r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Nov 06 '22
Meta Meta Thread - Month of November 06, 2022
A monthly meta thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Rule Changes
We Are Trialing Some Changes
- Starting November 9, we will trial disabling post thumbnails. This trial will run for two weeks.
- We are trying out the moderation bot /u/BotDefense for the month of November.
Fanart
- "AI-generated artwork" has been added to our list of low-effort prohibited content.
Moderator Applications Open Later This Month
- We will be opening moderator applications on November 27. Applications will be open for two weeks.
Previous meta threads: October 2022 | September 2022 | August 2022 | July 2022 | June 2022 | May 2022 | April 2022 | March 2022 | February 2022 | January 2022 | December 2021 | Find All
Next meta thread: December 2022 | Find All
•
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Nov 06 '22
October Mod Report
Voted to have a two week trial period where post thumbnails are disabled, starting from November 9. [Vote Passed]
Voted to add "AI-generated artwork" to low effort rules. [Vote Passed]
Voted to hold open mod applications for two weeks starting on November 27. [Vote Passed]
Voted if the CSS post filters should be removed? [Vote Passed]
Ongoing Discussions
October by the Numbers
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Dec 07 '22
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
19
u/Ponkool4 Nov 06 '22
Thanks for all that you do to keep this community running!
If I may offer my two cents: I really enjoy seeing the key visuals and they're the main way that I find out about upcoming anime. For instance, I never would would have watched Lycoris Recoil if I hadn't been interested by the key visual. So losing the thumbnails will be a bit of an inconvenience for me.
19
u/TobiasAmaranth https://myanimelist.net/profile/TobiasAmaranth Nov 10 '22
Strong dislike. I feel like my quick-glance browsing for news on upcoming/new series is strongly hampered by this choice. It'd be nice if it could be selective based on flair, such as disabling it for clips and text posts I guess, but since that's likely not possible, the loss of KeyVisuals and new anime trailers is negatively impacting my news-searching techniques.
14
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Nov 27 '22
We have made some small changes to two animated comment faces, reducing the number of frames they have.
#shakeit And #floweryhug
Shakeit has gone from five short bangs then three long bangs to just two short and two long. While Floweryhug now has less lingering flower bedazzling post hug.
Previously each of these comment faces took up an entire stylesheet image which reddit limits to only 50 of. The shortening of these two comment faces lets them now fit in single image together, freeing up one image for other uses. A huge thanks to /u/vaclav_2012 for continuing to help out and keep quality high.
This additional space offers some capacity to add a few more static comment faces. My current thinking is expanding out the number of seasonal faces. If you have any suggestions for a face category, please post them below. Some that have been mentioned to me in the past are: Blush, eating/drinking, cup/mug.
Additionally if you can think of a specific niche that isn't captured by one of the many existing faces, we would love to hear it.
12
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Nov 06 '22
Okay, so about user (CSS) flairs again.
We spent a large part of past month thinking about and discussing this even after the discussions in the meta thread waned. Unfortunately there isn't a perfect way forward that makes everyone happy, otherwise it would have been fairly straightforward to go for it, so we haven't decided on any changes yet.
From my perspective in particular and trying to take into account everyone's viewpoint here's the current slate of issues with custom CSS flairs, the process of removing them, and possible alternatives, such as similar unique native flairs:
Technical problems:
:MOD::AL:Durinthal • Myne's #2 fan) but imperfect.Community problems:
Mod problems:
Now any particular change will run into one or more of the above problems, and specifically there's a choice to be made between using CSS flairs or native flairs where half of the technical issues listed above will apply to either. Asking for "both" as an option is substantially more work for us to support them together without losing the flaws of either and leads to some weird issues in trying to decide how to handle them for a given user (e.g. they could add or remove their native flair at will which could look bad if it's seen in conjunction with the CSS one).
Another thing we've never settled on is how to manage granting and revoking flairs which had zero regulation to this point and is largely where all three of the mod issues listed above stem from because our view on flairs as the mod team (overall) has shifted over time and is currently rather nebulous. If we could all agree that flairs are meant to be a little bit of extra color and fun sprinkled throughout /r/anime, not necessarily something that's earned and is now yours to keep as long as you're here, then maybe we can find a way forward to keep them around in some form.
12
u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Nov 06 '22
I think taking measures to encourage more "high value" content (reviews, well thought out discussion, etc) is good. That said I'm skeptical that getting rid of thumbnails will move the needle. But nothing wrong with a trial!
12
u/notathrowaway75 https://myanimelist.net/profile/notathrowaway75 Nov 16 '22
Begging and pleading and crying to stop making My Hero Academia episode discussion titles so annoying. I do not care that Crunchyroll makes them like that or whatever other reason there is. The latest episode is season 6 episode 7. Not episode 120. At the very least include it in the body.
21
u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman Nov 11 '22
I'm not a big fan of the removal of thumbnails. It feels like it's attempting to address a problem (discussion posts not doing well) by making everything else less interesting rather than by attempting to do something to improve those posts. And all that's doing is making r/anime less interesting overall which will likely lead to even less engagement with the discussion posts.
9
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Nov 06 '22
Just a reminder to the mods that the rewatch wiki page is still used and could use more frequent updates. E.g. right now, neither Grenadier, nor Quintessential Quintuplets are listed, despite starting today/tomorrow.
9
u/baseballlover723 Nov 09 '22
Can we ban posts that are mostly just a redirect to a simple blog post or website? Basically posts that more or less have a generic title, body text that doesn't really precisely describe what the linked content is about, and then a link. Most of these posts are just people looking to plug their own blog site (which I don't have a problem with if theres substantial information there), but usually its dead simple stuff that would function better as an inline discussion on reddit.
An example of a post like this would be https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/yq9atw/daily_anime_recap_071122_081122/. The title tells me very little about the linked content. The body description of the content basically boils down to its some sort of a recap (of what you'll have to click and find out). And then is followed by twice the amount of text unrelated to the content (feedback about their writing).
Again, I'm not opposed to completely removing links to blog posts and the like, but I think there should be, for the most part, reserved for content that heavily features inline images or video (and is essential to content) or is of substantial length. Basically something that would be unwieldy to convert into a reddit post. Also the body text for these types of posts should make it pretty clear what the content is of the link without needing to click on it, and ideally should have some sort of prompting to discuss parts of it (I don't think this really works on all types of posts though).
I'm starting to get kinda sick of these low effort plugs.
8
u/Castor_0il Nov 22 '22
I'm wondering what's the Mod's stance towards "the race" to post the ED or OP of seasonal shows before it even airs in their streaming sites.
Probably OP's are fine since they don't change so often. But in cases like Chainsaw Man that each episode will have a different ED, I do feel that it spoils us the anime only audience, even with just the ED title.
https://old.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/z1wggp/chainsaw_man_ending_7_all_kinds_of_kisses_by_ano/
Clips have the rule to wait a whole week before being allowed to be posted. I'm not saying that EDs should have to wait a week, but at the very least wait until the episode is out on their responding streaming site.
7
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Nov 07 '22
The seasonal comment faces have rolled over. Thanks to everyone who made nominations.
Once again a panel of mods rated all 540 image nominations, then the highest were selected.
The image's source shows are here.
7
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Nov 16 '22 edited Nov 16 '22
If you use old Reddit, you'll probably have noticed that flairs got a bit taller. It'll probably look weird at first, but we're trying it out for the moment. Let us know what you think!
Edit: For now we're reverting back to the smaller size. We're going to be playing around with flairs a fair bit in the future, so don't be surprised if we jump the size again at some point. Appreciate all the feedback!
7
u/bernasxd :Gi:Gj:Gk:Gl::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bernas3000 Nov 16 '22
Seems like the comment face source wiki page needs an update on who to contact, and why no new comment faces are being made (which is outdated info).
All 3 are no longer mods so I'm not sure if the team wouldn't prefer to redirect people to modmail instead? Although, nobody ever contacted anyone over that page so maybe it's irrelevant either way lol.
6
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Nov 16 '22
I like the changes to post flairs that have given most of them a standard width. Makes it much easier to read titles and absorb what type of post they are all at once
This has been addressed by others but I don't like removing the thumbnails for reasons already said, namely making it hard to know what type of post is what and if it's a link I even want to click on. I just stopped clicking on anything and then turned them back on in my own settings instead
6
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Nov 22 '22
Requesting episode thread for Tonikawa Seifuku, which is currently available on Crunchyroll
6
u/Ponkool4 Nov 27 '22
The thumbnails are back—hooray! It's so much easier to find visuals for upcoming series now. This is how I discover shows for next season.
5
u/captainAwesomePants Nov 23 '22
I'm assuming r/anime strictly for stuff produced in Japan. But I've started watching "The Daily Life of the Immortal King" on Crunchyroll, and it's funny and I'd like to discuss it. Is there a subreddit for non-Japanese shows? I checked r/donghua, but it seems pretty dead.
4
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Nov 10 '22
just giving a bit of feedback re: the thumbnails being gone, i can't say I'm a fan of the change even though I understand where you guys are coming from.
but, given how i using old reddit have already switched back to the "old appearance", if it actually does achieve the desired effect of more discussion and what not, then keeping it might not be a bad thing!
just as an fyi, i like them thumbnails because I also have Imagus, and so I can easily enlarge them thumbnails and can look at key visuals and what not without properly clicking into the link straight from the front page.
4
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Nov 24 '22
So, I kinda liked the experiment with the removed thumbnails. It felt nice to just browse the sub without feeling screamed at to check this out or to check that out. But I wanted to reserve judgement until they return.
And yeah, now that they're back they're really not a big deal. I think the standardization of the flairs helped a ton with that as well, as they put some consistent not-quite-empty space between the thumbnails and the titles. As it is right now seems close to optimal to me.
4
u/Stoppels Nov 28 '22
I think the bot was set to stop after episode 26 of Chiikawa. We're now at episode 35.
7
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Nov 09 '22 edited Nov 11 '22
As mentioned in the body of the post we're now started the trial of disabling thumbnails for posts.
If you use old reddit you can override the subreddit's settings through your personal preferences and select "Show thumbnails next to links".
We've already seen a couple of comments against it and that's exactly why we're running this as a trial, we aren't yet sure we want it ourselves but would like to see what it does to the front page.
3
u/phantomthiefkid_ Nov 09 '22
So have you guys turned off thumbnails yet? I'm still seeing them on new Reddit and official app
3
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Nov 11 '22
Apparently the no-thumbnails trial has started but thumbnails haven’t disappeared for me? Still there both on desktop (with RES) and mobile (without RES), both using old Reddit. It seems to be working for most others so I assume the issue is on my end somehow, but I’m curious as to how that could be the case and if it is for anyone else?
3
u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Nov 15 '22
There is one more option to deal with the thumbnail issue: Instead of removing them from everybody else, start adding them to the discussion posts.
I know that if you have any link in your post to an image, then that image would become a thumbnail (I don't know when this was implemented). Maybe try and make an automatic thumbnail? So if you have a show name or a character name in a discussion thread, you get an automatic thumbnail of that show/character. You can use a pre-defined source for these, like they use in the best girl contest.
So if you have a post saying "Konosuba is just hilarious!!" you'd have the picture from MAL for Konosuba se1 pop up. Or if you have one saying "Megumin is actually a really deep character, here's 5000 words why", again you take her picture from MAL or wherever.
You can have a closed list of anime titles and characters and I think it will be good enough for 90+% of shows talked about here.
3
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Nov 22 '22
[]Is this intended to go through?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22
Could we get episode threads for the Kage-Jitsu shorts, please?
3
u/Leonature26 Nov 25 '22
Apparently uploading old anime clips that has 4:3 ratio breaks this sub's rules cuz reddit automatically puts black bars on the side. The only way around it is cropping or stretching the pixels to fit the 19:6 ratio(either way degrading the integrity of the clip). Is there any chance this black bar rule can be ammended for old anime with 4:3 ratios?
3
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Nov 28 '22
I use RES to preview my posts so I usually don't trigger automod, but sometimes I miss a broken spoiler that looks like plain text to my eyes.
People who don't have RES are in even worse shape, who have to parse their input or binary search to find the error!
Almost certainly not feasible and/or a waste of space, but what if there was something in the row of stuff under the text box that says "Bot-Chan likes me?" that ran the post through some of the same regexes and gave an approval?
Can't remember who manages the regexes, /u/durinthal I think?
3
u/bbqboiAF Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22
For the love of god, please increase ban minimums for improperly tagged spoilers, or lack thereof, in general. That shit is rampant in CSM and probably other popular weekly anime episode discussion threads.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '22
Repeating the request for discussion threads for the Kage-Jitsu shorts. They post to YT, so will the bot find them as it's currently set?
7
u/TheHammer34 Nov 06 '22
Great changes! Especially regarding AI content and the addition of BotDefense.
6
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Nov 10 '22
Reading through the comments on that announcement for The Marginal Service, and thinking of some recent threads about shoujo and BL, I can't help but think that the sexist and homophobic gatekeeping in this subreddit is a bigger impediment to quality discussion posts than preview images. Any post about anime that isn't targeted to a specific kind of straight bro attracts a whole host of hostility.
5
u/Egavans https://anidb.net/user/Egavans99 Nov 06 '22
Since basically every sub I'm subscribed to has joined the Great AI Fanart Banwave of 2022, can anyone point me to subreddits/forums where it is allowed?
2
u/cppn02 Nov 25 '22
Day 3 of still having no episode discussion for the new Tonikawa special.
2
u/entelechtual Nov 30 '22
I don’t think this has been enforced or reported that often, but can we be more lax about the formatting for spoilers?
Specifically the need to specific the name of the source material in the tag. A lot of the times it is pretty self evident and contextual. Like if someone responds to a thread about favorite fantasy anime with a comment about “What do you do at the end of the world? Are you busy? Will you save us?” and if there weren’t a handy or well known abbreviation/nickname, it would be enough to reply to that with [anime spoilers] or [light novel spoilers] or [episode 6 spoilers] instead of typing out the name of the show. Given that that is the only show referenced in the original comment. This happened to me recently with “More than a married couple but less than lovers” which had a shorthand (FuuKoi) but I’d make the case that this abbreviation is so unknown that it would provide less context than just saying [episode 8 spoilers]. Similar for shows like RikeKoi or other shows where there is a long title but the English name is more familiar to anime viewers than the Japanese shorthand.
Some context is needed of course, like you can’t just comment in an anime thread and say [spoilers] and talk about the manga that’s unadapted. Or talk about a different anime. But I think the point of the tag should be so that people who want to click on the spoiler will know what to expect, and don’t accidentally get spoiled on something unintentionally.
I think the standard should be by default to mention the anime name or medium in the tag, unless it’s mentioned in the comment already or is self-evident from the context of the comment/thread.
Again, I think this is kind of the de facto way the tags get used as is. But with the way the rules are written currently I always get worried if I don’t say the name in the tag that it’ll be considered improperly tagged spoilers…
2
u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Dec 01 '22
The episode 25 links in the JoJo chart (in the megathread and later episodes) are linking to episode 24 instead.
3
u/RobotiSC https://anilist.co/user/Lonebot Nov 13 '22 edited Nov 13 '22
I would like to bring up something regarding sources for visuals. This is a concern especially considering this new Attack on Titan visual: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/ytz0ve/attack_on_titan_final_season_new_key_visual/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
Although the 'source' is claimed to be from the official website, the quality between that and the one posted does not match up.
In addition, the 'source' given also only leads to the website homepage itself, and not the image link specifically, which is this: https://shingeki.tv/final/img/home/visual_07.webp. This might be a lesser point to bring up, but it's still quite relevant to this.
So, my suggestion is that regarding visuals, if what is posted does not match the same quality of the source given, or the link is not specific enough, it should be considered a leak and should therefore be removed.
The reason why I'm bringing the possibility of a leak up is because a well-known leaker had leaked the AOT visual a few minutes before the official announcement, and the quality of that image from their tweet matches up with the one posted on the sub.
I hope some action can be taken about this. Thank you.
4
u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Nov 16 '22
Do we really need a post for an episode preview? For example CSM now had 3 different posts on the front page - a preview, an episode discussion, and an ED post. Seems excessive.
I think local subs can have episodes previews while r/anime will keep the major discussion only.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '22
Can the anime recommendation bot be made to trigger a bit less? It is like on every post.
1
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Nov 27 '22
As prommised have opened Mod applications! You can find the full details on how to apply in this thread.
Applications will be open for two weeks (ending 11:59 PM UTC on December 10).
1
u/Warm-Enthusiasm-9534 Nov 06 '22
AutoModerator deleted a comment of mine because there was a space between the brackets and the spoiler. The space was within the spoiler tag. What possible point does this serve, other than to make the subreddit more unfriendly?
0
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Nov 06 '22
Sad that after all the comments and discourse from the last Meta this is the way the mods tell us that it's still happening.
1
u/noxnoctum :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nox0s Nov 24 '22
Can we do a sub secret santa? Pleeeease. They're so much fun.
-22
u/DickWriter69 Nov 06 '22
Chainsaw Man hate posts are warranted
The series is extremely overhyped and has some of the most basic cookie cutter characters I've ever seen
Denji = the horny mc
Power = the annoying loud idiotic sidekick to the mc + fanservice points
Aki = the smart-ass that fights with the mc but helps once in a while like a rival
Nothing else noteworthy about this anime lol
0
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22
[removed] — view removed comment