r/windsynth • u/Yourmama_666 • 3h ago
Complete comparison of current EWI available models
Wanted to share this doc that I created with AI to compare my current own EWI's and the rest in the market thought it was going to be useful for the community.
I compared the current EWIs on completeness, portability, and cost — including my Clarii PRO C20 vs. Aerophone Pro AE-30
This version uses only Reddit-compatible Markdown: no HTML, no images, and no table wider than five columns, so it should render on desktop, mobile, and old Reddit.
I own a Robkoo Clarii PRO C20 and a Roland Aerophone Pro AE-30, so I compared them against the rest of the current EWI market on three things: completeness, portability, and cost.
Prices are US prices checked on 18 Nov 2026, mostly on Sweetwater. Specs are from manufacturer and retailer listings — where sources disagreed, I flagged it at the bottom instead of picking one quietly.
TL;DR
- Most complete: Roland Aerophone Pro AE-30 — $1,799.99. 300+ scenes, 600 user scenes, ZEN-Core + SuperNATURAL, 5-pin MIDI IN/OUT, motion sensor and thumb pad.
- Most portable: Odisei Travel Sax 2 — $699 on sale / $789 list. 23 cm long, about 335 g, real sax keys and mouthpiece, built-in speaker, 6 hours on USB-C.
- Best value: Robkoo Clarii PRO C20 — $699 at Patchman Music / $799 direct. 100 sounds, 1,000 user sounds, 650 g, USB-C rechargeable, at about 39% of the AE-30's price.
- Nothing I found is both more complete AND more portable than the two I already own. Everything more portable gives up a lot of sounds and features. Everything more synth-deep is heavier or needs extra batteries.
My two, head-to-head: Clarii PRO C20 vs. AE-30
| Area | Clarii PRO C20 | Aerophone Pro AE-30 |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $699–$799 | $1,799.99 |
| Presets | 100 sounds | 300+ scenes |
| User storage | 1,000 sounds | 600 scenes |
| Weight | 650 g | 1,140 g |
| Length | 66.5 cm | 68.7 cm |
| Battery | Li-ion, USB-C, 5–8 hrs | 6x AA Ni-MH, ~6 hrs |
| Speaker | Dual, 98 dB peak | 1.5 W x 2 |
| 5-pin MIDI | No — needs USB host | Yes, IN/OUT |
| Keys | Touch pads, Boehm layout | Moving sax keys |
| Extra expression | Bend plates, 3D Glide, gyro | Motion sensor, thumb pad |
Where the AE-30 wins: preset breadth (300+ vs. 100), 4-part layering, full effects (multi-effects, chorus, delay, reverb), moving sax keys, motion sensor + thumb pad, and pro connectivity. It is the only one of the two that talks to hardware synths without a computer or USB host in between.
Where the C20 wins: user storage (1,000 vs. 600), weight (490 g lighter), battery (rechargeable Li-ion over USB-C — the AE-30 cannot charge or run off USB-C and its AAs are not included), speaker loudness on paper, and price. It also has more dedicated bend/glide surfaces: an analog portamento plate, dual bend plates, and 3D Glide on ClariiOS 4.0, though 3D Glide needs a $14 keycap kit.
The honest gap on the C20: no native 5-pin MIDI, a smaller preset library, and touch pads instead of moving keys. Whether touch pads are a downside is a feel preference, not a spec win for either side.
Completeness at a glance
| Model | Sounds | User storage | 5-pin MIDI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aerophone Pro AE-30 | 300+ scenes | 600 scenes | Yes |
| ASM Diosynth | 384 factory | 768 total | Yes |
| Aerophone AE-20 / AE-20W | 250+ sounds | 600 scenes | No |
| Akai EWI Solo | 200 sounds | Not published | No |
| Aerophone AE-10* | 128 tones | 100 tones | No |
| Clarii PRO C20 | 100 sounds | 1,000 sounds | No |
| Aerophone Brisa | 100 tones | Via app | No |
| Akai EWI 5000 | 100 patches | Editor-based | Out only |
| Yamaha YDS-152 | 89 voices | Via app | No |
| Yamaha YDS-150 | 73 voices | Via app | No |
| Travel Sax 2 | 50+ sounds | Via app | No |
| Clarii Mini | 50+ sounds | 10 favourites | No |
| Sylphyo Phoenix | 30+ universes | Via software | No |
| Aerophone AE-01 Mini | 6 tones | None | No |
| Akai EWI USB | 0 onboard | None | No |
* Discontinued — see status notes below.
Notes on completeness:
- Deepest synth: ASM Diosynth ($1,099) — Hydrasynth-based engine, 384 factory / 768 total patches, mechanical keys, joystick and pressure pads, full editor. Fewer ready-to-play acoustic presets than the AE-30, and no Roland Cloud.
- Best expansion ecosystem: AE-30 and AE-20 — Roland Cloud, Sound Packs, and a desktop editor.
- EWI USB is a controller only. No onboard sounds, no speaker, no battery. It only works with a computer or iPad running software instruments.
Portability at a glance
| Model | Weight | Length | Battery | Speaker |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Travel Sax 2 | ~335 g | 23 cm | USB-C, ~6 hrs | Yes |
| Clarii Mini | 263 g | 46 cm | USB-C, ~12 hrs | Yes |
| Sylphyo Phoenix | 395 g | 43 cm | USB, ~6 hrs | No |
| Aerophone AE-01 Mini | 500 g | 44.4 cm | 4x AA, ~10 hrs | Yes |
| Aerophone Brisa | 437 g | 75.2 cm | Li-ion, ~8–9 hrs | No* |
| Clarii PRO C20 | 650 g | 66.5 cm | USB-C, 5–8 hrs | Yes |
| EWI Solo | 820 g | 76.5 cm | Li-ion, 12+ hrs | Yes |
| Diosynth | 900 g | 69.8 cm | 2x 18650** | Yes, 2 W |
| Aerophone AE-20 | ~1,100 g | 63.2 cm | 6x AA, ~6 hrs | Yes |
| Aerophone Pro AE-30 | 1,140 g | 68.7 cm | 6x AA, ~6 hrs | Yes |
| Yamaha YDS-150 | 1,000 g | 69.9 cm | 4x AAA, ~3 hrs | Yes, in bell |
* No built-in speaker was listed in any source checked for the Brisa.
** 18650 batteries not included, and no battery-life figure is published for the Diosynth.
Portability takeaways:
- The Travel Sax 2 is in a different size class from everything else — less than half the length of the next shortest full instrument — and it still has real moving keys, a real alto mouthpiece, and a speaker.
- The Clarii Mini is lighter and lasts longer, but it is twice as long, uses touch pads only, and has about 50 sounds.
- The Sylphyo is short and light with 40+ fingerings, but with no speaker you always need headphones.
- The Yamaha YDS line feels the most like a real sax, but the YDS-150 gets only about 3 hours from 4x AAA batteries.
Prices — US, checked 18 Nov 2026
| Model | US price | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Clarii Mini | $299 + shipping | Patchman Music |
| Akai EWI USB | $349 | Controller only |
| Aerophone AE-01 Mini | $407.99 | Current |
| Akai EWI Solo | $549 | Stock fragile |
| Yamaha YDS-120 | $599.99 | Discontinued |
| Aerophone AE-05 GO | $611.99 | Current |
| Yamaha YDS-122 | $659.99 | Pre-order, Jan 2027 |
| Travel Sax 2 | $699 | Sale, $789 list |
| Clarii PRO C20 | $699–$799 | Patchman / Robkoo direct |
| Yamaha YDS-150 | $799.99 | Current |
| Akai EWI 5000 | $899 | No longer at Sweetwater |
| Aerophone AE-20W | $899.99 | White AE-20 variant |
| Yamaha YDS-152 | $1,049.99 | New, Oct 2026 |
| ASM Diosynth | $1,099 | New, Jan 2026 |
| Aerophone AE-20 | $1,149.99 | Current |
| Aerophone Pro AE-30 | $1,799.99 | Current |
| Aerophone Brisa | $1,799.99 | New, Nov 2025, flute-style |
Value ranking
This is features + portability per dollar, not a "you should buy this" list:
- Clarii PRO C20 ($699) — Near-flagship features and the most user storage in the field, at about 39% of the AE-30's price.
- Aerophone AE-20W ($899.99) — The AE-20's 250+ sounds and 600 user scenes for $250 less than the black AE-20. You lose the AE-30's motion sensor, thumb pad, and 5-pin MIDI.
- Akai EWI Solo ($549) — 200 sounds, 12+ hour battery, and a speaker at the lowest standalone price. Touch-key EWI fingering, and stock is fragile.
- ASM Diosynth ($1,099) — Deepest synth and mechanical keys, $700 less than the AE-30. Batteries not included, battery life unpublished.
- Travel Sax 2 ($699) — Best portability per dollar, but the onboard sounds are basic. The depth lives in the app.
- Aerophone Pro AE-30 ($1,799.99) — Most complete, but the premium over the AE-20W and C20 mostly buys 5-pin MIDI, the motion sensor, thumb pad, and about 50 extra scenes.
- Yamaha YDS-150 / YDS-152 ($799.99 / $1,049.99) — Best if sax feel for practice is the priority. Only 73–89 sax-centred voices.
- Akai EWI USB ($349) — Cheapest way in, but only as a DAW controller. Not a standalone instrument.
If you only care about one thing
Most complete — AE-30. Largest preset library, largest mainstream expansion ecosystem, and the only full pro I/O set in this comparison: 5-pin MIDI IN/OUT + USB-C audio/MIDI + Bluetooth audio/MIDI + 1/4" line out. Trade-offs are weight, AA batteries with no USB-C power, and price. Closest challenger: Diosynth, if synth editing matters more than preset breadth.
Most portable — Travel Sax 2. Pocket-scale, real sax keys and mouthpiece, self-contained with a speaker and a 6-hour USB-C battery, and still a full USB-C + Bluetooth MIDI controller. Trade-offs are basic onboard sounds, no listed bite sensor or dedicated bend plate, and a full-size price for a travel instrument. Closest challenger: Clarii Mini — lighter, cheaper, longer battery, but longer, touch pads only.
Caveats — where the sources disagreed
- Travel Sax 2 weight: 335 g (Thomann / Dawkes) vs. 279 g (Odisei's own Instagram, 18 Nov 2026). I used 335 g above.
- EWI 5000 battery: About 6 hours in Akai's spec vs. 12 hours on one dealer page. I used 6 hours.
- Brisa battery and speaker: About 8 hours (Sam Ash) vs. about 9 hours (B&H). No speaker was listed in any source checked.
- Diosynth battery life: Not published anywhere I checked.
- YDS-122 / YDS-152: Weight, dimensions, and battery life were not published in the sources checked. Prices were verified.
- Speaker specs are not comparable across brands. Some publish watts, the C20 publishes 98 dB peak, and several publish nothing. Do not rank speakers off these numbers alone.
Discontinued / superseded as of Nov 2026: Roland AE-10 (2022), Yamaha YDS-120 (replaced by the YDS-122), Akai EWI 5000 (no longer available at Sweetwater).
New in 2025–2026: ASM Diosynth, Roland Aerophone Brisa, Yamaha YDS-122 / YDS-152, Roland AE-20W, Sylphyo Phoenix, and the Clarii PRO C20 on ClariiOS 4.0.
Happy to be corrected on any spec — especially from anyone who owns the Diosynth, Brisa, or Sylphyo, since those were the hardest to verify from listings alone.
Sources