to me in a review that I haven't been able to stop thinking about.

I was a very laid back blues and slow jazz player, so being unable to vibrato and pitch bend in and out of notes is a huge dealbreaker for me. To my knowledge the back thumb scroll can achieve this on the 120 but I'm not sure if I would like that.

Whereas I hear the AE-10 has mouth and jaw sensitivity to respond to vibrato and pitch bending which, combined with its large catalogue of all of the sax sounds (and cheaper pricetag) is leading me there.

If anyone has anything else I should consider, good or bad experiences, I would love to hear because, while I'm leaning more towards the AE-10, I'd love to know more before I pull the trigger.