r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Feb 05 '23
Meta Meta Thread - Month of February 05, 2023
Rule Changes
Fanart
- Users may now make Fanart posts two times per week rather than one time per week.
- Videos that are fan-created content (e.g. fan animations, drawing time-lapses, and music covers) are now allowed to be posted as link posts using the Fanart flair. They must still follow the other Video rules including being at least a minute in length.
- Music covers now fall under the Fanart flair rather than Video as they had previously.
Moderator Applications Open Later This Month
- We will be opening moderator applications on February 26. Applications will be open for two weeks.
A monthly meta thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: January 2023 | December 2022 | November 2022 | October 2022 | September 2022 | August 2022 | July 2022 | June 2022 | May 2022 | April 2022 | March 2022 | February 2022 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/GallowDude Feb 05 '23
January Mod Report
Ongoing Discussions
January by the Numbers
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Mar 13 '23
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
13
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Feb 20 '23
The new seasonal faces have changed over. You can see them all on the wiki page. Or this image here.
We have listened and heard you want some of your favorites back. We have brought back a single face from each previous seasons. We will continue 'hall of faming' a seasonal face as long as there is a suitable candidate and CSS space to do so.
During the Celebrating 15 years of /r/anime! announcement thread we snuck in a hover text form to submit a comment face. We had a handful of submissions and from those we have added:
#michaelwink
Finally, as mentioned in the seasonal nomination thread we also want to fill in several missing niches, we have some categories in mind and we know you will have great ideas as well. Next month we will have an open submissions period where we will be asking for your thoughts on missing niches and faces that fit them.
11
u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Feb 05 '23
For anyone interested the bounty board for suggesting new flairs will close in a week. We've had a bunch of flair suggestions (over 100) which is a pretty good turnout. Not all of them are viable and we still need to vote on them but its cool to see what the community can come up with.
I am currently prepping for the next bounty board. Do you guys have any suggestions for categories? Things I'm looking for in suggestions.
Of course, put down whatever ideas you think would be good! The worst I can say is no.
Thanks to anyone who submitted a flair. It was fun seeing the diverse flairs chosen and some of you guys got really creative! There's a couple of really good ones in there that I'm excited to possibly see out in the wild.
9
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Feb 05 '23
So the trial for hiding comment scores passed by and ended a few days ago. A few people gave their thoughts in the previous thread (thank you!) but asking about it again for folks that weren't checking in regularly:
One thing to note (based on already given feedback) is that it's a subreddit-wide setting and not something that we can turn on or off for individual threads.
8
u/Verzwei Feb 05 '23 edited Feb 05 '23
So if anyone's wondering what's up with the fanart changes, I can provide a little more detail.
On a personal level, it always struck me as odd that "musical covers", despite being a fan creation, operated under an entirely different (and far, far less restricted) set of rules from the rest of video-format fan-made content, like time-lapse drawings.
From what we could dig into it, the cover exception in the music rules originally happened because, at one point, the music rules themselves were extremely strict, and music-related posts were almost entirely prohibited. The cover exception was carved out so that covers could be posted at all.
Then, separately from all that, the big change to switch Fanart from link/upload posts to text posts occurred. Since covers were previously moved out of the fanart rules and into the music rules, they sort-of got "glossed over" by the text post changes. They were fan-made content but not governed by the fanart rules, so when fanart rules got tighter, covers were still afforded way more freedom.
A while back, we had a vote to move covers back into Fanart. This would have added severe restrictions (1/week instead of 2/week, would have to be externally hosted and linked in the body of a text post) to covers to bring them back in line with other Fanart. That vote failed.
Ultimately, the goal was consistency, to treat covers the same as other fan-made content. So then we started talking about trying to swing the pendulum the other way: Instead of adding restrictions to covers, what if we loosened restrictions on other videos of fan-made content?
While we certainly do fear the idea of fanart taking over the subreddit, which is why the text post requirement was put into place, there are tons (upon tons) of external sites and other communities that give artists options for image hosting and would allow for text linking here. Comparatively, there are a lot fewer places to host videos, making it harder for artists to share their video-based content with us at all if we prohibit direct uploads. Additionally, our other video rules (namely the duration requirement and preclusion of TikTok) should help cut out most of the "low-hanging" types of video fanart, such as short, minimally edited .gifs and the like.
8
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Feb 05 '23
Seasonal Comment Face Survey.
You can see results are here.
7
u/Verzwei Feb 13 '23
Hey all. As some of you may or may not know, our subreddit currently uses automoderation tools to prohibit accounts less than 7 days old from posting on the subreddit. Those accounts can still freely comment in existing threads, and we've normally had the policy of allowing new users to send us a modmail for manual review and approval of a post within that 7-day window. This is a preemptive measure to help cut down on bot and brigade posts on the subreddit, but also has a somewhat handy bonus since new users are the ones most-likely to break our post content rules or guidelines.
A couple months back, Reddit implemented a new feature that allows us to configure automod to filter posts by the user's comment and/or post karma specifically on our subreddit. Karma-based tools existed prior to this, but it only tracked Reddit-wide karma.
Once in a while, discussion pops up about the concept of "self promotion" or accounts that routinely do nothing but swing by to post a link to their own content but then never otherwise engage with the community here in any other threads.
With the new ability to filter posts by karma activity on our subreddit, we're thinking of changing up how our new-user experience works. So, here's the pitch:
We already have an internal vote active to trial this, but the trial is scheduled to start in March. We wanted to collect feedback before we proceeded with a (relatively lengthy) trial to see whether or not people like the idea.
The goal here is to still catch obvious bots and brigades while also creating a low and easy-to-clear barrier for posts here, regardless of account age, to hopefully filter out a few of the "drive by" style of self-promotion, bait, or troll posts from people who otherwise never engage with our community.
6
u/Nebresto Feb 07 '23
I was browsing some rewatch interest threads through reddit search, and noticed only a couple of them had an image thumbnail, and the rest were the usual rewatch default.
Even starting the post with an image sometimes resulted in the default thumbnail, but all of /u/Badspler's posts for example had an image. Does selecting the 'Rewatch' flair in the submit screen predetermine what type of thumbnail gets applied?
10
u/Theleux https://myanimelist.net/profile/Theleux Feb 07 '23
Has there been any discussion surrounding the kinds of content being shared/ enabled that largely results in perpetuating incorrect knowledge within the community - ie. misinformation?
Chainsaw Man's recent revelations regarding its lack of "success" has been a hot topic of late, especially due to how heavily it was marketed and talked about leading up to its release.
These threads have largely been perpetuating old norms pertaining to the industry (specifically bluray sales), such as how revenue is made for studios or IPs in general, which are wholy outdated and have been attempted to be disproven through efforts by individuals actually involved with or knowledgeable about the anime industry as a whole. The current misconceptions and lack of understanding painted as truthful and factual information has helped promote some largely negative response. General engagements have shifted heavily towards being more validation attempts for people that seem to be bitter towards the fans of the series/ how much word of mouth it was generating, as well as contributing towards rather dismissive and approaching moderately toxic discussion.
I'd like to request, if it hasn't already been discussed, that it be looked into- with more of an effort into dissuading this kind of misinformation from being given ground to continue developing and spreading throughout the community.
This extends beyond just this instance, there is a lot of information that still gets repeated constantly that has been disproven for years, but those same takes end up being sent up to the top of comment threads/ the subreddit front page.
5
u/baquea Feb 05 '23
When will seasonal comment face nominations open? The season is nearly halfway over already, whereas I thought that previous rounds had happened earlier.
5
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Feb 10 '23
I'd really appreciate it if mods would at least reply to a comment they remove with why it gets removed. It's impossible to know why that happened unless a reason is given. Additionally, it's really annoying to have comments disappear silently without any notification.
5
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Feb 15 '23
Retiring is just a fancier word for ban.
Seems like a bad way to take r/anime. These overdone topics just need better moderated.
5
u/r4wrFox Feb 25 '23
Can we ban the word "woke" and anyone who frequently starts conversations/threads with it?
Bc I don't think a single worthwhile discussion has ever happened starting from a comment like this. Even the loli/shota discourse has more inherent value, and that is something the subreddit has done away with for a while. Shit just gets exhausting.
9
u/cppn02 Feb 07 '23
Can we ban Chainsaw Man Blu-Ray sales discussions?
4
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Feb 05 '23
I have two points regarding Best of /r/anime, one question and one correction.
Q) What, precisely, is the functional difference between Best Original Essay and Best Original Review? It feels to me like "reviews" in the traditional sense, I.e. consumer reporting, emphasis on value judgement over analysis, final score I.e. thumbs up/down or number/10, are not only somewhat antiquated in general, they nor even just posts labeled by their author as "reviews" don't really have a presence on this sub in any form, at least not in the time I've been here. Everything I saw nominated this year would have been just as at home under Best Original Essay, which makes me wonder, would it not be a good idea to consider just consolidating the two categories into just Essay? My only reservation in suggesting this is the risk of less quality content being rewarded in the end, which would be sad, but the category as is feels confusing and perfunctory to me.
C) On the Nominations Wiki, it lists me as having nominated all of Short and Sweet Sundays for Best Original Essay; while they're all quality posts that deserve it, that nomination was for Myrna's Bocchi the Rock! series of SaSS posts specifically (aside from the A Place post which was obviously a separate nomination, listed correctly). I realize that's probably a linking nightmare so I'm sorry for that but yeah
4
u/Nebresto Feb 11 '23
I noticed some great shows from this season lacking seasonal flair availability, so I would like to request 2, or more flairs so I and others can rep our favourite characters.
Lafa from Handyman Saitou, and Lulu or Zabuton from Nonbiri nouka. I have gone ahead and prepared potential images so its less work if one of you moderinos decides to be kind
Lafa one & two, Lulu one & two and Zabuton one & two
4
u/entelechtual Feb 21 '23
What is the opinion on tasteful memes/light anime related shitposting in the daily thread?
4
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Feb 22 '23 edited Feb 22 '23
Just noticed that this survey post was deleted for containing personal information.
With the premise that I agree with the removal for various reasons, there is no rule about this (I don't think there are site-wide rules about posting your own information either): is it a general guideline, or was it because the user claims to be in high school hence (likely) a minor? Or because they posted a bit too much personal information?
My actual comment actually wanted to be about surveys in general lol. Besides the seasonal surveys and occasional Fetch surveys we don't get many, but quite a few of them are a google form with a bunch of user info questions (generally age, gender, nationality and/or ethnicity) and a bunch of survey questions of varying quality.
Do you think there should be some guidelines or we simply don't get enough to be worth, just leave it to user discretion?
I'm mostly thinking about surveys collecting sensitive and/or personal information: academic research or anything goes, must disclose purpose or not, must have information about data treatment (and if so, having some contact info for who - person or organisation/etc - is responsible) or not, etc.
4
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Feb 25 '23
did we have mods join for the Adopt-an-Admin program? i think i probably saw one of them in CDF yesterday.
4
u/hehaaw Feb 25 '23
I had comment deleted by automod because it had link to novelupdates, the reason being novelupdates considered as site that host pirated content. As far as everyone know does host not any fan translation on their site, they only provide the link to the translator sites. Does hosting link to other site considered as hosting pirated contents?
4
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Feb 28 '23 edited Feb 28 '23
Just a quick heads-up that is misspelt in the categorised commentfaces as
#angeryvampireinstead of#angryvampire, both the commentface itself and the label(it is correct in the main and source pages)
7
u/r4wrFox Feb 14 '23
Something that crossed my mind with the recent thread of banning overdone topics is an idea FetchFrosh brought up about a month ago about a "Serious Discussion" flair.
With the reluctance people have to completely limit these overdone topics, I think there may be interest in separating between casual and serious discussion threads, w/ stricter posting requirements for a serious discussion thread (character/word count minimum, karma requirement, new user limits, etc.) applied both to the main post and comments.
I mentioned mod overhead concerns at the time and I'm still not 100% sure that it'll work or have an impact either way, but I think it'd be a more popular way of incentivizing better discussions rather than just limiting bad/overdone threads. May also provide a basis for interested newer users to see what a "good" discussion thread might look like, as oppose to "Name a Show" threads like these (1, 2).
3
u/Tarhalindur x2 Feb 05 '23
So, something I've been idly curious about for a little while now: is it at all technically possible to have a Source Material Corner in a rewatch? Most don't need it, but I've been idly eyeing a rewatch of a work that is a notoriously terrible adaptation of its source a ways down the line and if I go for it I'm trying to figure out a way to split the difference between "allow the source readers to go into great glorious detail on exactly how this is a bad adaptation" and not spoiling the source material for any participants who go in without have read it and who want to experience it unspoiled for themselves.
3
u/DarkestAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/darkaudit Feb 05 '23
That hidden comment face submission form in the 15th anniversary post has nothing to do with seasonal comment faces, right?
Right?
3
u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Feb 06 '23
A rules question, as I found the rules for this to be worded a bit unclearly...if I commission a piece of original anime related art and want to post it here, is one piece ok, or do I have to have 4+ images?
3
u/Darraya55 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Darraya55 Feb 11 '23
While reading the rules of this subreddit I saw there's a no memes rule but when I tried to make a post I saw among the flairs was a meme flair so which way is it?
3
u/DarkestAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/darkaudit Feb 15 '23
So can you confirm that Bot-chan will no longer nuke posts that use the spoiler tags as instructed on the sidebar? For the longest time, she'd kill anything that had the space between the ] and the >.
3
u/Bielna https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bielna Feb 23 '23 edited Feb 23 '23
What report reason should we use for toxic comments ? Looking at the report reasons, "targeted harassment at someone else" would seem to be the best pick, but to be honest I want my reports to go to the mod team, not the admins. A lot of comments would be removed by mods for toxicity, but don't break sitewides.
Should we use that one anyway, the freeform report, or something else ?
3
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Feb 26 '23
If you aren't currently watching the awards stream then go do that! But once it's finished mod apps are open as scheduled.
3
u/Ashteron Mar 02 '23
Are copyright watermarks that can be seen for example in the official Crunchyroll channel with short clips compliant with the no watermarks rule for the clip posts? Example (bottom right).
4
u/polaristar Feb 05 '23
On a more positive Note, a friendly suggestion:
Next Anime Award instead of bringing Sci Fi Back, why not make a category called "Speculative Fiction" where we group Sci Fi, Fantasy, Horror, Alt History, etc in one cat.
What would distinguish it from Adventure and a Bunch of Isekai's and Isekai adjacent is whether a huge focus of the work is meant as some kind of conceptual idea porn and "What if" scenarios as oppose to what is often either a Power Fantasy or Slice of Life Work Sim with a Dragon Quest coat of paint.
That and Suspense I think should just be removed as a whole tbh.
2
u/Castor_0il Feb 05 '23
Ah, guess posting the shorts from Gensho Yasuda are a no-no. But I kinda understand that it's all about filling short stories rather than what would be considered quick vines.
2
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Feb 15 '23
want a quick reminder to the mods that the Kaguya movie has screened in North America today: an episode thread is i think in order.
2
u/OwlAcademic1988 Mar 01 '23 edited Mar 01 '23
Why was this comment removed? I did everything correctly. The bot says there were spaces when there isn't any.
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/11fl3f8/comment/jajw1rv/?context=3
2
u/Samy_Ninja_Pro Mar 04 '23
My post was removed, it was about anime conventions
2
u/Cryten0 Feb 28 '23
I am curious why on old reddit we are no longer using the replacement thumbnail for NSFW flagged content. Are we treating loading into r/anime as a NSFW experience now?
2
u/polaristar Feb 05 '23 edited Feb 05 '23
A complaint I have is that the mods have been too gun-hoe about the spoiler policy lately, often removing things that are NOT spoilers, getting onto people that are newcomers but just too good at guessing the plot that don't proclaim they are newcomers, original Art vs Anime comparisons. (Which is stupid since they are links to a picture outside the site anyone that could be "spoiled" would have to click on it of their own volition anyway.) And sometimes if minor spoilers are posted they are properly tagged but still removed, once again leaving it up the users if they want to be spoiled.
I can't help notice it might be since we hired new mods and they want to feel out and get use to their authority.
Anyway I believe some spoiler policies that are clear (Like the Manga vs Anime art comparisons) Shouldn't count as spoilers, spoilers properly tagged even outside source corner in response to a comment should not be touched, speculation that seems too accurate for smart or experienced newcomers should be left alone etc.
But most of all, if we are going to continue with this, the spoiler policy should be made very black and white and clear what counts as a spoiler rather than based on the whims of the mods, because many things I'd consider completely innocuous have been warned, removed, and temp banned.
Not just me, but people I talk to, as well as lately catching strangers being mod hammered in real time for what appears to be nothings.
Until these are addressed I will post this comment Metathread, and I encourage anyone else that feels the same to give your own grievances on these threads, as well as comment your complaints/experience below. Maybe make a screenshot album and post it of any time you feel you were unfairly mod hammered. Here in the Meta. (Spoiler tagged of course)
;)
If this gets any traction I plan on compiling it as an ever growing album.
Am I butthurt that I got temp banned, yes your damn right I am and many other people aren't happy but either are afraid or have accepted it. If you feel you don't deserve it you SHOULD feel upset.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '23
[removed] — view removed comment