r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • May 04 '25
Meta Meta Thread - Month of May 04, 2025
Rule Changes
- Writing and Watch This! posts can now bypass the 10 karma requirement.
- Comments on Fanart/Cosplay posts now must be about the work or the show(s) it represents.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: April 2025 | March 2025 | February 2025 | January 2025 | December 2024 | November 2024 | October 2024 | September 2024 | August 2024 | July 2024 | June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | January 2024| Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky May 04 '25 edited May 06 '25
Hi everyone! Let's see what's been goi–
April Mod Report
April by the Numbers
92
u/Gippy_ https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gippy May 04 '25 edited May 07 '25
(Personal: I mod r/animecons and we have a hard ban on cosplay posts that are personal and not part of a specific convention event such as a photoshoot or masquerade. It has greatly encouraged actual convention discussion. Also, the amount of tourists who visit r/animecons and post about a comic con had become so frequent that this is now a tempban. That one's similar to the anime vs. donghua debate.)
Whenever I see a cosplay post on r/anime, I'm wondering why the poster has chosen this subreddit over r/cosplay or any of the myriad smaller cosplay subreddits. r/anime is certainly larger, having about 5.5x the sub count of r/cosplay. So I would assume they are only posting in here because it will have the most eyes on them, and not for a real love of the hobby. Food for thought.
For >90% of the shows that air in any given year, r/anime is the only subreddit where there is actual discussion about them, as dedicated subreddits are usually ghost towns except for the most mainstream shows. That's what I use r/anime for. Cosplayers have so many other active subreddits in which to show off their cosplay, so I understand the outcry from people who use r/anime for this niche purpose.
26
u/messem10 https://myanimelist.net/profile/bookkid900 May 05 '25
Any plans to remove “fanart” from users who’re just using a computer to generate a physical item with minimal work from a person? (ex. The incessant weekly “Made this rug” posts that are basically printed by a loom.)
Those, like with the OF cosplay spam, are solely meant to advertise a good to users rather than be an expression of creativity.
25
u/killyjoker :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/killyxjoker May 07 '25
Can someone tell me how to hide posts with the cosplay tag? Nothing against the people who like it but I genuinely do not care about it and I rather not see these posts in my timeline.
21
u/theangryeditor https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheAngryEditor May 05 '25
Please make the Hidamari Sketch flair wider
21
u/BatteryPoweredFriend :KI::KJ: May 09 '25
It looks like some recent changes have messed up the #seasonalthink face. It's been shrunk down from it's regular size.
20
u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine May 07 '25
Didn't realize until now that yet another cosplay post hit the front page some time ago.
time to read the comments
Trivia: 27.38% of all the comments (43 out of the 157 in total) in that thread are currently [removed]! A mighty percentage for sure!
39
u/IXajll https://myanimelist.net/profile/ixajii May 04 '25
To jump into the hottest meta topic these days, cosplay posts. One question for the mods first: Has there been a rule change regarding cosplay post in the last month or so? Because I could swear that up until 2-3 weeks ago there was like almost never if ever any sorts of cosplay posts hitting the sub‘s frontpage for some reason. In my general feed I‘m kinda used to all the nsfw cosplay posts due to me being in a couple of gacha game subs but those are horny gooner nests so it checks out. But from what I can remember r/anime never really had those which got me wondering if rules regarding them got more relaxed or something.
About my opinion about cosplay posts in general: Honestly don’t really care about them too much either way to bother getting into fights over it, but if it was up to me I could live without them. I’m not bothered by them but I just take zero interest in cosplaying in general so all it does for me is clogging up my feed. Nothing against any cosplayers themselves. What I do find cringe though is seeing some half assed horny cosplay getting more upvotes than some high effort write ups that actually encourage meaningful discussion instead of posts that are only allowing „looks great!!“ in the comment section (srsly there needs to be done something at least, in that Hancock post today, there’s more mod comments removing other comments than there are actually unremoved comments left lol, at least that’s what it feels like, kinda awkward)
53
u/Sangwiny :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sangwiny May 06 '25
Adding my insignificant voice to the fray. I've been subbed here for almost a decade and this has never really been an issue till recently. Yes, there'd be a bait-cosplay here and there but few and far in-between. Now it's like the world got around the coomer farming community and they flock here in droves to advertise.
72
u/hungryhograt May 04 '25
Ban cosplay post, imo since there is already a subreddit for cosplay they should go there.
15
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler May 09 '25 edited May 09 '25
The new seasonal faces have changed over. You can see them all on the wiki page. Or this image here.
#deadtiredhas been added as the seasonal hall of fame face for spring.103
u/AnonymousTurkeyTim May 04 '25
Ban cosplay
34
u/Cooptayto May 04 '25
Just wanted to also add that it’d be nice to see less cosplay posts. At this point when I see one, I check the profile to see if it’s marked NSFW with socials linked and then won’t engage with it further because I know that person isn’t looking for any community engagement to discuss their love of the thing or to get critique on quality. Their only engagement objective is with wallets.
I do love cosplay, I understand there’s cosplay subreddits but since it’s so often tangentially related to anime I’m fine seeing it in here especially if it’s truly come from a desire to connect with a character.
I don’t want to propose another solution as I’ve read some good ones in here, but I hope the topic is given more discussion because it makes me avoid coming here to read posts because I don’t want to see that stuff.
Thanks all
32
u/soy-saurus May 04 '25
Cosplay on r/anime: I like the idea of cosplay but It's a slippery slope that is prone to abuse to, usually low-effort and/or advertisement of an OnlyFans or OnlyFans-like accounts. It's a "word" vs "spirit" of cosplay IMO. It's going to lead to spamming of these posts, which I see ruin other anime series specific subreddits.
It should be banned or as a reluctant compromise collected under a daily/weekly/whatever megathread.
32
u/chilidirigible May 05 '25
While we're here:
Does that mean specifically only the costume/makeup? There are several unremoved comments in the Boa Hancock post about the cosplayer's anatomy.
10
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 May 05 '25
I noticed what you did with the search and hide flairs.
10
u/alotmorealots May 28 '25
Bot-spotter Report
Latest generation of the comment reposting bots that plague the sub spotted in the wild.
They take a comment, push it through an LLM to embellish it a bit, and then repost it.
Example here: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1kwjfm5/anime_questions_recommendations_and_discussion/muhppdc/
Screencap for the disinclined to click
76
u/Kurenai11 May 04 '25
remove onlyfans ads
82
u/Hina_is_my_waifu May 04 '25
Another Anime sub becoming another onlyfans advertising platform is sad to see
57
u/xForeigner May 04 '25
Ban cosplay
16
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh May 07 '25
An update to our policy on accounts which advertise on Reddit
8
u/LittleIslander https://anilist.co/user/LittleIslander May 09 '25
Purely as a product of curiosity: if someone was an active /r/anime user, had some kind of a paid service, but preferred to keep their cosplay posts on a separate account for reasons of privacy, would they still be disallowed because the account posting the cosplays is purely for posting them/advertising? Or is the judgement attached to the individual? I certainly do not plan to ever be operating that kind of account, but if I imagined myself in that position I certainly wouldn't be posting my cosplays on main.
8
u/Voltik https://myanimelist.net/profile/nXvoltik May 18 '25
I think Autolovepon posted One Piece episode 1129 for the recap last week so we're missing the actual episode 1129 thread for this week. https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1kk4aui/one_piece_episode_1129_discussion/
27
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii May 08 '25
To Be Hero X fans: The one thing that puzzles me most about this situation is... I understand that you'd like to talk about To Be Hero X, but why do you have to talk about it here?
To make a comparison: I'm a hockey fan and I talk about hockey on r/hockey (and sometimes specific subs for the teams I follow), but if someday I developed an interest for field hockey, I wouldn't expect r/hockey to allow game threads on field hockey just because it's close enough...
I would just go to r/fieldhockey
What's the "cons" of going to r/donghua or r/tobeherox to discuss it?
Sure these subs are smaller than r/anime, but subs grow over time, and you know what? If everyone who made pro-TBHX comments in META went to discuss the episode threads over there, they would be more popular than any Spring 2025 seasonals in r/anime
I can see a future where r/anime thrives with anime discussion and r/donghua thrives with donghua discussions.
It seems a better future to me, than the one where r/anime thrives with anime discussions + the 2-3 popular donghua we get every year, and r/donghua can crash and burn without these big hitters because who cares about donghua I guess.
35
u/Better_MixMaster May 07 '25
Just to add more fuel to the pyre. My main issue with the cosplay posts is that it hits my homepage every day. If a 3rd party glanced at my screen it would look like I'm following porn. The cosplays themselves aren't, but from a distance it would look like it.
I come here for industry news and episode discussion. If the problem continues I'll probably just unfollow to keep my homepage clean.
53
u/Roboute_Gulliman May 04 '25
Ban cosplay posts. There are already subreddits for cosplay this subreddit does not need them.
53
u/Goldenbrownfish May 05 '25
I don’t like the cosplay posts there’s so many other subreddits that they can go to to post
52
u/[deleted] May 04 '25
Ban cosplay NOW
7
u/Castor_0il May 17 '25
Could some mod add the Bakarina movie discussion to Lovepon, since it's now available on crunchyroll?
https://www.crunchyroll.com/es/watch/GN7UNJD01/my-next-life-as-a-villainess-all-routes-lead-to-doom--the-movie-
7
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler May 25 '25
r/anime Mod Applications are now open.
19
u/[deleted] May 07 '25
I never come to this thread but I did so in a whim and oh my god is this place filled with angry people. I'm glad I have a Cosplay RES filter set up since, like, 8 years, so I was absolutely living in my happy island where everything is nice and positive.
I just wanted to say. Mods... I don't envy you at all lol. Just coming here to answer always. the. same. things. over. and. over is energy consuming. So here's me doing something weird: Let me say thank you. This community looks clean, I'm a regular in the daily and it's a good place to be, plenty of great people here. I spend like 1 hour on Reddit everyday and 90% of that time is here. And none of that would have been possible if it wasn't for you.
(And yeah, this is a meta post, you can't remove it. Hah!)
28
u/Legal_Jeweler_7925 May 04 '25
Cosplay submissions can always be accepted directly into the modmail for moderator posting. This would greatly reduce the presence of OF cosplayers since they would be unable to advertise their OnlyFans.
17
u/Hitman7128 https://anilist.co/user/Hitman7128 May 07 '25
Since the vote on cosplay ended, here's a personal thank you to the mod team for all their work and effort in this situation and addressing the numerous comments throughout this thread.
Especially since I have nowhere near as much patience as you all. Also, I admire how it was resolved and discussed properly rather than immediately jumping to the "obvious" conclusion.
12
u/ComfortablyRotten https://anilist.co/user/Leuwtian May 09 '25
Petition to keep as is, it's funny
33
u/Tarhalindur x2 May 06 '25 edited May 06 '25
Alright, fuck it. Something about the Bulma cosplay today got me thinking I should actually take a closer look at the situation, and this is something I should actually be good at: my blessing and curse is a certain kind of pattern-matching and I spent enough time around some of the NSFW subs back when the modern OF stuff was just starting to professionalize out of the early 2010s amateur porn scene (this being back in the mid-to-late 2010s) that I kind of got used to what the OF-advertising type looks like (and, importantly, what their profile pages look like) from seeing it develop. So I hauled up the flair search option for cosplay and looked at the last month or so of results:
Conclusion: I am going to have to eat my previous words here: this does NOT appear to be strictly the results of the Reddit algorithm. While the crappiness of the internal Reddit search function for flairs means I may be missing shit, there is a reason why the response is blowing up now and it's because there actually does seem to be an actual, legitimate change in the cosplay posts in the last two weeks. With one exception and one possible exception everything before then is fairly likely just legit fans posting about what they did for their interest; since then a majority of cosplay posts appear to be stealth advertising. The part where nobody has complained about any stealth advertising in the fanart tag is a different kettle of fish entirely and a major reason why I consider the motivations of the complainers suspect (along with them reminding me of every sex-negative Tumblr puritan), but unfortunately they are identifying a legitimate potential issue. I suppose it is appropriate in a sub about a Japanese cultural product that the solution I would really want to deploy (a less severe version of) here is straight out of (possibly apocryphal) Shogunate history (execute the petitioners, then change the rules)?
47
u/AssassinOfSouls May 05 '25 edited May 05 '25
I am normally a lurker rather than a commenter but ban cosplays completely please.
I am sorry for the legitimate ones. Unfortunately OFers are ruining this beautiful art for cosplayers but the community should not bear the brunt of this type of content.
There are and should be dedicated subs for cosplays.
6
u/Nebresto May 12 '25
Seasonal flairs we wait
Is there a way to speed it up for future seasons? Have something like the commentface nominations, but people get to submit pre-cropped images to be used for flairs instead?
I just wanna rep my favourite shows of the season, and not being able to do that for half the time they're airing is a bummer
6
u/entelechtual May 25 '25
Regarding Umamusume: I don’t want to be a buzzkill, I get why a lot of people are excited hearing about real-life horse racing and it makes sense to give some context to some of the things happening in the show. But whether it’s the original manga or IRL history, I feel like it’s unsolicited context that will color my impression of the episode or show or characters. Most of the facts are benign and fun, like this horse wore this accessory in real life too, that horse actually had a tic like that. But I feel like too much knowledge with a fairly historically rigid series means less possibilities for the future. Like if someone were to say “and after that race, X never ran again.” Or “This was the highlight of Y’s racing career”. Maybe to a Japanese audience or to horse enthusiasts that’s how the show is meant to be experienced. But for the rest of us it’s entirely fiction/fantasy.
I’m never a stickler for source reader stuff, especially comparisons between the original and adaptations, but I feel like beyond saying there’s IRL context, details of real horse racing history should have to be put in the source corner.
6
u/[deleted] May 26 '25
Mods, if you do have a system that keeps tracks of how many times a person "lead people to piracy", please, make sure it's not triggering for me.
Unless something changed and now the word "torrent" is banned. In which case I would comply, but since less then a month ago you told me it's fine to use it, I'm using it.
Not really upset because you deleted a 1 word comment lol I'm worried one day I'll get banned because these "wrong deletions" are accumulating "ban points" on your system and the auto-mod will ban me without a second thought.
38
u/Iron_legacy96 May 05 '25
The "cosplay" posts are rather irritating, the way I see it is there's good cosplay, bad cosplay, and then there's "cosplay" that's only goal is to sell "something", I have no issue with the 2 former but the latter needs to be banished to the shadow realm
34
u/LG03 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bronadian May 04 '25
Ban cosplay.
11
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ May 04 '25
On a different note entirely, is there any interest in making a flair specifically for shorts that meet the requirements for our awards? It'd be nice to have an easy way to see them throughout the year in one place.
36
u/xgardian May 06 '25
I don't care that they're doing sex work, I care that I'm being bombarded with blatant advertisements for something unrelated to the sub.
I'm here for posts about anime, not about some random woman's tits. I don't see how wearing a costume is related to anime anyway. There's like a million subs to post that stuff on too like literally r/cosplay
26
u/No-Chemical-7667 https://anilist.co/user/dab May 04 '25
Seems like the overwhelming consensus is no more cosplay. Will the mods actually live up to this?
22
u/RPO777 x2 May 07 '25
My two cents:
To prevent most photoshop background funny business, limiting posting from any given event to 1 week or 2 week from the con in question I think would be a good rule. if someone starts posting content that's photoshopped into a location, instant ban--if PS/ChatGPT manipulation begins to be an issue, I think the rule can be revisited. But just making it harder to post promotional content might be enough to deter ad content.
2) I don't think it's realistic to ask the subs to research individual posters' histories to determine if the person is "shadow marketing" for an OF account or other pornographic account vs. those who are cosplayers. The mods are volunteers, regular people who aren't paid to do this.
There is enough content to moderate as it is, making each decision for a posting a research project is just not realistic. At a minimum, reducing the times such a thing needs to be done (such as allegations that someone is posting using photoshopped backgrounds to promote their OF account) would hopefully make things rare enough the workload increase on the mods would be minimal.
3) I don't think trying to moderate based on what is or isn't "appropriate" content is very realistic. I think it would open up the moderation to problems that go beyond simple yes no calls. For example, would we allow a guy with a Baki cosplay of a muscular guy in boxing trunks?
This will quickly turn into a ****show of sexist double standards and enforced modesty in terms of what types of cosplay are permissible and what are not.
The standard has to be something other than "modesty" as that's gonna get loaded and problematic in a real hurry.
4) I think a blanket rule that all cosplay needs to be NSFW marked might be a simple and more effective rule as well (either in parallel to or in addition to the above). It would simplify enforcement. That would at least block the main field from Cosplay images from those who should be seeing NSFW content, and those who want to avoid it.
Again, it avoids needing to codify some kind of modesty standard that some posters clearly are willing to skirt--to avoid having such content be plastered over the main feed on this sub, simply requiring all cosplay content to include a NSFW flag would solve a substantial part of the issue.
5) I wouldn't necessarily be against simply banning cosplay, but I have seen numerous cosplays here I thought were fun. The Truck-kun cosplay was great, I've seen some fun photos from people at cons having a good time. It'd be a shame to lose cool content like that, so if it can be worked out, I hope we can avoid throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
Appreciate the mods taking this seriously.
31
u/Mlpskystars May 04 '25
Cosplays should not be allowed in this sub at all imo, this is not a cosplay sub this is an anime sub
34
u/abarthy May 07 '25
I left all other social media due to the amount of OF advertisements being shoved in my face, and I’m about to leave this subreddit because of it.
24
u/RiceKirby May 05 '25
I don't come to this sub very often, but I'm subbed to it so there's always one or two post on my front page. These past few days I noticed some cosplay ones popping up, and reminded me of how I read someone saying a few months ago the One Piece sub basically turned into a softcore cosplay sub.
Personally, I think every community needs to be a clear scope, which should be what users expect to find when they check the sub. While cosplay may be adjacent to anime fandoms, I feel like it deviates too much from this sub's scope (or rather, my personal impression of what this sub's scope is). It's like how in a football sub I don't expect to see posts about other sports, despite there being plenty of users who are interested in them.
Another point I'd like to bring up is how when people see something being posted and getting traction, they'll want to post their own take on that too. It's basically the concept of a meme (not the funny internet pics, but the actual meme concept), and this easily spiral into a mess. I'm sure many of you already saw in some other community a user would post some kind of post like a tier list, then another user would post their own list, then soon everyone is posting the same thing. I imagine that's how the One Piece sub became like that, and personally it's not something I'd like to see happening on this sub.
Last point is that Reddit was previously known as a place where discussions can run quite deep, but this has been changing recently with the admins attempts to make it more and more like other social media. The consequences is that simple image posts tend to get far more attention than a well-elaborated and insightful text. An example is the Seiyuu sub, which is a sub about voice actors, but barely has any discussion about the voice acting itself, it's mostly photos from events and other jobs. I'd personally would prefer if this sub kept having more of the good discussion than the eye candy posts.
33
u/cain261 May 06 '25
I like keeping up with anime, but I’m getting progressively more annoyed that half the things I see on my feed from here are just gooner material. If things stay consistent I’ll most likely unsub.
Not that my opinion matters, but it doesn’t hurt to comment.
5
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary May 11 '25
I don't see the new faces in the repo
5
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii May 29 '25
I would love some clarification about the ruling regarding spoilers, mainly when it comes to things that DO NOT happen;
Say, I assume that "This character doesn't die" is a spoiler, just as much as "This character dies"... Is that correct? (I think I may have asked about this before)
Same with "They never catch the bad guy", or "The world doesn't end", etc...
But what about the "less dramatic stuff", like say for a romcom; Is "There's no romantic progress in this series" or "They never get together" a spoiler?
In my mind it is, but these comments are everywhere in so many romcom announcement threads, and sometimes I do report some of them but they're never removed, which gets me to wonder if these are not considered spoiler (and if that's the case, what's the difference with the other examples named above; Is it because 'no progress' is common in many romcoms so it's not considered a spoiler, as the fans expect it? But one could argue that 'this character doesn't die' is usually expected as well, most characters don't die. And the world usually doesn't end in most anime, etc..)
And while we're on the topic of spoilers: To what extent are 'genre spoilers' considered spoilers?
Personally I think they are - unless the genre is not meant to be a secret, like "Hey, Gotoubun is a harem romcom!"... Say If I talk about [title] Talentless Nana I always try to spoiler as much as I can because of the nature of the show, and the fact that (even if it happens early) there is a big reveal that changes what you expect from this show, and if you already know about the genre, it will make the reveal less impactful...
But a recent anime (forgot the name, to be honest) is kinda presented as a charming slice of life with bits of drama, but everyone and their mom spoiled that it isn't. The "OMG I CAN'T WAIT TO SEE ANIME-ONLIES CRY THEIR LIVES AND SHUDDER IN HORROR!" type of comments.
28
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh May 05 '25 edited May 07 '25
Effective five minutes ago a vote is underway (edit: within the mod team) regarding the current cosplay/advertising situation. You are still free to comment on it here of course, but we're not going to have any changes to the rules until voting concludes 168 hours from now (Edit: sike, I lied). Just for anyone who's curious, the vote is basically broken down as follows:
Vote 1: Should any changes be made.
Vote 2: If Vote 1 passes, should any content be banned outright. Options for cosplay, fanart, "only lewd cosplay," and no.
Vote 3: Also if Vote 1 passes, should advertising accounts be banned. Options for "based on a specific metric," "based on mod discretion," "only if OnlyFans or similar link present," and no.
Vote 4: Also if Vote 1 passes, should any additional measures be taken. Options for changing cosplay/fanart frequency, locking comments in cosplay/fanart posts, reverting to the old ruleset where cosplay fanart had to be text posts, and no changes.
Any questions or concerns, feel free to mention them.
38
u/Accomplished_Area_50 May 06 '25
If I wanted to see cosplay pictures, I'd go to the cosplay sub. Clogging up my feed with stuff I have no interest in doesn't help me nor the cosplayers.
36
u/PTRWP May 07 '25
This is my favorite subreddit to see tons of soft core porn. I’m so glad that so much of this subreddit is porn with over half the comments removed (due to commenting how annoying the porn spam is). /s
Ban cosplay posts. There are multiple other active subreddits for it. The frequency has been increasing and will continue to do so as there is a direct monetary incentive for those posters to do so.
38
u/Alihzahn May 05 '25
Instead of deleting comments, maybe the mods should focus on removing low quality posts.
20
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary May 05 '25
pls ban thinly veiled Patreon ads
anyway, I was wondering about the following potential rule: link/image posts about stuff that isn't your own should have the artist/author name/username/whatever in the title
rn only some flairs (e.g. fanart) enforce this but only in a comment
tbh the reason I thought about this is that even if I filter an author's name I may still see posts about their content if a 3rd party posts them without mentioning the name, whereas with the above rule it couldn't happen
maybe it's too complex for such a narrow scope, but hey maybe it makes sense for other purposes, idk
20
u/SCVGoodT0GoSir May 06 '25
I mentioned this in the April meta thread, but basically with the current state of things, all the comments in the cosplay posts fall into (roughly) 4 categories:
#1 and #2 get removed because they violate the rules for comments on cosplay posts. That means what's left are a mix of comments praising the cosplay with massive downvotes, and comments insulting the cosplay with upvotes.
This is not a healthy environment. Especially when opening a post shows 70% of comments being [removed] and then all the actual upvoted comments being insults.
Something needs to be done with cosplay posts. If we want to continue to allow cosplay posts, maybe something like 1 post per 30 days would be a good tradeoff and can mostly mitigate the effects of OF advertising, since most casual cosplayers (who want to show off their cosplay from conventions, events, etc) probably won't have a stockpile of multiple pictures per month. I don't mind cosplay posts that have good intentions, so I understand the hesitation to ban them outright.
14
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO May 08 '25 edited May 08 '25
I understand To Be Hero X is suppose to be a ok show but people aren´t making the real questions... where isa discussion thread for Kill Bill. Such masterpiece of a movie, with great action and great animation done by Production IG so is a shame there isn´t a thread to discuss it
19
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead May 07 '25 edited Jul 14 '25
Making the petition now, before the widely anticipated new movie drops: Allow the discussion of all Heidi properties. The source novel is basically part of the literary canon in Japan and there's the old anime that got a duly needed visual refresh with much better CGI than the 50 year old version. The new series is also animation that exists in Japan, where it is considered anime. We should not gatekeep these modern renditions, many people might not even learn about the outdated original if they can't discuss the movie here.
Furthermore, productions like Arcane from Fortnite are anime, as Riot Games produced Arcane, owns parts of Fortnite and is itself owned by Tencent, a Chinese and thus east-asian company.
Also, all Crunchyroll productions like Onyx Equinox and FreakAngels are obviously anime, they are produced by a Sony-owned company. Same goes for any other Sony produced property of course. Allow Spiderverse and the 100% CGI scenes of the Venom movies.
Alternatively, if this does not succeed, we should ban all Kadokawa properties in the case they get acquired by Korean "Kakao Company" after all.
8
u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman May 06 '25
[Checks Watch]
So only around 120 more hours until we get to see the results of the Cosplay Vote...
[This is fine meme]
8
u/punching_spaghetti https://myanimelist.net/profile/punch_spaghetti May 08 '25
Per the clip rules, posts can be up to 5 minutes long.
Theoretically, would it be acceptable to post the complete episode from a short? Wakako-zake, Miru Tights, Henkei Shoujo; all the greats have episodes lengths well under 5 minutes.
16
u/Duckerscraft May 06 '25
Stop people posting NSFW images without the tag
4
u/SSjjlex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Clone_Tau May 07 '25
I thought someone would've mentioned it by now but apparently they haven't and so I guess its my turn to do it (though now that I think about it I guess its already a tad late for that, oh well)
Since Takamine-san's 5th episode discussion post was based on early unofficial fansubs, shouldn't there have been an official cross/repost for when the official release came out the other day? or did something change regarding that practice?
4
u/chilidirigible May 11 '25
This week's episode of Lazarus was missed by AutoLovePon? (Also asked in modmail.)
29
u/yamiyaiba May 07 '25
To me, the bottom line is this: the thirst trap OF ad accounts are ruining legit cosplay posts. The community is loudly, clearly indicating that we don't want OF advertisers here. That would be easier to demonstrate if all the comments weren't bulk removed by overzealous rule enforcement, instead of just the lewd, crude, and rude ones.
If we want to support real cosplay, then the bottom line should be: if a poster has an OnlyFans link in their history, anywhere, ever, they should be disallowed from posting cosplay. Reportable option, mods nuke the post, the end. Real users can use an untainted alt account if they do both independent of each other, and aren't just baiting. Not like it's hard to make a second account. Unfortunately, OF spammers ruin things for everyone. That's just the reality of it.
17
u/Comprehensive_Dog651 May 05 '25
Seems like there's been an uptick in cosplay posts recently?
7
u/[deleted] May 13 '25
What's the reasoning behind disallowing TBHX to be discussed while posts like these are allowed, where there are several donghua's mentioned in the video and several of the comments discuss TBHX?
I can probably guess it's because it's mostly Japanese works mentioned. (For the record I would personally prefer stricter criteria)
20
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead May 04 '25
/u/Emi_Ibarazakiii commented the number of donghua produced per year her. If those numbers are at least stable, this should be the deathknell for any serious discussion about expanding the scope of r/anime.
Ignoring obviously disingenious changes to turn the subreddit into r/animeandafewpopularchinesecartoons, opening the subreddit to Korean and Chinese animation (but apparently nothing from Indonesia or the Philippines, India or Taiwan etc.) would bring another 50 series per season. This would mean a big expansion of the current amount episode discussion posts. Not sure these days, but usually there's around 60 anime airing that get any discussion + a bunch of shorts and kid's shows that don't really exist for this sub. Even if we say the seasonal number was 100, that would be a 50% increase. And that's not even counting the Korean children's series and smaller productions throughout Asia. Or those motion-manwha and webtoons with animated panels.
It's also more than enough for a healthy community to form around. Especially with those almighty trailblazer shows like Link Click and TBHX shining a strong spotlight on Chinese animation and the most successful animated movie being a Chinese one (which is a lot more culturally relevant than the flavor of the season, yet nobody wants to talk about it apparently.)
And if the special pleading leads to success, it will happen again soon enough.
17
u/The_Swag_Titan May 04 '25
Look. I'm all for having cosplay from time to time on this sub since we barely get any (according to data from the mods). So, it should not be that big of a problem. However, we should moderate it if it's going to far with cosplayers making non-genuine posts that are basically just low effort advertisements. If a professional cosplayer makes a post that is of high quality, it should be allowed. Or maybe just find one day of the week where cosplay should be allowed on.
We also must be incredibly careful not to punish someone who posts a cosplay of their favourite character here, only to take them down and bash on them just because it was "low quality" even though they were being serious. For some it takes an incredible amount of courage to post a photo or picture of yourself and put it on a sub like this, only for that individual to be a target of receiving immediate disapproval or negativity.
This is just my take.
23
u/Endranii https://anilist.co/user/Endranii May 05 '25
Please remove the blatant OF promotion posts. They are some of the worst "cosplay" posts you can get. Low effort, photoshopped slop only meant to sell sex work. I don't wanna see cosplays posts removed all together, but there should be rules to prevent this kind of content from popping up, especially when more often than not it's botted to the front page.
At least when it comes to selling art commissions, it's more often than not some decent piece of work that's being showcased. But the OF content is just unbridled slop in 99% of cases when it's posted on big boards.
10
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW May 05 '25
Since we are now on the right track to beat last month's comments, it is my turn to request the slaying of
6
u/Humg12 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Humg12 May 07 '25
I'm guessing this has already been answered and I'm sorry for adding fuel to the fire, but I couldn't find it when I looked:
What's different about To Be Hero X vs the original To Be Hero that was allowed on the subreddit back when the rules were even stricter than they are now? I remember watching season one 8 year ago and there being very little (if any?) controversy about the discussion threads at the time.
8
u/Moikrochip_Master May 09 '25
Can something please finally be done about all these "Is x worth watching posts?" "Recommend me an anime that-" posts? They're so repetitive and pointless.
18
u/3HaDeS3 May 04 '25
I think there is a simple solution, if someone posts their Cosplay, it’s fine but when you open their profile and see bunch of ads that lead to nudes (example: OF) then it’s not a cosplay but advertisement and has nothing to do with anime but the website they are promoting.
3
u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke May 13 '25
The Clannad Anime of the Week post is still pinned on Shreddit at least, despite being replaced with a new AotW
3
u/Time_Fracture https://myanimelist.net/profile/Time_Fracture May 15 '25
I see the members and online users titles have been changed from Initial D-themed (Project D racers) to Apocalypse Hotel-themed (Tanukians). A recent change or it's been there since few days ago?
Don't worry we're not going to [Apocalypse Hotel]ruin the hotel rooms with holes and empty the hotel's alcohol stock this time.
3
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW May 17 '25
On mobile, the community highlights tab links to last last week cdf
3
u/NekoWafers May 31 '25
How would the rules work for posting something like Fumiko's Confession?
That is the official upload on YouTube from 2009, but it is in 360p and doesn't have an English subs option.
There is also a newer Blu-ray release with English subs but that would need to be uploaded to Reddit.
Also would that need an NSFW tag for panty shots?
Thanks
15
u/Aprem https://myanimelist.net/profile/aprem May 06 '25
After seeing several cosplay threads get totally bombed out of comments and going through this thread and the top 100 or so all time posts on this subreddit, it really does seem silly to continue allowing these lewd cosplay posts to continue.
I guess for me the problem is that I don't necessarily want to see the total removal of all cosplay posts. I hate to see SFW cosplays also get the axe but at the same time if we can't have a civil discussion around them then maybe they shouldn't be here.
Maybe there is some kind of weekend post situation or something that could be put together? Where cosplay posts are allowed occasionally but not all the time? Although I'm not entirely sure that would fix the discussion/karma farming problem.
12
u/AnimeHoarder May 07 '25
I'd like to propose that additional "promotional cosplay" and "promotional fanart" flairs be created for use by submitters with onlyfan type/ shop links in their profiles. I don't know if you'd want to include general social links in this. Violators will have their posts removed for the first three times and banned if they continue. This won't necessarily solve the issue, but force the submitters to be upfront about their intentions.
18
u/Extension-Ad-9371 May 04 '25
My King!!!! Its another OF… cough i mean cosplay post!!! Getting massively upvoted immediately again!!!
God Save Us….
22
u/dirtyhashbrowns2 May 05 '25
@ mods, why is nothing being done about the OF astroturfing cosplaying posts? I’ve seen your reasoning but when an overwhelming amount of people are expressing concern and giving good reasons, including mods from other subs that have implemented similar rules, why not do anything? What incentive do you have to keep the OF accounts around? Why not appease the community?
If anything just try out banning them and if a ton of people come out from the woodwork demanding them back then so be it. Otherwise it’s a good change.
7
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy May 07 '25 edited May 07 '25
On the topic of real and fake fanart:
How is this subreddit planning to counter AI-created fanart? With the rapid advances in AI, it’s only a matter of time before this will become truly indistinguishable from the real thing to the layman.
I’m somewhat surprised that r/anime hasn’t already been flooded with all sorts of AI creations like other social media platforms. Has the mod team been this vigilant on the matter or have we merely been lucky until now?
Nevertheless, it’s bound to happen eventually with the door being open to fanart submissions. If faced with the dilemma, I’d rather have the subreddit’s frontpage be clogged with NSFW clips of fake (anime) boobs than fake pieces of art.
15
u/Interesting-Ad1352 May 06 '25
Most of the comments on cosplay posts are removed, it’s clear that a lot of us don’t want that stuff here.
There’s plenty of other places for them to advertise their OF.
22
u/[deleted] May 04 '25
Please for the love of god do not allow discussions about donghua or future korean animation in this subreddit. I'm a long term lurker (10 years+ and counting) and I'm happy that this subreddit has stayed purely about japanese animation over these years.
6
u/Erens-Basement https://anilist.co/user/erensbase May 13 '25
Remove recommendation/"what to watch" posts. It's honestly a bigger problem than cosplay and we get several posts a day asking for recs. We have a pinned megathread for it already so why aren't these posts removed? You can also search up old posts too.
15
u/HitmanManHit1 May 05 '25
Its not even the cosplay posts itself. Mods nuking literally ANY discussion that does not directly reference the post in the comments (a shit ton of replies just get deleted, apparently they dont like any discussion at all???) is actually crazy. I literally cant see a reason other than "witchhunting", any replies that even pull a quip or a joke get removed, especially if its remotely negative to that cosplayer... ngl those OF accounts prob have a Mod alt lmao
13
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod May 04 '25 edited May 04 '25
Since several people in the prior thread asked whether any of the cosplay posts bought votes or otherwise engaged in vote manipulation, I asked the admins whether they saw any evidence of vote manipulation on a group of recent cosplay posts. Their response was pretty clear: "After looking at the voting patterns, [they] didn't see anything concerning from a vote manipulation" perspective.
So, to the best of our knowledge, their scores are obtained legitimately. We have both a theory for why they got the upvotes they did—posts people can be horny about get a disproportionate number of upvotes on /r/anime—and admin confirmation that nothing looks funny. Together, these paint quite a convincing picture.
17
u/Few-Mail3887 May 05 '25
Ban cosplay posts. Every single time I’ve seen one it’s an only fans model pretending they know what anime is.
4
u/sfisher923 https://myanimelist.net/profile/sfisher923 May 04 '25
A rather small issue - The pinned CDF post on the "Community Highlights" is from last week and needs updated (Sidebar is pointing to the right post though)
4
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick May 06 '25
Quick question. Is there a reason why the cosplay posts aren't appearing in the past year's top posts? Do they have to make it past 1 month first or something?
4
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead May 08 '25
I wonder if the recommendation page in the wiki would benefit from a section explicitly shouting out non-anime properties. Might be a more visible place for new people to find other animation-specific subreddits and get a taste of what other regions have to offer.
The section about locating sequels could also use the addition of the Chiaki Sequel Locator, which is a lot faster if you search for single properties instead of analyzing your hwole list.
10
u/PreludeToHell May 05 '25
Unsurprising increase of more ads. I've seen comments from mods saying "what about art" and I agree there should be a blanket ban instead of being selective. I've always preferred being proactive but w/e
12
u/fkvirginredditmods May 05 '25
Ban the OF thirst traps or I will leave.
13
u/joey_feeler May 06 '25
How much do mods get paid to allow onlyfans ads on here?
9
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick May 06 '25
Man. You'd think Dress-Up Darling was the most despised show in the history of the sub, with how people are acting here.
4
u/lma_posts May 27 '25 edited May 27 '25
Sub Question.. I just got comment downvoted when I asked a question (no rude stuff, people just didn’t like it, I guess) and now I can’t seem to post anymore. Says I need even more Karma now. Anyone know how I can see what my karma score is now for “just this sub” on the iOS app?
Extra Q: Just joined the sub a few weeks ago. Does this happen a lot here?
Edit: thanks for the help. Channel -> sub.
4
u/Verzwei May 27 '25
How is this post passing the anime-specific rules?
It's a whole thread of people talking about western books and has nothing to do with existing nor announced anime, except in the handful of cases where someone points out that an adaptation was already made for something someone else brought up.
7
u/Shuyakucchi May 06 '25
Why do you guys keep allowing cosplay posts if you both will delete most of the comments that come with that kind of posts or are gonna downvote them to oblivion?
9
u/Lemurians myanimelist.net/profile/Lemurians May 06 '25 edited May 06 '25
I just want to say, that if your issue with certain cosplay posts is that they're low-effort, thinly-veiled OnlyFans advertising, that's an area where I'm actually inclined to agree with you and I'm perfectly happy to have those be disallowed.
The person who posted the Power cosplay today, from what I can tell is a legitimate cosplayer and doesn't have an OnlyFans and it certainly isn't a thirst trap, and that comment section is still getting brigaded with downvotes for every comment that is even just giving the person a compliment.
At least pick your targets so as to be consistent with your ideology. Otherwise it just looks like, well...