r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 02 '23
Meta Meta Thread - Month of July 02, 2023
Rule Changes
No rule changes this month.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: June 2023 | May 2023 | April 2023 | March 2023 | February 2023 | January 2023 | December 2022 | November 2022 | October 2022 | September 2022 | August 2022 | July 2022 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 02 '23
Oh, heya everyone!
This is my first time posting the Meta Thread, so let’s see if I can try my best to not accidentally delete the subreddit.
June Mod Report
Voted to participate in the Reddit Blackout from June 12th-14th. [Vote Passed]
Voted to extend the Blackout to no more than a week starting from June 15th–19th. [Vote Passed]
/u/autolovepon has now been moved to a new host. I hope they're comfy there.
/u/Verzwei, /u/abyssbringer, and /u/reddadz have stepped down from the moderator team.
Mod applications are now finished: /u/Dagonsnake and /u/MyrnaMountWeazel (Oh hey, that’s me!) have now joined the moderator team.
June by the Numbers
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 08 '23
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
26
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 02 '23
Sorry for all the years-old replies many of you have been getting in your inbox recently.
There are multiple levels of things going on here but it's generally reddit's fault for each of them. Users are getting wrongly shadowbanned and their previous posts/comments (including all of the ones that are fine and don't break any rules) are removed by the spam filter because of that. After they successfully appeal and can start posting again none of that history is restored, however.
I wrote a script that uses our mod tools to bring back everything of theirs removed by the spam filter anyway, because it shouldn't stay removed due to reddit's mistakes. Approving comments like those (which were previously visible prior to their ban) shouldn't trigger notifications either but it does, so it causes inbox spam.
24
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 04 '23 edited Jul 04 '23
Well now/u/AutoLovepongot shadowbanned so we're working on that.Edit: it's back!
If you want to look up older threads while they're being restored the airing discussion archive should be up to date.
18
u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jul 22 '23
Excited to see in next's month meta thread how many people were restored in July due to shadowban, that should be interesting
16
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 02 '23
Hey mods just a heads up, it looks like u/MetaThPr4h is the next victim of the shadowbanning spam filter, taken down right after they posted today's edition of the "What Have You Watched This Past Week That is NOT a Currently Airing Show?" thread.
I didn't even get to post in it before it was gone since I prioritized the YGO 5Ds rewatch...16
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 13 '23
Admins have announced changes to Reddit gold/premium and awards.
Long story short, awards are going to be replaced by some unannounced alternative, Reddit premium is staying but accrued coins must be spent by September 12.
Over the years Autolovepon has gathered a dragons horde of coins.
We also have a stack of community coins that need to go as well.
Do you have any ideas for events or ways we could reward the community using coins before they are gone?
13
u/StardustGogeta myanimelist.net/profile/StardustGogeta Jul 07 '23
A random question I've had for a while - why is the discussion thread bot called "AutoLovepon"? Is it a reference to something?
12
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jul 02 '23
This is for the whatever mods wants to answer: What was your favorite anime seasonal the last 3-5 years? (Just out of curiosity)
11
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 19 '23
Starting on Wednesday of next week we'll doing a "Weekly r/anime Poll". Each week will have a specific theme, and the results will be posted the next week. We're going to start off with some fairly broad topics and see how the results look before seeing how much we want to narrow things down. There's definitely some topics that have plenty of options technically, but that the average r/anime user just doesn't have enough exposure to for meaningful contributions (RIP "Best of the 70s"). The first poll is going to be "r/anime's Favorite Original Soundtracks" so if you want to start thinking about it, this is your heads up!
11
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jul 21 '23
Ever since r/AnimeSuggest went private, we've been getting a lot more people wanting anime recommendations.
Can we have the automod direct the people who want anime recommendations to the Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussion Thread?
21
u/OrdinarySpirit- Jul 02 '23
Will something be done about Twitter links? It now blocks people without accounts from accessing the site, and non-paying users have a view limit of 300 posts per day, which is enough if you're just checking announcements, but still pretty low.
Maybe require the poster to paste the content in the comments, which some already do.
20
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 02 '23
Have been bouncing this around the mod team, and looking to try it out soon, but figured I'd solicit feedback here as well. I'm looking to start a new weekly mini-event of sorts on the subreddit: a weekly "r/anime's Favorite X" Poll series.
The basic jist of it is pretty straightforward. There will be a fairly open ended question like, "What Are Your 10 Favorite Action Anime," you fill out the ballot, and then we tabulate the results. The goal would be to have the poll on the Wednesday and then the results posted on Tuesday, with the next poll a day later on Wednesday. We'd probably bounce around the general genres (action, comedy, drama), more specific genres (isekai, mecha, magical girls), character archetypes (tsundere, OP main character), technical details (best animated, best OST), and whatever else we might come up with.
Just looking to see if anyone has any general thoughts on the idea!
10
u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 03 '23
Discord anime Swap coming up SOON on July 3rd 9:00 PM PST
If anyone is interested in a fun event our Discord server's Secret Santa event is about to start for this month. The anime swap is a monthly event where users anonymously force one another to watch a certain anime. It starts soon!
What happens is that you sign up and are asked to send a letter to your Santa. In this letter, you tell your Santa what type of anime you might be interested in. You usually will list a length requirement and maybe some genres or themes you do not want to watch. It's also best practice to link a MAL or Anilist.
Time passes and when the swap starts your Santa will receive your letter. But on the other hand, you also receive someone else's letter. You then look at their letter and anonymously send them a show to watch. Then everyone spends the month watching their show given to them by their Santa and shitposting in the Anime-Swap chat. At the end of the month, everyone does a formal write-up of their thoughts and then the Santas are revealed.
Anime Swap is a fun way to get shows to watch and interact with the community. It's kind of like an anime contract that the sub has done before but the anonymous element of it is something I enjoy. It's fun trying to figure out who your Santa is and I love playing detective and shitposting.
If you want to try something low-committal you can ask for a shorter anime or even a movie if you want. It's a good way to test the waters. Usually, a couple of mods participate
including meso it's not just Discord people. I've gotten a decent amount of CDF people as well!How to Join
You go to our Discord
Click the react to get access to everything
Go to Channels & Roles and click Anime Swap
Go to the Anime Swap chat
(If you can't see the channel you need to give yourself the Anime Swap role. If you can't find it or its not working DM me on Discord I'm literally at the very top and I'll fix it.
Click the pins and find this chat
Follow the instructions.
10
u/entelechtual Jul 05 '23
I’m curious if the daily thread has gotten more activity lately or if there’s some kind of change to the rules/removals that has caused a spike. It feels like it used to be 150-250 comments per day and now it’s often 350+. Is it the holidays? Summer break? Start of season? Big shows? Coincidence?
10
u/AmusedDragon :Bs::Bu: Jul 06 '23
Just for my own curiosity and not because the mod team is talking about anything - but do users find the polling in the episode discussion threads useful?
Do you vote?
Do you look at the scores?
If they just went away one day would you actually mind that?
10
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Jul 16 '23
Meta post about the Meta Thread in the Meta Thread time, I find it interesting that the Thread’s been a lot more active this month and how that’s because the mods seem to have been actively incentivizing such, between having promoted it in the sidebar a couple times on-and-off and having it be stickied a lot more often. Only halfway through the month and we’re already at almost 400, a rare feat! Even the month of the blackout/great API debacle last month didn’t crack 300 the whole month through.
It looks like the mods are taking direct steps to encourage more active participation in the sub, and that’s cool to see! Kudos on that.
8
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jul 14 '23
Apparently reddit notifications are lagging today.
I thought I was shadowbanned.
8
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Jul 15 '23
How about hosting a large AMQ tournament for those Bot-chan golds?
8
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 29 '23
How long does it usually take to get an episode thread discussion through a modmail request? I sent one over an hour ago for the new Bleach episode and I'm still for it.
7
u/HikikomoriMan Jul 02 '23
What happened to the anime suggest subreddit?
7
u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 05 '23
How is the effort to do more AMAs going / is that on hold with reddit being reddit?
Did Cloverworks ghost us
7
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 08 '23
Actually now that it's finally up, is there a reason why Bleach: Thousand Year Blood War episode 14's discussion thread only has the romaji title (Sennen Kessen-hen - Ketsubetsu-tan) in it and not the official English one (Thousand Year Blood War - The Separation) as well? I thought every airing show was supposed to have both titles in it.
7
u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Jul 13 '23
Hi, question about AutoLovePon - Why mark episode number sequentially instead of by season?
For example, JJK is now on Season 2, episode 2. And everybody refers to it as "episode 2". But the discussion thread is from "Season 2, episode 26" which is just confusing?
It's even more problematic in the future. When someone will try and google for a discussion thread they'd look for episode 2 (that they've just watch), not calculate how many episodes were in season 1 then add 2. It's even more convoluted for multiple seasons.
7
u/Verzwei Jul 17 '23 edited Jul 17 '23
Totally altruistic request and not at all selfish personal salt because I missed the recent End of Spring survey, but can the team consider:
The combination of "doesn't run for very long" and "isn't even advertised/stickied for the entirety of its run" makes it really easy for dummies like me to completely miss community events despite the fact that I'm on this subreddit every single day. For people who aren't here every day, then they'd be even easier to miss, as it would come down to the user coincidentally happening to use the subreddit at the right time when the content happens to be promoted, otherwise they'll never even know that something was active for them to participate in.
Edit: Even maybe a sidebar category for "Events" like the existing "Contests" category, if there's concern about dedicating the sidebar image and/or the second sticky slot to a single thing for too long of a period. Could also list future events with their start date on the table, too. Would work for more than seasonal surveys; you could use that to list major dates (application deadline, public voting, results, etc.) for other big events like the annual Awards.
6
u/astolflo_ Jul 02 '23
Where’s the episode thread for Fate/Strange Fake?
6
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 04 '23
AutoLovepon is missing the glasses girl stream
6
u/Nomar_95 :Ed:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nomar_95 Jul 06 '23
this is reddit-wide and not really related to this sub, but it sucks that the hide button no longer works. Never realized how much I used it until it was gone.
6
u/Nebresto Jul 09 '23
Not too important since its a week old already, but the database links on the Mushoku Tensei episode 0 thread go to the main show instead of the special episode page
6
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 28 '23
A bit surprised that /u/FetchFrosh's survey isn't getting any kind of permanent spot. Sticky slots are limited so that's fair although I think it's a valid option, but it's nowhere in the sidebar including the two image slots, and it's not in the "CSS News Feed" (the one with "A Quick-Start Guide to /r/anime" and others) either.
6
u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Aug 02 '23
Discord anime Swap coming up SOON on August 3rd 9:00 PM PST
If anyone is interested in a fun event our Discord server's Secret Santa event is about to start for this month. The anime swap is a monthly event where users anonymously force one another to watch a certain anime. It starts soon!
What happens is that you sign up and are asked to send a letter to your Santa. In this letter, you tell your Santa what type of anime you might be interested in. You usually will list a length requirement and maybe some genres or themes you do not want to watch. It's also best practice to link a MAL or Anilist.
Time passes and when the swap starts your Santa will receive your letter. But on the other hand, you also receive someone else's letter. You then look at their letter and anonymously send them a show to watch. Then everyone spends the month watching their show given to them by their Santa and shitposting in the Anime-Swap chat. At the end of the month, everyone does a formal write-up of their thoughts and then the Santas are revealed.
Anime Swap is a fun way to get shows to watch and interact with the community. It's kind of like an anime contract that the sub has done before but the anonymous element of it is something I enjoy. It's fun trying to figure out who your Santa is and I love playing detective and shitposting.
If you want to try something low-committal you can ask for a shorter anime or even a movie if you want. It's a good way to test the waters.
How to Join
You go to our Discord
Click the react to get access to everything
Go to Channels & Roles and click Anime Swap
Go to the Anime Swap chat
Click the pins and find this chat
Follow the instructions.
6
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
Question about movie ep threads -
What actually is the official mod policy on those? im very happy to request them as i notice screenings pop up (e.g. right now for the first slam dunk, even tho im not going to see it), and surely Miyazaki's new film later on, but is there like an automated process for them? Or is it like unofficial subbed releases where it's more ad hoc.
If it's the latter, is there a way where if a region-wide Eng-subtitled screening time/date is noted, that a thread be scheduled in advance to go out on that date at the time of the first screening? I just feel like timely movie threads will really help discussion esp for more niche/single screening or 2 movies (which slam dunk... isn't actually lol). Since sometimes, though rarely for these niche-er screenings they just dont pop up at all.
Much thanks!
edit: i realize right now that this thread is probably about to get replaced LOL. I'll repost in the new thread if the mods haven't answered this by then :)
5
u/phantomthiefkid_ Jul 02 '23
What do you think about linking PV from Crunchyroll Youtube channel?
PV on Crunchyroll channel are not available in these countries. For a few of us from those countries it's pretty annoying to see a PV on the front page while not being able to watch it.
Edit: Hidive is even worse their PV are only available in US and Canada
5
u/ashketchum2095 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kiruko- Jul 03 '23
Hello, I just had a question regarding a post of mine that was removed:
Sorry, your submission has been removed.
My removed post:
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/14ovles/which_anime_made_you_say_wow/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=1
To my knowledge I met all the criteria, I don't really care that it was removed but would like to avoid it in the future thank you.
5
u/phantomthiefkid_ Jul 03 '23
You got the English name of this show wrong
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/14pqalh/yumemiru_danshi_wa_genjitsushugisha_my_dreamy/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=1
"My Dream Realist" is the localized name of the LN in Germany
5
u/DarkAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkAudit Jul 04 '23
Chibi Godzilla ep 13 is up.
5
u/chilidirigible Jul 14 '23
A couple of months ago I had a user flair submission accepted... but I've found that it doesn't look as good in use as I thought it would when I was testing it out. Can I submit an edited version? Can I submit a different image from the same series? Can /u/abyssbringer still get in there to change things?
5
u/DarkAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkAudit Jul 20 '23
Are we about due for Seasonal Comment Face nominations?
5
u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 30 '23
I sleep
Very happy with shortening the contests/batch releases assuming that helped to fit space. So many of those were outdated
8
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '23
I’d like to have transparency on the backup plan should Reddit continue to tighten the screws. Everything here should start being mirrored somewhere else so a cutover can happen cleanly if possible.
4
u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria Jul 02 '23
Are there any plans for when the next Flair Bounty Board will be? I think it's been a couple of months since that was last posted for suggestions.
4
u/DerpyMcFrakles https://myanimelist.net/profile/KakkaKarrotCake Jul 02 '23
I've noticed that the episode discussion bot will often say there are no streams available when their actually are. Take the Ryza no Atelier discussion thread for example. That thread is the most recent example I could find, but I've seen it happen in other threads.
4
u/MrJackfruit Jul 04 '23
If I want I ask a question that is basically “can I get a list of short busty anime characters” where would I post that? I don’t see a clear subreddit for where I’d ask this.
4
u/entelechtual Jul 11 '23
Is there an issue with reporting comments on old.reddit on mobile? It doesn’t give me the full list of rule violations, just something like “belongs in the source corner”, even on non episode threads, and other.
4
u/JoshFB4 Jul 20 '23
Hey mods. Since this month appears to be a down month traffic wise on the sub, is that playing out the same in the data that you guys have for the month so far. You don’t have to actually respond to this if you want to wait and reveal the traffic numbers in the next Meta Thread. :)
4
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '23
What with the recent influx of recommendation posts? They're all the same in different words.
Should there be a recommendation megathread for the most common ones like "new to anime" & "haven't watched in x years"?
4
u/docks4cocks Jul 21 '23
Hey mods, can i ask what isekai communities would be intrested to join an communual isekai fan discord server?
4
u/LordTrinity https://myanimelist.net/profile/LordTrinity Jul 25 '23
Hello mods, I'm thinking about parsing some data with Best Girl 10 comments and posting it here, once it is over. Do you have any ideas about which data could be interesting to get and share?
I'm thinking about the users themselves (like who comments more, who gets more upvotes when doing comments), the girls (which ones get mentioned the most) and some overall stats (like total comments, how many times the world "salty" and its variants get mentioned, among others). I'm open to suggestions
4
u/thevaleycat Jul 26 '23
Do y'all have any plans to share stats on flairs? Curious which ones are popular and which ones are not
10
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Jul 03 '23
Mushoku Tensei S2E0 dropped less than a week ago and their is already drama in the thread about censoring.
This is going to be a busy season for you mods.
7
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 12 '23
Shouldn't this post and most of the replies to this be nuked by spoiler removals, especially as it is not even tagged as spoiler post?
Unsure how this can stay up, but discussion of content warnings, themes or "it gets darker later" are against the rules.
15
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 02 '23
Why was this post removed? It just restates a trigger warning that got removed the day before due to spoilers the day before, with a short mention of that removal.
First, what the fuck? You can hardly genuinely claim that trigger warnings are spoilers. This flied directly in the face of your usual explanation that you're being strict about spoilers in order to be inclusive and welcoming to everyone, because this is the exact opposite of that.
Secondly, you might disagree about the tone they used, but explaining that the equivalent comment from the day before got removed for spoilers is in no way whatsoever a meta comment. There is no way you can claim a removal for what amounts to a context note as being made in good faith.
6
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Jul 08 '23
Mods, what is your favorite desert?
3
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 05 '23
Looks like I can see tweets without being logged in? So this shouldn't be needed anymore - unless Elon does weird shit again.
3
u/drstripjo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hanten Jul 08 '23
Can we get Bleach discussion thread please?
3
u/phantomthiefkid_ Jul 14 '23
Where's Kanokari thread? The episode's been out for an hour now
3
u/Thatsmaboi23 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Thatsmaboi23 Jul 27 '23
Why was this post removed?.
Was it something on my part that was done wrongly? Didn’t even get a notification/comment for the removal. Weird.
3
u/Martian_on_the_Moon Aug 04 '23
Care to explain why my comment was removed: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/15gaimk/bungo_stray_dogs_season_5_episode_4_discussion/juqi7dt/?context=10000
Everything I said is from anime only (previous seasons) and I don't read manga/novel/etc of this show. What is there to spoil? Unless you want to tell me that I correctly predicted what is gonna happen in the future...
3
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Aug 05 '23
Care to explain why my thread was removed?
Thread
The thread is inspired by this similarly titled thread made around the same time, but about a different character.
7
u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jul 08 '23
Me observing the inconsistency between last week and this week's Atelier Ryza thread:
Last week's thread had one correctly removed comment despite actual plot spoilers throughout it. Every comment discussing [Ryza, game]the series' fanservice, while not allowed in Seven Spellblades, or game-anime comparisons, specifically those calling it [Ryza, game]a comfy slice-of-life or coming-of-age story, should have been removed. Examples one, two, three, four (plus child comments), five (plus child), six (character name isn't known), seven, eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve, thirteen, fourteen, fifteen (who knows how many I missed, just ctrl+f a couple words). Then there's this week's thread where mentioning [Ryza, game]a monster's strength compared to level 1 characters or elements is removed, yet mentioning this game not having alchemy failures remains.
I continue to believe that nuking threads of mid-to-low popularity shows to strictly enforce a Source Corner not mentioned in the subreddit's rules page is a terrible decision. Precisely adhering to a rules page doesn't make a a better community; considering the situation and using discretion to determine if actions outweigh the cost does.
Anyway, now that it's been called out in the meta thread and thus brought to attention like reports, hope whoever removes comments in last week's thread enjoys doing so.
6
u/J765 Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23
Could a "source material corner"-like thing be considered as an option for news announcement posts?
Like in the split cour announcement thread for Mushoku Tensei S2, some of the comments about future events in the next Mushoku Tensei season, while not explicitly stating what those events are, they do describe their feelings about those future events quite clearly. Or those discussions about if "that one" thing out the source material will happen in that new season (They are effectively spoiling that a type of event in the story, that is numbered, will have further similar happenings [Mushoku Tensei] there won't just be a turning point 3, but also a turning point 4 ). Or talking about what volumes are going to be adapted while also talking about in which of them something big will happen, while also talking about how many volumes having been adapted in S1.
Maybe I'm just super sensitive about this kind of "setting expectations" spoilering my experience with adaptations, but it does feel like that kind of stuff should be discussed under a "source corner" like post, and not in the general thread. Like it isn't the official trailers setting those expectations, but it is the readers of the source material bringing that information from outside.
Or maybe that is just the accepted natural way of talking about anime adaptations and I just have to stop clicking on even news threads about adaptations to not get spoiled like that.
4
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jul 25 '23
so are all these spice and wolf posts on the front page coincidental? i guess all the users are holo fans judging by the username.
4
u/Salty145 https://anilist.co/user/yLSalty145 Jul 28 '23
Call me crazy, but the amount of “What to Watch” threads that I have to sift through is becoming a bit overwhelming. That and the amount of “Discussion” threads that are “I discovered this semi-popular anime and just want to let you know about it” also seems to be on the rise.
I know there’s not much of anything that can be done, since it seems a lot of the casual audience from r/animesuggestions have come over here and there’s not much that can be done about that. At the very least, I’d like to not have to scroll through 20,000 requests for more anime boobs or super niche recs just to browse this page every day.
4
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 16 '23
What would you say is the best amount of time wait before bumping a modmail? Been a week for one of mine but with the history here of people being banned or threatened with permabans in modmail discussions I don't want to push my luck there.
3
u/4v33n0 Jul 17 '23
With, for example, Fate series' spoilers, should it be a rule to state which entry the spoiler actually applies to?
Today, I saw this comment, and initially I didn't click the spoiler, because I haven't watched all the Fate anime. I later came back to thread, and then realised that I've watched nearly all the Fate anime that I actually am interested in, so I don't mind getting spoiled on one of the others, so I clicked it. No biggie, it turns out that it was a Heaven's Feel 2 spoiler (though if you hadn't watched HF2, but had watched Fate/Zero, you'd also be aware of that information), one of the ones I'd watched.
But, if I was someone who had say, watched F/SN and F/Z, but hadn't yet watched the El-Melloi spinoff, or Apocrypha, etc., then it'd be a pretty big risk to click the spoiler, because all it says is [Fate Series spoiler].
If someone tagged a Monogatari spoiler as [anime adapted from Nisio Isin work spoiler], I think people would rightfully see that as unnecessarily vague (and I assume it would be removed?), and he only has something like 6 anime adaptations, which is fewer than the no. of different Fate series there are.
I used Fate as an example, but this would also apply to any other big anime franchise with many spin-offs.