r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Apr 06 '25
Meta Meta Thread - Month of April 06, 2025
Rule Changes
No rule changes this month.Silly u/baseballlover723, not realizing that I was supposed to edit it here too- Amended the Clip quality rules
- Cosplay rules now inherit from the general Fanart rules
- Updated the wording of anime-specific
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: March 2025 | February 2025 | January 2025 | December 2024 | November 2024 | October 2024 | September 2024 | August 2024 | July 2024 | June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | January 2024| Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/baseballlover723 Apr 06 '25
Hey everyone, it's been a busy month.
March Mod Report
baseball seasonShizuku cosplay posts.March by the Numbers
63
u/PrinceZero1994 https://myanimelist.net/profile/pz16 Apr 27 '25 edited Apr 27 '25
Just wanna say that you can see multiple obvious alt accounts making comments on the last 2 OF post.
This is to increase engagement, I guess. Of course, they upvote the post too.
I still believe they are here not because of anime, but just to promote their junk.
Mods have the final say on which post stays up or not and I can't say I'm not disappointed seeing all the complaints seemingly fall on deaf ears.
41
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25
It seems like a consistent sub-argument against cosplay posts is that the OPs are not active in the subreddit outside of posting their pictures, which leads to no or low quality discussion and no feeling of community. And it drowns out posts that are seen as more valuable.
I also think that drive-by posting is a big concern for the community. Many of the current user-created posts on the frontpage have 0 interaction of the OP beyond creating the post — despite being discussion type posts. Often these OPs also don't have much prior subreddit activity. In the spirit of saving the subreddit from all these troubling posts, Cosplay or not, they should just get deleted if the OP does not respond to comments. And maybe get a temp ban for flooding the frontpage with something other than episode discussions and news.
182
u/__Parasyte__ Apr 27 '25
With how divisive the obvious OF cosplay ads are, I'd love to just ban cosplay in general. I'm in r/anime for the anime/media, not to be bombarded with thinly veiled Etsy shop and OF account ads.
74
u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine May 01 '25
Mr. President, another cosplay post has hit the front page!
29
u/SCVGoodT0GoSir Apr 30 '25
I don't have any strong opinions about whether cosplay should be allowed or not allowed on this subreddit, but I strongly believe the moderation of the comments needs to be more consistent.
For example, my comment poking fun of the bloodbath of removed comments in the thread got removed after about 7 hours, while the top comment which was posted 3 hours before my post, also poking fun of removed comments stayed up until I pointed out the inconsistency.
And even now, there's a comment about mass deletion of comments that's currently up, 15 hours later.
To reiterate, I don't have a strong opinion on cosplay posts. I'll leave that decision up to the mods. However, inconsistent moderation (and unclear rules) makes it hard to know what we can and can't say in the comments section.
22
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 06 '25
Just something I was curious about the general community's thoughts on and figured with the new meta thread it couldn't hurt to ask.
Last summer fanart and cosplay rules were changed to allow them as image posts again. On the whole this hasn't overflowed the subreddit like it did in the past, and I was just wondering how people were feeling in general about the change.
I've definitely seen some good fanart and just fun stuff over the months since the rules change. But at the same time I frequently am disappointed seeing stuff where it's pretty transparent that the poster isn't really trying to be a member of the community or anything like that, but is just using r/anime as a platform to advertise their fanart for the purpose of sales.
22
u/Nebresto Apr 21 '25
I got an idea for the cosplay situation. As it is now its generating pointless strife without anyone necessarily being in the wrong, stemming from what users deem as "outsiders" coming in only to advertise their other stuff.
So why not mandate every user that makes a post under the cosplay flair to add a brief comment explaining the creation process, inspiration for the outfit, etc.
A "picture proof" was mentioned earlier, but that was deemed too restrictive for various reasons.
A text explanation doesn't rule out anyone.
If the poster doesn't have the patience to spend a minute or two writing, chances are they also don't have the patience to actually craft a cosplay by themselves, so it can be filtered out as cheap.
This way users get a better insight on what went into the costume, and posters are less likely to be labeled as "fakes"
18
u/chilidirigible Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25
Not-entirely-organized thoughts on one of the present tempests in a teapot: The Cosplay Situation:
Cosplay as a topic, in this subreddit, is acceptable as part of the anime-related culture?
The total number of cosplay posts has significantly diminished over time and what few have appeared lately share a particular aesthetic.
In a perfect scenario where the specific aspects of the cosplay posts are ignored, the posts themselves are blameless and all fault lies with the reactionary commenters.
Not a perfect scenario: The cosplay posts now appearing are predominately fanservice-oriented. The posts routinely receive thousands of upvotes and remain on the front page for extended periods.
The responses to these posts have not meaningfully contributed to the subreddit's content and appear to be motivated by a desire to shame the cosplayers for matters which technically exist outside of the subreddit's current rules boundaries. Considering the interactions between OP and commenters in general, it seems that most of the cosplayers who are posting here are not bothered by the criticisms versus the significant visibility boost from posting.
The subreddit routinely discusses anime fanservice topics which are similarly NSFW. Real-world individuals engaging in fanservice activities exposes hypocrisy in how such topics are viewed? In both cases, the creators of the work are aware of what they are trying to sell, whether it is animated or on their person.
The "moral outrage" over the posts as demonstrated by comments is much less significant in proportion to the apparent tacit approval of them shown by their accumulated karma. But bad reviews are the reviews which get attention.
The comments require significant moderator intervention in order to maintain community standards. This is a problem for the moderation team, but due to automod filtering mostly does not externalize itself to the community at large.
Moderator convenience is not a great reason to change rules or lock comments except in extreme circumstances. Where is that benchmark?
Remedies?
Remove cosplay posting. Cuts off some level of community involvement, but as noted above, nearly all of its recent appearances have been of this specific and controversial type instead of a broader representation of the category.
Return to self-post format for cosplay. Does remove the obvious thumbnail image, probably would still be found and attract controversy.
Lock comments when these posts appear. Appears as censorship or endorsement of the cosplay.
Continue without changes. Doesn't "solve" anything, if one believes that there is a problem to begin with.
Ultimately it may be about a determination of whether the "community" "outcry" is enough of a problem in itself that requires remedy versus the statistically-low number of cosplay posts, and when the angry comments are restricted to the posts themselves and the Meta Thread. Optics may be a factor in this issue if the subreddit seems to be damaged by it. The convenience of moderators ultimately is... not?
18
u/chilidirigible May 01 '25
Omedetou to April 2025 for making /r/Anime meta more than it's ever metaed before.
Fortunately for those who wish to find relief from the battle here, the subreddit offers many other topics in which one can find shelter.
17
u/AnimeHoarder Apr 08 '25
FYI: The maintainer of senpai.moe has posted the following on their site:
So their entry in the related_sites in the wiki could be updated. The ANN story they mentioned is dated April 1st, so this was posted just in the last week.
15
u/W8tin4BanHammer2Fall Apr 21 '25
I'm going to be that guy and point out that the comments in the cosplay posts about comments being deleted also violate this rule:
I'm not too serious about this though as it would take some of the joy out of the conversation in those posts and add more work for the mods :-)
41
u/dorian_gayy Apr 06 '25
I've read that Link Click is not allowed to be posted in this subreddit as an original post, as it is a donghua, but will posts about To Be Hero X, which has mixed Chinese and Japanese production, be allowed? Crunchyroll has been advertising it with the Japanese audio as though it is an anime, not a donghua.
Is there a rule on this?
58
u/Astan92 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Astan92 Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25
Are there not going to be discussion threads for To Be Hero X? The anime series(not music video) I just watched on Crunchyroll, An anime streaming site, in Japanese from well know seiyuu, with the name of a well known Anime studio right on it, with music from one of the best anime composers Hiroyuki SAWANO.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25
Was there a change of policy related the interpretation of "direction toward illegal anime sources"?
I've made this comment. I assume it was removed because I mentioned a certain internet exchange protocol (T*****t). Not a site or source or anything, just the name of a tech. Is this word now banned?
Because I've been using this since forever and I don't recall ever getting moderated. I also vaguely remember a mod linking even to the wikipedia definition of said internet file exchange protocol.
Genuine question, I obviously don't want to violate the rules, asking for future reference.
11
u/chilidirigible Apr 12 '25
The obligatory front page on reaching another million screenshot.
29
u/Akriosken May 01 '25
Chiming in about the giant Cosplay discussion as a mostly lurker these days.
I have been seeing these Cosplay posts same as pretty much everyone else, and couldn't help but notice they are largely a comment graveyard, though I did notice stuff before it gets mod-nuked, and to be honest morbid curiosity at the comments is what sometimes keeps me coming back into those threads.
It is obvious that these Cosplay posts engender an extremely toxic response from a subset of the community, despite the amount of upvotes making them eclipse even the daily seasonal discussion threads. And I don't see this trend going away any time soon. I personally doubt that people would suddenly stop making completely inappropriate remarks in those threads.
Thus, my concern, and cause for making this reply in the wind, is that it is blatantly obvious that moderating these threads is extremely resource-intensive, and this is compared to the volume of posts you guys monitor every day when it comes to stuff like unmarked spoilers, which I assume involves sifting through many users reporting them.
I am in favor of some better-defined rules when it comes to these posts, whatever direction the mod team decides to go with, mostly because I would like you guys to not burn yourselves out on these threads.
The subset of the cosplay posts that are problematic are thus also because they are thinly-veiled advertising. Most communities have strict rules against advertising, lest the communities devolve into a sea of ads drowning out the conversations people come to the sub for. And I would hate for the quality of the community to be diminished because of this. And we can already see this, as of writing this comment, the current first post of r/anime front page is one such cosplay post, which has orders of magnitude more upvotes than the highest upvoted show in this week's karma ranking chart. If this is not a rare peak but the start of a rising trend, I suspect we'll have to scroll past a few of these to reach the discussion threads. Whether or not the mod team is ok with this is admittedly out of our hands, but I personally feel like it would diminish the quality of the community at large.
65
u/Odd_Link_7231 May 01 '25
Im extremely confused why this sub is allowing thinly veiled only fans adverts.
10
u/Rumpel1408 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rumpel1408 Apr 06 '25
Roll text in the topbar could use some updatingto include the seasonal survey.
10
u/Castor_0il Apr 08 '25
Can you mods do something about this probably bot account that just spams "W" on most threads?
https://old.reddit.com/user/Financial_Exit_7710
9
u/piruuu https://anilist.co/user/dvj Apr 06 '25
It's been almost a year and a half since the mod team announced that discussion had begun about softening rules regarding piracy and 8 months since the last update.
Is it fair to say that this discussion is dead in the water or is it just very low on your priority list?
9
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 30 '25
For a more light-hearted discussion:
Is there no place in r/anime where we can post a "META" joke?
Because in Casual Discussion Friday, there's
And in META, there's
So are META jokes banned from the whole sub?
Or are META jokes not considered "META discussion" and thus allowed on casual discussion friday? (though I imagine they may devolve in meta discussion anyway, and then they'd probably all get deleted for it?)
I was wondering about that because a comment below made me think of a silly joke then I realized "I can't post it anywhere!"
9
u/cppn02 May 02 '25 edited May 02 '25
I haven't watched them yet so can't speak to their quality but according to the release notes the subs for Takamine-san seem to be atleast partially AI translated.
Wouldn't that be against r/anime policy for episode discussions?
9
u/chilidirigible May 02 '25
And now for something completely different:
When is the subreddit user counter going to be changed from the Initial D theme? It feels like it's lasted through the entire split cours of MF Ghost and that's been finished for weeks now.
25
u/theangryeditor https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheAngryEditor May 02 '25
Based on the comments in this thread I get the impression that due to the relatively high number of votes the cosplay posts have been getting they're way overrepresented in the feeds of people who don't check the sub's front page often, which makes it seem like the cosplay posts are dominating in absolute terms. It has as much to do with the structure of the website as it does with the posts themselves. And the fact that not much other stuff have been getting a lot of upvotes recently.
16
u/Tetraika :Lu::Lv::Lw::Lx:https://anilist.co/user/Tetraika Apr 22 '25
Oh since this is happening I guess I'll drop my 2 cents on this.
Personally I don't really care about if someone is secretly just promoting their OF or something. It's fairly easy to just ignore most of the cosplay content on /r/anime already, and so far they're very few of them.
I guess my "fear" is that it becomes like a front for a bunch of people to do the same thing and make the sub become saturated with those. I know I would hate the sub to become an ad front for people who aren't really intend to be a part of the community. This goes for fanarts too.
There is also an unfortunate amount of what is just basically veiled slut shaming. I know not everyone critical of the current situation is like this, but yeah.
Honestly if I had any solution I would propose it would just be banning cosplay (and maybe even fanarts) post entirely unless there is a specific /r/anime event. Might not be a popular opinion though.
On a different note since this is the other hot topic, I'm mostly fine with how /r/anime is defining "anime" and allowing/disallowing certain productions for now. Out of curiosity, if Twins HinaHima get acceptable subs would it be qualified for discussion?
8
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Apr 07 '25
Minor thing: daily thread links haven't been updated for new CDF/meta thread as of today.
8
u/RPO777 x2 Apr 11 '25
OK, I have some constructive feedback to the Mods about how rules on source material discussion are applied, because I frankly think the way the rules are actively preventing relevant discussion of anime, instead of promoting it
As I understand it, the reason we have rules about source material discussions on r/anime are because we want the focus to be about anime. Not manga--there are other subreddits on manga, and this is supposed to keep the focus squarely on anime, thus discussions about manga should be limited.
I understand that, and I don't disagree with the underlying philosophical point.
The problem I have is with the ways in which this rule is being applied is being used to limit discussion that relates to anime.
For example, I had a mod just shut down a thread where I tried to tell people why they should care about the upcoming adaptation of Kore Kaite Shine
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1jwa6wa/comment/mmlblzm/?context=3
The logic was that the discussion focused on the source material manga, and not on information about the anime (which is presently very sparse), thus was impermissible source material discussion.
The mod may be applying the rule correctly as written, but that is a crappy rule.
If you look at how people engage with the post in the comments, the overwhelming response is "i knew nothing about this anime, but now I'm interested." People are asking about how it compares to other anime, like Look Back, and the engagement is overwhelmingly about how people want to see this anime in the future.
If someone goes on a long review of the manga of Jujutsu Kaisen or Demon Slayer, sure I understand why that review of manga has no place on r/anime. No debate from here. Everyone knows about what those manga are about already, so previewing the quality of the manga to hype upcoming arcs aren't really about anime.
That is not what I'm doing here at all.
Koreshine is a work where people don't know much about the original work. They can't get interested in it, because they don't know anything about it. Telling people what kind of story it well tell, what kinds of themes it engages in, and what kind people it would appeal to IS about anime, when people have no idea what that anime is about.
Context matters. If the anime is already well known and a person dives deeply and unnecessarily into the source material, sure that should e moderated out.
But if 99% of the sub has never heard about this, and no English language synopsis appears anywhere, this type of spoiler-free coverage of the material is absolutely warranted.
I want to emphasize, what I wrote here is the most extensive summary of Koreshine that has been written in English anywhere. I originally planned to post a summary some other anime site had already posted, but there was none to be found.
I went through a lot of work to try to communicate what makes this story worth learning about without giving away any part of the story. It got people engaged. Several people responded that they are now going to pay attention to anime announcements about this work.
I don't really understand how someone can look at the materials written here, and the response it received and say "this is irrelevant to anime and is harmful to have in this sub."
It makes no sense to me.
8
u/Nebresto May 02 '25
Do the mods have stats on how many users are using the various post filters? I would imagine its astronomically low
Also on the topic of the link tool bar, is it possible to extend it? The 'Search for' Section that is under 'post filters' could be its own thing.
Also was gonna ask for the rewatch page to be added to the wiki section, but its apparently under "anime info" which seems strange to me, especially when "watch this!" is in the wiki section, even though they are literally information about specific animes to get people to watch them
38
u/Dentorion Apr 21 '25
Sorry to say it but it gets overhand with these Barely hidden OF cosplays the last few months.
I know that cosplays can be a bit of ecchi sometimes but it's annoying to have all these barely hidden OF cosplays who were ordered on Temu just to sexualize some characters are getting votes here.
Can we have maybe for a few months a mod who controls that until the only fans things come down again?
I don't know how that works but at least a bit better Moderation would be nice. I know you do your best work I'm just a bit frustrated cause my little cousin asked me why I watch naked girls on phone and he is too young to have the flower bee conversation
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan May 04 '25
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
40
u/evenstar40 May 01 '25
Can we please ban the obviously bought upvotes OF ads? Like, most other subs have basic standards for this shit. I really don't want to see /r/anime turn into another shitty karma farming ad/bots subreddit. Low effort shit like this just scares away legit people wanting to discuss anime and devalues the overall community.
7
u/Castor_0il Apr 12 '25
Can some mod make autolovepon create the discussion thread for Bloody Escape movie? It just got released on Crunchyroll and it's part of the universe of Estab-Life: Great Escape series
7
u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Apr 18 '25
Are we getting a thread for the aot final season final movie last attack?
7
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal May 02 '25
Minor thing just to keep making this thread longer instead of waiting until the new one's posted tomorrow: the events wiki page should be updated with the 11m scavenger hunt results link.
...and I stand by the bottom part of the page from before the revamp being unnecessary to keep around, especially with the "Upcoming Film Releases" section having dates from nearly five years ago now.
33
u/FrankyPropaganda Apr 30 '25
We shouldn’t ban cosplay posts in general, but cosplays that are obvious OF bait need to be banned. The rule can be amateur cosplay only, and people who have OF/patreon accounts are banned from posting
44
u/Throw__Package555 Apr 29 '25
Why do yall keep the cosplay posts which are obviously promotional?? And all the comments which talk about it get deleted
18
u/Verzwei Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25
Sorry to harp on cosplay, I know that's been one of the two big topics this month, but I'm gonna copy some select rules from the rules page:
The post I'm complaining about.
cardboardfoam truck helmet with the word "isekai" on it to qualify as fanart within this subreddit's rules.While certain controversial cosplay posts might technically be within the rules as written, I fail to see how an anime-inspired non-specific helmet gag meets the above-quoted criteria for a cosplay post. It's funny, sure, I chuckled at it, but also seems outside the scope of the rules as written, and seems like the sort of "low effort" stuff this subreddit normally wouldn't permit, and it's the top post on the sub right now.
If cosplay only has to follow the OC Fanart subsection and not the main Fanart header, meaning that cosplay doesn't have to be from an anime, and the OP doesn't need to put that anime's title in the title of their post, then that seems like a rule loophole that should be closed.
Edit: If someone were to throw on a straw hat with regular everyday clothes and say it was anime cosplay, would it be allowed as a cosplay post?
22
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh May 01 '25
I've mentioned this buried in some comments, but might as well just make a top level post so we can direct things here rather than buried deep down some random chain.
At present there's an ongoing discussion about various flavours of content that are posted as not-so-subtle advertising. This ranges from:
There's a bunch of nuance through these and they aren't really equal, but they also often bleed into each other in various ways.
Within the discussion there's been talk of returning to the old 10:1 self promotion rule (10 non-promoting posts/comments per 1 promoting post/comment), as well as a softer self promotion ratio like 1:1. There's also been talk of not using a ratio, but instead going for something that's more of a "you know it when you see it" and evaluating things case-by-case where if the mods view an account as being near-singularly focused on advertising then we reserve the right to issue a ban. Main reason to consider not doing a firm ratio is just that it's either easy to game, or a huge pain unless you're an active commenter.
There's been plenty of talk about the specifics, and my plan is to call for the vote this weekend, barring any sudden changes. From there we have a week before the vote is settled, and next weekend we'll have a final word on the matter. Any thoughts or considerations feel free to let me know.
63
u/BasedLelouch_ Apr 30 '25 edited Apr 30 '25
Stop allowing only fans bait “cosplay”
So fucking sick of it. I’m sure the mods won’t disallow it though, because that would increase the quality of the sub. They’re so defensive about it too. Idk if they’re being paid in money or titty pictures but clearly they all banded together to continue allowing this garbage.
17
u/susgnome https://anime-planet.com/users/RoyalRampage Apr 20 '25
Welp, since this comment was removed for I guess, the off-hand remark I made at the end of it against the sub.
So I'll make an actual point about the rule then instead of some off-hand comment.
I don't like that the current ruling on "Cosplay" posts, say it's to be treated like Fan Art but it's not taken as seriously in comparison.
For posts saying "This is something I've made". There's a lot of majority store-bought. Most cosplay competitions, you have to have made minimum 80% of the costume to participate (and there are still people that lie about that).
Take the one from the current front page: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1k2zvwz/a2_cosplay_jezlene_rae_nier_automata/
It's not a "final" nor is it of "good quality". It's clearly a "Work-In-Progress" with "poor lighting" and "incorrect orientation" that has no "respect for the art".
6
u/AashyLarry Apr 08 '25
Any idea why the AutoMod is so inconsistent at listing where to stream in the Episode Discussion?
It’d be a really useful feature if it worked every time.
For example:
In fact, if you search ‘Episode Discussion’ and sort by New, you can see nearly every Episode Discussion that has released in the past few days has “Streams: None” on it.
I hope you guys can find a way to fix this since it’s such a useful feature (especially in the beginning of a season when all the shows are first releasing everywhere).
6
u/chilidirigible Apr 28 '25
/u/ZaphodBeebblebrox another note that I was looking at CDF through old.reddit.com on my phone and wanted to quickly flip over to the Meta Thread, so I used the link in the sidebar of the desktop-emulated simulacrum and it sent me to the Meta Thread but in the Reddit app.
I suspect because the Meta Thread link in the sidebar is represented by https://redd.it/1jshay8 and thus is a www.reddit.com link when expanded.
42
u/Brilliant-Aide-3759 May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25
Cosplay by OF accounts really should be banned, it's starting to just become a non nude porn subreddit at this rate. If you sort by top of this week 4 of top 5 is that
20
u/chronokingx May 02 '25
theres a subreddit for cosplays. I have a problem with cosplays and fanarts being displayed on a Subreddit that people would go to for official anime discussions or news. I'm not saying i dislike fan creations as a whole, but there are already established and popular Subreddits for this content.
34
u/Etheo May 01 '25
I'm tired of the cosplay posts boss. It's so obvious what they're doing but because they're skirting within the rules moderation team is just letting it be. I get upholding rules for rules sake but the sea of removed comments especially about the state of cosplay posts tells the story. Removing thirst comments is good but also removing the criticisms and redirecting to here where nothing seems to get done regardless, I don't understand.
From a certain standpoint I get the difficulty in managing the situation without a blanket ban. But when it's so painfully obvious and the sub is still upvoting the post enmass but dissing it in the comments it really sets tone on the duality of this sub. Not an easy fix but I hope mods have something in the works.
17
u/Verzwei Apr 06 '25
This sounds like needless (or maybe just needlessly wordy) complication.
Is LOTR: War of Rohirrim anime, or not? Why or why not?
Is Scott Pilgrim Takes Off anime, or not? Why or why not?
I guess the question I'm getting at here is how do you define creative control?
5
u/Arachnophobic- https://anilist.co/user/Arachnophobic Apr 15 '25
The GQuuuuuuX discussion threads say there are no streams, but it can be streamed on Prime Video.
5
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Apr 21 '25
Is the new daily thread bugged or is that a star wars bit?
5
u/cppn02 Apr 22 '25
Where daily thread?
5
u/Castor_0il Apr 22 '25
My Hero Aca movie: You're Next, came out on Crunchyroll a couple of days ago.
Can someone update Lovepon to create the discussion thread?
5
u/chilidirigible Apr 26 '25
Out of curiosity, is there any idea of how many people return to their removed comments to add [spoiler]censoring blocks versus leaving them removed?
Out of morbid curiosity, how many people fight you first and then edit the blocks back in?
13
u/Verzwei Apr 07 '25 edited Apr 07 '25
Uhhhh how is video game
developerdesigner says on Twitter that he's watching an anime relevant to the sub and within the rules against low effort content?It's the top post of the sub and has been up for 9 hours so I have to assume someone on the team has seen it by now.
Really don't want to see this community become a place to dump social media posts (especially that fucking site) from people who literally have nothing to do with anime aside from saying they're watching it. And in the past that was extremely clearly against the rules.
9
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 07 '25
Now that the first seasons of Blue Box and Sakamoto Days have ended, I was wondering if the mod team has any good data/insight on if the cross-posted episode threads have affected the engagement in any meaningful way.
In addition, will this stay a temporary measure or become permanent policy?
Wanted to get this question out there before I forget about it again.
9
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Apr 20 '25
I haven’t really seen anyone speak up about this, but I’ve noticed over the last year or so that there’s been some karma manipulation happening in popular and/or discussion threads.
From my impression, someone is downvoting other people’s comments en masse to either promote theirs or negate others’ from rising up.
How did I become aware of this? Because I usually try to break the deadlock of 1-point karma points in the early hours of these threads by often upvoting (most) comments, and will then suddenly see lots of users drop back to 1 point.
I’m frequently getting hit with this myself as well. Probably on the majority of my comments - even if there’s nothing controversial of sorts. Someone might just hold a grudge against me personally, but I’ve seen this systemically happen with other users as well.
What’s the problem of this? People’s comments are purposefully made to plummet in the sorting algorithm. This system seemingly doesn’t only work by the karma total but also the upvote percentage to some degree. In other words, someone’s effectively censoring others’ comments by making them less visible.
I unfortunately doubt that something can be undertaken against this, but I merely wanted to bring it to the attention and hear other people’s experiences. It’s a sort of toxicity that I’m not too happy with.
38
u/A_Erthur Apr 29 '25
FUCK THOSE GOONER COSPLAY POSTS
26
u/Extension-Ad-9371 May 01 '25
25% of the top 2 dozen post this past month are NSFW “cosplayers” like wtf
8
u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine Apr 22 '25
I think you guys should add a Dragon Ball commentface or two. I don't have any personal attachment to the series, I just looked at the list of source shows a few days ago, started thinking about it and found it kinda funny that it has zero representation there despite it being the most famous battle shounen show, and probably the most famous anime, of all time.
The people yearn to be able to post the Yamcha pose as a commentface!
4
u/ussgordoncaptain2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Edmund_Nelson Apr 13 '25
Kakushite! Makina-san!! is being streamed in this extremely niche site oceanveil (NSFW) the site does host actual pornography though so I can understand if you don't want it to be put in the streams bar
4
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Apr 20 '25
Are we getting a thread for the final episode of Duel Masters Lost: Tsuioku no Suishou since a proper fansub of it was recently released?
4
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Apr 22 '25 edited Apr 22 '25
I didn't realise that we used to have so many cosplay posts 2+ years ago at about 4 per month, when since then it's been just about one cosplay every 2 months. Had there been some cosplay-related rule changes around that time or did cosplay posts just die on their own?
4
u/ARES_GOD https://anilist.co/user/ARESxGOD Apr 23 '25
I am really curious why this was removed on the basis that it is a spoiler ?
Because its on topic of the thread and doesnt give details or says what happened, just answering the question of the thread without going into specifics.
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1k3rqx2/comment/moa5mcj/?context=3
17
u/P_S_Lumapac Apr 21 '25 edited Apr 21 '25
Got my comment removed for pointing out porn business advertisements, then directed here to raise the complaint.
I don't really know why mods here are spending time without being paid running defense for these spammers. Spamming is against the reddit site wide rules. Is it about enjoying the numbers going up on the sub membership and views? But it's an anime sub... sure the numbers will go up if it becomes a porn sub, but then those numbers won't mean anything.
Rule 2 of reddit has this part about authenticity: ... Post authentic content into communities where you have a personal interest ... and the claim here is accounts that are made just to advertise a product do not have an authentic interest. If their fanart account only posts across reddit about their fence painting services, that's also spam.
12
u/Puddo x3https://anilist.co/user/STPuddo Apr 29 '25
Since there hasn’t been said enough about cosplay stuff yet:
Do I like it? No. But I also don't like the classic horny clips that have always done well around here. Do I wish other content like industry deep dives, interviews with staff members and writing, besides the occasional SakugabooruBlog or some clickbait Animehunch article, would do better around here? Yes. But they don’t. And they probably never will. But, it's what it's. The power of the up/downvote button.
However we currently have the 7 day rule. I feel like that’s quite short to begin with, but eh that’s also not that big of a deal. However I looked at the post history of the most recent poster because I was curious if they just spam across multiple subs and I see that they posted 4 times or something on this sub after their first post 5 days ago. So they should know the rules by now since you keep deleting them with also a comment about the 7 day rule. So how many strikes does it take for someone like that to get banned?
22
u/Psclly May 01 '25
I completely understand the rationality mods are trying to show when it comes to moderating the sub, but the idea of common sense should still be a strong factor when making decisions.
I've seen other modding teams for different types of communities follow this discussion cycle and while I obviously respect rationality and such (keeps the drama out), sometimes it can really hurt the quality of the community because no action can be taken due to the requirement of such formal discussions.
I remember in a speedrunning community someone was caught obviously cheating, then the moderation team said "yeah but we have no rule in place for this". In the end no one was punished, and the rule against the cheats had to be added later along the line after lengthy discussions, but it left an extremely sour taste in the community.
If someone is clearly abusing loopholes, workarounds or running around the rulebooks for obviously unethical profit, I think it's clear grounds to just get rid of them immediately.
Whenever I see a cosplay on here it's VERY easy to figure out whether it's a thinly veiled OnlyFans ad. You take one look at the cosplay itself and you just know. On the other hand, you can easily see when something ISN'T an ad.
And if you want confirmation? Just go to the profile. If the profile is linking to OnlyFans, then the profile solely exists to promote that. No one would put links like that in their profile if they weren't hoping for people to find it, and posting horny bait (which is practically a minor form of psychological manipulation) is just the right method for that.
My opinion is simple, lets stop beating around the bush and just get rid of it. Make a rule against obvious porn advertisements. The community sees it, the mods see it, why are these people still around?
20
u/TacticalBattleCat https://myanimelist.net/profile/serialsaboteur Apr 06 '25
Can the community and mod team weigh in on this?
Lately, I’ve noticed a rise in cosplay posts that feel less like authentic cosplay and more like stealth advertisements for OnlyFans accounts.
These posts often follow a pattern: pick a popular character with a simple outfit, tweak it to be overtly sexual, pose with a suggestive expression, and include a weak justification for the sexualization of the cosplay like “oh my pants are unbuttoned because I'm showing off the character's tattoo.”
A quick look at the poster’s profile usually reveals links to their OF and the same image spammed across other sub-reddits/platforms. I’m not against spicy cosplay or creators promoting their work in the right space, but r/anime has always felt like a place for discussion, memes and other fun shenanigans... not for promoting adult content.
To preserve the spirit of this sub, I’d like to propose a simple guideline: accounts that contain OF links & other explicit content should not be allowed to post cosplay content here. There are other communities for that kind of promotion, and this would help keep r/anime focused on what we’re all here for—anime.
14
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Apr 12 '25
To be Hero X: Beating a dead horse
...Ok, no, I'm trying to find a way to stop the dead horse from getting beaten so much;
I don't have a dog in this fight, I don't care about To Be Hero X being here or not, but I did read the discussions for fun, and one thing I noticed is that pretty much all the suggestions are framed on either of 2 positions, both of which are incorrect... We get "That's what I like/would want!" (which is irrelevant - other people want/like different things), and "We should do this this or that thing but just this once!" (which obviously slippery slopes into a decisional nightmare).
This isn't how you propose a suggestion... This is a 'bandaid fix' idea. The kind of stuff that everyone will write 50 angry comment about because they feel they're not being heard, and whatever happens, they'll do it again on the next one because it doesn't address the problem at all.
The 'problem' is how do you define what is or isn't anime, which is directly linked to what is or isn't allowed on r/anime.
This isn't a matter as simple as "put the show to the vote, see how people feel", for three reasons;
So the GOOD way to propose a solution, is to not talk about To Be Hero X. To not talk about any specific show at all. (I'm still not sure voting on this would be the way to go, 1 year from now some people would say "I DIDN'T VOTE FOR THAT!", but IF we were to hold the vote on anything, THIS is what we should be voting on, i.e. the definition of anime we'll accept in r/anime).
This is how you fix a problem for good, instead of addressing 1 tiny symptom of it.
So that's why I'm asking you, the people who think the show should be allowed (or the people who WANT it to be allowed, without giving consideration to whether or not it should);
What do you think should be allowed in r/anime?
I don't have the right solution myself (i.e. I don't know what the right thing to ask for would be), but THIS is the kind of 'right question to ask' people should focus on, THIS is the problem they should find a way to solve, i.e. "How do we, as a community, agree on what is anime and what is cartoons/something else, so we don't have to hold this debate every single time a new show is produced and makes waves".
In short: Rather than making emotional arguments about To Be Hero X (one way or the other), the better way to approach this is to take a shot at finding a logical, reasoned argument about "What is the definition of an 'anime' that should be accepted in r/anime".
You want to answer the question "What is an anime?", not the question "What is To Be Hero X".
/2 cents.
7
u/IXajll https://myanimelist.net/profile/ixajii Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25
Not sure if this is the right place for this but I just wanted to get the proposal out there to make the current seasonalshock commentface permanently available after the season ends. Don't know how such decisions are made here but just wanted to put this out here. That commentface is probably the best seasonalshock we ever had imho.
19
u/Volitar May 02 '25
I'm in favor of the cosplay ban. Everytime I've opened the subreddit this week I see a half naked women as the first thing that loads and that is simply not why I visit this board.
Any subreddit that allows it gets overrun with cosplay posts and becomes nothing but that.
Maybe keep a weekly or monthly cosplay thread stickied and people can post their cosplay there, all in once place.
26
u/[deleted] May 01 '25
Can we stop with the blatant only fans ad? Or are the mods too busy jerking off to it?
6
u/ExpiringMilknCheese Apr 20 '25
i understand To Be hero X not being here because as everybody mentioned its not being made by a Japanese Studio, but why is TBATE still getting episode threads?
All their episodes have been outsourced to China, and the studio that was supposedly in charge of animating it, doesnt even have a 2d department. Should it remain getting episode threads just because it has a sticker of the Japanese studio on the title? How many episodes should we get to and know that this is obviously not going to be animated by Studio A Cat
8
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Apr 14 '25
Sorry for bringing up TBHX (I'm sure nobody is tired of this yet) but for the by the Numbers stickied stats next month, might want to see if it's possible for the removed comments to have a separate stat for the reasons "This doesn't appear to be about anime per our definition." combined with "You might consider posting this to /r/Donghua instead." and if possible look back to when Link Click was airing (idk what discussion was like here or if the mod removal reasons have changed since then but elsewhere when it first aired it had similar praise). I don't know how much work that is for the by the numbers data section but if it did happen before with Link Click that data might help get an idea of is this requiring more moderation (if that's worth knowing).
On the other hand this might make TBHX fans feel singled out (or a badge of honour - from modding experience ~20 years ago this is tough situation you're trying to de-escalate/clarify/reform/course correct) because why them and not other rule violations like not say, piracy site linkers? (which I imagine is another big mod removal reason).
17
u/Roboute_Gulliman May 01 '25
Goonerbait cosplay begone!
23
u/RIP-Fredo Apr 21 '25
Can we stop allowing OF ***** here in this sub? The worst part is there are simp Mods who support it 😒Pathetic
7
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Apr 22 '25
Monthly request to change #volibearq to #tableflip.
While humbly reminding the mod team that #hyoukanod and #hyoukawink were once the same comment face. It can be done. You have the technology.
15
u/PrinceZero1994 https://myanimelist.net/profile/pz16 Apr 21 '25
Is there an official reason why an OnlyFans advertisement is being allowed to remain on the front page?
This has happened multiple times now and judging by the recent reactions, it appears that the anime community does not like it.
These kinds of posts are often propelled to the frontpage with upvote buying.
You can get like 100 upvotes for 5 bucks.
I would not be surprised if there was karma manipulation involved and this is a violation of reddit site-wide rules.
At the end of the day, I feel like the recent controversial post is not appropriate for /r/anime.
5
u/mekerpan Apr 28 '25
No Aharen episode 4 discussion thread yet today (that I can find).
5
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Apr 30 '25
First episode of Tsurezure Popipa was released yesterday. But I don't see any thread for it other than mine.
14
u/titanicboi1 May 02 '25
Remove all cosplays that are from posters that have only fans in their bio please
11
u/QinsSais May 01 '25
Porn sells and the gooners are paying well. So seeing the cosbait post is never going to stop unfortunately. It's a business for them and apparently it's good
10
u/Zonca Apr 10 '25
I want To Be Hero X on this sub, as an exception since its shaping up to be the biggest anime this season, every creator and fan thinks its anime enough.
I agree it shouldnt be here according the the technical definition, dont care, put it to the vote of the community and make this an exception.
Talks about how this would open the door to all chinese stuff and we would have to vote on every their show is obfuscation, there wont be such extraordinary show every season, let people have their one thread a week a leave them be.
If people vote they dont wish this, then I stand corrected, only after we vote.
14
u/ATraffyatLaw Apr 21 '25
Kind of odd the mod team on here is so defensive of anything slightly off-topic but the onlyfans spam is just good to keep chugging along.
14
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian May 01 '25
Man some of these reactions to the cosplays...borderline misogyny for some replies/takes.
Bring back the participation rule, if someone wants to use our community to advertise then the least they can do is be a part of it.
4
u/Hitman7128 https://anilist.co/user/Hitman7128 Apr 17 '25
Not sure if this belongs here.
I plan on posting a clip from the LycoReco ONA that recently aired with the ED gag but am iffy about titling it. I was originally thinking “ED gag (RIP Sayuri) [Lycoris Recoil - Friends are thieves of time]” because reading the room on the thread, people found humor in a gag during the short while also honoring the LycoReco ED singer who unfortunately passed away last year. But my proposed title feels jarring to me and can be misconstrued because it juxtaposes humor (ED gag) with the death of a real person. It seems hard to give attention to the crux of the clip (the gag) whilst honoring the late singer in a compact title. (Not sure if any of you have suggestions for the title)
I felt like erring on the side of caution here, not only because of the tragedy and this being more a unique situation but also the clip rules. Unlike fixing a clip post to rectify violations of the rules, fixing a clip for cosmetic reasons (like to change the title or extend it a bit) isn’t pardoned and counts against the 2 clip limit.
Other than that, I should be good to go with the actual clip rules: While I have to wait to post it on Apr 23 (7 days after the discussion thread), the 30 day cooldown on my second-to-last clip post (Mar 20) expires by then.
10
u/SpiritTunnel Apr 30 '25
unpopular opinion but the pattern of heavy indignation being given out to people who post their cosplay who also leverage their account for adult content promo. I don't think that it's healthy
making critique is valid for sure, I find the use of these AI looking chains strange in that controversial makima cosplay, among others but some of the feedback I think is forgetting that on the other end is someone is putting effort into doing a cosplay
personally I don't enjoy when I'm being presented with sexually suggestive content in a way that's instrumental to marketing their adult content, especially in some of the extreme examples when it doesn't even track with the IP, or is just low effort. I don't like that.
I don't really have an answer to the problem of not so subtly being advertised adult content or what the sub should do. but I think ppl need to remember ppl creating content are humans. cuz I don't want people who'd post their own OC/Cosplay to anticipate getting shat on heavy or alienated for how they fit balance between how suggestive to high quality their cosplay is that they lose the confidence to express themselves fully and have fun