r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jan 05 '25
Meta Meta Thread - Month of January 05, 2025
Rule Changes
- No rule changes this month.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: December 2024 | November 2024 | October 2024 | September 2024 | August 2024 | July 2024 | June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | January 2024 | December 2023 | November 2023 | October 2023 | September 2023 | August 2023 | July 2023 | June 2023 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/Esovan13 Jan 05 '25
December Mod Report
December by the Numbers
12
u/entelechtual Jan 07 '25
I was gonna hold off on commenting about this for the 19th time because the post had blown up and the animator in question had a decently large following on twitter anyway. But given the recent “update” about the tweets for overwork/bad conditions for 100 Gfs, can we please consider vetting posts that are just tweets that aren’t announcements/official media/actual news? These are people working in the anime industry who clearly aren’t tweeting in an official capacity. I’m sure if they knew that a large subreddit was going to make a big deal out of it and also spell out dire consequences for the fate of a series, they’d have reconsidered what they said. But no one should be under that much scrutiny for twitter.
Do I believe that the tweets in question were motivated by not great working conditions? Clearly. Do I think she was pressured by execs to clarify her intention? Duh. But even so, vague and emotional tweets like that lead to nothing but baseless speculation. People tweet shit all the time, and it would suck if you tweeted something to the effect “this is a hell week at work I’m dying” and the internet went out and basically told your boss.
My previous stance has been that if a post consists solely of a tweet link or contents of a tweet, it should either be an official account, official media, news by a news outlet, or tweets from someone speaking in an official capacity related to an anime (e.g. “I’m so excited to be working on Reborn as a Slug in a World Made of Salt, it’s going to be 2 cours and start with a 90 minute premiere”). If it’s a tweet from an animator or character designer or director that’s just venting about work, at least let some publication follow up that can say “We reached out to the animator for comment”.
Yes, we shouldn’t back away from highlighting insights about the state of the animation industry. But this is not the way.
11
u/baseballlover723 Jan 29 '25
Since there are 2 more seasonal comment faces being added, I personally think there would be value in a #seasonalwildcard slot, as a catch all for something that as comment face potential, but doesn't fit into one of the other categories.
Currently I don't think there's a good avenue for things that would be a good comment face overall, but don't really fit with any of the seasonal tags. Since seasonal comment faces being promoted seems to be the predominant way for permanent comment faces to be added IIRC (man is it hard to search reddit for historical comment face discussion).
It could also be used to double up on a category if there are 2 really good distinct comment face nominations for a single category.
Personally I think a single "flex" spot would give a disproportionate amount of value, and I hope you consider it. Either that, or more frequent general comment face addition polling outside of the seasonal ones. Note that I'm not saying that the number of comment faces should increase (I'm well aware of the limitations with them).
8
u/Siqueiradit https://myanimelist.net/profile/lampadatres Jan 05 '25
I have to come here with something I've always had a problem with. Why is it so hard to find all the info on the awards? Specially the schedule.
8
u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Jan 07 '25
This thread should be deleted since the episode seems to have been leaked.
7
u/LittleIslander https://anilist.co/user/LittleIslander Jan 06 '25 edited Jan 06 '25
I kind of question the decision to have an anime of the week thread posted with Best Of and Anime Awards voting both going on. Like I'm sure the pinned threads conundrum is something the mods are aware but I really would've thought it made more sense to just not run that for one week with two big things going on that need all the visibility they can get. If anything I probably waited on Best Of until it wasn't overlapping the Awards voting, but obviously it's too late for that now.
Obviously Best Of is mostly for us powerusers who know it's there anyways, but I'm a bit worried about Awards outreach.
13
u/notathrowaway75 https://myanimelist.net/profile/notathrowaway75 Jan 05 '25
Damn it I knew I should've waited for the new Meta Thread. Reposting here for visibility:
Can we please do away with continuous episode numbers entirely? I requested this for My Hero Academia and it's so much better.
Solo Leveling today for example.
It is not season 2 episode 13. It is season 2 episode 1. Crunchyroll's formatting is terrible and should not be followed.
6
u/Holofan4life Jan 07 '25
Why was my Air announcement post removed for no interest thread even though I posted an interest thread?
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/s/IqsScOaGdF
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/s/jyTlESNiXV
6
u/Draco_Estella :Iv::Ix:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Estella_Rin Jan 10 '25
I have to ask this - what is the mod team's stance on posts not in English?
There are times where I do see posts posted in other languages, like what I assume is in Spanish in this instance. Is it possible that we can post stuff without having to post in English?
6
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Jan 19 '25
Why was this post here removed?
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1i4g26w/best_100_anime_of_2024_according_to_ranime_surveys/
6
u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Jan 31 '25
Hey mods, just wanted to throw a suggestion out there:
Can we add rewatch specific flairs that go out to the participants of a given rewatch? Iirc Durin tested it out last year, and I love the idea, I think we should make it permanent.
I mean, if we get flairs for a good chunk of series that happen to air in a given season, then shows that we as a community go out of our way to celebrate and rewatch deserve that love too.
Granted, there would be obvious issues if people abuse that, so it could use some effort/discussion qualifiers.
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Apr 06 '25
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
5
u/wintrywolf :GJ::GK::GL: Jan 05 '25
Each daily thread has a link to the previous one, so why doesn't CDF? I was trying to look through some of the old ones to find best comment contenders but it's very inconvenient without direct links.
5
u/baseballlover723 Jan 11 '25
I think you should add clarification to this rule that characters are not words and that they are letters. I've seen a ton of people try and circumvent this rule and pad their posts with garbage, which makes the post non compliant for essentially no reason.
I'm not sure it'll actually help, as that would require them to read the rules (which we all know that they don't), but even then it would probably clear up a little confusion for people.
5
u/DarkAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkAudit Jan 13 '25
AFAIK, there is no RL legal standard for how many women are required to constitute a harem. What does /r/anime consider to be the minimum guideline for a harem size?
5
u/Komarist https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jan 16 '25
Is there a r/anime awards public nomination predictions post/contest like last year?
5
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
Are the seasonal salt best girl contests still happening? I noticed there wasn't one for Fall 2024
5
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Jan 26 '25
Why did the nominations thread get stickied again?
5
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Feb 01 '25
It appears that Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussion - February 1, 2025 has not defaulted to sorting by new.
9
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Jan 21 '25 edited Jan 21 '25
Why did the nominations infographic get posted on twitter, but not on the sub, where most of us would actually see it??????
4
u/notathrowaway75 https://myanimelist.net/profile/notathrowaway75 Jan 05 '25
I messaged the mods awhile back on a watch order for the Prince of Tennis series. I never got a response so I'll post it here.
https://myanimelist.net/stacks/21304
4
u/Lamprarian Jan 06 '25
This might be a stupid question, or im stupid, but.... Why is there no "episode" filter to only see that flair?
4
u/messem10 https://myanimelist.net/profile/bookkid900 Jan 09 '25
Can we please do away with these cross-post episode discussions?
The whole point of AutoLovepon was to eliminate the rush to post discussion threads and ensure they don’t get deleted when/if OP decides to do so.
Now we have that back with even more confusion.
4
u/messem10 https://myanimelist.net/profile/bookkid900 Jan 10 '25
Episode 2’s discussion for I’m Getting Married to a Girl I Hate In My Class is missing.
4
u/mekerpan Jan 10 '25
I looked everywhere but can't find the ep. 2 discussion thread for "Married to the Girl I Hate".
4
u/ExpiringMilknCheese Jan 11 '25
just like Blue box, i dont think exceptions should be made.
4
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jan 15 '25
Yatta-Tachi's theater screening list under references on the wiki has been updated for 2025.
4
u/Komarist https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jan 23 '25
[Oshi no Ko]Spoiler but not spoiler
4
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Jan 25 '25
I wonder who controls the autolovepon bot, but the Vanguard anime is legally available on Youtube. That could've been added to the "Streams" part.
4
u/ComfortablyRotten https://anilist.co/user/Leuwtian Feb 01 '25
Is yesterday's daily thread being locked a new thing or some kind of error? The previous ones don't seem to be
4
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Feb 02 '25
Quick bit of feedback. I had a comment I made removed from "Kimi to Idol Precure♪ • You and Idol Precure♪ - Episode 1 discussion" with the mod reason given "This belongs in the Source Corner at the top of this thread.".
This is not the most helpful thing to say when there is no source corner to post in.
I made the assumption that elements of unadapted content (there was a live show which partly featured that) which I had spoiler marked very clearly was the mod reason. In any case I have edited that out. My feedback is: clearer instructions I can actually follow in the future.
For example: move paragraph starting with: "PSA" to source corner (or remove if no source corner)
19
u/baseballlover723 Jan 21 '25 edited Jan 21 '25
So the topic of twitter/x is being discussed in a lot of subreddits today (mostly sports subreddits), and I think it's worth at least discussing for r/anime as well. The thing the that would be most affected on r/anime would be news announcements I think. Though I'm not sure exactly how much impact it would have, since it's quite common for major announcements to have multi media components (like a YouTube PV or an official website posting, etc).
Outside of the political aspects of twitter/x, twitter/x's usability for those without an account is just awful now, and I think there is an argument to be made that twitter/x is user hostile enough (or really any auth locked website) to warrant some deincentivisation. Of specific relevance to r/anime, is that when logged out, the translate post button does not work. Which is something that I think is important since many of the twitter/x posts are in Japanese, which many members of the subreddit can't read. You also can't navigate the thread like at all, though I don't think that's really a major issue for the types of posts that are often posted to r/anime.
Personally I think that if there was to be a restriction on user hostile website like twitter/x, it should be in the form of a delay restriction. Something like
links to user hostile / auth locked sites can only be posted 24 hours after originally posted. Content on r/anime is already time gated (clips, and seasonal anime discussion posts), so theirs precedence for moderating like that. And I think it strikes a balance between encouraging alternative, more user friendly websites and not completely locking out twitter/x exclusive news.There is also the possibility that such a deincentivisation could tangibly affect companies decision making on where to post their news, as reddit is a major site in the west and r/anime is the premier anime discussion subreddit. Though I think such a decision should not be made on the basis that it will lead to more widespread change.
Additionally, I think that if this is in serious contention, that the community should be more explicitly brought into the discussion (as I think there is more to this discussion then just what I mentioned), either via a direct meta post (or crosspost) (Edit: preferably not in the next few days, when everyone is still very charged about the situation / prone to brigading etc), or by initiating a community driven poll or discussion at the start of the next meta thread. But lets be real, very few users check the meta thread when it's off the front page. And I think this is a topic that warrants discussion beyond just the mods and/or power users.
7
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Jan 07 '25
Since my message to the mod team appears to have been ignored, I would like to once again - but now publicly - ask why the (official) discussion thread for the 3rd episode of Ameku M.D. hasn't been pulled yet. I don't get it.
I remember from previous rulings that leaks wouldn't be given an official discussion thread. When episodes of Konosuba and Sound Euphonium got leaked last spring, they were labeled as such. I don't believe that the leaks concerning multiple episode of Dandadan and Ranma 1/2, during the summer season, even got discussion threads because of the bad quality.
But taking this case of Ameku M.D. into account, it's supposedly okay if the overall quality of the leak is sufficient enough? So to my understanding this implies that Dandadan and Ranma 1/2 would've gotten official discussion threads, months ahead of their actual releases, if they'd been leaked in a higher resolution?
I simply don't understand the general policy in regard to leaked episodes anymore - if there's even one. Is priority always given to discussion or not? And when does something qualify for an official discussion thread? The mod team, and thereby the subreddit, doesn't seem to be consistent on this.
I also hope that there's a plan ready for Sakamoto Days, which will presumably be facing a similar situation to Blue Box's.
7
u/MiLiLeFa Jan 22 '25
Could the Japanese title of a show be added to the text body of episode discussions?
Not the romaji, which is already present, but whatever kana/kanji is used in Japanese. It would make searching for threads easier, and the major databases all have it available.
9
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jan 05 '25 edited Jan 05 '25
A quick heads-up that the 2024 edition of Best of r/anime should be starting from tomorrow around Noon Eastern time, with voting threads posting daily for ~a week. Pretty much everything will be the same as the 2023 edition; last year's winners can be found here.
Edit: Index Thread here.
And the best of 2023 wiki page will get sorted pretty soon haha so it's all archived nicely, whoops. (and of course the 2024 one will be done a bit more timely).
6
u/baseballlover723 Jan 13 '25 edited Jan 13 '25
I don't think comments like this should be allowed on the subreddit, just because they are directed at people offsite.
11
u/DarkAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkAudit Jan 26 '25
As Elon descends further and further into Rule 2 madness, and the denials get harder and harder to defend, the more I support a ban on twitter links. So what if "Japan likes it." That's a THEM problem. It should be up to the user here to find an alternative link, such as bsky, ANN, pixiv, etc. Otherwise too bad. Inertia is no excuse.
3
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Jan 09 '25
Noticed in the daily thread someone was having problem finding the "post filters" as in "Search for: Episode Discussions".
It seems the problem is on new/sh reddit. These used to be on the right side but now they're gone completely? (ofc, on old reddit they're the drop down at the top)
Don't know if anything can be done about that as I use old reddit and I also don't know if there's a way to encourage users to use old reddit for better navigation features, general readability and fun like the comment faces (however, I'm just a user so have not paid attention to see if that kind of thing is forbidden for subreddits to do).
3
u/steven4869 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maskirade Jan 11 '25
Mods, are you going to do any 12M celebratory post or a quiz related to it?
3
u/Wimbledofy Jan 12 '25
Stop censoring comments that even mention the word manga or source please and thank you.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
should there be an automoderator comment (or message) if you link the anime piracy subreddit similarly if you link pirated websites? rn it gets filtered out and the poster would have to check if their comment is visible to others.
3
u/daIIiance Jan 18 '25
So is a mod or bot gonna cross post the Sakamoto Days episode 2 thread? Like what’s been happening for blue box? Feel like episode 2 is what most people would watch today and it’d be helpful to at least see the thread.
3
u/mekerpan Jan 31 '25
I can't find a discussion thread for ep 5 of Married to the Girl I hate...
5
u/Mitsuyan_ https://anilist.co/user/mitsuyan Jan 08 '25
On Ameku M.D.
This was a weird one as the 'mod' * who deleted the dupe thread. The way that AutoLovepon sets off at the moment meant that episode 3 and a duplicate thread went out early. The duplication issue should now be fixed.
On "Should I Watch" Threads
I hate these. Just watch the damn anime instead of asking for random people's validations. If you don't like it then you're free to drop it at any time. I do now think it is time to ban these. They add nothing to the subreddit other than clog.
On Industry Quotes
As individual threads they should be banned as they can be misleading. Using DD or the episode thread should be fine though IMO as it lets people find out what they actually mean without causing a mass panic that, say, 100 Girlfriends has fallen apart. I think it's good that we can get clarification and ask probing questions but not everything needs its own thread.
On Common Threads
This came up with N7CombatWombat earlier. We don't need 'hot take' threads every other day. I think it's time to consolidate these into weekly/monthly threads and let people run riot, where mods can run things like Contest Mode or different sorts to make sure all of the unpopular/hot takes are seen and given a chance to be up or downvoted without dogpiling. We saw it in a recent thread where anyone who dared not put Frieren et al among their best were downvoted. Maybe we can use different sorts in different places, one for the mods to discuss I would think?
On External Views
Most of us have seen THAT ANN blog at this point which might have put out the least informed take I've ever seen on this subreddit. I love that we can share our opinions on different anime but all views should be hosted internally. I do not think that randombloke69 or randomblog420 really has use having their viewpoints here - it just descends into "why's Frieren not #1 it's peak" or "L didn't put Dandadan top 10" to paraphrase how those threads tend to go. My view, to be short, is that any opinion or ranking thread should be a text post and not an external link, and not the result of random site polls. I think discussing it here would help me clarify my point.
I think that's about everything I have to say on the sub at the moment, it sounds negative but there's a lot of good stuff going on too - plenty of good discussion, infographics and so much more. It's a good place to come and a damn sight better than most other anime discussion boards.
Quick one on the discord mods: we changed our colour to yellow
* I'm not a sub mod as you've gathered by me talking here. I do however have access to AutoLovepon but only use it for anime episodes and when no other mod is around, I couldn't imagine being enough of a dick to abuse that
2
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Jan 12 '25
I’m a little confused: why did the discussion thread for Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun get posted that early (more than 8 hours). It shouldn’t have been out yet on any service, right?
2
u/baseballlover723 Jan 19 '25
I think this should also include wording for asking for pirate sites (like this post, though it's far from the only one and is no way extraordinary). Really there's just no other answer then to link to the sidebar (at least when it's phrased in general, asking for a specific anime is I think distinct from this), so they might as well just get removed and include a link to the sidebar in the removal message or something like that.
Not that it'll really reduce the number of these posts, but I'm pretty sure it's already being enforced like this (with these obvious pirate site asking questions being removed). I just think it'll be (theoretically) more clear with it explicitly mentioned in the rules.
4
u/risarnchrno Jan 18 '25
The inability to discuss or upvote current WORLDWIDE release episodes for shows is getting to be annoying. An episode shouldn't have any discussion posts without an available worldwide source (aka non-VPN source) this is effectively killing discussion on series like Blue Box and Sakamoto Days because Netflix's current contract with its studio is STUPID.
5
u/LunarieReverie Jan 05 '25
Monthly request to remove/rename #vollybearq.
2
u/daIIiance Jan 11 '25
So is the cross post thing gonna happen next week when Sakamoto Days Ep 2 comes to US Netflix? Also does the karma from the cross post also count along with the original post karma? I noticed the cross posts usually have a few hundred points.