r/anime • myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 02 '23

Meta Meta Thread - Month of July 02, 2023

Rule Changes

No rule changes this month.


This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.

Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.

Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.


Previous meta threads: June 2023 | May 2023 | April 2023 | March 2023 | February 2023 | January 2023 | December 2022 | November 2022 | October 2022 | September 2022 | August 2022 | July 2022 | Find All

New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.

71 Upvotes

493 comments sorted by

•

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 02 '23

Oh, heya everyone!

This is my first time posting the Meta Thread, so let’s see if I can try my best to not accidentally delete the subreddit.

June Mod Report

Voted to participate in the Reddit Blackout from June 12th-14th. [Vote Passed]

Voted to extend the Blackout to no more than a week starting from June 15th–19th. [Vote Passed]

/u/autolovepon has now been moved to a new host. I hope they're comfy there.

/u/Verzwei, /u/abyssbringer, and /u/reddadz have stepped down from the moderator team.

Mod applications are now finished: /u/Dagonsnake and /u/MyrnaMountWeazel (Oh hey, that’s me!) have now joined the moderator team.

June by the Numbers

  • Total traffic: 17618012 pageviews, 2192788 unique pageviews
  • Total posts: 7151, 4667 unique authors
  • Total comments: 141142, 21609 unique authors (excluding mod bots)
  • Removed posts: 700 by moderators, 4123 by bots, 4739 distinct
  • Removed comments: 1325 by moderators, 1834 by bots, 2705 distinct
  • Approved posts: 1185
  • Approved comments: 1974 (and 28376 more restored after users were wrongly shadowbanned)
  • Distinguished comments: 1033
  • Users banned: 126 (109 permanent, 62 by BotDefense)
  • Users unbanned: 0
  • Admin/Anti-Evil Operations: removed posts: 13, removed comments: 67.
→ More replies (28)

2

u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 08 '23

This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.

26

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 02 '23

Sorry for all the years-old replies many of you have been getting in your inbox recently.

There are multiple levels of things going on here but it's generally reddit's fault for each of them. Users are getting wrongly shadowbanned and their previous posts/comments (including all of the ones that are fine and don't break any rules) are removed by the spam filter because of that. After they successfully appeal and can start posting again none of that history is restored, however.

I wrote a script that uses our mod tools to bring back everything of theirs removed by the spam filter anyway, because it shouldn't stay removed due to reddit's mistakes. Approving comments like those (which were previously visible prior to their ban) shouldn't trigger notifications either but it does, so it causes inbox spam.

15

u/LG03 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bronadian Jul 02 '23

Approving comments like those (which were previously visible prior to their ban) shouldn't trigger notifications either but it does

That's the part that was throwing me for a loop, approved comments shouldn't be inboxing as if they're new. I shouldn't be surprised anymore at the ways in which reddit fucks up.

6

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Jul 02 '23

Approving comments like those (which were previously visible prior to their ban) shouldn't trigger notifications either but it does

The most baffling part to me is that, at least when I did it two years ago, approving comments that a user made while they were shadowbanned didn't create a notification.

5

u/mutsuto https://myanimelist.net/profile/mtsRhea Jul 02 '23

thx for the update, i was super confused earlier today.

i thought shadow banning was removed years ago

is shadow banning now back? site wide?

6

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 03 '23

It's always been around for as long as I've been a mod, it just usually hit spam accounts and not actual regular long-time users. Some false positives here and there but never the wave that we've seen in the past month.

24

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 04 '23 edited Jul 04 '23

Well now /u/AutoLovepon got shadowbanned so we're working on that.

Edit: it's back!

If you want to look up older threads while they're being restored the airing discussion archive should be up to date.

16

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 04 '23

This is, what, the sixth significant account on this sub to get shadowbanned recently, isn't it? Reddit why.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 04 '23

I dunno if this is a good or bad idea, but with how central Lovepon is to the sub you may actually want to consider a separate PSA thread for this one...

11

u/DurdenVsDarkoVsDevon https://myanimelist.net/profile/U18810227 Jul 04 '23

Have you reached out to the admins yet? Are they just completely useless? Like you guys are doing great patching the dike, but the dike is gonna burst here soon it feels.

13

u/AmusedDragon :Bs::Bu: Jul 04 '23

We've reached out to modsupport about /u/autolovepon and also mentioned the recent user shadowbans as well.

12

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 04 '23

We've already reached out about the few specific users before but going to try again with more details/emphasis on this being a recent trend along with asking them about our bot now.

→ More replies (11)

11

u/AsterJ https://myanimelist.net/profile/asteron Jul 04 '23

Ooof thousands of episode discussion threads are inaccessible now. Admins are punishing us for going dark, so petty.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/WeMustPrevail Jul 04 '23

Ah was wondering why the discussion threads just started showing up as [removed]

8

u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jul 04 '23

Edit: it's back!

The SukiMega thread will stay under Gaporigo post?

8

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 04 '23

That one is kind of stuck on our end, if the admins don't reapprove it not much we can do.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 04 '23

Lmao what the actual fuck

7

u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jul 04 '23 edited Jul 04 '23

What's the post+comment count for it? Also, this one's big enough you guys might want to sticky a post saying you're working on it instead of getting 12412 modmails/comments

6

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 04 '23

Luckily the account barely made any comments before becoming the episode bot. It started as a sort of Mayoiga gimmick account.

7

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 04 '23

you should pin that to the Daily Discussion thread

5

u/AsterJ https://myanimelist.net/profile/asteron Jul 04 '23

Oh nice it's back! Good job getting things fixed

5

u/marcopolos059 https://myanimelist.net/profile/marcopolos059 Jul 05 '23

Edit: it's back!

yayy, thank you mods!

18

u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jul 22 '23

Excited to see in next's month meta thread how many people were restored in July due to shadowban, that should be interesting

9

u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jul 23 '23

Welcome back!

15

u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jul 23 '23 edited Jul 23 '23

Not 100% back yet, I believe the mods can approve comments from people in the Shadow Realm, Reddit sends you a message when you are out u/Manitary?

That said since u/badspler warned me early (thanks again!) I was also able to have an idea what got me into the spam filter, it was a comment with me talking about the shows I watched this season with links to MAL + one op from animethemes.moe

That did the trick, but to be honest I was already waiting for this, but I thought it would be due to the Japanese streaming ranks I post every week under my post, not MAL

So be careful with those links, which also includes commentFaces

Edit: It was this comment that triggered the filter

→ More replies (8)

8

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jul 23 '23

7

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 23 '23

16

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 02 '23

Hey mods just a heads up, it looks like u/MetaThPr4h is the next victim of the shadowbanning spam filter, taken down right after they posted today's edition of the "What Have You Watched This Past Week That is NOT a Currently Airing Show?" thread. I didn't even get to post in it before it was gone since I prioritized the YGO 5Ds rewatch...

10

u/MetaThPr4h https://myanimelist.net/profile/MetaThPr4h Jul 02 '23

lmfao, I haven't really been following this stuff much, why are people getting shadowbanned in first place? Been getting so many restored comments on my notifications lately.

9

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 02 '23

No idea what's causing it. The rough speculation is that Reddit's interpreting comment faces as spam links, but that's pure speculation. You'll have to go through Reddit and get that sorted out.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad Jul 03 '23

I was wondering what happened to that thread. I checked for it a few times today and thought I must keep missing it somehow.

3

u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine Jul 02 '23

Heh. I managed to open the thread immediately, myself. It's a desolate place I must say.

I don't know if it's related to the filter, but I can't even see the big man's account, so I personally thought it was a Reddit-wide thing and not just r/anime one.

8

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 02 '23

Yeah it's a Reddit-wide thing, I just wanted to give the mods a heads up because they'll have to reapprove all of Meta's comments/posts on this sub once the shadowban is reversed. They've had to do that a lot recently, between DarkAudit, Manitary, JustAnswerAQuestion, and ZapsZzz (the latter two of which both got struck down on Friday).

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 13 '23

Admins have announced changes to Reddit gold/premium and awards.

Long story short, awards are going to be replaced by some unannounced alternative, Reddit premium is staying but accrued coins must be spent by September 12.

Over the years Autolovepon has gathered a dragons horde of coins.

We also have a stack of community coins that need to go as well.

Do you have any ideas for events or ways we could reward the community using coins before they are gone?

8

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 13 '23

Obviously we could have a premature round of "Best of", maybe also best of decade or something like this?

Doing a contest for coins just introduces moral hazard for cheating, so not the best unless it is something you can not cheat at.

Go through Writing, Watch This!, Rewatch etc. posts and give awards to users who are still active on Reddit.

Award users for service to the sub, like if they manage a bot, some server, a project.

7

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jul 14 '23

Will we have the 8M subscriber contest before September 12?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jul 14 '23

i feel like a premature best of is defo one way of doing things: at the least though I'd probably suggest, if there is a mutual agreement, that the coins be awarded in a way so that the recipient doesnt then have to spend more of them lol (I.e. not the way how it works rn with gold) given the circumstances.

im gonna guess the 8M event isnt gonna be held in time, but a participation prize there wouldve been an idea too. Maybe a retrospective award for 7M/6M event participants? would help use up some of them

edit: also maybe some for the old mods?

or just gild every single comment in CDF you'll run out of them like tomorrow

→ More replies (4)

4

u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Jul 15 '23

I would not mind for each admin to give our arbitrary "personal best of" awards each day. Just put an award on the TOP X posts/comments you read each day. Yes, it would be arbitrary, but the price is very ephimeral in any case and it gives us some admin involvement.

3

u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Jul 23 '23

Maybe giving awards to the top-3 comments of every 100+ comment thread (that isn't a discussion thread)? Or just in general throwing them around in pure discussion threads, which in my opinion are the best content in the sub.

Also a question, if we're talking awards - how can I get one of those cute colorful stars or something fun next to my Kaguya flair?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/StardustGogeta myanimelist.net/profile/StardustGogeta Jul 07 '23

A random question I've had for a while - why is the discussion thread bot called "AutoLovepon"? Is it a reference to something?

16

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 07 '23

8

u/StardustGogeta myanimelist.net/profile/StardustGogeta Jul 07 '23

Thank you for the reply! I am still a bit confused, though. Is there anything special about that character which makes them especially relevant in this context? I haven't seen Mayoiga, and I can't find anything on that wiki page which pops out as particularly notable.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jul 02 '23

This is for the whatever mods wants to answer: What was your favorite anime seasonal the last 3-5 years? (Just out of curiosity)

11

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 02 '23

Not a mod anymore but I can give some insight into the best modern anime among the team. It's easily Kinobox 2 and Kinosaga 2. They are both saving modern anime as we speak and keeping it alive.

Some other fan favorites are Mushoku Tender, Redo a Girlfriend, and So I'm a Source Reader, So What?

10

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 02 '23 edited Jul 02 '23

Oh gosh, there's too many that I loved. I'll try to go by year:

From this year, I was pleased with how cute Skip and Loafer became and I was incredibly impressed by how much better Tsurune: Linking Shot was compared to its first season. I love them both for separate reason and right now they're my top contenders for AotY.

Last year, I (alongside most everyone I imagine) was infatuated with Bocchi, but I was also super into Healer Girl, the little anime that could. However, my personal favorite for that year belonged to Yama no Susume: Next Summit.

Moving to 2021, I would have to go with KyoAni's triumphant return with Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid S, SSSS.Dynazenon, and the final season of Non Non Biyori that was not, in fact, nonstop.

Keep Your Hands Off Eizouken and season 3 of Chihayafuru take home top marks for me in 2020.

And finally, I'll cheat and skip over 2019 to head over to 2018's SSSS.Gridman, which remains as not only as my favorite for that year, but also as one of my favorites in general.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Dagonsnake https://anilist.co/user/Dagonsnake Jul 02 '23

That's a tough one. It's probably between either 86 or Uma Musume S2 for me. Though Bocchi the Rock and Idoly Pride both come close.

6

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 02 '23

An excellent question, and one that I'd be happy to answer.

It's hard to pick a single favorite, but if I had to choose just one, then I'd say that last season's Vinland Saga S2 blew me out of the water. Before that, I'd probably pick Made in Abyss S2 as a standout (if you couldn't tell from my flair, I do somewhat enjoy this show!). Now if we're strictly speaking non-sequels, then probably Vivy or Odd Taxi. I'd also give Lycoris Recoil an honorable mention as far as originals go because Chisato's VA gives me life.

I also like some of the big anime like JJK, Oshi No Ko, and Chainsaw Man, but I left those off because I felt like it would be stating the obvious.

5

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 02 '23

I'd definitely say Bocchi the Rock

5

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23

I haven't been a mod in the past 3-5 years, but I really liked Summertime Rendering. I made a prediction after watching like 2 episodes, my prediction was wrong, and I was hooked for the rest of the ride.

I'm also enjoying Witch from Mercury, probably going to be the first Gundam I finish.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Verzwei Jul 02 '23

Are former mod answers acceptable?

Last summer's Call of the Night by far for me. Vivy was very solid, but COTN vibed with me better.

This spring's Insomniacs After School is way up there for me, too, but I think once recency bias fades it'll settle somewhere below COTN. I also really enjoyed Yuri is my Job from the season, but as just one season, no confirmation of a second, and with how far the adaptation reached, I don't know if I could rate the anime (as a standalone product) above something like COTN or Insomniacs, which both already feel much more "complete" despite having more story to tell.

If you'd have included the last 6 years, the answer probably would have been Princess Principal which was apparently 5 years, 11 months, and 22 days ago.

3

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 03 '23

I am to greedy to pick one; so here are my favs from the last 5 years:

  • Sora yori mo Tooi Basho
  • Shoujo☆Kageki Revue Starlight
  • Yuru Camp△ SEASON 2
  • Odd Taxi
  • 86: Eighty Six
  • Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic
  • Made in Abyss: Retsujitsu no Ougonkyou
  • Honzuki no Gekokujou
  • Eizouken ni wa Te wo Dasu na!
  • Bocchi the Rock!
→ More replies (1)

11

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 19 '23

Starting on Wednesday of next week we'll doing a "Weekly r/anime Poll". Each week will have a specific theme, and the results will be posted the next week. We're going to start off with some fairly broad topics and see how the results look before seeing how much we want to narrow things down. There's definitely some topics that have plenty of options technically, but that the average r/anime user just doesn't have enough exposure to for meaningful contributions (RIP "Best of the 70s"). The first poll is going to be "r/anime's Favorite Original Soundtracks" so if you want to start thinking about it, this is your heads up!

4

u/cppn02 Jul 19 '23 edited Jul 19 '23

Sounds fun.
Will results and the new poll be a single post? And how are the posts gonna be titled? Will the poll question be in the title or will it just be numbered?

6

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 19 '23

The plan is two separate posts. So on Wednesday there will be the poll, then on the following Tuesday the results will be posted as an infographic of the Top 20. There will also be a stickied comment with the remaining results, as well as announcing what the poll for Wednesday will be.

Haven't actually thought of a title format yet. We'll see, but probably something simple like "r/anime's Favorite OSTs - A Community Poll" or something like that.

11

u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jul 21 '23

Ever since r/AnimeSuggest went private, we've been getting a lot more people wanting anime recommendations.

Can we have the automod direct the people who want anime recommendations to the Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussion Thread?

7

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 21 '23

We've been talking a bit about the effect that r/animesuggest privating is having on the /new queue. We'll probably gather up some data and see if it's actually having a substantial impact before making any decisions.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

21

u/OrdinarySpirit- Jul 02 '23

Will something be done about Twitter links? It now blocks people without accounts from accessing the site, and non-paying users have a view limit of 300 posts per day, which is enough if you're just checking announcements, but still pretty low.

Maybe require the poster to paste the content in the comments, which some already do.

10

u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Jul 02 '23

and non-paying users have a view limit of 300 posts per day

That's the limit for brand new accounts. I don't know what the threshold is, but older unverified accounts are 600 per day, being upped to 800 soon apparently.

8

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 02 '23

Agree, if a post is a link post and the link is a tweet, it should be a rule to copy its contents (and a machine translation if the original is Japanese?) in a top-level comment for people without an account.
iirc links to attached pictures etc are visible, so it would be just for tweets

20

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 02 '23

Have been bouncing this around the mod team, and looking to try it out soon, but figured I'd solicit feedback here as well. I'm looking to start a new weekly mini-event of sorts on the subreddit: a weekly "r/anime's Favorite X" Poll series.

The basic jist of it is pretty straightforward. There will be a fairly open ended question like, "What Are Your 10 Favorite Action Anime," you fill out the ballot, and then we tabulate the results. The goal would be to have the poll on the Wednesday and then the results posted on Tuesday, with the next poll a day later on Wednesday. We'd probably bounce around the general genres (action, comedy, drama), more specific genres (isekai, mecha, magical girls), character archetypes (tsundere, OP main character), technical details (best animated, best OST), and whatever else we might come up with.

Just looking to see if anyone has any general thoughts on the idea!

9

u/baquea Jul 02 '23

I feel it would in most cases end up just being too much of a popularity contest to be particularly interesting. The current best girl/etc. contests work because even someone who is fairly new to anime will still have a decent selection of entrants they're familiar with to pick between, but for a category as specific as 'favourite magical girl anime', even most people who have been active anime fans for multiple years are likely to have no more than a handful of relevant titles watched, leading to very predictable results.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Jul 02 '23

Polls/Contests are always super fun, for the discussion it creates, to root for your favorites, to get salty when they lose, and sometimes just to make you revisit some old anime just by thinking about them/the characters and all that!

100% supporting this!

And there's enough categories to keep this going just about forever, even when you've exhausted the main ones, there's always a lot of stuff, like "smart character", "evil character", "weak character", "character who has killed at least 1 person", etc..!

Anyway, really looking forward to this, if it happens!

5

u/JoshFB4 Jul 02 '23

It would be like your usual polls that you sometimes run right, but this time it would be a mod team effort so you could do it weekly? Sounds fun if that’s the case

→ More replies (3)

5

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jul 02 '23

And will the results be posted to the /r/anime twitter?

Sorry. Couldn't help it.

4

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Jul 02 '23

It would be fun to compare between what makes it to the list selections and what r/anime counts as [tsundere, isekai,...].

4

u/Nebresto Jul 02 '23

Polls = Good

3

u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jul 02 '23

Sounds like fun!

3

u/padichilbert Jul 02 '23

really love the idea!

3

u/Syokhan https://myanimelist.net/profile/Syokhan Jul 04 '23

I'm all for it, sounds like a fun idea!

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 03 '23

Discord anime Swap coming up SOON on July 3rd 9:00 PM PST

If anyone is interested in a fun event our Discord server's Secret Santa event is about to start for this month. The anime swap is a monthly event where users anonymously force one another to watch a certain anime. It starts soon!

What happens is that you sign up and are asked to send a letter to your Santa. In this letter, you tell your Santa what type of anime you might be interested in. You usually will list a length requirement and maybe some genres or themes you do not want to watch. It's also best practice to link a MAL or Anilist.

Time passes and when the swap starts your Santa will receive your letter. But on the other hand, you also receive someone else's letter. You then look at their letter and anonymously send them a show to watch. Then everyone spends the month watching their show given to them by their Santa and shitposting in the Anime-Swap chat. At the end of the month, everyone does a formal write-up of their thoughts and then the Santas are revealed.

Anime Swap is a fun way to get shows to watch and interact with the community. It's kind of like an anime contract that the sub has done before but the anonymous element of it is something I enjoy. It's fun trying to figure out who your Santa is and I love playing detective and shitposting.

If you want to try something low-committal you can ask for a shorter anime or even a movie if you want. It's a good way to test the waters. Usually, a couple of mods participate including me so it's not just Discord people. I've gotten a decent amount of CDF people as well!

How to Join

You go to our Discord

Click the react to get access to everything

Go to Channels & Roles and click Anime Swap

Go to the Anime Swap chat

(If you can't see the channel you need to give yourself the Anime Swap role. If you can't find it or its not working DM me on Discord I'm literally at the very top and I'll fix it.

Click the pins and find this chat

Follow the instructions.

10

u/entelechtual Jul 05 '23

I’m curious if the daily thread has gotten more activity lately or if there’s some kind of change to the rules/removals that has caused a spike. It feels like it used to be 150-250 comments per day and now it’s often 350+. Is it the holidays? Summer break? Start of season? Big shows? Coincidence?

9

u/Silent_Shadow05 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silent-Shadow05 Jul 07 '23

I think there are those that don't really enjoy CDF likes to hang around there, driving up the comment count.

7

u/Verzwei Jul 06 '23

I remember it ticked upward sharply when the subreddit comment karma requirement was put into place, but yeah it does seem higher on average now than even then.

10

u/AmusedDragon :Bs::Bu: Jul 06 '23

Just for my own curiosity and not because the mod team is talking about anything - but do users find the polling in the episode discussion threads useful?

Do you vote?

Do you look at the scores?

If they just went away one day would you actually mind that?

9

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jul 06 '23

also no to all of them, especially since now the weekly chart i think has stopped featuring them?

5

u/cppn02 Jul 07 '23

especially since now the weekly chart i think has stopped featuring them?

Yep it did. Sadly starting around Winter 2022 is was being heavily manipulated and therefor we no longer have a seperate poll ranking.
The karma chart does still show the poll scores too but obviously they get less attention.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 06 '23

No to all questions

(as the thread is not stikky, not many are gonna see this, so you may wanna poll this in other ways)

5

u/cppn02 Jul 07 '23

Do you vote?

Yes

Do you look at the scores?

Less than I used to.

If they just went away one day would you actually mind that?

It would be a bit sad but it wouldn't be a major loss tbh.

4

u/Verzwei Jul 09 '23

Do you vote?

Only for shows I really, really care about. So like 2 or less per season.

Do you look at the scores?

On the poll site? Only when I submit my vote. On the next week's episode discussion thread table? Sometimes.

If they just went away one day would you actually mind that?

Not particularly. I know what a pain in the ass it is whenever the episode bot misses a thread and then someone has to go manually make the poll, make the poll options, look at the previous week's results and manually tally and average them, then insert them into the table for the new thread. Was literally my least-favorite thing to do as a moderator.

4

u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Jul 09 '23

They are beyond useless

6

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 07 '23

Do you vote?

sometimes

look at scores?

often, but mostly just the score that the bot updates

would I mind it being gone?

It's nice to have, but not crucial. The scores suffer extreme bias. Even shows that most viewers call mid(dling) at best get often scores >4 or they get brigaded/memed to death. It sort of works to gauge which episodes got a better or worse reception, but sometimes it is just because outstanding episodes (postively or negatively) just get more votes.

3

u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 08 '23

nope

never

not at all

→ More replies (7)

10

u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Jul 16 '23

Meta post about the Meta Thread in the Meta Thread time, I find it interesting that the Thread’s been a lot more active this month and how that’s because the mods seem to have been actively incentivizing such, between having promoted it in the sidebar a couple times on-and-off and having it be stickied a lot more often. Only halfway through the month and we’re already at almost 400, a rare feat! Even the month of the blackout/great API debacle last month didn’t crack 300 the whole month through.

It looks like the mods are taking direct steps to encourage more active participation in the sub, and that’s cool to see! Kudos on that.

8

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jul 14 '23

Apparently reddit notifications are lagging today.

I thought I was shadowbanned.

8

u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Jul 15 '23

How about hosting a large AMQ tournament for those Bot-chan golds?

8

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 29 '23

How long does it usually take to get an episode thread discussion through a modmail request? I sent one over an hour ago for the new Bleach episode and I'm still for it.

6

u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jul 29 '23

I made one for temple and still waiting RIP lol

5

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 29 '23

4

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 30 '23

It depends on time of day/who is around to make the threads. Generally, we're very active during EST hours, but anything outside of that is very hit or miss for thread coverage.

7

u/HikikomoriMan Jul 02 '23

What happened to the anime suggest subreddit?

7

u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 05 '23

How is the effort to do more AMAs going / is that on hold with reddit being reddit?

Did Cloverworks ghost us

8

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 05 '23

We have one in the works maybe! We'll let you know when we find out more.

Did Cloverworks ghost us

As far as I know, yeah, haven't heard anything from them for a solid minute.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 08 '23

Actually now that it's finally up, is there a reason why Bleach: Thousand Year Blood War episode 14's discussion thread only has the romaji title (Sennen Kessen-hen - Ketsubetsu-tan) in it and not the official English one (Thousand Year Blood War - The Separation) as well? I thought every airing show was supposed to have both titles in it.

5

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 09 '23

The En name got added as an alias instead of an En title. Should be fixed in following weeks.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Jul 13 '23

Hi, question about AutoLovePon - Why mark episode number sequentially instead of by season?

For example, JJK is now on Season 2, episode 2. And everybody refers to it as "episode 2". But the discussion thread is from "Season 2, episode 26" which is just confusing?

It's even more problematic in the future. When someone will try and google for a discussion thread they'd look for episode 2 (that they've just watch), not calculate how many episodes were in season 1 then add 2. It's even more convoluted for multiple seasons.

4

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 13 '23

We are aware of the error around the naming of "25" for episode 1.

The bot didn't trigger for episode 2, and it was manually made as "26". Hoping to have this resolved from next week onward.

7

u/Verzwei Jul 17 '23 edited Jul 17 '23

Totally altruistic request and not at all selfish personal salt because I missed the recent End of Spring survey, but can the team consider:

  1. Running mod-lead community surveys for a longer period of time. Even just two weeks instead of one feels like it would result in a lot more eyes on them.
  2. Advertising them more consistently and visibly. Don't get me wrong, I love the "The Place" images on the sidebar that highlight the Daily Thread image when there's nothing else going on, but a time-sensitive survey that lasts for such a short amount of time should be insanely visible on the subreddit for its entire duration.

The combination of "doesn't run for very long" and "isn't even advertised/stickied for the entirety of its run" makes it really easy for dummies like me to completely miss community events despite the fact that I'm on this subreddit every single day. For people who aren't here every day, then they'd be even easier to miss, as it would come down to the user coincidentally happening to use the subreddit at the right time when the content happens to be promoted, otherwise they'll never even know that something was active for them to participate in.

Edit: Even maybe a sidebar category for "Events" like the existing "Contests" category, if there's concern about dedicating the sidebar image and/or the second sticky slot to a single thing for too long of a period. Could also list future events with their start date on the table, too. Would work for more than seasonal surveys; you could use that to list major dates (application deadline, public voting, results, etc.) for other big events like the annual Awards.

6

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 22 '23

Edit: Even maybe a sidebar category for "Events" like the existing "Contests" category, if there's concern about dedicating the sidebar image and/or the second sticky slot to a single thing for too long of a period.

One thing in general is that I think we maybe need to re-evaluate the sidebar as a whole. There's a lot of stuff, and most people aren't going to see most of it. Might be a good idea to figure out what we really need and what we can trim down.

8

u/Verzwei Jul 22 '23 edited Jul 22 '23

First off, I apologize in advance for my formatting in this comment. It's painful to look at but it's late at night/early in the morning and I didn't originally intend to review and comment on the entire sidebar, it just sorta happened.

My unsolicited suggestions at a glance:


1

I'd say bin the AMA section. Those 2 links over there are to threads that are over a year old, their dates are for 2022, not 2023. Replace AMA with "Events", include AMAs on it (if they happen again) alongside anything else mod-run like seasonal surveys, Awards stuff, feedback threads like we did for show titles on episode threads or regarding the blackout, etc. Format the table like the contests, where you have "completed" and "ongoing" for status, and then additionally include anything upcoming that has a set date.

Keep the list tight, maybe to a rolling 3-month (6-month at the very most) window so that the table feels fresh and relevant to what's going on. At bare minimum, seasonal survey activity will always have a few entries on the table to make it not seem dead.


2

The spoiler section can probably be massively trimmed, down to:

All spoilers must be tagged. The code to make a spoiler in a comment or text post body is:

[Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<

All the other info is (somewhat) superfluous and a user unfamiliar with our rules probably won't read that far down on the sidebar anyway, actually most users who don't follow our spoiler rules are just going to post a tag without context and get hit by automod which has all the instructions anyway.


3

I'd maybe change the "Megathreads" category to something like "Recurring threads" and you could probably cut the daily thread off the list. Since it 100% always has the first sticky slot, I don't think there's a big need to have it additionally linked in the sidebar.


4, In the rules chunk...

You can probably get rid of the "flair your posts" section, pretty sure the sub is set to not allow unflaired posts, if it's not, flip that on.


  • Do not post untagged spoilers.

Remove this, there's already an entire section dedicated to spoiler syntax.


Old:

  • No memes, image macros, reaction images, "fixed" posts, or rage comics.

New:

  • No memes or image macros

The reaction, fixed, rage stuff is either dated (nobody does rage comics any more) or is implicitly included under memes anyway.


Old:

  • Do not link to/lead people towards torrents, proxies, or unofficial streams/downloads.

New:

  • Do not link or lead people to unofficial streams or downloads.

Move the Legal Streams and Downloads link down to the help section with all the other links.


Old:

  • Do not sell things, use affiliate links, spread referral scams, or link to crowdfunding.
  • Links to sales or products that you do not profit from are OK. It is not OK to try to sell your own stuff here.

New:

  • Do not attempt to buy, sell, or trade products or services.

Old:

  • Do not post Hentai here. Lightly NSFW things are okay. Read the rules for examples.

New:

  • Do not post about or link to hentai.

Or:

  • Do not post about or link to pornography.

Omit the bit about lightly NSFW and reading the rules for examples. Porn is porn and most people should be able to figure out what is and is not porn. Regardless, the blurb about it in the sidebar needs to be short and to the point.


Old:

  • Merchandise should be posted in our Daily Anime or Casual Discussion Fridays threads. Collection posts and purchases, including gifted/received items, count as merchandise. You may also use this thread for Merchandise related questions.

New:

  • Topics about merchandise and collections should be posted in our Daily Anime or Casual Discussion Fridays threads.

Old:

  • Do not post screenshots, jokes, single images of cosplay, wallpapers, comics, or any other low-effort content.
  • Albums of 5 or more images (3 or more images for cosplay) will be exempt from this rule so long as the images are relevant to the point or idea being illustrated.

New:

  • No single images, except for newly released official media.
  • Albums of 5 or more related images that illustrate a point are permitted.

The mention of cosplay is probably unnecessary because IIRC all cosplay has to be a text post now, like fanart, so there's no reason to bring it up as an album post. If that's not the case, probably consider revising/streamlining the cosplay rules to match the fanart ones. Broke the album thing into its own bullet point both to keep the individual points short but also the album rule is such an odd bird that it deserves separate mention, since it might(?) supersede other rules.


  • Full song link posts are considered low-effort unless officially uploaded and newly released.

This can probably just go, I think it's some weird leftover before music/official media rules changed anyway, song posts require video content and are governed by the OM or edit rules depending on if it's an official upload or something fan-made.


  • All [Fanart] posts must be posted as a text post. You may submit up to two Fanart posts per 7-day period.
  • All [Watch This] and [Writing] posts must be text posts with a minimum of 1500 characters.

These aren't necessary. Automod already pops fanart posts that don't follow the expected post format, and it either removes or re-flairs WT and Writing posts that don't meet the character threshold. Details can be on the full rules page but it probably doesn't need to be on the sidebar. If anything, rather than going into details within the sidebar itself, you could just have:

  • See Fanart rules here.
  • See Clip, Edit, and Video rules here.

That way people who want to share that kind of content have an easy link to the (admitted complicated but also necessary) detailed section without trying to force it into the sidebar where most users probably don't need that info in the first place.


Move the Watch This Archive down to all the other links in the help category.


Proposed version of the rules section of the sidebar, could still need tweaking:

  • Everything posted here must be anime specific.
  • Posting requires 10 comment karma on r/anime.
  • No memes or image macros.
  • No single image posts, unless they are newly released official media.
  • Albums posts of 5 or more related images that illustrate a point are permitted.
  • Do not link or lead people to unofficial streams or downloads.
  • Do not use link shortening services.
  • Do not attempt to buy, sell, or trade products or services.
  • Do not post about or link to hentai.
  • Post Meta concerns in the monthly meta threads.
  • Topics about merchandise and collections should be posted in our Daily Anime or Casual Discussion Fridays threads.
  • See Fanart rules here.
  • See Clip, Edit, and Video rules here.

That should cover most of the basics in a very direct manner, with links to the Fanart and Clip/Edit/Vid stuff which TBH have so many requirements that you might as well direct the user to the relevant rules page instead of even attempting to truncate it into the sidebar space.

Then you put the legal streams and downloads and the WT archive links in the help section.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/astolflo_ Jul 02 '23

Where’s the episode thread for Fate/Strange Fake?

6

u/Nomar_95 :Ed:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nomar_95 Jul 06 '23

this is reddit-wide and not really related to this sub, but it sucks that the hide button no longer works. Never realized how much I used it until it was gone.

4

u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Jul 07 '23

any reason why they removed the hide button?

6

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 07 '23

Allegedly some mistake on their part

I wonder (and dread) what the fuck could have caused it

5

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 07 '23

6

u/Nebresto Jul 09 '23

Not too important since its a week old already, but the database links on the Mushoku Tensei episode 0 thread go to the main show instead of the special episode page

6

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 10 '23

I shall fix this shortly. Thanks for bringing this to our attention.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 28 '23

A bit surprised that /u/FetchFrosh's survey isn't getting any kind of permanent spot. Sticky slots are limited so that's fair although I think it's a valid option, but it's nowhere in the sidebar including the two image slots, and it's not in the "CSS News Feed" (the one with "A Quick-Start Guide to /r/anime" and others) either.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Aug 02 '23

Discord anime Swap coming up SOON on August 3rd 9:00 PM PST

If anyone is interested in a fun event our Discord server's Secret Santa event is about to start for this month. The anime swap is a monthly event where users anonymously force one another to watch a certain anime. It starts soon!

What happens is that you sign up and are asked to send a letter to your Santa. In this letter, you tell your Santa what type of anime you might be interested in. You usually will list a length requirement and maybe some genres or themes you do not want to watch. It's also best practice to link a MAL or Anilist.

Time passes and when the swap starts your Santa will receive your letter. But on the other hand, you also receive someone else's letter. You then look at their letter and anonymously send them a show to watch. Then everyone spends the month watching their show given to them by their Santa and shitposting in the Anime-Swap chat. At the end of the month, everyone does a formal write-up of their thoughts and then the Santas are revealed.

Anime Swap is a fun way to get shows to watch and interact with the community. It's kind of like an anime contract that the sub has done before but the anonymous element of it is something I enjoy. It's fun trying to figure out who your Santa is and I love playing detective and shitposting.

If you want to try something low-committal you can ask for a shorter anime or even a movie if you want. It's a good way to test the waters.

How to Join

You go to our Discord

Click the react to get access to everything

Go to Channels & Roles and click Anime Swap

Go to the Anime Swap chat

Click the pins and find this chat

Follow the instructions.

6

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23

Question about movie ep threads -

What actually is the official mod policy on those? im very happy to request them as i notice screenings pop up (e.g. right now for the first slam dunk, even tho im not going to see it), and surely Miyazaki's new film later on, but is there like an automated process for them? Or is it like unofficial subbed releases where it's more ad hoc.

If it's the latter, is there a way where if a region-wide Eng-subtitled screening time/date is noted, that a thread be scheduled in advance to go out on that date at the time of the first screening? I just feel like timely movie threads will really help discussion esp for more niche/single screening or 2 movies (which slam dunk... isn't actually lol). Since sometimes, though rarely for these niche-er screenings they just dont pop up at all.

Much thanks!

edit: i realize right now that this thread is probably about to get replaced LOL. I'll repost in the new thread if the mods haven't answered this by then :)

5

u/thevaleycat Aug 03 '23

It'd be nice if these didn't have to be user-requested. I think the Bakuten Movie never got a thread when it came out on Crunchyroll a few months (?) ago but it's so niche and kinda late at this point I doubt it'd get much discussion anyway, unfortunately.

3

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Aug 03 '23

In every case for movies, its a manually process of someone creating a thread.

I now manage a lot of the episode bot stuff. I live in New Zealand which has the benefit of being a day ahead. So things that are mainstream and get a subbed theatrical releases (like Slam Dunk) are on my radar as I make an effort to see all of them (and thats why you get those AU/NZ release threads first like Suzume or Go-toubun).

If it is something like a streaming site releases; we are generally pretty onto it (eg: Bubble).

Unofficial subbed releases or BD/DVD releases that come much later sometimes don't get a thread. These are harder to track and are not as well caught by the team. However we would create a thread if one was asked for (eg: Bakuten we didn't u/thevaleycat).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/phantomthiefkid_ Jul 02 '23

What do you think about linking PV from Crunchyroll Youtube channel?

PV on Crunchyroll channel are not available in these countries. For a few of us from those countries it's pretty annoying to see a PV on the front page while not being able to watch it.

Edit: Hidive is even worse their PV are only available in US and Canada

6

u/cppn02 Jul 03 '23

PV on Crunchyroll channel are not available in these countries.

FYI it is different for every show. Crunchyroll usually only makes them available in countries where they have the license so if they have a show in the US but not in Europe the trailer won't be available for us Euros either.

5

u/ashketchum2095 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kiruko- Jul 03 '23

Hello, I just had a question regarding a post of mine that was removed:

Sorry, your submission has been removed.

  • Edited footage (AMVs, compilations, scene splicing, cross-media comparisons, etc) from shows should use the "Video Edit" flair, be at least 60 seconds long, and include the anime name in the title of the post if the edit comes from a single specific anime. If any footage is from a recently aired episode, wait a week after the episode's discussion thread is posted before posting the edit. Additionally, we only allow each user to post two edits per 30 days.

My removed post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/14ovles/which_anime_made_you_say_wow/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=1

To my knowledge I met all the criteria, I don't really care that it was removed but would like to avoid it in the future thank you.

6

u/AmusedDragon :Bs::Bu: Jul 04 '23

Honestly, per our rules and criteria that should not have been removed. There is some talk of there maybe formerly being a line about listing sources if an edit has many in a comment but I don't see that in our rules at present. I did reapprove it for now. Not sure if that rule will change in the future but it meets criteria at present.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/phantomthiefkid_ Jul 03 '23

4

u/AmusedDragon :Bs::Bu: Jul 04 '23

Should hopefully be fixed for next week as "The Dreaming Boy is a Realist" as that is what is being used elsewhere. Thank you.

5

u/DarkAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkAudit Jul 04 '23

Chibi Godzilla ep 13 is up.

4

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 04 '23

I guess the bot didn't pick it up because they didn't add the episode to the playlist

5

u/chilidirigible Jul 14 '23

A couple of months ago I had a user flair submission accepted... but I've found that it doesn't look as good in use as I thought it would when I was testing it out. Can I submit an edited version? Can I submit a different image from the same series? Can /u/abyssbringer still get in there to change things?

6

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 14 '23

I'm probably the mod most involved in user flairs with Abyss gone, so feel free to send it my way (though I'm out in the boonies for the weekend, so I won't actually do anything until Monday).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DarkAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkAudit Jul 20 '23

Are we about due for Seasonal Comment Face nominations?

4

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 21 '23

Nominations usually come around when shows are on episode 3 or 4, right? So I would guess they'll start within a week or so.

3

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 22 '23

Nomination thread coming Tuesday (25th) and will be open a weekish.

In the meantime here is the seasonal comment face survey.

You can see the results here.

5

u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jul 22 '23

Was the #writeitdown face suggestion from the Animegataris rewatch discussed or forgotten? Sometimes when quoting someone, a #thumbsup or #think works, but other times it's more like "I should copy that or do the same." Also, don't think it needs animated and #noted may work better than #writeitdown.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 30 '23

host applications

I sleep

a third image on the sidebar

Very happy with shortening the contests/batch releases assuming that helped to fit space. So many of those were outdated

4

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 30 '23

a third image on the sidebar

Yeah, trying something new in this space.

Still a work in progress for sidebar cleanup. So nothing is final yet.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '23

I’d like to have transparency on the backup plan should Reddit continue to tighten the screws. Everything here should start being mirrored somewhere else so a cutover can happen cleanly if possible.

9

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 10 '23

Right now, the simple answer is that there isn't really a backup plan. There's been some talk about various options, but it's not really a major focus at the moment. The Wiki is backed up, but beyond that we haven't really spent too much time on it. There's a couple places like Tildes and Lemmy, and we could either migrate to those or set up our own instances. We'll probably talk more about it in the future to try to have something ready in case it's necessary, but for now I don't think it's a huge priority for the team.

7

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 10 '23

I will also piggyback off of /u/FetchFrosh and say that sites such as Lemmy and Tildes already have established anime communities, which means that it would be highly unlikely for the entirety of the r/anime mod team to migrate over and continue to moderate as we have been. Not to mention, we would lose a significant margin of our userbase. So currently it's not worth the headache for us to move outside of Reddit.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jul 11 '23

You're welcome to show up at my house and sit on my couch and chat about anime anytime after reddit dies. Bring beer!

4

u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria Jul 02 '23

Are there any plans for when the next Flair Bounty Board will be? I think it's been a couple of months since that was last posted for suggestions.

11

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 02 '23

u/AbyssBringer normally ran that and he has stepped down from the mod team. Right now I'm focused on getting the seasonal flairs together (Yohane got an early release) and dropping those probably middle of the month. So I'll probably run something in August once all the early seasonal stuff runs its course.

9

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 03 '23

AbyssBringer

You really had to ruin the perfect aesthetics of my name by making the B capital. It works for your name because they are both F thus making them match really nicely. Abyssbringer > AbyssBringer

6

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 03 '23

I stepped down from the mod team and that was my personal project and I didn't ask anyone to take it over. I'm sure Gap or Fetch will probably do something in the same spirit but it can be a fair amount of work to do it the way I did it.

4

u/DerpyMcFrakles https://myanimelist.net/profile/KakkaKarrotCake Jul 02 '23

I've noticed that the episode discussion bot will often say there are no streams available when their actually are. Take the Ryza no Atelier discussion thread for example. That thread is the most recent example I could find, but I've seen it happen in other threads.

7

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 02 '23 edited Jul 02 '23

Sometimes we do add them if we notice, but the bot missing streaming services is one of the few downsides to automation. If you do notice an episode thread that is missing a streaming link, send us a modmail, and we can either add it or try to reconfigure the bot for future weeks.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/MrJackfruit Jul 04 '23

If I want I ask a question that is basically “can I get a list of short busty anime characters” where would I post that? I don’t see a clear subreddit for where I’d ask this.

7

u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jul 04 '23
→ More replies (1)

4

u/entelechtual Jul 11 '23

Is there an issue with reporting comments on old.reddit on mobile? It doesn’t give me the full list of rule violations, just something like “belongs in the source corner”, even on non episode threads, and other.

3

u/cppn02 Jul 11 '23 edited Jul 11 '23

For me reporting on mobile+old.reddit doesn't work at all.

I pick 'Breaks r/anime rules' but the 'Next' button stays greyed out.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/JoshFB4 Jul 20 '23

Hey mods. Since this month appears to be a down month traffic wise on the sub, is that playing out the same in the data that you guys have for the month so far. You don’t have to actually respond to this if you want to wait and reveal the traffic numbers in the next Meta Thread. :)

5

u/AmusedDragon :Bs::Bu: Jul 20 '23

Just from an initial look there is no noticeable change in the negative for traffic, subs per day, and comments per day. In fact, some of those figures are a bit higher than normal comparing to other previous months and we're not even done with this month yet.

We're tracking for this to be one of the more active months in recent history.

6

u/JoshFB4 Jul 20 '23

That’s so strange lol. Just from looking at upvotes you’d think half the sub was thanos snapped.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '23

What with the recent influx of recommendation posts? They're all the same in different words.

Should there be a recommendation megathread for the most common ones like "new to anime" & "haven't watched in x years"?

6

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 20 '23 edited Jul 20 '23

What with the recent influx of recommendation posts?

I haven't dug up any stats but if there's an uptick in [What to Watch?] threads here recently that's likely due to /r/animesuggest closing down, it was a fairly large community focused on recommendations.

Should there be a recommendation megathread

That's what the daily thread — the pinned post at the top of the subreddit (today's edition) — is for. As per the title: Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussion.

If you think there should be a separate megathread just for recommendations: there used to be one! It was a weekly thread, but that (along with a few other weekly threads) was retired about a year ago in favor of the one that's rotated every day. Data here but in short the weekly threads were fine while pinned but had next to no activity when not, and changing that over to something that will always be pinned was more beneficial overall even if it traded off specificity. We can only have two pinned posts at a time so having a separate megathread just for recommendations again isn't really an option as we use the second slot for a lot of other things.

4

u/docks4cocks Jul 21 '23

Hey mods, can i ask what isekai communities would be intrested to join an communual isekai fan discord server?

6

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 21 '23

We don't allow posts that are primarily focused on advertising other communities like Discord servers.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/LordTrinity https://myanimelist.net/profile/LordTrinity Jul 25 '23

Hello mods, I'm thinking about parsing some data with Best Girl 10 comments and posting it here, once it is over. Do you have any ideas about which data could be interesting to get and share?

I'm thinking about the users themselves (like who comments more, who gets more upvotes when doing comments), the girls (which ones get mentioned the most) and some overall stats (like total comments, how many times the world "salty" and its variants get mentioned, among others). I'm open to suggestions

4

u/thevaleycat Jul 26 '23

Do y'all have any plans to share stats on flairs? Curious which ones are popular and which ones are not

5

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 26 '23

10

u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Jul 03 '23

Mushoku Tensei S2E0 dropped less than a week ago and their is already drama in the thread about censoring.

This is going to be a busy season for you mods.

6

u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Jul 04 '23

if both sides could just behave we wouldn´t have this problem but hey we are in the internet so we can´t expect that

8

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 04 '23

Feel bad for the new mods who have to jump on board while the show that creates easily the most toxic discussions is airing.

Good luck!

6

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Jul 05 '23

Nothing says Summer like a good old training arc with two of the most controversial shows out there.

I'm not looking forward to the people whose comments are being removed coming back to scream about how the r/anime mods are silencing all criticism/defense of a show.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Verzwei Jul 04 '23

Meanwhile three mods stepped down just before that show and another controversial one began airing...

7

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 12 '23

Shouldn't this post and most of the replies to this be nuked by spoiler removals, especially as it is not even tagged as spoiler post?

Unsure how this can stay up, but discussion of content warnings, themes or "it gets darker later" are against the rules.

3

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 13 '23

It has since been removed, and most of the replies have been nuked (I'll comb through again later). Sometimes things like that slip through because our application of the meta-spoiler rule is a bit inconsistent. If you ask for a specific anime scenario, you're going to get specific answers (eg. Anime where the main character dies?). We do technically have the meta-spoiler rule but I don't think I've ever seen anyone use it outside of 1-2 powerusers. Does this mean we should give up enforcing it? No, but I think it's hard to justify its application sometimes. The thread you linked had over 300 comments, so that's 300 recommendations/discussion comments down the drain. Basically, it's a very tough gray area for us, where yes they're spoilers, but man it does not feel good removing all of those.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 02 '23

Why was this post removed? It just restates a trigger warning that got removed the day before due to spoilers the day before, with a short mention of that removal.

First, what the fuck? You can hardly genuinely claim that trigger warnings are spoilers. This flied directly in the face of your usual explanation that you're being strict about spoilers in order to be inclusive and welcoming to everyone, because this is the exact opposite of that.

Secondly, you might disagree about the tone they used, but explaining that the equivalent comment from the day before got removed for spoilers is in no way whatsoever a meta comment. There is no way you can claim a removal for what amounts to a context note as being made in good faith.

11

u/cultpet Jul 02 '23

Won't touch the e-drama brewing down in the other comments, but about this

You can hardly genuinely claim that trigger warnings are spoilers.

How can you not? Telling people a murder or a sexual assault happens in the anime is definitely a spoiler, is it not?

The person did not post it maliciously to spoil people (they meant it as a trigger warning) but if it spoils people, well it's a spoiler.

I'm not trying to be insensitive here, but this is a sub for people who like to watch anime first and foremost, and I'd wager that many more users care more about not being spoiled, than they care about trigger warnings.

Plus, there are ways to put a trigger warning in spoiler tag without rendering it useless. Example: [Trigger Warning: Title of a show airing this season with a graphic sexual assault scene] Title of the anime goes here

This way the people who want to avoid triggering content will check the spoiler to know they have to avoid the show, and the people who do not care about triggering content will skip it so they don't get spoiled about the content in advance.

7

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 02 '23

Well I didn't comment on that too much as I haven't seen it myself, but the discussion seemed to agree it's a thing from the beginning on, thus it being a spoiler in the first place is questionable.

But I've also advocated for years now to regard things like for example [HxH]"keep watching beyond the first few arcs, it becomes much darker halfway through" as spoilers, when it's my experience in the sub that these are free to go untagged in places like recommendation threads. If that's not considered spoilers then trigger warnings certainly aren't spoilers either.

10

u/thevaleycat Jul 02 '23

I haven't watched the show in question but it seems the SA isn't a one-off "plot twist" scene, it's a frequent occurrence starting from ep 1 much like the death in Vinland Saga or AoT, and no one spoiler tags those. In any case, it just seems spoilers are moderated inconsistently, since Ridley is not the only one who brought up the SA in that show without tagging it, and those other comments haven't been removed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (32)

6

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Jul 08 '23

Mods, what is your favorite desert?

7

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 08 '23

Atacama, one of the oldest and driest, to the point where it's used for testing experiments for Martian missions.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 08 '23

Rangipo Desert, more commonly known as the desert road.

I also like brownie with custard.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 10 '23

I have a prominent sweet tooth, so I’m always down for a visit to the bakery, but even still, I’m a fiend for ice cream at the end of the day.

Off the top of my head, I’ve really enjoyed Coolhaus, McConnell’s, MayDay, Smitten, High Road, Nancy’s Fancy (okay, I know it’s gelato, but c’mon), Walpole Creamery, Jeni’s, and High Point Creamery if I’m visiting Denver and Cloud 10 Creamery if I’m visiting Houston.

EDIT: You know what, I’m keeping my original comment. Reading is hard.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 08 '23

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 05 '23

Looks like I can see tweets without being logged in? So this shouldn't be needed anymore - unless Elon does weird shit again.

4

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 05 '23

We are continuing to monitor it.

3

u/drstripjo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hanten Jul 08 '23

Can we get Bleach discussion thread please?

3

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 08 '23

I send a modmail like 50 minutes ago, still ing for it.

3

u/phantomthiefkid_ Jul 14 '23

Where's Kanokari thread? The episode's been out for an hour now

3

u/Thatsmaboi23 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Thatsmaboi23 Jul 27 '23

Why was this post removed?.

Was it something on my part that was done wrongly? Didn’t even get a notification/comment for the removal. Weird.

3

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 30 '23

Looks like you got an answer in the thread, but just to clarify, pillarboxing is when black bars artificially appear on the screen, meaning the clip was captured or uploaded in an unintended aspect ratio. We require clips to not have those black bars by being captured and uploaded in their original aspect ratio.

3

u/Martian_on_the_Moon Aug 04 '23

Care to explain why my comment was removed: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/15gaimk/bungo_stray_dogs_season_5_episode_4_discussion/juqi7dt/?context=10000

Everything I said is from anime only (previous seasons) and I don't read manga/novel/etc of this show. What is there to spoil? Unless you want to tell me that I correctly predicted what is gonna happen in the future...

3

u/AmusedDragon :Bs::Bu: Aug 04 '23

Hi, took a look at the comment and agree it should not have been removed, it's been restored.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Aug 05 '23

Care to explain why my thread was removed?

Thread

The thread is inspired by this similarly titled thread made around the same time, but about a different character.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jul 08 '23

Me observing the inconsistency between last week and this week's Atelier Ryza thread:

Last week's thread had one correctly removed comment despite actual plot spoilers throughout it. Every comment discussing [Ryza, game]the series' fanservice, while not allowed in Seven Spellblades, or game-anime comparisons, specifically those calling it [Ryza, game]a comfy slice-of-life or coming-of-age story, should have been removed. Examples one, two, three, four (plus child comments), five (plus child), six (character name isn't known), seven, eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve, thirteen, fourteen, fifteen (who knows how many I missed, just ctrl+f a couple words). Then there's this week's thread where mentioning [Ryza, game]a monster's strength compared to level 1 characters or elements is removed, yet mentioning this game not having alchemy failures remains.

I continue to believe that nuking threads of mid-to-low popularity shows to strictly enforce a Source Corner not mentioned in the subreddit's rules page is a terrible decision. Precisely adhering to a rules page doesn't make a a better community; considering the situation and using discretion to determine if actions outweigh the cost does.

Anyway, now that it's been called out in the meta thread and thus brought to attention like reports, hope whoever removes comments in last week's thread enjoys doing so.

27

u/cppn02 Jul 08 '23 edited Jul 08 '23

a Source Corner not mentioned in the subreddit's rules page is a terrible decision.

I mean there literally is a sticky at the top of every single episode discussion...

Also, as an anime only I'd rather have 120 comments about the actual show than 300 comments with 250 of them making some relation to the game.
People love to complain about LN and manga readers but after Arknights (some episode discussions were basically unusable as an anime only), Nier and now Ryza I'm confident in saying that people who played the game are the worst lol. Less heavy on plot spoilers maybe but they can't seem to be able to shut up about the game at all.

Genshin is probably gonna be an absolute shitshow lol.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/J765 Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23

Could a "source material corner"-like thing be considered as an option for news announcement posts?

Like in the split cour announcement thread for Mushoku Tensei S2, some of the comments about future events in the next Mushoku Tensei season, while not explicitly stating what those events are, they do describe their feelings about those future events quite clearly. Or those discussions about if "that one" thing out the source material will happen in that new season (They are effectively spoiling that a type of event in the story, that is numbered, will have further similar happenings [Mushoku Tensei] there won't just be a turning point 3, but also a turning point 4 ). Or talking about what volumes are going to be adapted while also talking about in which of them something big will happen, while also talking about how many volumes having been adapted in S1.

Maybe I'm just super sensitive about this kind of "setting expectations" spoilering my experience with adaptations, but it does feel like that kind of stuff should be discussed under a "source corner" like post, and not in the general thread. Like it isn't the official trailers setting those expectations, but it is the readers of the source material bringing that information from outside.

Or maybe that is just the accepted natural way of talking about anime adaptations and I just have to stop clicking on even news threads about adaptations to not get spoiled like that.

10

u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jul 07 '23

Counterpoint is what do you expect to see opening the thread? People saying "I like MT" and nothing beyond that?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jul 25 '23

so are all these spice and wolf posts on the front page coincidental? i guess all the users are holo fans judging by the username.

9

u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jul 25 '23

That was due to the best girl contest, same reason we got multiple Marin related posts

→ More replies (2)

6

u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jul 25 '23

Huh, figured you've been around long enough to know why. Expect another dozen or two clips for contestants (12 alive atm) over the next 4 days.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Salty145 https://anilist.co/user/yLSalty145 Jul 28 '23

Call me crazy, but the amount of “What to Watch” threads that I have to sift through is becoming a bit overwhelming. That and the amount of “Discussion” threads that are “I discovered this semi-popular anime and just want to let you know about it” also seems to be on the rise.

I know there’s not much of anything that can be done, since it seems a lot of the casual audience from r/animesuggestions have come over here and there’s not much that can be done about that. At the very least, I’d like to not have to scroll through 20,000 requests for more anime boobs or super niche recs just to browse this page every day.

4

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 28 '23

In the meantime (or if nothing changes), if you're on a browser you can use xr.reddit.com instead of www/new/old.reddit.com to hide "What to watch?" flairs (also available here). If you're on an app, I hope it has a way to filter out flairs.

3

u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Jul 30 '23

We're a bit ambivalent about what to do for recommendation threads since those are generally the gateway post for most new users. We want to be careful about how to limit them because of that.

We're happy to take suggestions, but we don't have any concrete plans to sort out WTW/Discussion threads at this time.

4

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 16 '23

What would you say is the best amount of time wait before bumping a modmail? Been a week for one of mine but with the history here of people being banned or threatened with permabans in modmail discussions I don't want to push my luck there.

9

u/Verzwei Jul 17 '23 edited Jul 17 '23

Been a week for one of mine but with the history here of people being banned or threatened with permabans in modmail discussions

From my time as a mod, I've don't believe I've ever seen anyone get threatened with a ban over simply asking about a legitimate issue via modmail. The only time I've seen modmail escalate in that direction is when the user sending the modmail is openly hostile, usually using slurs, when disputing a (probably extremely valid) removal. Like Fetch said, there have been times where someone publicly comments something that is incredibly sus, and then we pop it for incivility, and then in modmail we'll get full-on six-letter words.

Sometimes we'd toss a mute on someone who was already banned and simply refused to accept or understand the explanation for that ban, even after many attempts (and usually multiple moderators) rephrasing it several different ways. In those cases that's more of a temporary "you can't modmail us again for X days" and not a direct extension of a subreddit ban. There is a threshold at which it simply becomes spam, but, as one of the community's regular powerusers, I sincerely doubt anything you'd sent would fall into that particular category. Sometimes a modmail can slip through the cracks, maybe the person answering (other) messages at the time doesn't have a proper response, or the issue requires the input from a particular mod who isn't available, and then the mail becomes "old" and then glossed over due to a lack of communication. There were a couple times where I meant to follow up on something then completely forgot to do so.

I obviously can't speak for the team but I'd say if just a day passes and you don't get any response then it probably wouldn't hurt to bump the modmail. If it is a complicated issue, we'd usually at least try to write back something along the lines of "Yes we see the modmail we don't have a good answer yet, hang on" so that you'd know it wasn't lost in the shuffle.

5

u/cppn02 Jul 16 '23

You have a lot of patience lol. The 2-3 of times I did that I waited mere hours.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 17 '23

As far as modmail goes, I think it's pretty hard to get temp banned in modmail by mistake, let alone permabanned. Unless someone's trolling we rarely even mute people. The only real cases where it happens is people escalating from a regular ban to a permanent ban when, as an example, they got hit for racism and doubled down on it.

3

u/4v33n0 Jul 17 '23

With, for example, Fate series' spoilers, should it be a rule to state which entry the spoiler actually applies to?

Today, I saw this comment, and initially I didn't click the spoiler, because I haven't watched all the Fate anime. I later came back to thread, and then realised that I've watched nearly all the Fate anime that I actually am interested in, so I don't mind getting spoiled on one of the others, so I clicked it. No biggie, it turns out that it was a Heaven's Feel 2 spoiler (though if you hadn't watched HF2, but had watched Fate/Zero, you'd also be aware of that information), one of the ones I'd watched.

But, if I was someone who had say, watched F/SN and F/Z, but hadn't yet watched the El-Melloi spinoff, or Apocrypha, etc., then it'd be a pretty big risk to click the spoiler, because all it says is [Fate Series spoiler].

If someone tagged a Monogatari spoiler as [anime adapted from Nisio Isin work spoiler], I think people would rightfully see that as unnecessarily vague (and I assume it would be removed?), and he only has something like 6 anime adaptations, which is fewer than the no. of different Fate series there are.

I used Fate as an example, but this would also apply to any other big anime franchise with many spin-offs.

9

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 18 '23

As it stands, our spoiler rules are already pretty involved, and these are fairly niche cases. I don't think that we really want to start policing exact spoiler formats for individual series. As long as the spoiler tag accurately reflects what is under it, I don't think we're looking to add more complications.

7

u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 18 '23

That feels like incredible overkill, if someone is worried about getting spoiled for some aspect of the series, don’t click it?

Your example of it being a HF2 spoiler:

User marks it as HF2 spoiler - people that have seen HF2 can unspoil it safely, people that have seen 3rei or Fate Zero or Emiy Gohan etc. can take a calculated risk and not get spoiled, others can get spoiled

User marks it as Fate spoiler - people that have seen everything can unspoil it safely, people that haven’t seen everything can take a calculated risk, others can get spoiled

There’s always some level of spoiler “risk” invoked, but forcing someone to be as specific as possible is just going to kill comments

→ More replies (5)