r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jun 04 '23
Meta Meta Thread - Month of June 04, 2023
Rule Changes
Official Media Links
All Official Media posts must be link posts to the relevant content, and image rehosting (via i.reddit, imgur, or any other source) is now prohibited. Multi-image albums, such as collections of countdown images, are still allowed via imgur.
Moderator Applications Now Open
Running for another week if you'd like to help manage things around /r/anime! Thread with details and the form here.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: May 2023 | April 2023 | March 2023 | February 2023 | January 2023 | December 2022 | November 2022 | October 2022 | September 2022 | August 2022 | July 2022 | June 2022 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/Thrasher439 https://anilist.co/user/Thrasher Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 04 '23
Bit of a slimmer month once again with not too much to go into. However in case you missed it Scavenger Hunt Results have been released. With that said.
June Mod Report
Voted to require Official Media posts to be direct link posts, prohibiting rehosts. [Vote Passed]
Voted to amend recent Official Media link post vote so that image albums (countdown art collections, Megami poster compilations, etc) may still be rehosted as normal. [Vote Passed]
May by the Numbers
49
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 08 '23
We are conscious that Reddit's announced API changes have stirred up frenzy and outrage. While our general stance over the years has been not to get involved in reddit activism, we are seriously discussing the issue.
Edit: 6/6/23:
We have not yet decided on our full involvement.
We have expanded the discussion discussion to its own thread here. Consider leaving your thoughts there, even if it is just a repeat of statements made here.
Edit: 8/6/23:
/r/anime will be going dark starting June 12 in protest against Reddit's API changes.
16
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 23 '23
Now that the drama has died down, I just wanted to take a moment to say thanks. I don't have anything constructive or insightful or poetic to say... just thanks. Thanks for taking the time out of your day to moderate a bajillion rule-breaking comments, again and again and again and again and again. Thanks for going above and beyond the basic requirements of moderating the sub, and making it into a genuine community. Thanks for putting up with what must no doubt be a truly enormous tonne of stupid bullshit, insults, asinine complaints, harassment, and I assume worse.
Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you.
Lastly, to the mods that have chosen to step down this month (not sure if it's okay to tag/name), please don't feel any guilt over it - I think you've each done far, far more than enough for this community over some long services and you absolutely deserve a rest from it all.
11
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jun 06 '23
Here's our post about potentially joining the blackout next week.
We're still discussing our options but wanted to get broader feedback than from those that visit the meta thread. Thank you if you do check in here regularly!
20
u/Terranwaterbender https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teranwaterbender Jun 19 '23 edited Jun 20 '23
This is just an old-timer lurker these days talking but just wanted to say the whole commenting in threads when the sub is down isn't cool at all and the mod team should have known better. Y'all should have seen that from a mile away the ramifications of talking about shutting down the sub for the greater good, shutting it down, and then doing that stuff.
That aside, it's hilarious how many of the haters in the thread have little to no history on /r/anime so to be completely blunt, their opinions are basically worthless. The amount of work you guys do to keep this subreddit running on volunteer time is admirable.
But seriously check yourselves and learn from this experience. I get that commenting on threads was not done with anything remotely close to malice but it put an easily avoidable stain on the mod team. Keep up the good work y'all have always done and I do appreciate the decision to run with the blackout. Honestly helped me appreciate anime from my PoV and not immediately run and see what everyone else thought. The haters will run off to whine elsewhere or disappear until the next big controversy where they suddenly think they know how to keep a subreddit running and don't know how many mods rely on 3rd party apps to keep the subreddit going.
26
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 04 '23
Heyo. This isn’t a question or request or anything, but I figured it belonged here since it is technically meta; in the wake of Reddit’s recent attacks on access to archivism, history and free flow of information, through their attacks on Pushshift and restriction and paywalling of API, I’d just like to extend words of thanks and appreciation to the mods and community of this subreddit for their incredible work over the years keeping good, comprehensive, open archives and indexes of this subreddit’s history, in regards to the rewatches, currently-airing episode discussions which may serve as invaluable historical documents for when these shows first touched an audience, the WT! and Writing Club essay archives, etc. Every piece of valuable discussion being saved from the gnawing abyss of internet forever-obscurity is an absolute win. This is indispensable, and everyone involved in curating and maintaining something which essentially protects and preserves easily-accessible history itself deserves a hand. So, from the bottom of my heart, kudos and thank you to everyone involved in the subreddit wiki and such.
As I’ve stated, I do strongly hope and encourage that this subreddit will participate in any and all sitewide protest and action against Reddit’s current actions and plans with the API and I dearly hope, if mass user revolt is strong enough, these decisions can be made to be reversed and API can be restored to be free and openly accessible.
9
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jun 30 '23
Today's thread is missing from the front page, no message from automod.
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/14ndgki/rewatch_scrapped_princess_discussion_episode_11/
14
u/sofastsomaybe Jun 04 '23
What is the rationale behind making it more difficult for users of this sub to view key visuals?
7
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 06 '23
/u/Durinthal, I've been musing on your discussion prompt/thoughts from the last meta thread about a second, more casual/fandom-oriented subreddit. I failed to really put any clear, organized thoughts to paper but since it's been a month figured i should just get it over with and drop a big messy ramble on it here.
Most specifically, my thoughts have been drifting towards what the "final form" of such a thing could be, because once you open the pandora box for two subreddits I wonder if it becomes hard to close it firmly again, and soon enough you might wind up with calls for a 3rd or 4th or 5th subreddit (your own example was 3 gaming subreddits after all).
Of course there's dozens or hundreds of anime and anime-adjacent subreddits out there already, but I'm not trying to encompass all of them - most are way too specific anyway. I've just been thinking about what the major niches or "roles" of reddit anime content are and how they could fit into a group of subreddits that make up a primary "r/anime family" - i.e what types of posts are commonplace enough that they could drive an entire subreddit themselves and that at least some people think they would be better as their own separate content stream instead of part of r/anime.
The thing is, that list still quickly gets too big to be easily manageable. You've got your r/anime and your "casual" sub, e.g.:
And then it's really easy to add to the family something like:
and many more possibilities. I guess it comes down to subreddit scaling - as more and more anime are made, there's going to be more and more discussion threads and announcements posts, but r/anime's front page won't get any larger, so once there's the idea of multiple subreddits there will increasingly be desire to move certain types of content to their own subreddit, as you noted about r/AnimeSketch and r/AnimeART exploding in growth when r/anime pushed that type of content to them in 2020.
But that's way too many subreddits to one team to manage. And most of these already have existing subreddits with their own moderators and the like.
So I could see it happening where you sort of declare r/anime to be the "hub" and "flagship" subreddit (which it already is, you're just making an official declaration) and launching the "r/anime family of subreddits". Each subreddit in the family can have its own moderators and run itself the way it wants, but there's an agreement across all the subreddits in the family of what types of content go to which subreddit and perhaps a few high-level common moderating principles. Of course if someone wants to make their own subreddit that is about, say, "anime memes and also fanart" they can, but it won't be part of "the family". At the most ambitious goal, each subreddit in the family could have a common banner/layout that helps redirect to all the other subs in the family, too.
And then perhaps as the flagship subreddit, r/anime itself would also have a rotating weekly thread on one day of the week that is a showcase of another subreddit in the family (e.g. "This is the r/animesuggest demo thread, the rules in this thread follow the same rules as r/animesuggest. Go check out r/animesuggest for content like this any day of the week" and then the week after it is /animeART, etc).
Though you know what would really be the legendary final form? Take over r/otaku (currently just a weird, low-population sexy cosplay subreddit?) and make THAT both the "casual discussion" subreddit as well as the "hub" subreddit of the overall "family", branching from there into anime subreddits (of which r/anime would still be the premiere/gateway anime sub), manga subreddits, a cosplay subreddit, a central otaku art subreddit, even a donghua branch if they want to join in, etc.
7
u/Silent_Shadow05 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silent-Shadow05 Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Is referring to the real human history counts as spoiler in a historical show?
The reason I'm asking that because in Vinland Saga there was a question of Thorfinn's love interest and I responded that if we check the historical data about the real-life Thorfinn Karlsefni from his Wikipedia page, we can see who its going to be (I'm not a source reader btw). But my comment ended up getting removed.
This is why I'm curious because what happened in human history shouldn't really count as spoiler if we are watching a historical show, atleast from my perspective. In historical TV Shows or Movies discussion on reddit I know there are those who share information on the topic as they know more of the events and I appreciated them for it.
13
u/Verzwei Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 04 '23
Hey, all. I already answered a few questions in this thread regarding the Official Media changes, but I'll try to present it in a more complete and straightforward manner in this comment.
What changes for end-users who just want to view official media images?
Ideally, not very much. In many instances, using a post to directly link to an image will still give easy access to that image. It should still thumbnail properly, and should still expand properly.
What changes for OM posters who want to share content with the subreddit?
We're removing the intermediate step where the OP takes an image from an official site and then uploads it to Reddit or rehosts it on a third-party image hosting site. Images themselves may still be linked under this new rule, it's just that they need to link to the original host (be that a news article, press release, or any other formal announcement) without the OP "doin' stuff" with the image.
This is going to ruin the monthly Megami Magazine posts!
That's why we added an exception so that albums of multiple images may still be posted and shared the exact same way they always have. Getting a singular link to go to officially uploaded album-style content would be way too big of an ask, bordering on impossible in a lot of situations.
Why are you doing this?
A variety of reasons that added up, including but not limited to:
Hopefully that clears some stuff up. If there are still questions or concerns, ask away and I or another mod will try to get to them as we're able.
6
u/cppn02 Jun 24 '23
Saving myself having to make multiple reports but I'm pretty sure everyone in this thread other than me and u/dagreenman18 is a bot.
They've gotten pretty common sadly but 60% of the comments is still a rare sight.
11
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jun 04 '23
Do we really need 15-20 mug/cup comment faces? I'm sure quite a few of them don't ever get used.
It'd be nice to have more niches fit in. I can't believe it took so long to get a permanent listen comment face (for example).
Just a thought though.
Is there a way to find how often a comment face is used?
15
u/hasso666 Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 29 '23
Editing all comments since apollo is dead and spez is a lying shithead. Thanks for killing third-party apps and running the site. Remember to short reddit on IPO. Edited using Power Delete Suite v1.5.0 fork.
10
u/entelechtual Jun 22 '23
I don’t think it needs to be said, since I think everyone can easily discredit the disingenuous opinions of lurkers/SRD brigadiers that have no interest in participating in this community, but I’ll say it anyway: the leaders of this community have done a great job making it feel inclusive and feel like a place where people can actually discuss anime, at any level.
I’ll include in that grouping not just mods but also “power users” and other regulars. And I think it’s only gotten better over time (daily thread is probably the best change I’ve seen introduced, and I’ve seen subs where that kind of thread can be a ghost town). The process for making changes has never been purely bottom-up, but is usually grounded in user feedback/concerns, and there’s usually ample explanation for the change (English episode titles in threads, for example—second best change I’ve seen).
I was fully on-board with the blackout protests and will go with any viable alternative that will actually work and last more than a few months and scale to the level of Reddit, but for now I’m content to stay here and begrudgingly figure out how to use mobile browser/app navigation, until whenever Reddit becomes fundamentally impossible to manage/participate. I do think at this point Reddit is the best option for the immediate future. And for better or for worse, this subreddit has harbored such an unnatural gathering of different demographics and tastes all converging, that would be very difficult to replicate on another platform immediately.
I feel like staying on this subreddit for long enough, you get beaten down into eventually caving in and watching shows/genres you’d never pick up, just by the flood of interactions with other users. Or just wildly different takes on the same show, where you can find a place to express an opinion without always being downvoted. Well. Mostly. So I hope any future transition is mindful of preserving that community. I know a lot of people using Reddit just want to see memes and clips and screenshots and fanart but I think the current content restrictions have been good in promoting discussion without shoving it down people’s throats. And given the scale, no matter how obscure the question there’s always some sicko who manages to decipher and answer some innocent newbie’s query about an anime they watched on tiktok.
Anyway I don’t mean to butter y’all up too much here. Autolovepon still needs to get their act together. And I’ll continue to post my suggestions/opinions/criticisms. But I appreciate the mods and users on here and hope this next stage isn’t too challenging to get through.
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jul 05 '23
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
5
u/Lanaerys Jun 09 '23
I have a question regarding the blackout.
While I, as a quasi-exclusive user of RIF and old Reddit, wholeheartedly support the blackout, I do have to wonder about something.
r/anime has pretty much become my main source of watch order information. During the blackout (12-14 June, and onwards if the blackout continues like some subreddits are planning), will the contents of the wiki (including stuff like watch orders, recommandations, ...) be copied somewhere that is accessible to most users? Since surveys and flairs use r-anime.moe, I'm assuming it could be used for that purpose, at least as a temporary measure?
9
u/Turbostrider27 Jun 04 '23
I have some questions regarding the Official Media links and need some confirmations:
4
u/baseballlover723 Jun 09 '23
Would be very interested in seeing the subreddit numbers for the week prior to and the week after the blackout (if it comes back at all). Seems like even if things go smoothly, there will be non negligible drop off.
4
u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Jun 25 '23
I wish the moderators good luck! on dealing with the Rurouni Kenshin threads this season.
The issue is widely known and the threads will be a cesspool of hate, i'm not sure if i'll even read what's gonna unfold in the episode threads, i myself am only hyped to see more Kenshin content since i loved the OG series so i don't want to ruin it for myself.
4
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jun 30 '23
Hello Mods!
Lonely castle in the mirror got its theatrical release in North America, would hope you guys can get an episode thread up, thank you!
edit: unless this counts lol
19
u/Ralon17 https://anilist.co/user/Ralon17 Jun 20 '23
Most of the time I'm happy to be critical of mods overstepping, but I just wanted to leave a comment saying I appreciate the work that y'all put in, and I'm glad you chose to participate in the blackout, whether or not it will have any effect, and no matter how long it went (a large part of me thinks it should have just gone on indefinitely, but I understand I'm in the minority).
You did the right thing in being open with the sub about the fact you weren't sure whether to do it, and then again when it was decided. The fact that the return thread is overrun with opposition means little to me when none of them could be bothered to speak up pre-blackout. It's just the entitlement of consumers who don't think beyond their own convenience.
The commenting during the off-time was clearly a bad PR look, but I don't think it really changes the point of the blackout or the effectiveness of it. Reddit doesn't care if some mods are active, they care whether the subreddit as a whole is. I'm sure you were twiddling your thumbs waiting for actual community engagement like the rest of us. Still shouldn't have commented, but I swear people are acting like you undermined the whole exercise or something.
Whether you stick around and keep moderating or whether you decide to spend your unpaid free time on something else, don't worry about it too much. Modding is a thankless job and you don't owe the average lurker here a thing.
11
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jun 19 '23
Week in Review threads are being discontinued.
The juice isn't worth the squeeze. No traction, moderate effort.
10
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jun 05 '23
Would it be possible to have a more SFW sidebar image?
3
u/cppn02 Jun 05 '23
Is it just me or are the episode polls currently not working?
3
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jun 08 '23
/r/anime's going private on June 12th to join the protest with other subreddits, more details in that thread.
Our Discord server will stay open for everyone in that time and more info will be posted to r-anime.moe as well if necessary.
3
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jun 08 '23
Not a high priority right now due to circumstances, but I noticed that expanded flairs go under a post text
I think the same used to happen for comments/commentfaces, but it got fixed before release or something? Might be misremembering here.
(On a side note, the commit names for the sidebar updates sometimes are just as fun lol)
3
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jun 11 '23
Is Set your r/anime flair here the only place you can go to, in order to link your MAL/Anilist/Kitsu, etc?
3
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jun 21 '23
"the place" picture changed before the new daily thread is up (I didn't check, but I assume exactly one hour before? 9utc vs 10utc)
just mentioning in case it was not intentional
3
u/The_Loli_Otaku Jun 25 '23
Can I just check, is anyone else getting flooded with casino spam posters lately? That's been them popping up in my threads a few times now and I don't really get it.
3
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 26 '23
Looks like Princess Principal Crown Handler 3 has some english subs now (that aren't just crappy auto-generated ones) but it didn't trigger automod. Should an episode discussion thread be manually created for it?
5
u/dorkmax_executives Jun 10 '23
Are Twitter image links (pbs.twimg.com) not considered as Official Media links? (assuming they're posted from an official Twitter account) I tried posting here but it was automatically removed because the bot thought the image was rehosted, despite not being the case.
6
u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jun 04 '23
So reposting even Key Visuals is not allowed anymore? They all have to be link posts?
7
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jun 19 '23
I totally get that people want to vent their frustrations over the blackout/fallout and they should be allowed to but are we still banning users who are just flat out insulting others?
2
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jun 05 '23
I've fixed my spoilers here
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/141tg1j/rewatch_last_exile_discussion_episode_20_spoiler/
can you reapprove it?
2
u/DarkAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkAudit Jun 12 '23
So it appears not all my comments have been restored yet after returning from that shadowban?
2
u/GenesisEra myanimelist.net/profile/Genesis_Erarara Jun 24 '23
Hello, first time posting in a meta thread, have a question.
Will there be any support for the old /r/anime stuff like the comment faces in the scenario that the legacy format (old.reddit) is retired?
2
u/orange-shades :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/orangeshades Jun 27 '23
Is there a way to filter out contest posts on redditisfun?
3
u/Schibelscky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Schibelscky Jun 04 '23
Religiously coming yearly at June Meta Thread just to ask one thing: When will we have Best Girl Contest this Year? My salt levels are quite low right now tbh
3
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jun 25 '23
Can we do something about people asking for anime suggestions when they don't post on the daily Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussion thread?
Not everybody who gets into anime knows about MAL or Anilist, maybe have an automod share links to them?
Have an Automod share some of the anime charts. And maybe share r/animesuggest and then have it get deleted?
Or just have the automod share the daily thread link to Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussions?
I don't mind people asking for recommendations, but at the same time it doesn't seem like they do any kind of research beforehand.
It's fine if it's something super specific: Like living in the countryside or something like that. But when it's just a generic: Can I get some anime recommendations? Seems low effort.
1
u/DEVINURDOG :AMQ: Jun 19 '23
Hey there, I have a question that I'd like to ask regarding a certain post I'd like to make. I've created an AI model of EGOIST/chelly and would like to post a song from that here, would that be considered a low-effort post and against the rules or will I be okay posting it?
1
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jun 19 '23
You probably know already, but as some comments pointed out apparently the Black Clover movie was released recently during blackout, and needs its thread
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment