r/anime • myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Apr 06 '25

Meta Meta Thread - Month of April 06, 2025

Rule Changes


This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.

Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.

Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.


Previous meta threads: March 2025 | February 2025 | January 2025 | December 2024 | November 2024 | October 2024 | September 2024 | August 2024 | July 2024 | June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | January 2024| Find All

New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.

37 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

•

u/baseballlover723 Apr 06 '25

Hey everyone, it's been a busy month.

March Mod Report

March by the Numbers

  • Total traffic: 43,837,048 pageviews, 8,766,131 unique visitors
  • Total posts: 14,228, 9,512 unique authors
  • Total comments: 196,934, 35,582 unique authors (excluding mod bots)
  • Removed posts: 1,158 by moderators, 8,123 by bots, 9,213 distinct
  • Removed comments: 2,787 by moderators, 1,402 by bots, 4,083 distinct
  • Approved posts: 2,725
  • Approved comments: 2,555
  • Distinguished comments: 2,248
  • Users banned: 220 (97 permanent)
  • Users unbanned: 0
  • Admin/Anti-Evil Operations: removed posts: 25, removed comments: 51.
→ More replies (9)

63

u/PrinceZero1994 https://myanimelist.net/profile/pz16 Apr 27 '25 edited Apr 27 '25

Just wanna say that you can see multiple obvious alt accounts making comments on the last 2 OF post.
This is to increase engagement, I guess. Of course, they upvote the post too.
I still believe they are here not because of anime, but just to promote their junk.
Mods have the final say on which post stays up or not and I can't say I'm not disappointed seeing all the complaints seemingly fall on deaf ears.

38

u/jnads Apr 29 '25 edited Apr 29 '25

It's interesting that these "Cosplay" posts end up having more total upvotes than, say, the weekly leading anime Apothecary Diaries discussion.

It's no secret you can buy upvotes online.

The fact that one person came back twice in the same week says it was apparently a good investment.

edit: The downvote ratio on the posts points evidence to this, it's far outside other contentious topics (Ecchi/NSFW anime posts). The point of buying votes is to rapidly push a post onto r/all. These people are targeting subs they are allowed to post on that get r/all visibility to peddle what they are selling. r/anime is an easy sub to exploit.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (26)

41

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25

It seems like a consistent sub-argument against cosplay posts is that the OPs are not active in the subreddit outside of posting their pictures, which leads to no or low quality discussion and no feeling of community. And it drowns out posts that are seen as more valuable.

I also think that drive-by posting is a big concern for the community. Many of the current user-created posts on the frontpage have 0 interaction of the OP beyond creating the post — despite being discussion type posts. Often these OPs also don't have much prior subreddit activity. In the spirit of saving the subreddit from all these troubling posts, Cosplay or not, they should just get deleted if the OP does not respond to comments. And maybe get a temp ban for flooding the frontpage with something other than episode discussions and news.

6

u/entelechtual May 01 '25

Would it be possible to have a higher sub-specific karma requirement for posts that feel, let’s say, disingenuous to participation in the community? I think historically fanart and cosplay posts have just had naturally low frequency and traction here but I feel like it was always an expectation if certain user-generated content was really dominating over normally activity, there’d be options to restrict them.

Personally I don’t think we’re there yet either with discussion or cosplay.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

182

u/__Parasyte__ Apr 27 '25

With how divisive the obvious OF cosplay ads are, I'd love to just ban cosplay in general. I'm in r/anime for the anime/media, not to be bombarded with thinly veiled Etsy shop and OF account ads.

43

u/PrinceZero1994 https://myanimelist.net/profile/pz16 Apr 27 '25

Just ban OF. Other subs have done it. That's why they are seeking new subs. Cosplay is not the fault.

→ More replies (4)

32

u/lans_throwaway Apr 27 '25 edited 19d ago

I love listening to classical music.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/N7CombatWombat Apr 27 '25

Content being divisive isn't a reason by itself to remove content. If that were the case then you wouldn't find any Jobless Reincarnation or Gushing Over Magical Girls posts here.

"Bombarded" is a little bit hyperbolic in my opinion, there's currently one cosplay post on the front page and zero fan art, video or video edit posts. If we do get actually bombarded to the point the amount of content overwhelms most other content, then that's a different story and we would be examining how to reduce the load in that event.

The fact of the matter is that every content creator who posts their content here does so to promote themselves in one way or another, some of them try to monetize it, and our rules don't allow them to directly do so on the subreddit. We have no control over what people do off the subreddit and no one is forced to click through to the account and leave the subreddit. That's a conscious choice by the person doing the clicking.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (14)

74

u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine May 01 '25

Mr. President, another cosplay post has hit the front page!

30

u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy May 01 '25

Rinse and repeat everyday very soon at this rate.

When's the plug gonna be pulled?

17

u/Greboso May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25

The post got nuked. full gone. Wonder if there's an announcement in the works.

Edit: never mind mods just nuked me from the post for telling people to block the account.💀💀

→ More replies (4)

11

u/[deleted] May 01 '25

All subreddits are falling to goonerification.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

29

u/SCVGoodT0GoSir Apr 30 '25

I don't have any strong opinions about whether cosplay should be allowed or not allowed on this subreddit, but I strongly believe the moderation of the comments needs to be more consistent.

For example, my comment poking fun of the bloodbath of removed comments in the thread got removed after about 7 hours, while the top comment which was posted 3 hours before my post, also poking fun of removed comments stayed up until I pointed out the inconsistency.

And even now, there's a comment about mass deletion of comments that's currently up, 15 hours later.

To reiterate, I don't have a strong opinion on cosplay posts. I'll leave that decision up to the mods. However, inconsistent moderation (and unclear rules) makes it hard to know what we can and can't say in the comments section.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 06 '25

Just something I was curious about the general community's thoughts on and figured with the new meta thread it couldn't hurt to ask.

Last summer fanart and cosplay rules were changed to allow them as image posts again. On the whole this hasn't overflowed the subreddit like it did in the past, and I was just wondering how people were feeling in general about the change.

I've definitely seen some good fanart and just fun stuff over the months since the rules change. But at the same time I frequently am disappointed seeing stuff where it's pretty transparent that the poster isn't really trying to be a member of the community or anything like that, but is just using r/anime as a platform to advertise their fanart for the purpose of sales.

8

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Apr 06 '25

just using r/anime as a platform to advertise their fanart for the purpose of sales.

I wonder if that was also generally the case back before the text post requirement, but I'll leave y'all to do the data analysis there.

Similarly since fanart hasn't overrun the front page these days I don't mind the change back, but I'm assuming the minimum karma requirement might be helping there even if it doesn't do much to encourage long-term participation.

It's more trouble than would be worth I bet but a dev platform application for more than a flat absolute threshold could be interesting. For example that could require 10 karma per fanart post so you'd need 20 total to post your second, 50 for the fifth, etc. or even make it scale up the more you post to stop one popular comment from covering an entire year of posts.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Apr 06 '25

i think it's been good

i only wish that commissions could be shared as image posts. i commission anime art pretty regularly, would be fun to share like that

5

u/Verzwei Apr 06 '25

I think that the less-complicated rules (not having to do text posts, etc) that are hard for users to understand is a good thing, I think the change to allow them to be image posts is good over-all.

But at the same time I frequently am disappointed seeing stuff where it's pretty transparent that the poster isn't really trying to be a member of the community or anything like that, but is just using r/anime as a platform to advertise their fanart for the purpose of sales.

What about implementing/upping the minimum r/anime comment (specifically comment, not including posts) karma necessary to make fanart or cosplay posts?

This won't stop someone from dropping an "Attack on Titan is the GOAT" in a semi-relevant thread and farming upvotes to then post their content, but it could act as a little bit of a barrier for people with no or little interaction with the community.

Originally, "forcing some level of interaction with the community" was a major part of the intent behind the karma requirement for posting, so if you feel like it's too-easily bypassed by people who don't seem to be participating in the community in good faith, how about turning up the dial on that filter?

Crazy and probably bad idea: I don't know how robust the filter is or what other backend tools you've gained in the last few years, but is there a way to easily (as in, be able to handle it with auto-mod so it doesn't take up human moderator time in every instance) check recent activity on the sub? Say if someone hasn't gained X karma in the last Y days (like a month or more?) then they can't post, and an automod message could tell them why?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke Apr 06 '25

It at least allows me to post my medium-effort but unfortunately low-skilled art. :P

Joking aside, if it looks like it's just an advertisement fanart, I don't really interact with it other than sometimes looking at specific aspects to see if I can learn anything from it. Which would be irritating, except the number of "recommend me an anime like X" posts exceed the fanart ones by a huge margin.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Nebresto Apr 21 '25

I got an idea for the cosplay situation. As it is now its generating pointless strife without anyone necessarily being in the wrong, stemming from what users deem as "outsiders" coming in only to advertise their other stuff.

So why not mandate every user that makes a post under the cosplay flair to add a brief comment explaining the creation process, inspiration for the outfit, etc.
A "picture proof" was mentioned earlier, but that was deemed too restrictive for various reasons.
A text explanation doesn't rule out anyone.

If the poster doesn't have the patience to spend a minute or two writing, chances are they also don't have the patience to actually craft a cosplay by themselves, so it can be filtered out as cheap.

This way users get a better insight on what went into the costume, and posters are less likely to be labeled as "fakes"

10

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 23 '25

So why not mandate every user that makes a post under the cosplay flair to add a brief comment explaining the creation process, inspiration for the outfit, etc.

If what we're trying to achieve is to weed out 'outsiders' who don't give a fuck about r/anime, then we could simply ask for a minimum karma requirement (from other threads) in order to post cosplays!

They could even make it a "recent karma" if that's possible, so they won't just be able to post some stuff once and then post cosplay forever.

(I imagine someone people might now think "They'll just find ways to farm karma!", but I'm sure a hundred people will scan the profile of anyone who posts cosplay in here to see if they did that, so that shouldn't be an issue! All the "OF commenters" will make sure they're not doing anything wrong).

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/Nebresto Apr 22 '25

The effort they would spend setting up the prompt would be more or less the same as it would take to just write the "minimum requirement" so I don't see that being a problem.

And if it does come out someone used an AI to do it for them, that could be easy grounds for a ban.

18

u/chilidirigible Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25

Not-entirely-organized thoughts on one of the present tempests in a teapot: The Cosplay Situation:


Cosplay as a topic, in this subreddit, is acceptable as part of the anime-related culture?

The total number of cosplay posts has significantly diminished over time and what few have appeared lately share a particular aesthetic.

In a perfect scenario where the specific aspects of the cosplay posts are ignored, the posts themselves are blameless and all fault lies with the reactionary commenters.

Not a perfect scenario: The cosplay posts now appearing are predominately fanservice-oriented. The posts routinely receive thousands of upvotes and remain on the front page for extended periods.

The responses to these posts have not meaningfully contributed to the subreddit's content and appear to be motivated by a desire to shame the cosplayers for matters which technically exist outside of the subreddit's current rules boundaries. Considering the interactions between OP and commenters in general, it seems that most of the cosplayers who are posting here are not bothered by the criticisms versus the significant visibility boost from posting.

The subreddit routinely discusses anime fanservice topics which are similarly NSFW. Real-world individuals engaging in fanservice activities exposes hypocrisy in how such topics are viewed? In both cases, the creators of the work are aware of what they are trying to sell, whether it is animated or on their person.

The "moral outrage" over the posts as demonstrated by comments is much less significant in proportion to the apparent tacit approval of them shown by their accumulated karma. But bad reviews are the reviews which get attention.

The comments require significant moderator intervention in order to maintain community standards. This is a problem for the moderation team, but due to automod filtering mostly does not externalize itself to the community at large.

Moderator convenience is not a great reason to change rules or lock comments except in extreme circumstances. Where is that benchmark?


Remedies?

Remove cosplay posting. Cuts off some level of community involvement, but as noted above, nearly all of its recent appearances have been of this specific and controversial type instead of a broader representation of the category.

Return to self-post format for cosplay. Does remove the obvious thumbnail image, probably would still be found and attract controversy.

Lock comments when these posts appear. Appears as censorship or endorsement of the cosplay.

Continue without changes. Doesn't "solve" anything, if one believes that there is a problem to begin with.


Ultimately it may be about a determination of whether the "community" "outcry" is enough of a problem in itself that requires remedy versus the statistically-low number of cosplay posts, and when the angry comments are restricted to the posts themselves and the Meta Thread. Optics may be a factor in this issue if the subreddit seems to be damaged by it. The convenience of moderators ultimately is... not?

23

u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Apr 28 '25

Remedies?

I suppose you could add one more option: require cosplay posts to be an original creation rather than a store-bought costume.

It would make good sense regardless of the OF issue, bringing cosplay posts in line with fanart posts, which aren't showing off art they bought. If people have to post in-progress photos showing they made it themselves, we'll get fewer posts, but the ones we get will be more creative, and the hue and cry about OF can be dismissed as basic slut shaming.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '25 edited Apr 30 '25

You are ignoring the main criticism people have of them and talking about what is at best a secondary concern. The main criticism is they are advertisements for OnlyFans accounts that are pretending (very lazily pretending, mind you) to be genuine.

None of your remedies are addressing that concern or providing a method for trying to discriminate between advertisements and those from people with a genuine desire to engage with the subreddit via their cosplay.

It is super obvious when they are just OF advertisements, so it shouldn't be that hard for Mods to just make a rule against such advertisement, identify when it is an instance of being a deceptive advertisement, and then remove the post and apply whatever other penalties are appropriate for breaking the rules.

It might be a little difficult to provide a one size fits all technical definition, but a more vague "No advertisement cosplay posts" and some basic moderator judgement would be more than adequate.

If they have an actual desire to prevent advertisement posts, at any rate.

18

u/chilidirigible May 01 '25

Omedetou to April 2025 for making /r/Anime meta more than it's ever metaed before.

Fortunately for those who wish to find relief from the battle here, the subreddit offers many other topics in which one can find shelter.

10

u/steven4869 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maskirade May 01 '25

Legit, 1K comments on a meta thread is bonkers.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/Verzwei May 02 '25

The last meta to meta this much was back when one could not find shelter here.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal May 02 '25

I wonder what stats are for people commenting on this thread and how many (not removed) comments they have elsewhere in /r/anime in the same period.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii May 01 '25

the subreddit offers many other topics in which one can find shelter.

But how will people know about the cosplay situation if only 500 people post the exact same comment about it?

We probably need 5000 at least.

(People are now even resorting to using alt accounts and stuff... Some of them haven't posted in r/anime in 2 years - which is kinda funny considering how some are floating the idea of enforcing "participation in r/anime" as a requirement to post cosplay! Maybe we should ask "participation in r/anime" as a requirement to post in META!)

17

u/AnimeHoarder Apr 08 '25

FYI: The maintainer of senpai.moe has posted the following on their site:

Notice of closure

In light of the recent news that MyAnimeList has been sold to an AI/NFT company (ANN link) I have decided to stop updating Senpai. The work necessary to add an integration with another service is more than I can handle at the moment. Due to health issues(*) I haven't had the energy to update new seasons in a timely manner, so this will be a weight off my shoulders.

I encourage all users of MyAnimeList to migrate their lists to other services lile Anilist. Here is an exporter — I haven't tested it.

This site will remain up for the foreseeable future, until a prudent amount of time has passed or it breaks.

(* It's nothing life-threatening, please don't worry about me.)

So their entry in the related_sites in the wiki could be updated. The ANN story they mentioned is dated April 1st, so this was posted just in the last week.

10

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 08 '25

Damn, that's a shame. Loved senpai.moe.

5

u/entelechtual Apr 09 '25

Watch over us, senpai…

15

u/W8tin4BanHammer2Fall Apr 21 '25

I'm going to be that guy and point out that the comments in the cosplay posts about comments being deleted also violate this rule:

  • Comments on Fanart/Cosplay posts must be about the work or the show(s) it represents.

I'm not too serious about this though as it would take some of the joy out of the conversation in those posts and add more work for the mods :-)

41

u/dorian_gayy Apr 06 '25

I've read that Link Click is not allowed to be posted in this subreddit as an original post, as it is a donghua, but will posts about To Be Hero X, which has mixed Chinese and Japanese production, be allowed? Crunchyroll has been advertising it with the Japanese audio as though it is an anime, not a donghua.

Is there a rule on this?

32

u/Komarist https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Apr 06 '25

88

u/Zonca Apr 06 '25

I think the sub should have voted instead, especially now that the first episode is out and people can judge it whether they believe it belongs here or not.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (61)

58

u/Astan92 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Astan92 Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25

Are there not going to be discussion threads for To Be Hero X? The anime series(not music video) I just watched on Crunchyroll, An anime streaming site, in Japanese from well know seiyuu, with the name of a well known Anime studio right on it, with music from one of the best anime composers Hiroyuki SAWANO.

17

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25

Haha, look at the destruction you caused :P

(not music video)

Flashback to Shelter.

Anyways, there’s actually something implicit you bring up here. Which is, can a show that is arguably an “anime” have an episode discussion? It seems like the precedent requires the show to first be an anime and then to consider additional clauses before it is determined whether there can be an episode discussion.

I would like to see more open discussion on if episode discussions can happen for “close-but-not-anime” (there has to be some sort of baseline definition) but wanted by a lot of people. I’d rather this than discussion on whether X or Y is an anime as we all know it is a tried and tired discussion. Even academics / anthropologists / people in the industry whose sole job is to interact with anime can’t come to a consensus!

→ More replies (160)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25

Was there a change of policy related the interpretation of "direction toward illegal anime sources"?

I've made this comment. I assume it was removed because I mentioned a certain internet exchange protocol (T*****t). Not a site or source or anything, just the name of a tech. Is this word now banned?

Because I've been using this since forever and I don't recall ever getting moderated. I also vaguely remember a mod linking even to the wikipedia definition of said internet file exchange protocol.

Genuine question, I obviously don't want to violate the rules, asking for future reference.

14

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 12 '25

I'm sorry, that removal was incorrect. Just mentioning torrenting or that pirate streaming sites exist without naming specific sites is perfectly fine.

I've reapproved your comment.

11

u/chilidirigible Apr 12 '25

The obligatory front page on reaching another million screenshot.

8

u/Esovan13 Apr 13 '25

The top three posts being Jojo part 7 announcements feels right

→ More replies (2)

7

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Apr 12 '25

the SBR rewatch is in r/anime history! (thanks to the sidebar)

6

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Apr 12 '25

→ More replies (1)

6

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Apr 13 '25

Messed up that you upvoted Kowloon discussion thread but didn't upvote Mono's or Shoshimin's.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Akriosken May 01 '25

Chiming in about the giant Cosplay discussion as a mostly lurker these days.

I have been seeing these Cosplay posts same as pretty much everyone else, and couldn't help but notice they are largely a comment graveyard, though I did notice stuff before it gets mod-nuked, and to be honest morbid curiosity at the comments is what sometimes keeps me coming back into those threads.

It is obvious that these Cosplay posts engender an extremely toxic response from a subset of the community, despite the amount of upvotes making them eclipse even the daily seasonal discussion threads. And I don't see this trend going away any time soon. I personally doubt that people would suddenly stop making completely inappropriate remarks in those threads.

Thus, my concern, and cause for making this reply in the wind, is that it is blatantly obvious that moderating these threads is extremely resource-intensive, and this is compared to the volume of posts you guys monitor every day when it comes to stuff like unmarked spoilers, which I assume involves sifting through many users reporting them.

I am in favor of some better-defined rules when it comes to these posts, whatever direction the mod team decides to go with, mostly because I would like you guys to not burn yourselves out on these threads.

The subset of the cosplay posts that are problematic are thus also because they are thinly-veiled advertising. Most communities have strict rules against advertising, lest the communities devolve into a sea of ads drowning out the conversations people come to the sub for. And I would hate for the quality of the community to be diminished because of this. And we can already see this, as of writing this comment, the current first post of r/anime front page is one such cosplay post, which has orders of magnitude more upvotes than the highest upvoted show in this week's karma ranking chart. If this is not a rare peak but the start of a rising trend, I suspect we'll have to scroll past a few of these to reach the discussion threads. Whether or not the mod team is ok with this is admittedly out of our hands, but I personally feel like it would diminish the quality of the community at large.

→ More replies (39)

65

u/Odd_Link_7231 May 01 '25

Im extremely confused why this sub is allowing thinly veiled only fans adverts.

18

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead May 01 '25

This subreddit so far allows thinly veiled ads for anything and everything as long as the post is anime-related.

10

u/Rumpel1408 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rumpel1408 Apr 06 '25

Roll text in the topbar could use some updatingto include the seasonal survey.

8

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Apr 06 '25

Hi, do you mean the carousel up on the top? That one is currently updated as of now. I know it looks funny to see Fall 2024 on there but we're actually waiting on the results of the Winter 2025 before we update. The survey was recently posted, so once April 11th comes, I'll update the top to include the result.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Castor_0il Apr 08 '25

Can you mods do something about this probably bot account that just spams "W" on most threads?

https://old.reddit.com/user/Financial_Exit_7710

14

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 08 '25

They are/were a real person (which I largely know because they posted JJK spoilers at one point). But regardless, that sort of behavior is not wanted here. I've spammed all their comments in the past month and told them to knock it off. If they continue, let us know and they'll get a permanent ban.

12

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Apr 08 '25

Wonder how much you'd catch filtering comments under a certain length.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Apr 10 '25

Now that's some dedication!

9

u/piruuu https://anilist.co/user/dvj Apr 06 '25

It's been almost a year and a half since the mod team announced that discussion had begun about softening rules regarding piracy and 8 months since the last update.

Is it fair to say that this discussion is dead in the water or is it just very low on your priority list?

9

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25

Yes. Other things overtook it in priority.

9

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 30 '25

For a more light-hearted discussion:

Is there no place in r/anime where we can post a "META" joke?

Because in Casual Discussion Friday, there's

No meta discussion.

And in META, there's

Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.

So are META jokes banned from the whole sub?

Or are META jokes not considered "META discussion" and thus allowed on casual discussion friday? (though I imagine they may devolve in meta discussion anyway, and then they'd probably all get deleted for it?)

I was wondering about that because a comment below made me think of a silly joke then I realized "I can't post it anywhere!"

5

u/cppn02 Apr 30 '25

Now I wanna see that joke. Pls ping me when you post that wherever.

11

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Apr 30 '25

Meta-related jokes are allowed in CDF, it's extended discussion about content that belongs in the meta thread that is banned from there. You can post whatever joke you came up with there.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/cppn02 May 02 '25 edited May 02 '25

I haven't watched them yet so can't speak to their quality but according to the release notes the subs for Takamine-san seem to be atleast partially AI translated.

Wouldn't that be against r/anime policy for episode discussions?

→ More replies (3)

9

u/chilidirigible May 02 '25

And now for something completely different:

When is the subreddit user counter going to be changed from the Initial D theme? It feels like it's lasted through the entire split cours of MF Ghost and that's been finished for weeks now.

25

u/theangryeditor https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheAngryEditor May 02 '25

Based on the comments in this thread I get the impression that due to the relatively high number of votes the cosplay posts have been getting they're way overrepresented in the feeds of people who don't check the sub's front page often, which makes it seem like the cosplay posts are dominating in absolute terms. It has as much to do with the structure of the website as it does with the posts themselves. And the fact that not much other stuff have been getting a lot of upvotes recently.

15

u/punching_spaghetti https://myanimelist.net/profile/punch_spaghetti May 02 '25

There's actually more Rewatch threads than cosplay threads on the front page.

Although this does raise a good question: how much traffic is actually driven by the front page? Do people generally want to get the broad sense of things, or do they know what they want (episode discussion, Rewatches, CDF, etc) and navigate directly there?

12

u/theangryeditor https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheAngryEditor May 02 '25

I honestly have no idea how people browse using new reddit, and frankly I don't want to know

→ More replies (4)

13

u/alotmorealots May 02 '25

Yes, and Reddit's engagement algorithm just keeps pushing the posts higher the more the complainers comment in the thread, which just pushes it onto more people's feeds. Given how many of those people are mobile users, they just see the pic and upvote it without even opening the thread lol

...which in turn leads to it staying on more and more people's feed, drawing in more complainers and so on!

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Tetraika :Lu::Lv::Lw::Lx:https://anilist.co/user/Tetraika Apr 22 '25

Oh since this is happening I guess I'll drop my 2 cents on this.

Personally I don't really care about if someone is secretly just promoting their OF or something. It's fairly easy to just ignore most of the cosplay content on /r/anime already, and so far they're very few of them.

I guess my "fear" is that it becomes like a front for a bunch of people to do the same thing and make the sub become saturated with those. I know I would hate the sub to become an ad front for people who aren't really intend to be a part of the community. This goes for fanarts too.

There is also an unfortunate amount of what is just basically veiled slut shaming. I know not everyone critical of the current situation is like this, but yeah.

Honestly if I had any solution I would propose it would just be banning cosplay (and maybe even fanarts) post entirely unless there is a specific /r/anime event. Might not be a popular opinion though.


On a different note since this is the other hot topic, I'm mostly fine with how /r/anime is defining "anime" and allowing/disallowing certain productions for now. Out of curiosity, if Twins HinaHima get acceptable subs would it be qualified for discussion?

10

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 23 '25

Unless this "Fear" materializes at some point, this 'controversy' always felt so silly to me...

Like, we're getting what, 0.5 cosplay post a day? (4 in the past week according to the search)...

Yet it feels like the 2nd biggest drama happening on r/anime, the 1st being To Be Hero X.

If the 2nd worst thing that ever happens in r/anime is that every 40 hours someone posts a lewd cosplay they don't like, I'd say things are going great!

I mean, how difficult it is to just hit "hide" on the thread and never think about it ever again?

I do it a hundred times a day on poorly thought recommendation threads.

I would understand if (like that 'Fear') we were flooded with those, but 4 in a week doesn't seem like a problem to me... And it's not even 4 problematic ones, I think it's like 2 (the other 2 were fine).

Honestly if I had any solution I would propose it would just be banning cosplay (and maybe even fanarts) post entirely unless there is a specific /r/anime event. Might not be a popular opinion though.

I think my solution would be even more unpopular hah; At this point I'd just give temp bans to everyone who repeatedly post META stuff in these threads. I'm sure it's a lot of repeat offenders.

And one more thing I'm sure of, is that calling out OF in every single thread, probably brings more business to their OF, than if they said nothing.

They bring SO much attention to the threads/their OF, while completely ignoring the non-OF cosplay threads.

9

u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Apr 22 '25 edited Apr 22 '25

On a different note since this is the other hot topic, I'm mostly fine with how /r/anime is defining "anime" and allowing/disallowing certain productions for now. Out of curiosity, if Twins HinaHima get acceptable subs would it be qualified for discussion?

I guess that's the next big existential question coming soon, isn't it?

My thoughts on this are that it probably does not make much sense to treat it as anything other than yet another technological shift in how anime is made - not so different from xerography, digital scanning, digital colouring, CG rendering, etc. Especially that last one.

If we compare the advent of generative AI in the anime industry to the advent of 3DCG rendering in the anime industry, I suppose in terms of the timeline of adoption we're somewhere around the time for genAI now that would be equivalent to, say, the late 1990s/very early '00s were for 3DCG rendering. I.e. the time when stuff like Visitor or Garm War or that 3DCG Gegege no Kitaro short film were coming out... and no one really cared. They were more like experimental productions than actual anime films expected to sell, and overall quite "low-profile" anyways. Plus you could easily tell them apart at a glance from conventionally-made anime.

They weren't any sort of "threat" to the question of "what is anime?"... but they were a herald of what was to come. The 3DCG rendering tools got better and people in the industry got better at using them. Anime creators found useful ways to use 3DCG rendering in small ways within the conventional anime production pipeline, making it no longer a matter of a work being totally 3DCG or totally handdrawn-2D, it could be a mix of both. Two and a half decades later and 3DCG rendering technology is so intertwined in the anime industry that there's no way we could try to say that works made with 3DCG rendering shouldn't be considered "anime".

So similarly, I don't think there's a lot to worry about with Twins HinaHima or Who Said Death Was Beautiful? - these are the early, low-profile works that are largely just experimenting with the genAI technology. Very few people are going to even notice them, and they are so easy to tell apart from what current "conventional" anime look like that they are easy to see as simply "other". They don't threaten any sort of existential question on the nature of what is and isn't "anime"... or rather, perhaps, on what should and shouldn't be "anime".

But there's a very good chance that 25 years from now various genAI tools will be completely ingrained in the industry's conventional production pipelines. Perhaps only used in parts of the pipeline - just like Re:Zero uses 3DCG for some parts of its production today. Or, perhaps there will even be shows being made with an entirely different animation process which entirely uses generative AI at that time - much like how these days we have shows such as Beastars, Kingdom, MyGO!!!!!, etc, which are made entirely with 3DCG rendering, no hand-drawn animation at all.

Nobody is calling for Re:Zero, Beastars, or MyGO!!!!! to be considered "not anime" in the popular zeitgeist, and they are unquestionably being made by people and companies which are fully-fledged members of the anime industry. They're not "special cases" anymore, they're conventional.

Hence, 25 years from now there will probably be shows made in part or "entirely" with genAI and at that time it will be unthinkable not to consider them "anime".

Saying Twins HinaHima isn't anime today feels to me like being in 2001 and saying RUN=DIM or Platonic Chain aren't anime. Yeah, they looked very different and were a big departure from the conventional way of making anime at the time... but here in the future, we know how wrong that would prove to become.

All that said, I think there is potentially a line in the sand that is worth being drawn for now between works that have an actual animator doing some sort of "manual" animation work, no matter how "assisted" that is by genAI tools... versus a project that doesn't even have an animator role of any sort and is completely "generated" - i.e. no one did any work of moving their hand to create the visuals, it was entirely driven by typing words into prompts.

In other words, trying to make some sort of cut-off for when we consider something to actually be animated by a person versus only generated by a tool according to a person's prompting.

Where exactly that line could be is tricky. There could be works where all the frames are generated from word-based prompts, but then there is still a person credited as the "animator" who edits/cleans up the generated frames. There could be works where someone with no art or animation background makes some very crappy doodles which are basically just storyboards for the genAI program to read, and then they using word-based prompts the tool generates the frames based on those doodles plus the promot - was making those doodles "animation" enough?

There's not really that much information about it to be had, but it seems like what Twins HinaHima is mostly doing is having a person still manually draw the keyframe animation, and then using a generative AI tool to generate the in-betweens? At the least then, the KA artist is still doing what we would normally consider animation, just as in a conventional show where one person does the KA and another does the in-betweens, we still consider the KA artist to be 'doing animation'.

generAIdoscope, on the other hand, looks like it might have zero people doing any sort of manual animation work and is entirely created by people typing prompts into genAI tools. Hard to say for sure since there's also not much info about it, but if that's the case, there is certainly a case to be made that it could be ruled out based on being solely "generated by people" and not "animated by people".

Then again, who's to say that in some amount of time every high school romcom and isekai wish-fulfillment anime won't be made entirely through generation...

While we're at it, I also expect that there's definitely going to be some meaningful intersection between hand-drawn animation and motion capture-rendering technologies like live2D that will shake up how we have to think about what rotoscoping means in animation, and that genAI tools will be trying to get into that space, as well.

So both of them are going to lead to us really needing to ponder what we want "being an animator" to even mean anymore, and if the industry starts getting muddled with all sorts of folks making "animation" from means other than "being an animator" how do we handle that muddling of the "anime industry" in r/anime.

Lastly, I expect that there are many people who will want to raise the flag about the morality of the anime industry using genAI tools in anime production. From what I've seen, there are lots of folks who feel that usage of these genAI tools (at least for commercial usage) could/should be considered immoral, as the development of (most of?) those tools was done by scraping data/works made by people who will not be credited or renumerated for that tool's usage in creating other works.

Some might even argue that any anime made with such tools should be considered an illegal copyright violation.

Personally, I do find the moral basis of many of these tools and how they are monetized/used very concerning in that regard but I don't expect any such concerns will ever stop these tools from being developed or adopted by the industry, and eventually even the most effusive moral opposition to them will have to accept that the tools are here and aren't going away, that their usage by the industry is simply inevitable. (Though how useful they end up actually being and therefore how widely they end up being adopted is, of course, still to be seen.)

I don't think it would make much sense for r/anime to officially weigh in on the morality of the tools one way or another. Just like how the director of a particular show might turn out to be a molester and that doesn't mean we stop considering that show to be anime and eligible for discussion here - though of course we can still share that news to anyone watching it and let them make their own informed decision of whether they want to watch it or not. Or perhaps a better example is that one show where they abusively "pranked" that one voice actor by lying to them about getting the role - immoral industry practices that can certainly affect your opinion of the show or whether you want to watch it at all, but that doesn't disbar it from being considered anime.

15

u/N7CombatWombat Apr 22 '25

If the number of cosplay posts consistently started surging and pushing out other content then that would be something we would take another look at, not because of OF, but because of content balance in general, that isn't close to being an issue at the moment, we don't get very many cosplay posts to begin with, and that's counting what doesn't make it on the sub in the first place.

Right now the only thing that's disruptive about them are some peoples reactions.

I don't have an answer for you on Twins HinaHima though (I don't recall us having any major conversations about that yet, doesn't mean we haven't, just means I don't remember off the top of my head).

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Apr 07 '25

Minor thing: daily thread links haven't been updated for new CDF/meta thread as of today.

11

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Apr 07 '25

First time I have forgotten ever this month.

8

u/RPO777 x2 Apr 11 '25

OK, I have some constructive feedback to the Mods about how rules on source material discussion are applied, because I frankly think the way the rules are actively preventing relevant discussion of anime, instead of promoting it

As I understand it, the reason we have rules about source material discussions on r/anime are because we want the focus to be about anime. Not manga--there are other subreddits on manga, and this is supposed to keep the focus squarely on anime, thus discussions about manga should be limited.

I understand that, and I don't disagree with the underlying philosophical point.

The problem I have is with the ways in which this rule is being applied is being used to limit discussion that relates to anime.

For example, I had a mod just shut down a thread where I tried to tell people why they should care about the upcoming adaptation of Kore Kaite Shine

https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1jwa6wa/comment/mmlblzm/?context=3

The logic was that the discussion focused on the source material manga, and not on information about the anime (which is presently very sparse), thus was impermissible source material discussion.

The mod may be applying the rule correctly as written, but that is a crappy rule.

If you look at how people engage with the post in the comments, the overwhelming response is "i knew nothing about this anime, but now I'm interested." People are asking about how it compares to other anime, like Look Back, and the engagement is overwhelmingly about how people want to see this anime in the future.

If someone goes on a long review of the manga of Jujutsu Kaisen or Demon Slayer, sure I understand why that review of manga has no place on r/anime. No debate from here. Everyone knows about what those manga are about already, so previewing the quality of the manga to hype upcoming arcs aren't really about anime.

That is not what I'm doing here at all.

Koreshine is a work where people don't know much about the original work. They can't get interested in it, because they don't know anything about it. Telling people what kind of story it well tell, what kinds of themes it engages in, and what kind people it would appeal to IS about anime, when people have no idea what that anime is about.

Context matters. If the anime is already well known and a person dives deeply and unnecessarily into the source material, sure that should e moderated out.

But if 99% of the sub has never heard about this, and no English language synopsis appears anywhere, this type of spoiler-free coverage of the material is absolutely warranted.

I want to emphasize, what I wrote here is the most extensive summary of Koreshine that has been written in English anywhere. I originally planned to post a summary some other anime site had already posted, but there was none to be found.

I went through a lot of work to try to communicate what makes this story worth learning about without giving away any part of the story. It got people engaged. Several people responded that they are now going to pay attention to anime announcements about this work.

I don't really understand how someone can look at the materials written here, and the response it received and say "this is irrelevant to anime and is harmful to have in this sub."

It makes no sense to me.

→ More replies (18)

8

u/Nebresto May 02 '25

Do the mods have stats on how many users are using the various post filters? I would imagine its astronomically low

Also on the topic of the link tool bar, is it possible to extend it? The 'Search for' Section that is under 'post filters' could be its own thing.
Also was gonna ask for the rewatch page to be added to the wiki section, but its apparently under "anime info" which seems strange to me, especially when "watch this!" is in the wiki section, even though they are literally information about specific animes to get people to watch them

6

u/cppn02 May 02 '25

Do the mods have stats on how many users are using the various post filters?

I do remember this being asked once in a meta thread or a survey so almost certainly not.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 May 03 '25

Do the mods have stats on how many users are using the various post filters?

Definitely not, that's something we would have to ask the users on.

Also on the topic of the link tool bar, is it possible to extend it?

Yes, but no haha. Yes as in it is theoretically possible to do, no as in it's a CSS change and nobody on the team will most likely tackle this issue.

Also was gonna ask for the rewatch page to be added to the wiki section

I added it now to the wiki section.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

38

u/Dentorion Apr 21 '25

Sorry to say it but it gets overhand with these Barely hidden OF cosplays the last few months.

I know that cosplays can be a bit of ecchi sometimes but it's annoying to have all these barely hidden OF cosplays who were ordered on Temu just to sexualize some characters are getting votes here.

Can we have maybe for a few months a mod who controls that until the only fans things come down again?

I don't know how that works but at least a bit better Moderation would be nice. I know you do your best work I'm just a bit frustrated cause my little cousin asked me why I watch naked girls on phone and he is too young to have the flower bee conversation

→ More replies (21)

2

u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan May 04 '25

This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.

40

u/evenstar40 May 01 '25

Can we please ban the obviously bought upvotes OF ads? Like, most other subs have basic standards for this shit. I really don't want to see /r/anime turn into another shitty karma farming ad/bots subreddit. Low effort shit like this just scares away legit people wanting to discuss anime and devalues the overall community.

16

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod May 01 '25

the obviously bought upvotes

We recently asked the admins about whether any of the recent cosplay posts on our sub bought upvotes. But, honestly, I doubt that they did. All sorts of horny stuff gets way too many upvotes on /r/anime. I cataloged it somewhat here.

→ More replies (15)

7

u/Castor_0il Apr 12 '25

Can some mod make autolovepon create the discussion thread for Bloody Escape movie? It just got released on Crunchyroll and it's part of the universe of Estab-Life: Great Escape series

7

u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Apr 18 '25

Are we getting a thread for the aot final season final movie last attack?

7

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Apr 18 '25 edited Apr 18 '25

No, from the information online this should just be a rehash of the tv anime's final episodes, with some minor extra scenes. Hence, as per usual, this will not get an episode thread from Lovepon.

You (or any user) are however free to post a thread discussing any changes/post a rule-abiding clip from the movie (except the 7 day rule doesn't count, because no ep thread) to discuss it now.

7

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal May 02 '25

Minor thing just to keep making this thread longer instead of waiting until the new one's posted tomorrow: the events wiki page should be updated with the 11m scavenger hunt results link.

...and I stand by the bottom part of the page from before the revamp being unnecessary to keep around, especially with the "Upcoming Film Releases" section having dates from nearly five years ago now.

9

u/chilidirigible May 02 '25

the 11m scavenger hunt results link.

That was 2.3 million bots ago!

4

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 May 03 '25

Updated and cleaned up the sheet.

33

u/FrankyPropaganda Apr 30 '25

We shouldn’t ban cosplay posts in general, but cosplays that are obvious OF bait need to be banned. The rule can be amateur cosplay only, and people who have OF/patreon accounts are banned from posting

→ More replies (2)

44

u/Throw__Package555 Apr 29 '25

Why do yall keep the cosplay posts which are obviously promotional?? And all the comments which talk about it get deleted

→ More replies (22)

18

u/Verzwei Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25

Sorry to harp on cosplay, I know that's been one of the two big topics this month, but I'm gonna copy some select rules from the rules page:

Cosplay

  • All Cosplay posts must use the [Cosplay] flair and otherwise follow the OC or non-OC fanart rules as appropriate.

Fanart

Fanart broadly refers to creative, anime-related artistic work, and you may submit one Fanart every 7 days. All Fanart works must include an element from an anime (such as a character or an object): "anime-inspired" content (such as landscapes or original characters) is not allowed. Fanart depictions of surprise characters or events from source material that have not yet appeared in the anime adaptation are considered spoilers and not allowed to be posted.

OC Fanart

  • Must be final and of good quality. Work-In-Progress, including foreign objects in the frame, poor lighting, incorrect orientation or similar content is not allowed. Please respect your art.

No Memes, Image Macros...


The post I'm complaining about.

  1. "Truck-kun" is a meme.
  2. To the best of my knowledge, there is no truck "character" in any anime that has a Fuso head, human body, and carries around a bloody baseball bat. This would make this cosplay "anime-inspired" and not an element from an anime.
  3. If this character is a representation of a specific character from an specific anime, OP didn't cite it.
  4. If the only connection being made to "anime" (in the general sense, since OP isn't specifying a particular series) is the truck helmet and the rest is a gag, then I'd say that this is a joke post, or a helmet post, not a "cosplay" post. I wouldn't even consider a cardboard foam truck helmet with the word "isekai" on it to qualify as fanart within this subreddit's rules.

While certain controversial cosplay posts might technically be within the rules as written, I fail to see how an anime-inspired non-specific helmet gag meets the above-quoted criteria for a cosplay post. It's funny, sure, I chuckled at it, but also seems outside the scope of the rules as written, and seems like the sort of "low effort" stuff this subreddit normally wouldn't permit, and it's the top post on the sub right now.

If cosplay only has to follow the OC Fanart subsection and not the main Fanart header, meaning that cosplay doesn't have to be from an anime, and the OP doesn't need to put that anime's title in the title of their post, then that seems like a rule loophole that should be closed.

Edit: If someone were to throw on a straw hat with regular everyday clothes and say it was anime cosplay, would it be allowed as a cosplay post?

11

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 26 '25

Yeah, I think people gave it a pass because

  1. "That's funny!"
  2. "They're not just trying to promote XYZ!"

But (unless I missed it) I do not think the thing he's cosplaying has ever been in any anime;

I DO believe that if someone actually cosplayed 'Truck-kun' (as in, an actual truck) that would count as a cosplay even if it's not listed on MAL, because no one says characters have to be important... But that's not really a character, it's a reference to a character, and imagery (the bat) hinting that it kills people.

The nuance is see between these is like: You could cosplay 'A chibi character' (that's a cosplay), but you can't just crouch and act cutesy to say "I'm chibi, therefore I'm a cosplay".

5

u/chilidirigible Apr 26 '25

Edit: If someone were to throw on a straw hat with regular everyday clothes and say it was anime cosplay, would it be allowed as a cosplay post?

I'm obliged to note Box Gundam here too.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh May 01 '25

I've mentioned this buried in some comments, but might as well just make a top level post so we can direct things here rather than buried deep down some random chain.

At present there's an ongoing discussion about various flavours of content that are posted as not-so-subtle advertising. This ranges from:

  • Fanart that are selling physical goods or art commissions.
  • Cosplay and video posts that are advertising subscription services.
  • Videos and video edits that aren't directly selling, but benefit from advertisement.

There's a bunch of nuance through these and they aren't really equal, but they also often bleed into each other in various ways.

Within the discussion there's been talk of returning to the old 10:1 self promotion rule (10 non-promoting posts/comments per 1 promoting post/comment), as well as a softer self promotion ratio like 1:1. There's also been talk of not using a ratio, but instead going for something that's more of a "you know it when you see it" and evaluating things case-by-case where if the mods view an account as being near-singularly focused on advertising then we reserve the right to issue a ban. Main reason to consider not doing a firm ratio is just that it's either easy to game, or a huge pain unless you're an active commenter.

There's been plenty of talk about the specifics, and my plan is to call for the vote this weekend, barring any sudden changes. From there we have a week before the vote is settled, and next weekend we'll have a final word on the matter. Any thoughts or considerations feel free to let me know.

19

u/Verzwei May 02 '25

but instead going for something that's more of a "you know it when you see it" and evaluating things case-by-case where if the mods view an account as being near-singularly focused on advertising then we reserve the right to issue a ban.

Talked about it a bit through other channels but I think the "solution" that I'm the biggest fan of is amending the bot/novelty account section of the rules to accommodate this "you know it when you see it" approach.

I'm going to quote the relevant section of the rules, buckle up because it's very lengthy:

Bots/Novelty Accounts

We do not allow

...Okay so maybe not that lengthy. Anyway, there's some more text which applies specifically to bots but it appears the wording for "Novelty Accounts" was lost over time. My interpretation of that rule was to prohibit non-bot, human-operated accounts that were used for a singular purpose other than open communication within the community. This would include stuff like joke or roleplay accounts, or some dude who only ever replies "that's hot" without any further commentary, things that aren't necessarily harmful within a vacuum but can be disruptive to or don't foster natural discussion.

With that in mind, I propose fleshing out "Novelty Accounts" (y'all really should have some kind of description for it in the rules) and then also adding "Advertising Accounts" to that section of the rules.

When you look at someone's profile, is nearly all of their content self-promotion across this and/or other subreddits? Then that account isn't allowed here, it's a "novelty" account for the purpose of "advertising" a good or service.

Do they have a store/service link in their profile but also happen to have what appears to be ongoing good-faith engagement with the community, including a chunk of commentary outside of their own threads? Then that account would be allowed.

The reason I like this is because it doesn't single out and punish any one particular type of content. It isn't unduly focused on Only Fans like much of the commentary in this Meta thread has been. It isn't even specific to cosplay and can be applied uniformly across promotional fanart and youtube posts. Is someone only swinging by to post their printed hat fanart, when they also happen to sell printed hats, and otherwise doesn't engage with the community? Gone. Is someone only ever posting their own shit take youtube links in the comments of episode discussion threads rather than discussing the episode with the community? Yeeted.

But if anyone does those things while also clearly participating within the community then they'd be safe. Sort-of a "If you wanna shill to us, you at least have to be one of us" mentality, I guess?

It's "you know it when you see it" but with extra rambling, and utilizing the Novelty Account rules gives it a place within the existing rule page and structure instead of being a completely new and foreign entry on the restricted/prohibited content sections.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/cppn02 May 01 '25

If you wanna get ontop of these kinda posts the second method seems to be the only way to go. Because how could a ratio ever catch people who don't actively advertise in the sub but via their profile.

Ideally I would have the mods do nothing but as a regular user it is clear that these kinda posts (especially cosplay) are currently gaining momentum here and sadly are only gonna get more if not stopped.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Etheo May 01 '25

Glad your team have a plan in mind. Seeing critiques just being removed from the threads definitely upset the community, and it's super easy for upset people to turn on mods when communication isn't clear.

It's not an easy job, so kudos for doing that. I'm not happy about the situation, but I'm at least happy that the mods are doing something about it. Looking forward to a positive change.

Personally I'm in the "you know it when you see it" camp. Sometimes, you just gotta be the bad guy and take some hit on likeability.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Komarist https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST May 01 '25

If it's between those options, I'd rather have rules say "you know it when you see it" while mostly enforcing it through the 10:1 ratio. Allows for exceptions when strongly suspecting someone is gaming it.

9

u/Puddo x3https://anilist.co/user/STPuddo May 01 '25

What actually changed? Because lots of people already have a ‘solution’, but I always feel like that’s the wrong order of doing things. Before we jump to a solution we first have to look at why we're in this situation. Is it even a problem that requires action? Is it a situation that we expect to get worse if we don't do something? Because people could already post cosplay and it wasn’t an issue until a few days ago. So why are we here now?

Is it a delayed effect of removing the ‘text post’ rule for fanart/cosplay? We’ve seen in the past that easy to consume content did pretty well with fanart and clips dominating the front page. Which is why we even got to the text post rule for fanart. But removing the text post rule didn’t suddenly make fanart return en masse I feel. Though, cosplay is at the moment also ‘only’ one or two post a day or so. But anyway, maybe there has been something else the past weeks? Another rule change? Is there something odd going on with their scores that push them to the top while otherwise the up/downvote system would’ve taken care of it? Is it something we also see on other subs (like Twitter had a huge pornbot followers issue)? Is it because other subs banned them and they’re moving to other subs like this one? Etc.

Finally I would advise against adding lots of exceptions on exceptions and subjectivity to the rules (and with that I’m not only talking about the cosplay situation). Fine, you'll always have subjectivity and grey areas. It’s foolish to think that you can make rules or laws that cover a big topic without any room for interpretation. But take ‘it can’t be self promotion’. Okay. Does that mean no one can post a fanart drawing because they also have a shop somewhere? Does that mean no one can post their own blog/video here? Isn’t just posting your own stuff always a bit self promotional? Is it a problem that people are basically reposting old stuff from other subs? Do mods need to check the post history to see if they actually engage with the community? What is enough engagement? When you get a vague line you’re going to get even more discussion and frustration about what is and what isn’t allowed. And you’re also going to get mods interpreting it in different ways and I fear that’s going to lead to extra frustration. Prepare for the ‘why is my post removed while that one isn’t’. The same with things as 'low effort'. Also exceptions lead to more complicated rules and thus be more time consuming for mods and be more frustrating for posters because it’s not clear what the rules are.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/jnads May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25

Would just marking all Cosplay tagged posts as NSFW fix it since they would be ineligible for r/all?

It seems the people are posting here because it's an easy way to skyrocket it onto all.

Other creators are taking notice and the problem is accelerating.

Now 4 of the top 8 6 posts from the past week are OF content creators (as sorted by Top > This Week).

I get you can't target specific people, and rules are difficult since some of the creators hide their OF links behind redgif posts.

Seems like the two simplest fixes are either go back to text Cosplay posts OR mark all Cosplay posts NSFW no matter the content.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius May 01 '25

Within the discussion there's been talk of returning to the old 10:1 self promotion rule (10 non-promoting posts/comments per 1 promoting post/comment), as well as a softer self promotion ratio like 1:1. There's also been talk of not using a ratio, but instead going for something that's more of a "you know it when you see it" and evaluating things case-by-case where if the mods view an account as being near-singularly focused on advertising then we reserve the right to issue a ban. Main reason to consider not doing a firm ratio is just that it's either easy to game, or a huge pain unless you're an active commenter.

I like the case-by-case idea, 10:1 would probably kill all cosplays/fanart/videos and 1:1 is too lenient (nothing stopping the "offenders" in question from making a low-effort post for every self-promotion post).

I'd also like to suggest a ban on photoshopped cosplays/images - the problematic posts that caused this discussion are almost always so heavily photoshopped you'd be justified to ban them through the "No AI" clause.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

63

u/BasedLelouch_ Apr 30 '25 edited Apr 30 '25

Stop allowing only fans bait “cosplay”

So fucking sick of it. I’m sure the mods won’t disallow it though, because that would increase the quality of the sub. They’re so defensive about it too. Idk if they’re being paid in money or titty pictures but clearly they all banded together to continue allowing this garbage.

40

u/ryanlak1234 Apr 30 '25 edited Apr 30 '25

What’s more is that these OF girls aren’t cosplaying out of genuine passion for cosplay (or even like anime very much, for that matter) but rather posting it as a shady underhanded hustling tactic to get horny gooners to come to their profile and have them subscribe.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/susgnome https://anime-planet.com/users/RoyalRampage Apr 20 '25

Welp, since this comment was removed for I guess, the off-hand remark I made at the end of it against the sub.

So I'll make an actual point about the rule then instead of some off-hand comment.


All Cosplay posts must use the [Cosplay] flair and otherwise follow the OC or non-OC fanart rules as appropriate.

I don't like that the current ruling on "Cosplay" posts, say it's to be treated like Fan Art but it's not taken as seriously in comparison.

OC fanart refers to content that you have drawn, built or otherwise created yourself.

For posts saying "This is something I've made". There's a lot of majority store-bought. Most cosplay competitions, you have to have made minimum 80% of the costume to participate (and there are still people that lie about that).

Must be final and of good quality. Work-In-Progress, including foreign objects in the frame, poor lighting, incorrect orientation or similar content is not allowed. Please respect your art.

Take the one from the current front page: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1k2zvwz/a2_cosplay_jezlene_rae_nier_automata/

It's not a "final" nor is it of "good quality". It's clearly a "Work-In-Progress" with "poor lighting" and "incorrect orientation" that has no "respect for the art".


4

u/Dentorion Apr 21 '25

Well the onlyfans debate is rising again with the last post and it's hilarious how many comments get removed for pointing out what you say and are not satisfied that low quality onlyfans promotion posts with cosplays from Temu gets so many upvotes to the frontpage

Especially with how the whole up and downvoting works and some clearly visible ai accounts posting from minute old accounts Found in the last thread at least two of them

→ More replies (1)

6

u/AashyLarry Apr 08 '25

Any idea why the AutoMod is so inconsistent at listing where to stream in the Episode Discussion?

It’d be a really useful feature if it worked every time.

For example:

  • Orb was listed as ‘Streams: None’ even though it’s on Netflix
  • Country Bumpkin has ‘Streams: None’ even though it’s on Amazon (this one is actually what made me want to ask here, cause I would have never guessed Amazon).

In fact, if you search ‘Episode Discussion’ and sort by New, you can see nearly every Episode Discussion that has released in the past few days has “Streams: None” on it.

I hope you guys can find a way to fix this since it’s such a useful feature (especially in the beginning of a season when all the shows are first releasing everywhere).

10

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Apr 08 '25

Old Country Bumpkin lacking a stream listing is due to it being the start of a new season. It usually takes a few weeks to get everything fully added to the bot, and previous threads will be updated with that info the next time a thread for that show is posted once it is fully loaded.

In Orb's case, that was just a mistake that Netflix was somehow missed for the entire season.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/chilidirigible Apr 28 '25

/u/ZaphodBeebblebrox another note that I was looking at CDF through old.reddit.com on my phone and wanted to quickly flip over to the Meta Thread, so I used the link in the sidebar of the desktop-emulated simulacrum and it sent me to the Meta Thread but in the Reddit app.

I suspect because the Meta Thread link in the sidebar is represented by https://redd.it/1jshay8 and thus is a www.reddit.com link when expanded.

5

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Apr 28 '25

That's updated by a script, shouldn't be too hard to fix on old reddit but I'll leave it as an exercise for the current mods to figure it out.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/Brilliant-Aide-3759 May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25

Cosplay by OF accounts really should be banned, it's starting to just become a non nude porn subreddit at this rate. If you sort by top of this week 4 of top 5 is that

→ More replies (31)

20

u/chronokingx May 02 '25

theres a subreddit for cosplays. I have a problem with cosplays and fanarts being displayed on a Subreddit that people would go to for official anime discussions or news. I'm not saying i dislike fan creations as a whole, but there are already established and popular Subreddits for this content.

34

u/Etheo May 01 '25

I'm tired of the cosplay posts boss. It's so obvious what they're doing but because they're skirting within the rules moderation team is just letting it be. I get upholding rules for rules sake but the sea of removed comments especially about the state of cosplay posts tells the story. Removing thirst comments is good but also removing the criticisms and redirecting to here where nothing seems to get done regardless, I don't understand.

From a certain standpoint I get the difficulty in managing the situation without a blanket ban. But when it's so painfully obvious and the sub is still upvoting the post enmass but dissing it in the comments it really sets tone on the duality of this sub. Not an easy fix but I hope mods have something in the works.

→ More replies (12)

17

u/Verzwei Apr 06 '25

Likewise, if a non-Japanese studio outsources animation work to a Japanese studio, we do not consider this to be anime if the primary non-Japanese studio maintains overall creative control of the work.

This sounds like needless (or maybe just needlessly wordy) complication.

Is LOTR: War of Rohirrim anime, or not? Why or why not?

Is Scott Pilgrim Takes Off anime, or not? Why or why not?

I guess the question I'm getting at here is how do you define creative control?

19

u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Apr 06 '25

Not a mod, but pretty sure this section is specifically there to avoid things like an episode of SpongeBob that was outsourced to a Japanese studio getting in here on that technicality.

Is LOTR: War of Rohirrim anime, or not? Why or why not?

Yes. Even though the executive control and high-level management was western, and the screenplay was written by westerners, the director (Kamiyama) is an industry veteran, it looks like he did have significant ability to talk with the upper production management and shape the film (not just handed a script and ordered to deliver it without changes), most/all of the animators were folks within the industry, etc. It's weird how there's not really a primary animation studio, just a production management company (Sola) contracting a ton of freelancers and secondary work, but even so that production management company is a pre-existing anime industry company with a headquarters in Japan so it still checks out.

This is a good corollary to the Transformers example on the rules page, which is likewise a western-lead project with a western IP and writing that "outsourced" the animation part to Japan, but WotR has actual back and forth involvement in the planning and boarding from it's anime-industry-director and fully controls the animation production within Japan, while Transformers did not.

Is Scott Pilgrim Takes Off anime, or not? Why or why not?

Definitely. Regardless of the IP, basically everyone who worked on it are established anime industry folk, and they produced it at a Japanese animation studio.

15

u/Verzwei Apr 06 '25

What you've said makes sense and I agree with your conclusions. And those conclusions for LOTR and SPTO are consistent with the old version of the rules.

I just think this is a bad rewrite and the previous rule was simpler and more straightforward to interpret. Years ago, the rules were written that anime had to be produced in Japan. With the rise of international co-productions, the word "produced" became a problem. Did it mean the funding? That cuts out a whole lot of shows. Did it mean the animation? Makes logical sense, but when "produced" is a particular film/TV term, it gets muddy. Years before that, the rules also included that anime had to be primarily for a Japanese audience, which caused the shelter incident.

The rules 10 days ago were simple. "Was it animated by a Japanese animation studio, or an indie work that received recognition by the industry? Then it's anime." Sure that may have let some weird edge cases in, but that seemed a risk worth taking in the name of streamlined, simple rules.

This new rewrite is trying too hard to throw words at every situation, resulting in rules that are ironically more difficult to figure out. Intended audience is back in there. This "creative control" thing is nebulous and will be hard to pin down, especially with new announcements when details are scarce. There will be situations where a new project will be deemed anime only for it to turn out to be outsourced without "creative control" and situations where a new project will be deemed not anime but later details make it look like it does fit.

I simply do not see the value in complicating the rules like this.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Arachnophobic- https://anilist.co/user/Arachnophobic Apr 15 '25

The GQuuuuuuX discussion threads say there are no streams, but it can be streamed on Prime Video.

12

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Apr 15 '25

It should be added soon, it usually just takes a bit at the start of a new season to get all the streams added to the bot.

5

u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Apr 21 '25

Is the new daily thread bugged or is that a star wars bit?

7

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 21 '25

This is called Zaph forgetting that he has to update daily this week.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cppn02 Apr 22 '25

Where daily thread?

5

u/baseballlover723 Apr 22 '25

I approved it. It seems that not even /u/AnimeMod is immune from the spoiler rules.

4

u/ComfortablyRotten https://anilist.co/user/Leuwtian Apr 22 '25

5

u/Castor_0il Apr 22 '25

My Hero Aca movie: You're Next, came out on Crunchyroll a couple of days ago.

Can someone update Lovepon to create the discussion thread?

4

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 22 '25

5

u/chilidirigible Apr 26 '25

Out of curiosity, is there any idea of how many people return to their removed comments to add [spoiler]censoring blocks versus leaving them removed?

Out of morbid curiosity, how many people fight you first and then edit the blocks back in?

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Verzwei Apr 07 '25 edited Apr 07 '25

Uhhhh how is video game developer designer says on Twitter that he's watching an anime relevant to the sub and within the rules against low effort content?

It's the top post of the sub and has been up for 9 hours so I have to assume someone on the team has seen it by now.

Really don't want to see this community become a place to dump social media posts (especially that fucking site) from people who literally have nothing to do with anime aside from saying they're watching it. And in the past that was extremely clearly against the rules.

13

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Apr 07 '25

We were actually talking about it right before you commented, so I guess we were on the same wavelength for a sec.

Anyway, yeah, we agree that "celebrity watches anime" is a bit outside the scope of our sub, so it's been pulled.

7

u/Time_Fracture https://myanimelist.net/profile/Time_Fracture Apr 07 '25

I recall this was also the case with Shuumatsu Train last year (since he also watched that one as well), except that tweet was only brought up within the discussion thread and AQRADT.

So keeping it in the discussion thread/AQRADT perhaps is the most feasible way.

9

u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 07 '25

Now that the first seasons of Blue Box and Sakamoto Days have ended, I was wondering if the mod team has any good data/insight on if the cross-posted episode threads have affected the engagement in any meaningful way.

In addition, will this stay a temporary measure or become permanent policy?

Wanted to get this question out there before I forget about it again.

16

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 07 '25 edited Apr 07 '25

The short summary is that the crossposts clearly had a positive effect, but that effect was not as good as we had hoped.

The initial place we obtained data from was the single Noko-tan thread that was crossposted. There, when compared to another thread from the same week that got a similar overall number of comments, Wistoria, we see a clear double peak (y axis is comments/hour; I just realized the graph is unmarked). The second peak was just as, if not larger than, the first, which is exactly what we hoped we would get with the Blue Box and Sakamoto Days crossposts.

If we now look at the present, in the last two episodes of Blue Box, we still have a double peak, but it is significantly less pronounced. There's clearly a primary peak at the start and a secondary peak when the crosspost happens. This means two things: the crosspost is better than only the initial thread, but we are losing some people who likely otherwise would have commented on it if the thread had only gone up at the later time. Of course, some of this might be people transitioning to watching it earlier, but there is no chance that that accounts for all of it.


So, what does all of this mean? To start off, the situation just sucks all around. A delayed release like this, where large portions of our community will watch the show days apart, inherently will lead to less engagement and results that are not ideal and less equitable than desired. Every possibility has significant downsides.

Currently, we think we will hope that this does not happen again, but likely will crosspost again if it does. Crossposting helps at least somewhat, so we never have a reason to return to just posting the thread for the first release and doing nothing for the second. There is at least some interest in trying one show as double posts (one thread at our normal time, and one at official time) and seeing how that goes.

However, double posts need the right scenario, and they're a maybe even then. We'd certainly never do them on something with a 7 day gap, as that would cause people to wander into the wrong thread accidentally. And all members of the mod team who were around for the Higurashi Gou split threads appear to still be traumatized by it. I suppose the short version here is our desire to test is fighting with our desire to not rock the boat and cause any more problems for episode discussion threads. People care a lot about them. And, despite what it may seem like at times, we also care a lot about them and genuinely want to have them be as good of an experience as possible.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Apr 06 '25

Hi, thanks for asking this. We're still compiling the data for them, which means it might take a bit of time for us to organize it all. I apologize for the wait and we'll get back to you on this ASAP.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Apr 20 '25

I haven’t really seen anyone speak up about this, but I’ve noticed over the last year or so that there’s been some karma manipulation happening in popular and/or discussion threads.

From my impression, someone is downvoting other people’s comments en masse to either promote theirs or negate others’ from rising up.

How did I become aware of this? Because I usually try to break the deadlock of 1-point karma points in the early hours of these threads by often upvoting (most) comments, and will then suddenly see lots of users drop back to 1 point.

I’m frequently getting hit with this myself as well. Probably on the majority of my comments - even if there’s nothing controversial of sorts. Someone might just hold a grudge against me personally, but I’ve seen this systemically happen with other users as well.

What’s the problem of this? People’s comments are purposefully made to plummet in the sorting algorithm. This system seemingly doesn’t only work by the karma total but also the upvote percentage to some degree. In other words, someone’s effectively censoring others’ comments by making them less visible.

I unfortunately doubt that something can be undertaken against this, but I merely wanted to bring it to the attention and hear other people’s experiences. It’s a sort of toxicity that I’m not too happy with.

9

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 20 '25

It's been like that for so long, and I think part of it is people who want to boost their comment to the top, but I think it's also more present in 'anime you're not supposed to like', comments seem to be downvoted more there. (stuff with bad animation, or controversial, etc..)

I unfortunately doubt that something can be undertaken against this, but I merely wanted to bring it to the attention and hear other people’s experiences. It’s a sort of toxicity that I’m not too happy with.

Not much to say other than "It's happening and it sucks but there's not much one can do about it".

(In my opinion the upvote system is shit in general, that's just one of the reasons why).

→ More replies (1)

8

u/cppn02 Apr 20 '25

This has been going on more or less for years and I think there are various plausible explanations for this phenomenon.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Hitman7128 https://anilist.co/user/Hitman7128 Apr 20 '25

I don't know about you, but I see it most frequently in discussion threads for anime that are either CGDCT or yuri (or both).

It's super obvious when you see 0 points on every comment made in the last 10-15 minutes. I usually don't worry too much about it because the 1 or 2 frivolous downvotes tends not to matter much in the face of a dozen or more upvotes, so it's more like "What are they even doing with their lives..."

→ More replies (3)

7

u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine Apr 21 '25

I've seen that too. I usually get downvoted once every now and then, usually in the daily thread, regardless of how hot or mild my takes are. Occasionally if I'm early to some other thread, I do see multiple people with 0 karma on their comments, no matter what they've posted as well.

I suppose it is possible that someone has a grudge against me for one reason or another too, but I dunno. I just tend to shrug and move on.

8

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 20 '25

While this is obviously bad behavior, I'm afraid that there isn't anything we can do about it. We cannot see who is upvoting or downvoting posts (and it's honestly good that we cannot). I don't even think we can report it to reddit, as their definition of vote manipulation appears to require either coordination, sockpuppets, or solicitation of votes, while this seems to just be one person (or a few people) downvoting independently.

I suppose we could set episode discussion threads to sort by new or random at for the first hour to remove the incentives for downvoting, but that seems rather excessive, and likely would cause more problems than it would solve.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Nebresto Apr 21 '25

I unfortunately doubt that something can be undertaken against this,

Sorting threads by new/random, but for whatever reason there's never any support for it

→ More replies (4)

38

u/A_Erthur Apr 29 '25

FUCK THOSE GOONER COSPLAY POSTS

26

u/Extension-Ad-9371 May 01 '25

25% of the top 2 dozen post this past month are NSFW “cosplayers” like wtf

→ More replies (3)

8

u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine Apr 22 '25

I think you guys should add a Dragon Ball commentface or two. I don't have any personal attachment to the series, I just looked at the list of source shows a few days ago, started thinking about it and found it kinda funny that it has zero representation there despite it being the most famous battle shounen show, and probably the most famous anime, of all time.

The people yearn to be able to post the Yamcha pose as a commentface!

6

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Apr 23 '25

I agree with the idea, but if we're going with Yamcha, we might as well use Toriyama's drawing

The monochrome colours add more to the feeling of defeat, and it wouldn't be our first manga commentface

4

u/ussgordoncaptain2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Edmund_Nelson Apr 13 '25

Kakushite! Makina-san!! is being streamed in this extremely niche site oceanveil (NSFW) the site does host actual pornography though so I can understand if you don't want it to be put in the streams bar

4

u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Apr 20 '25

Are we getting a thread for the final episode of Duel Masters Lost: Tsuioku no Suishou since a proper fansub of it was recently released?

4

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Apr 20 '25

Hi there, the threads have been created, with links as below (they have been created for all the episodes, since none were created to begin with). If we do not create an episode timely after a fansub for the sequel (Duel Masters LOST: Gekka no Shinigami) is released, please let us know similarly/send us a modmail. Thank you!

EpisodeLink
1Link
2Link
3Link
4Link

4

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Apr 22 '25 edited Apr 22 '25

I didn't realise that we used to have so many cosplay posts 2+ years ago at about 4 per month, when since then it's been just about one cosplay every 2 months. Had there been some cosplay-related rule changes around that time or did cosplay posts just die on their own?

10

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 22 '25

I believe the most significant factor was not a direct change to our cosplay rules, but the requirement for posters to have 10 sub comment karma for most types of posts that was introduced in early 2023. Before this, the majority of cosplay posts appear to have been drive-by.

For a concrete example, in 2022 we had a total of 123 cosplay posts. Only 43 of the posters had any comments on /r/anime whatsoever outside of their own posts, only 31 had at least five comments outside of their own posts, and only 23 had at least 10.


If you're asking about the drop between 2023 and 2024, there we actually went from 35 to 16. It looks more drastic than it is if you just search the sub because several people who posted cosplay in 2024 deleted their posts. The only rules changes that affected cosplay during that time made posting cosplay easier (by allowing link posts again), so I don't have a real explanation for that. Though I will say that these numbers are a very small sample size, so a lot of it could just be noise.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ARES_GOD https://anilist.co/user/ARESxGOD Apr 23 '25

I am really curious why this was removed on the basis that it is a spoiler ?
Because its on topic of the thread and doesnt give details or says what happened, just answering the question of the thread without going into specifics.

https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1k3rqx2/comment/moa5mcj/?context=3

5

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 23 '25

[Naruto Shippuden]There is a massive stretch of episodes in the show where the viewer believes that Madara was killed by Hashirama, and that's how his story ends. This not being true is a large reveal.

I mean there are much worse/bigger things in that thread

I took a look at the thread and hit a decent amount of other comments for spoilers (as well as asking other mods about some shows I don't know about). So you're certainly correct that that thread could have been better modded than it was.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

17

u/P_S_Lumapac Apr 21 '25 edited Apr 21 '25

Got my comment removed for pointing out porn business advertisements, then directed here to raise the complaint.

I don't really know why mods here are spending time without being paid running defense for these spammers. Spamming is against the reddit site wide rules. Is it about enjoying the numbers going up on the sub membership and views? But it's an anime sub... sure the numbers will go up if it becomes a porn sub, but then those numbers won't mean anything.

Rule 2 of reddit has this part about authenticity: ... Post authentic content into communities where you have a personal interest ... and the claim here is accounts that are made just to advertise a product do not have an authentic interest. If their fanart account only posts across reddit about their fence painting services, that's also spam.

5

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 23 '25

I get that people hate "OF posts", but we had like 2 of those in a week... I'm not sure that qualify as 'spam'.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Puddo x3https://anilist.co/user/STPuddo Apr 29 '25

Since there hasn’t been said enough about cosplay stuff yet:

Do I like it? No. But I also don't like the classic horny clips that have always done well around here. Do I wish other content like industry deep dives, interviews with staff members and writing, besides the occasional SakugabooruBlog or some clickbait Animehunch article, would do better around here? Yes. But they don’t. And they probably never will. But, it's what it's. The power of the up/downvote button.

However we currently have the 7 day rule. I feel like that’s quite short to begin with, but eh that’s also not that big of a deal. However I looked at the post history of the most recent poster because I was curious if they just spam across multiple subs and I see that they posted 4 times or something on this sub after their first post 5 days ago. So they should know the rules by now since you keep deleting them with also a comment about the 7 day rule. So how many strikes does it take for someone like that to get banned?

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Psclly May 01 '25

I completely understand the rationality mods are trying to show when it comes to moderating the sub, but the idea of common sense should still be a strong factor when making decisions.

I've seen other modding teams for different types of communities follow this discussion cycle and while I obviously respect rationality and such (keeps the drama out), sometimes it can really hurt the quality of the community because no action can be taken due to the requirement of such formal discussions.

I remember in a speedrunning community someone was caught obviously cheating, then the moderation team said "yeah but we have no rule in place for this". In the end no one was punished, and the rule against the cheats had to be added later along the line after lengthy discussions, but it left an extremely sour taste in the community.

If someone is clearly abusing loopholes, workarounds or running around the rulebooks for obviously unethical profit, I think it's clear grounds to just get rid of them immediately.

Whenever I see a cosplay on here it's VERY easy to figure out whether it's a thinly veiled OnlyFans ad. You take one look at the cosplay itself and you just know. On the other hand, you can easily see when something ISN'T an ad.

And if you want confirmation? Just go to the profile. If the profile is linking to OnlyFans, then the profile solely exists to promote that. No one would put links like that in their profile if they weren't hoping for people to find it, and posting horny bait (which is practically a minor form of psychological manipulation) is just the right method for that.

My opinion is simple, lets stop beating around the bush and just get rid of it. Make a rule against obvious porn advertisements. The community sees it, the mods see it, why are these people still around?

14

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke May 01 '25

It's mostly because the mods have a more or less decentralized power structure, so decisions just take time. You've probably seen communities where some mods go rogue and took actions that the community hated because it was obvious to them.

I appreciate the modding team here following strictly to the rules that are set up, and later amend the rules to adapt to the new situations. While it's slower due to having to debate and formalize rules and vote (across time zones, probably), it means that we don't have to worry about the whims of any one mod banning content that they personally don't like.

→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (7)

20

u/TacticalBattleCat https://myanimelist.net/profile/serialsaboteur Apr 06 '25

Can the community and mod team weigh in on this?

Lately, I’ve noticed a rise in cosplay posts that feel less like authentic cosplay and more like stealth advertisements for OnlyFans accounts.

These posts often follow a pattern: pick a popular character with a simple outfit, tweak it to be overtly sexual, pose with a suggestive expression, and include a weak justification for the sexualization of the cosplay like “oh my pants are unbuttoned because I'm showing off the character's tattoo.”

A quick look at the poster’s profile usually reveals links to their OF and the same image spammed across other sub-reddits/platforms. I’m not against spicy cosplay or creators promoting their work in the right space, but r/anime has always felt like a place for discussion, memes and other fun shenanigans... not for promoting adult content.

To preserve the spirit of this sub, I’d like to propose a simple guideline: accounts that contain OF links & other explicit content should not be allowed to post cosplay content here. There are other communities for that kind of promotion, and this would help keep r/anime focused on what we’re all here for—anime.

17

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 06 '25

Speaking personally, (and thus not distinguishing my comment) I don't think cosplay posts are particularly different from fanart posts in general. They both get the same sort of posts that you described as stealth advertisements. The pattern is simple enough: choose something popular and/or sexy, post the work to /r/anime and a bunch of other subs, and have links to where others can support you in your shreddit bio. Arguably, I'd say the non-cosplayers in this category are more blatant than the cosplayers; the cosplayers never mention anything explicitly, while the others will mention that they do commissions in the comments.

As such, I see little reason to impose restrictions on cosplayers without imposing similar restrictions on other posters. To me, an artist selling NSFW commissions isn't any less adult content or promotion than someone with an OnlyFans.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/baseballlover723 Apr 06 '25

No modhat for this comment.

I'll keep it simple. I don't like accounts who's sole or almost sole purpose is commercial in nature. They are not people trying to be a part of the community proper. They are people who see $$$ and wish to extract some of those. Sometimes, it can be beneficial, where their commercial nature is overshadowed by the diversity and the content they provide. Other times, it's clear that they're optimizing for effort per $. The later are detrimental to the community and the former can help it grow.

If I had a magic wand to automagically classify things, I would weigh, how much effort they put into the Cosplay (or Fanart more generally), how active they were in r/anime or other anime adjacent subreddits (or how much they've demonstrated knowledge of the underlying content, basically how much of a fan they actually are for what they're representing), what their self promo ratio is, how strongly are they pushing people into the purchase funnel. Sadly, such a thing done manually doesn't seem feasible and would also be susceptible to inconsistency due to us mods being made of meat. But that's the major factors that I think should ideally be in an equation.

From talking about this with the mods since I've joined, I'm reminded of the starving artist and articles like this one. This sort of mentality I find is quite embedded in society, where people want to appreciate the art, but not enough to actually support them to do it for a living (which is obviously not sustainable for the artist). Is commercialization now so easy to setup that anyone who doing anything of note will setup one up and make some money off of it? I'm not 100% sure we're quite there, but it's easier now then ever to setup up some kind of monetization strategy (even if it doesn't actually involve money at the current step). But the point is, that commercialization is now linked more then ever and perhaps it's time to rethink if the juice is worth the squeeze.

I'm personally not opposed to using a user's post history to determine if they likely only have a commercial interest in r/anime, but I do recognize that that's a pretty slippery slope to judge people on r/anime based on things that aren't in r/anime. And this is something that I think is extremely easy to see on some cases, where very similar posts are blasted to any relevant subreddit. It's a stark difference compared to something that is a labor of love and isn't their primary purpose.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Apr 06 '25

and this would help keep r/anime focused on what we’re all here for—animelow effort suggestion posts that make /new useless

fixed that for you

14

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Apr 06 '25

So in the past month we have had four cosplay posts (that were not removed). So to collate them for historic discussion purposes:

The community distaste and vocalization of OnlyFans has been very loud on a couple of these posts.

From our rules perspective; we remove posts/comments that directly advertise on r/anime as part of our "Do not sell things" rule. And we would remove posts if the stepped over the line into being explicit.

A quick look at the poster’s profile...

This is where r/anime ends, we don't police the content there. And if it is NSFW enough, that profile should be marked by the user or reddit as such. Anyhow Reddit has been turning profiles into their own hub of things and they do now have a section for links where you can advertise yourself.

So going back to the r/anime thread itself, the stream of comments all pointing out that OP has an OnlyFans and everyone should be outraged is more than anything, the most advertising part of these posts. As such we are in discussion if we should consider this kind of comments to be off-topic and remove them. As it so far seems to be fanning the flames.

I’d like to propose a simple guideline: accounts that contain OF links & other explicit content should not be allowed to post cosplay content here.

This is an interesting but it is kind of counter to the way we moderate. Outside of toxicity/bigotry/racism/etc, which may examine a users wider reddit history to inform decisions about ones actions on r/anime. We largely police within the bounds of r/anime, because we are not mods else where.


From my own perspective, I am curious through what angel people are being directed to profiles more than what feels like previously? Is it Reddit's new(shreddit)/mobile designs that are pushing people to check out users profiles more? Is it bandwagoning after initial comments in the thread?

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 06 '25

I have no dog in this fight (don't care whether they're allowed or not), but about this rule:

I've seen it proposed many times, but I'm not sure it achieves anything...

If I'm a horny weeb who sees some lewd cosplay and want to throw money at some OF girl, I don't need to see a link in her profile; I can just google her name with OF. (Or just her name, it'll usually link everything).

So it doesn't change anything for the people who want to buy erm, "services".

Now, it MAY change something for those who want to sell them; They'll then have a decision to make between 'posting on r/anime without the link' or 'posting everywhere else with the link'... Right?

WRONG.

All the have to do is turn the link on&off for a few days.

Or even better: Make another account.

There's like a million ways they can get around that rule, and none of them are particularly complex.

If they're 'business-savvy' enough to realize that posting sexy cosplay to a sub of horny weeb will earn them money, I'm sure they also realize how to do it without breaking the rules.

Another thing I noticed: People often complains about OF SELLERS even in cosplay threads where the profile doesn't even have an OF link.

People just assume they do... And yes they're often right (EVEN when they don't show it) which again brings to my first point: Even if there's no link, people know they have an OF so they'll just look it up and it changes nothing.

So for all these reasons, to me this feel like adding an extra hoop that changes nothing.

If the real issue is that people think there's too much of it, then limit the quality (like clips) but honestly I don't even know if I saw 5 this month... Seems like a super overblown issue to me.

19

u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Apr 06 '25

I don't care for the posts either, but it's a little silly that bath scene compilation videos on the front page = good, but sexy cosplay pictures = not who we are here.

19

u/N7CombatWombat Apr 06 '25

Speaking purely for myself and my own opinion, I honestly don't care how someone earns their (legal) money, the sub has rules against specifically directing people to any pages they use to solicit money, or directly selling things on the sub, people are free to do that elsewhere though. No one is forcing anyone to click on a user account to go to their profile, if you see content you don't like, I don't understand why one would engage with it by clicking through to their account. That's someone purposely putting themselves into a situation they don't want to be in and I fail to see how that's anyone's fault or problem but the person doing the clicking.

As an aside, I also find it rather ironic that two of the few topics that really seem to consistently bring the community together is defending ecchi content and condemning real people for trying to sell their own sex content.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 12 '25

To be Hero X: Beating a dead horse

...Ok, no, I'm trying to find a way to stop the dead horse from getting beaten so much;

I don't have a dog in this fight, I don't care about To Be Hero X being here or not, but I did read the discussions for fun, and one thing I noticed is that pretty much all the suggestions are framed on either of 2 positions, both of which are incorrect... We get "That's what I like/would want!" (which is irrelevant - other people want/like different things), and "We should do this this or that thing but just this once!" (which obviously slippery slopes into a decisional nightmare).

This isn't how you propose a suggestion... This is a 'bandaid fix' idea. The kind of stuff that everyone will write 50 angry comment about because they feel they're not being heard, and whatever happens, they'll do it again on the next one because it doesn't address the problem at all.

The 'problem' is how do you define what is or isn't anime, which is directly linked to what is or isn't allowed on r/anime.

This isn't a matter as simple as "put the show to the vote, see how people feel", for three reasons;

  • First, because sometimes, people vote wrong. I think everyone has an obvious, recent example in mind when I say that: Of course, I'm talking about how Utena Hiiragi didn't win our yearly best girl contest, because people voted wrong. Joking aside, the fact is that people can cast votes on decisions that would end up being detrimental. Or even without being detrimental, just... improper? If something is popular enough, I'm sure a vote could land on a positive result even if the thing has nothing to do with anime and shouldn't be here. People will vote based on popularity and personal preferences more than they would vote on the general idea of the show belonging here or not.
  • Second: If we start putting shows up to the vote and someday a show gets voted out, THIS WILL BE A MAJOR SHITSTORM. People shitting on every thread, posting 50 angry comments on META to talk about how the vote was a terrible idea after all, trashing each other, there ARE some people who will quit r/anime over it (due to the 'unfairness' of some shows being allowed while some others aren't), and so on. People are all up for democracy until democracy gives them a result they don't like.
  • Third and most importantly: It doesn't fix the actual problem, as mentioned above; The problem isn't "Should X specific show be allowed?", it's "What should be allowed?". Because people don't want to have that debate every single time a new show is on the fence between anime/not anime.

So the GOOD way to propose a solution, is to not talk about To Be Hero X. To not talk about any specific show at all. (I'm still not sure voting on this would be the way to go, 1 year from now some people would say "I DIDN'T VOTE FOR THAT!", but IF we were to hold the vote on anything, THIS is what we should be voting on, i.e. the definition of anime we'll accept in r/anime).

This is how you fix a problem for good, instead of addressing 1 tiny symptom of it.

So that's why I'm asking you, the people who think the show should be allowed (or the people who WANT it to be allowed, without giving consideration to whether or not it should);

What do you think should be allowed in r/anime?

  • Things that "looks anime enough to me"? This is another nightmare in the making, with everyone having a different opinion on what 'looks anime enough'.
  • Things that "have some % of Japanese influence or participation"? This one is objective at least, but it's gonna be a different sort of nightmare, a logistical one (finding accurate information about every single show there is to figure out whether it's Japanese enough/Anime enough to belong). Plus, another angry nightmare when a show misses the bar by 5% and people get mad again.
  • Things that are added on MAL, or whatever other website that will act as the omniscient anime decider? Well, if there was a trusted source with accurate decisions that might work, but always consider the hypothetical of "What if they add something that's cleary not anime someday?"

I don't have the right solution myself (i.e. I don't know what the right thing to ask for would be), but THIS is the kind of 'right question to ask' people should focus on, THIS is the problem they should find a way to solve, i.e. "How do we, as a community, agree on what is anime and what is cartoons/something else, so we don't have to hold this debate every single time a new show is produced and makes waves".

In short: Rather than making emotional arguments about To Be Hero X (one way or the other), the better way to approach this is to take a shot at finding a logical, reasoned argument about "What is the definition of an 'anime' that should be accepted in r/anime".

You want to answer the question "What is an anime?", not the question "What is To Be Hero X".

/2 cents.

16

u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Apr 13 '25

Ironically, I don’t think these are the right questions either.

What we really should be asking ourselves is: what do we want r/anime to be? Do we want this to be an anime subreddit (more formal) or foster an anime-related community (less formal)?

Because some of the ways in which certain discussion topics have been suppressed in the past have hurt this community feeling. The situation with To Be Hero X is merely another ‘battle’ in this continuing ‘war’.

→ More replies (16)

15

u/riishan_saki Apr 12 '25

But there's a definition already and they're following it. People wouldn't vote caring about the actual definition, it would be a proxy vote about these specific shows they like.

Making anime a loose term associated with a style is a slippery slope no matter what, you can't define things by them feeling like anime, especially when these perceptions are too influenced by specific trends and genres more popular in the west like shonen.

Mixing a bunch of different animated shows together would probably mean more niche japanese shows would lose even the little space they already have, as it happens on r/manga.

→ More replies (43)

7

u/IXajll https://myanimelist.net/profile/ixajii Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25

Not sure if this is the right place for this but I just wanted to get the proposal out there to make the current seasonalshock commentface permanently available after the season ends. Don't know how such decisions are made here but just wanted to put this out here. That commentface is probably the best seasonalshock we ever had imho.

15

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Apr 06 '25

For picking the Hall of Fame face we tend to lean most heavily on the survey results from the questioner that is included in the nomination post for the following season. So keep an eye out for the next comment face nomination thread (typically around the 3-5 week mark of a new season).

19

u/Volitar May 02 '25

I'm in favor of the cosplay ban. Everytime I've opened the subreddit this week I see a half naked women as the first thing that loads and that is simply not why I visit this board.

Any subreddit that allows it gets overrun with cosplay posts and becomes nothing but that.

Maybe keep a weekly or monthly cosplay thread stickied and people can post their cosplay there, all in once place.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/[deleted] May 01 '25

Can we stop with the blatant only fans ad? Or are the mods too busy jerking off to it?

6

u/ExpiringMilknCheese Apr 20 '25

i understand To Be hero X not being here because as everybody mentioned its not being made by a Japanese Studio, but why is TBATE still getting episode threads?

All their episodes have been outsourced to China, and the studio that was supposedly in charge of animating it, doesnt even have a 2d department. Should it remain getting episode threads just because it has a sticker of the Japanese studio on the title? How many episodes should we get to and know that this is obviously not going to be animated by Studio A Cat

15

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Apr 20 '25

So this was something I had actually noticed earlier in the season and then I realized it was from A-Cat, a studio that does not have a 2D animation department.

Looking into it further, I saw how their other roles were divvied up: series director, storyboards, episode directors, character designer, chief animation director, series composer, color coordinator, and production manager were all from the Japan side.

This isn't to downplay the role that animation has in anime; after all, one of anime's greatest visual strengths is the degree of artistic freedom that is given to the animators. However, we have to draw the line in the sand somewhere and see who maintains overall creative control of the work.

In this case, we believe that the roles up above constitute enough creative control on Japan's side to be considered anime. These are the roles that ultimately steer the story of the anime.

I do appreciate you bringing this up though because this was something that was already on my radar (and evidently yours too) and I believe it will soon be on everyone else's radar as well.

We'll continue to monitor for shows such as this in the future and stay consistent on our definition of what constitutes anime.

10

u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Apr 20 '25 edited Apr 20 '25

Not a mod, but I think the answer here falls under the outsourcing and consideration of creative control parts of the "is it anime?" section of the rules.

TBATE seems to have outsourced the key animation, in-between animation, and colouring (and perhaps more? I haven't been following it to closely) to studios from the donghua industry. But all the senior staff involved (the screenwriter, the storyboarders, the director, the episode director, the composer, the animation director, production manager, etc) are members of the anime industry and are working out of a Japanese animation studio (A-CAT). So the "creative control" is still predominantly with the anime industry - you have an "anime industry" staff deciding on all the pre-planning, the character designs, the scenario doc, then writing the episode scripts and storyboarding them, and then finally giving those storyboards out to the "donghua industry" animators/colourists/finishers via that outsourcing. But those outsourced staff don't have much, if any, creative control on the work - they have to follow the storyboard and instructions given by the production team from A-CAT.

It's still certainly a mixed scenario of sorts, but Japanese studios operating like this and outsourcing the animation work to other countries (not just China, but Korea, Vietnam, Philippines, and many more) is common in a ton of shows that are clearly "anime"... it's just usually only an episode or two, or just the in-betweening... TBATE is a really extreme version of this otherwise quite common practice.

Either way, the mods had to pick a line in the sand to draw somewhere, and that overall creative control by the senior staff all being established members of the anime industry is where that line has been drawn. Which makes a lot of sense to me. And this is something that the subreddit can stay pretty consistent on for future decisions which should mostly match the vague expectations of the masses of what is and isn't "anime".

For a helpful corollary situation, consider something like Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island - take a look at the staff list. Why is everyone American right up until you get to the key animation/in-betweening and suddenly the names are all Japanese? Because the animation on it was all outsourced overseas just like TBATE, but this time it was not the anime industry outsourcing to the donghua industry, it was the Hollywood industry outsourcing to the anime industry! The director, writer, character designer, storyboarders, production management, etc were all undeniably Hollywood staff and they did all the pre-planning, storyboarding, etc, then outsourced the animation work to a Japanese animation studio.

If that Japanese studio had been the ones directing and storyboarding Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island, then that would probably be enough creative control in the hands of anime industry personnel for that film to be eligible on this subreddit as "anime" (similar to how Scott Pilgrim Takes Off and War of the Rohirrim are still considered anime here despite being western IPs and having Hollywood screenwriters). But they weren't, all creative control was in the hands of the Hollywood staff and the anime industry animators were just executing the storyboards and instructions they were given from Hollywood.

Hence Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island is not considered anime here, for the same reason that TBATE is considered anime here.

8

u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Apr 14 '25

Sorry for bringing up TBHX (I'm sure nobody is tired of this yet) but for the by the Numbers stickied stats next month, might want to see if it's possible for the removed comments to have a separate stat for the reasons "This doesn't appear to be about anime per our definition." combined with "You might consider posting this to /r/Donghua instead." and if possible look back to when Link Click was airing (idk what discussion was like here or if the mod removal reasons have changed since then but elsewhere when it first aired it had similar praise). I don't know how much work that is for the by the numbers data section but if it did happen before with Link Click that data might help get an idea of is this requiring more moderation (if that's worth knowing).

On the other hand this might make TBHX fans feel singled out (or a badge of honour - from modding experience ~20 years ago this is tough situation you're trying to de-escalate/clarify/reform/course correct) because why them and not other rule violations like not say, piracy site linkers? (which I imagine is another big mod removal reason).

9

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Apr 14 '25

While it would be possible to get this information, it would be annoying and require a fair bit of manual work. To get it to any degree of accuracy, we would have to have someone manually inspect every single redirect to /r/Donghua and every meta thread redirect during that time period to ensure any degree of accuracy.

As such, I doubt it will be done.

17

u/Roboute_Gulliman May 01 '25

Goonerbait cosplay begone!

23

u/RIP-Fredo Apr 21 '25

Can we stop allowing OF ***** here in this sub? The worst part is there are simp Mods who support it 😒Pathetic

→ More replies (32)

7

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Apr 22 '25

Monthly request to change #volibearq to #tableflip.

While humbly reminding the mod team that #hyoukanod and #hyoukawink were once the same comment face. It can be done. You have the technology.

15

u/PrinceZero1994 https://myanimelist.net/profile/pz16 Apr 21 '25

Is there an official reason why an OnlyFans advertisement is being allowed to remain on the front page?
This has happened multiple times now and judging by the recent reactions, it appears that the anime community does not like it.
These kinds of posts are often propelled to the frontpage with upvote buying.
You can get like 100 upvotes for 5 bucks.
I would not be surprised if there was karma manipulation involved and this is a violation of reddit site-wide rules.
At the end of the day, I feel like the recent controversial post is not appropriate for /r/anime.

11

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 23 '25

These kinds of posts are often propelled to the frontpage with upvote buying.

While no one can say it's not happening, I'm not sure it's a certainty either...

r/anime is horny as fuck, especially when it comes to upvotes (i.e. 'anonymous horny').

Look at how many upvotes the horny clips get, often 5 times more karma than episode threads (which hints at people who don't even watch the anime, upvoting the clips).

People don't "horny comment" as much because it's not anonymous, but the upvotes speak volume. (And they comment even less when it's "controversial", which is obviously the case here with OF stuff).

→ More replies (2)

11

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 21 '25

In general we don't really use what people do off the subreddit as a justification for banning them or removing their posts. If they aren't directly advertising here that's pretty much all there is to it (though plenty in the comments will advertise on their behalf, as we've been seeing). I did actually ask about this at the start of the month because I've been seeing it a lot with fan artists that are pretty transparently just posting their work on r/anime for commissions/sales. Not a ton of a response, but overall people didn't really seem to care about the advertising when it was anything other than women doing cosplay.

It's definitely possible that there's karma manipulation, but given that this is r/anime I hardly think that's necessary. You can sort through clips from the past year and you'll find that the large majority of the top clips by upvotes are tagged NSFW. Or you could search the What to Watch flair and find a good chunk of the top posts from the past year are some variation of "give me something horny". We've always allowed mildly NSFW content, and on the whole the community has pretty consistently upvoted that sort of content.

As a user, yeah I'm not a fan of it for the same reason I'm not a fan of the fan artists who are transparently transactional in their engagement with the sub, and have no interest in r/anime beyond the opportunity to make a buck. There's a thread right now that's one below the cosplay post that's a fanart post from an account that only posts a specific style of fanart and in another subreddit their openly telling people that they do commissions. But we don't have anybody accusing that post of being an ad.

To speculate slightly on the future here:

I just searched the cosplay flair. How fan cosplay posts were there on r/anime in 2024? The whole year? All 366 days?

There were seven.

There might have been some from now deleted accounts or that got removed for some other reason, but by the end of the year only seven cosplay posts had still exist. Cosplay has been a largely pretty unused flair. The first cosplay post this year was on March 20, and so far this year we have nine in total. That's not really something that we're immediately pressed about, but if we see that it's surging then maybe it's something that we look to make a change about. It could very easily be a couple cosplay posts and then it dies back down. It could be that some people see the traffic that these posts have gotten and we get inundated.

For now we'll keep tabs on it and see where things end up.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/mekerpan Apr 28 '25

No Aharen episode 4 discussion thread yet today (that I can find).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Apr 30 '25

First episode of Tsurezure Popipa was released yesterday. But I don't see any thread for it other than mine.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/titanicboi1 May 02 '25

Remove all cosplays that are from posters that have only fans in their bio please

16

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii May 02 '25

Finally a good suggestion to this issue.

I wonder why no one thought about this before.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (24)

11

u/QinsSais May 01 '25

Porn sells and the gooners are paying well. So seeing the cosbait post is never going to stop unfortunately. It's a business for them and apparently it's good

10

u/Zonca Apr 10 '25

I want To Be Hero X on this sub, as an exception since its shaping up to be the biggest anime this season, every creator and fan thinks its anime enough.

I agree it shouldnt be here according the the technical definition, dont care, put it to the vote of the community and make this an exception.

Talks about how this would open the door to all chinese stuff and we would have to vote on every their show is obfuscation, there wont be such extraordinary show every season, let people have their one thread a week a leave them be.

If people vote they dont wish this, then I stand corrected, only after we vote.

29

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Apr 11 '25

I want To Be Hero X on this sub, as an exception since its shaping up to be the biggest anime this season, every creator and fan thinks its anime enough.

Sounds like the perfect time to kick off the growth of r/Donghua then

→ More replies (15)

23

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

there wont be such extraordinary show every season

Why should it work that way? That's not fair to every other non-Japanese production out there, I don't see why one show should get special treatment and I would certainly start arguing for everything else along those lines to be handled the same way if it did.

12

u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Apr 11 '25

I'd leave the sub if Invincible was ever allowed here.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/cultpet Apr 11 '25

Talks about how this would open the door to all chinese stuff and we would have to vote on every their show is obfuscation, there wont be such extraordinary show every season

What makes a show anime/not anime is not linked to its popularity.

So if we vote on this one, why shouldn't we also vote on the less popular ones?

17

u/neighmeansno Apr 10 '25

People need to stop making ridiculous claims to try to justify this opinion.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/ATraffyatLaw Apr 21 '25

Kind of odd the mod team on here is so defensive of anything slightly off-topic but the onlyfans spam is just good to keep chugging along.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian May 01 '25

Man some of these reactions to the cosplays...borderline misogyny for some replies/takes.

Bring back the participation rule, if someone wants to use our community to advertise then the least they can do is be a part of it.

17

u/steven4869 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maskirade May 01 '25

As far as I know for the cosplay posts you need 10 comment r/anime karma to make a post, but they are playing the system here by commenting once or twice to get the benchmark then post it every other week.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

4

u/Hitman7128 https://anilist.co/user/Hitman7128 Apr 17 '25

Not sure if this belongs here.

I plan on posting a clip from the LycoReco ONA that recently aired with the ED gag but am iffy about titling it. I was originally thinking “ED gag (RIP Sayuri) [Lycoris Recoil - Friends are thieves of time]” because reading the room on the thread, people found humor in a gag during the short while also honoring the LycoReco ED singer who unfortunately passed away last year. But my proposed title feels jarring to me and can be misconstrued because it juxtaposes humor (ED gag) with the death of a real person. It seems hard to give attention to the crux of the clip (the gag) whilst honoring the late singer in a compact title. (Not sure if any of you have suggestions for the title)

I felt like erring on the side of caution here, not only because of the tragedy and this being more a unique situation but also the clip rules. Unlike fixing a clip post to rectify violations of the rules, fixing a clip for cosmetic reasons (like to change the title or extend it a bit) isn’t pardoned and counts against the 2 clip limit.

Other than that, I should be good to go with the actual clip rules: While I have to wait to post it on Apr 23 (7 days after the discussion thread), the 30 day cooldown on my second-to-last clip post (Mar 20) expires by then.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/SpiritTunnel Apr 30 '25

unpopular opinion but the pattern of heavy indignation being given out to people who post their cosplay who also leverage their account for adult content promo. I don't think that it's healthy

making critique is valid for sure, I find the use of these AI looking chains strange in that controversial makima cosplay, among others but some of the feedback I think is forgetting that on the other end is someone is putting effort into doing a cosplay

personally I don't enjoy when I'm being presented with sexually suggestive content in a way that's instrumental to marketing their adult content, especially in some of the extreme examples when it doesn't even track with the IP, or is just low effort. I don't like that.

I don't really have an answer to the problem of not so subtly being advertised adult content or what the sub should do. but I think ppl need to remember ppl creating content are humans. cuz I don't want people who'd post their own OC/Cosplay to anticipate getting shat on heavy or alienated for how they fit balance between how suggestive to high quality their cosplay is that they lose the confidence to express themselves fully and have fun

19

u/SCVGoodT0GoSir May 01 '25

I mentioned this in another comment further down, but I don't have a dog in this fight about whether or not cosplay belongs on this subreddit. However, the way things are now, all the comments in those posts fall into (roughly) 4 categories:

  1. Comments calling out the OP's post being an OF ad.
  2. Comments calling out amount of removed comments in the thread.
  3. Comments praising the cosplay, and then getting downvoted to oblivion.
  4. Comments insulting the cosplay/cosplayer, and getting upvotes.

#1 and #2 violate the rules, and get deleted. As a result, the only comments left are the ones that are insulting the cosplay, with upvotes, and the ones that compliment the cosplay, which get heavily downvoted. There's also a smattering of comments here and there questioning what happened with all the deleted comments, and nobody is able to respond without getting their own comment removed. Doesn't seem like a very ideal environment.