r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 07 '24
Meta Meta Thread - Month of July 07, 2024
Rule Changes
OP/ED Posting
- Voted to remove the one week exemption from OP/ED's and to have them be treated as clips.
Previously, our rules allowed for clips of OP/ED’s to be exempt from the one week episode moratorium on clips. The intended purpose of this rule was to allow OP/EDs that were not officially uploaded by studios to be posted at the start of the season. However, this has occasionally led to situations where a show would release before the studio itself could release the official upload of an OP/ED, allowing users to upload a Clip version while still beating out others from submitting the official release. We are now removing this exemption in order to stop this situation from occurring again.
For shows who do not release an official upload of their OP/ED, they may still be submitted one week later as a Clip.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | January 2024 | December 2023 | November 2023 | October 2023 | September 2023 | August 2023 | July 2023 | June 2023 | May 2023 | April 2023 | March 2023 | February 2023 | January 2023 | December 2022 | | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 07 '24
Hello everyone~
It's been one year since I've been a mod! Time flies when you're having moderate amounts of fun.
June Mod Report
June by the Numbers
17
u/cppn02 Jul 07 '24
Monthly karma manipulation thread:
Dahlia EP01
58
u/Infernoooo Jul 13 '24 edited Jul 13 '24
Just echoing what I said in the Nokotan thread for the most part but the rules for when episode discussion threads go up need to change. You are killing a lot of discussion on one of the most hyped anime of the season by posting the Nokotan thread now when crunchyroll doesn't release the episode until tomorrow. If there's an official stream that releases weekly then the discussion thread shouldn't go up until it releases on the official stream. People like me who pirate can wait to discuss, while the vast majority of people who will be watching on crunchyroll shouldn't have to find and post on what will now be an old dead thread with way less visibility, karma, and discussion.
63
u/IXajll https://myanimelist.net/profile/ixajii Jul 13 '24
Gotta say, I‘m disappointed about how the Nokotan situation was eventually decided to get handled. It happened exactly how others and I feared, a thread is up before the official release. It is literally like the people in charge/the mods are telling the sub „you better go pirate the show right now if you wanna discuss the show lol“ which is a complete shame and makes zero sense beside the same old „that’s how it’s always been in this sub“. Because let’s be real, tomorrow when the subs officially release the thread will be dead and everything has been said already anyway at that point.
13
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Jul 11 '24
Were the Nokotan subs for ep2 checked by anyone before the bot uploaded the thread?
11
u/Time_Fracture https://myanimelist.net/profile/Time_Fracture Jul 11 '24
The new OP/ED rule is made due to Nokotan situation last week am I correct?
Anyway about Nokotan, why Episode 2 thread is live today instead of Sunday?
11
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Jul 22 '24
I think during one of the recent commentface changes, several of the images got moved slightly? I don't know much about CSS so I might not be communicating that right, but there are quite a few with have random white space around their sides:
58
u/Piapple1 Jul 13 '24
Please just put the discussion thread up for episodes when it officially comes out. I cannot believe someone thinks its a good idea to do anything but that. Right now is very arbitrary when it goes up and it sucks finding a thread a day or two later. It just fragments discussion. Imagine running a sub this big and not being objective about everything.
10
u/Glum-Lynx-8751 Jul 16 '24
The u/AutoLovepon account seems to be suspended.
10
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 30 '24
Heya everyone, hosts have been selected for the 2024 /r/anime Awards! Say hello to~
/u/2honeybeecake
/u/AdiMG
/u/bconeill
/u/Duckloader
/u/Fircoal
/u/Kenalskii
/u/Lemurians
/u/MetaSoshi9
/u/RoiAnanas
/u/Schinco
/u/Tehoncomingstorm97
/u/Totalenlo
/u/Vaxivop
I'm looking forward to seeing what each of these hosts will bring to the table! If you're unfamiliar with the project, then please check it out at https://animeawards.moe, and if you are familiar, you can provide feedback at https://animeawards.moe/feedback. This feedback goes directly to the moderators and host team.
If you would like to help the Awards as either a graphic designer, video editor, or website developer, then please fill out the Helper Form!
We hope to see you all in a bit!
38
u/bandannadann https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bandanaa Jul 13 '24
Please change the rule about discussion threads being allowed to go up before official distribution. It actively harms discussion.
8
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jul 16 '24
Following internal discussions and a vote, we have decided to alter the spoiler-tagging rules for "Official Media" flaired Season and Episode Teasers/PVs threads as follows with immediate effect:
In terms of spoilers, these threads will now be treated the same as episode discussions without a source corner. This means that the contents of prior anime episodes/seasons and the preview would be allowed without spoiler tags, but all source knowledge and discussion would still need to go under spoiler tags.
The immediate 8-day ban policy for untagged spoilers will continue to only apply to episode threads, not Official Media threads.
8
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 17 '24
Other minor thing: might want to include updates that are in other threads in comments here for future reference too, like the fanart rule change trial continuing and whatever's going on with the deer threads. I feel like the meta thread should always be the hub to check first rather than needing to check every possibly relevant thread.
8
u/DrJWilson x5https://anilist.co/user/drjwilson Jul 18 '24
Hello! In case you missed it, /r/anime Awards 2024 Host Applications are open until next Monday!
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1e3ygh0/ranime_awards_2024_host_applications_are_open/
What's a host and why should you be one? Well, the /r/anime Awards are one of our biggest subreddit events, and they take a lot of coordination and planning to deliver a final product. Being a host gives you the opportunity to see behind the scenes, collaborate with your fellow subreddit members, and ultimately results in an spectacle we can all be proud of. The awards has given previous hosts excuses to improve their coding and design our impressive website, practice transferable teambuilding and management skills, and really just have a deeper connection to both anime and the anime community as a whole. I've literally talked about my experiences as a host in job interviews!
We are always looking to improve, so if there's something in the process that you feel could be better, or some ideas you want to implement, we urge you to apply! Even if you don't feel up to the task of overseeing everything, hosts can have pretty specialized roles and focus on specific areas they'd like to work on.
Here's the application link and I hope to see your names! If there's any questions please ask, because I know that sometimes we can fall into the trap of presupposing knowledge whereas there are plenty of people for whom this event is new. Thanks!
https://forms.gle/r9z3tC98wCNXRCJz9
8
u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 20 '24
the source shows for the niche comment faces arent on the commentfacesources page /u/badspler
8
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Jul 24 '24
I really think that we should be a little more careful with the news that’s being posted on this subreddit, especially when there’s no English-language article attached to a story.
I’m glad that there were ultimately steps taken against the post about (one of) the mangaka(s) of Apothecary Diaries being convicted of a prison sentence, but it’s another example - after the debacle with the news on a Your Name producer being arrested - of how there’s a need for news articles to be more scrutinised on r/anime.
In this case, the title almost seemed to suggest that the mangaka was being sentenced to prison and suspended from their job, when this is in fact was not the case: their prison sentence was suspended under the condition that they remained on good behaviour from now on. Poor titles can lead to a lot of wrong assumptions.
Another issue is that said post’s title was directly taken from a (linked) tweet that links a Japanese news article in turn. Meaning that people can’t check the source if they don’t speak Japanese. This only enforces misinformation as most people won’t go out of their way to check other sources.
In my opinion, every (news) article that features sensitive topics should ideally have an English source for people to check themselves.
45
u/SnabDedraterEdave Jul 13 '24
Sub doesn't allow links to pirated streaming and download sites, yet allows discussion threads for episodes to come out if there are unlicensed fansubs that are released before a legal stream.
So ultimately, you guys are really encouraging us to sail the high seas, amirite?
14
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 10 '24
Apologies to anybody who's been waiting for the "r/anime's Favorite Cast" results. Life's been insanely busy these past few weeks and I keep having to put it off. Next week we'll be back to the normal schedule (thankfully for me) and those results will be posted.
7
u/mekerpan Jul 09 '24
A phantom down-rater seems to be stalking a number of new episode discussion threads.... Early (first hour or two) posts seem especially likely to get downvoted. No BIG deal I guess -- but kind of aggravating.
I wonder if the mods can see who this might be -- and whether it is a live person or a bot? (It would be pathetic to imagine someone spending a few hours a day doing this "by hand" -- but who knows.
41
u/frik1000 Jul 13 '24
Echoing what others are saying about the rules regarding discussion posts. It's absurd that those that are watching the show through legal means have to resort to day-old threads that will be buried away from the front page just because of some arbitrary rule on fansubs that are deemed "good enough." This week the difference will only be a day but over time, fansubs will only get faster and we'll eventually get to a point where there will be a gap of half a week between fansubs and the official releases.
As someone living in Asia, this is one of the few shows that I can actually watch legally and yet now we're the ones being inconvenienced because of that. It's also borderline promoting pirating the show.
6
u/messem10 https://myanimelist.net/profile/bookkid900 Jul 07 '24
I realize that managing the bot for the episode threads is difficult, but would it be possible to add a link to source material if it is available in English?
6
u/raichudoggy https://anilist.co/user/raichudoggy Jul 16 '24
This is just me thinking out loud, but if there's a rewatch sidebar image planned for Shugo Chara, might want that there pretty soon since it's an 8 episode up-front start.
6
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 17 '24
Update on the situation with Shikanoko Nokonoko Koshitantan threads.
The TL;DR: Episode threads for this series will go live with the official English release. This isn't something that's being codified as a standard, but we'll be evaluating how we want to handle similar and other edge cases over the coming weeks/months and praying to Haruhi that it just never happens again.
6
u/Verzwei Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 25 '24
Extremely minor quibble but there's a small typo in the body text for the "What have you watched this past week" threads.
In those threads, the demonstration for the spoiler syntax reads as follows:
I feel like the double quotation mark
"is misleading since it isn't a required part of the spoiler code, and having an opening quotation mark without an accompanying closing quotation mark probably isn't correct grammar anyway.I wondered maybe if it was a one-off (perhaps hand-typed for whatever reason) but it looks like it's the same text going back at least a few weeks.
Relevant thread
6
u/entelechtual Aug 03 '24
I don’t think there’s a ton of misinterpretation of this, but I feel like the language for official media spoiler content should be a bit clearer. Right now it says “Spoiler tags for events up to and including those depicted in the storyline presented are no longer required”. I would probably say “Spoiler tags are no longer required for events depicted in the anime up to this point, including those depicted in this piece of content/media”.
There’s a warning about source reader content about future events but otherwise it sounds like a source reader could stroll in and say “Oh man I’m so hyped we’re going to see the moment when __ fights __, it’s the best fight so far” or “I can’t believe they included that character in the visual”. I don’t think that was the intent, moreso that if you were an anime only watcher you could say things like “after __’s dad died in Season 1, I hope he can move on, it looks like he’s going to have a fight with his father’s killer based on this PV, and I wonder who that character at the end was?” and not have to worry about spoiler tagging previously aired anime events. Maybe I’m reading too much into it.
28
u/otto303969388 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/otto303969388 Jul 14 '24
Suggestion: If an anime has an official stream, the discussion thread should not go up until the official stream is released.
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 04 '24
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24
I can understand not wanting spoilers, but removing all comments that even mention how an episode was better than the source material is just dumb. “Omg they did this justice, exceeded the game” for example makes no sense getting removed
5
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 27 '24
As a minor thing you might want to update the redirect to CDF removal reason if using that in isolation without checking the "not anime-specific" one as well because it doesn't explicitly mention why the post/comment was removed. It's implied at the end but I think it's easy to miss, same applies for the redirecting to other subreddits reason.
5
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Aug 01 '24
Hey, since there is an official release of Deer on Wednesday, time to change the the thread creation day again ?
5
u/Castor_0il Aug 02 '24
I feel that the "clip rules" should have an extra clause or something.
There was this post yesterday that it was already posted in subbed version two weeks ago
Quoting u/Abysswatcherbel "you can only post the same clip every 6 months, but one was the sub version and a much longer scene, this one is the dub version". I feel there should be a clarification "if" a clip can be reposted despite the 6 month rule, if it's dubbed. Same for "that clip is longer than this one" kind of argument.
All I'm saying is that if you mods are going to allow "double dipping" it should at least be pointed out in the clip rules. Likewise if you guys are against double dipping.
4
u/Ao3y Jul 14 '24
Is it okay to post a thread sharing good fanservice? I couldn't find anything in the rules other than prohibition of pics that are way more explicit than what I have.
Thank you if anyone knows!
4
u/Snusmumriken11 Jul 14 '24
I just posted a comment under Tower of God S2E2 about the author's blog posts, and it was removed because of the 'no author comments' rule. I get that normally, but I think an exception should be made in this case since these blog posts are a bit more than just comments, they're often additional non-spoilery lore that was given at the end of every chapter, and while not 100% necessary, can definitely enhance the viewing experience. These two specifically were pretty light on the lore aspect, but it gets heavy later on. If we restrict them to the source material thread, 95% will miss out on that, and most people who read them will know about them already. They were also posted without issue when S1 aired. There was one point that could be considered a small spoiler (even though the author said it) but I edited and removed it. Could you help me out here?
4
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 17 '24
Daily thread still links to Hanayamata rather than Ao Haru Ride for Anime of the Week.
4
u/IXajll https://myanimelist.net/profile/ixajii Jul 22 '24
At around what time will the new seasonal flairs be available, approximately?
4
u/entelechtual Jul 30 '24
Would it be considered a spoiler to mention untagged that [Roshidere Episode 2]Yuki is the MC’s sister? I would think not given it’s revealed fairly early on in the series and is basically a given fact about the show (the clip about it wasn’t tagged) but I could see how technically it’s portrayed as a mild surprise in the context of the show. It’s hard to talk around it and I don’t think it ruins the experience for anyone.
10
u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 12 '24
it seems the pinned casual community discussion thread is locked, seems like a waste of a pin
can we instead pin the rent a girlfriend season 4 announcement?
20
u/Broad_Acanth Jul 13 '24
Crazy that mods created a discussion thread for Nokotan solely based on a single 4chan post.
7
u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin Jul 14 '24
So after watching Crunchyroll's version, it seemed that they did the subs this week and more than likely will be like this going forward. Is the timing of the thread still going to depend on when fansubs drop, since as far as I know, we aren't sure if those will consistently drop before Crunchy subs?
6
u/piruuu https://anilist.co/user/dvj Jul 14 '24
Mods, is there any progress on the discussion on piracy on r/anime that was once mentioned 7 months ago?
I believe that once Nokotan issue is over it would be a good opportunity to speed up the progress on this subject.
6
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 14 '24
The Niche Comment Face Suggestions are now live!.
With that #Headpat has been made static.
And the following new faces have been added. Enjoy!
3
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Jul 08 '24
Are the subs of Kinnikuman episode 0 good enough for an episode thread?
14
u/chemical_exe Jul 13 '24
Time your bot to official releases. Doesn't the bot pull from a torrent website or something?
5
u/PrinceZero1994 https://myanimelist.net/profile/pz16 Jul 25 '24 edited Jul 25 '24
I usually go blind on every show I watch except knowing the ratings.
After watching 2-3 episodes, I search for the anime announcement, pv and key visual threads and read them.
In these threads which are usually on the top of the sub for a whole day, I often read comments from LN readers who gives a run down of the story so far and in my opinion they count as spoiler as my mood immediately plummets.
The comments usually goes:
"The story is focused on this and that. It won't be this said author. The MC is doing this and that. There's no [insert important detail] and that so far. I only read til volume 5 of LN."
Comment chain:
"I don't mind spoilers, is this this and that?"
"Yeah kinda but they do it better than most. It will happen but slow and gradual and feel natural."
It's worse when you read the actual comments but these are highly upvoted comments without spoiler tags so they must not be spoilers, right?
I don't really know, maybe I'm just ranting coz I'm mad. I'll just be extra extra careful when reading next time.
11
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jul 13 '24 edited Jul 14 '24
After internal discussions, /u/autolovepon /u/AnimeMod will crosspost the existing Episode 2 thread for Nokotan once official English subtitles are available, currently scheduled for 14Jul. The crosspost itself will be locked, so all discussion will only be in the existing episode thread.
We are also discussing the approach on this show specifically, as well as episode discussion threads as a whole, going forward. We don't have any updates on that front yet, but will post them here when we have one.
2
u/amidloveandanime Jul 20 '24
What part of that Alya clip I posted the mods consider a spoiler?
Just to know what is and isn't considered a spoiler for this show, since that Yuki clip wasn't marked as spoiler I am really confused what is a spoiler there
2
u/Curious_Visitor9000 Jul 27 '24
Does someone know how to ask the mods to add a subreddit to the post in the 'Show information' section?
There's a subreddit for the anime r/MagicArtisanDahliya
2
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 29 '24
As another user noticed, the anilist link in the anime of the week thread points to Ao haru ride instead of ZnT (mal/anidb link are correct)
2
u/pussypowerr Aug 02 '24
hi, it looks like discussion threads for kimi ni todoke season 3 episodes 2 - 4 seem to have been deleted for some reason while episodes 1 and 5's are still up
3
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Aug 02 '24
Is there a way to promote CDF? It just feels so quiet there sometimes. I miss the meming and random joking around. It just doesn't feel the same as it did when it was FTF. I'm not suggesting to change the name to something else (I don't think that'd help much), but just some ideas to promote CDF.
2
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Jul 14 '24
I have removed the comments on the state of Nokotan episode discussion threads from the episode two discussion thread so that people coming in through tomorrow's crosspost have a nicer thread to comment in and because those comments were always in violation of our rules.
I'm tagging a bunch of people who participated in it here so you know it was done and aren't surprised by it.
/u/BiggieCheeseLapDog /u/LemurLord /u/zairaner
1
u/Usodearu007 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Doc101 Jul 25 '24
Hi ! will the polls never make their comeback in the episode discussion threads ?
-24
u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz Jul 13 '24
Complaining about a episode thread being out 'early' because it won't get the same amount of imaginary karma and your 'discussion' consisting of spamming the same lines over and over is such peak reddit. I love it.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment