r/BetaReaders • • 17d ago

Discussion [Discussion] r/BetaReaders check-in series! Share how your WIP is going, or how your beta reading is going, ask questions, and connect with more writers and readers!

4 Upvotes

Hello r/BetaReaders!

Who else can’t believe it’s November already? It’s basically 2027 now

Here’s this month’s prompt in the spirit of voting season: what happens/happened when you have/had split beta reader reactions? Do you ask for their reasonings before going with your gut decision or do you wait before implementing things? Or do you see if each beta view has a point and revise accordingly?


Welcome to our 11th monthly check-in thread!

These monthly pinned post aims to help the community connect with other writers and betas!

Share how your WIP is going, or how your current beta read is going, or other relatable beta reading topics in this thread!

This is a great thread to talk about writing, updates, accountability, trends, vents, and more.

It is not the right thread to post first pages as there’s another pinned thread for that, but you can link to your beta post if you wish.

Do NOT advertise any beta/editor services here, and no free samples to later ask for payment are allowed. You can try r/hireaneditor or r/freelance_forhire instead.

We also ask that self promotion of completed works do not contain links. Mentioning success is completely fine!

And we’d like to take this opportunity to remind people that works generated with AI, and AI-generated feedback is not allowed here, either. r/writingwithAI or r/betareadersforAI are better subreddits for that.

And because scammers are now targeting GDocs: please DM them and not leave them up on the sub publicly to avoid harassment

I’d also like to note that we have additional flairs available to help people know what specialty you have: traditional publishing, self-publishing, and fanfic. Please consider using them to help people match with you.

Also, it’s best to subscribe to our sub before commenting or posting to help avoid Reddit’s filters sending your content into the spam queue

Please ensure you comment in good faith and do not break any other r/betareaders rules.

Thank you, and happy writing/reading/editing/beta matching!


r/BetaReaders • • Oct 07 '26

Meta [Meta] Please review our subreddit’s resources on the sidebar and wiki to help with your posts here

14 Upvotes

For extra accessibility and convenience, r/betareaders is pinning this post with a link to the wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/wiki/index/

Additionally, you may find these comprehensive resources helpful in creating your own blurb or synopsis

If you are aiming for traditional publishing or self publishing, writing a query letter blurb will not only help tell potential betas what they can expect, but they also show you the core components of your story upfront and often helps with DIY revision

Many people prefer detailed information to help them decide on taking on a beta read, but the subreddit currently strictly enforces 2 key pieces of information in posts as some people want more privacy and will DM them to respondents

Please do take note of r/betareaders rules, which are found on the sidebar to the right, and are also expanded on in the wiki. The sidebar also has clickable links to templates that give suggestions for information beta readers would like to know before responding. The less you provide, the less enticing your post is. Conversely, extremely long posts also reduce likelihood in responses

And again, this is a fully free subreddit that does not permit services or requests for money in any form. It is also anti-AI generated works and pro-human

The wiki will have minor updates in future, and so will the comprehensive resources linked

Best wishes for your writing, revising, and beta reading!


r/BetaReaders • • 3h ago

80k [Complete] [86.4k] [Urban Fantasy] Heart of Magic: Adrift at Night

3 Upvotes

A bit about my work:

Some form of this series has been lurking in my mind as early as 2012, with character ideas and plot moments floating around, but it wasn't until 2017/2018 that I really sat down and wrote out the first draft of Adrift at Night, usually while in between classes or waiting for my creative writing club to start. Since then I've written rough drafts for the first six books the series and I've decided to try and share my attempts to capture the lives of these crazy people living in my head. From slice of life moments and romance, to scheming crime syndicates and bloodthirsty vampires. In terms of content, they are roughly comparable to Illona Andrew's Kate Daniels books, or earlier seasons of Buffy, with the later novels growing to be more adult, perhaps closer to Leigh Bardugo's Ninth House or Patricia Brigg's Mercy Thompson (none of that book 3 stuff though, waay too much for me).

Before I start rambling too much, here's the blurb for Heart of Magic: Rosebriar: Adrift at Night

As a child, Kasey Chase dreamed of being a veterinarian or a doctor. Or, if she was really lucky she’d meet a prince or princess charming and be swept off her feet to live a dream fairytale life where everything was perfect.

She never thought her mother would become a part of the Dermail Syndicate and smuggle and distribute drugs. She never thought her father would became nothing more than an addict. And she never thought she’d come home one day to find them murdered—or that she might be adopted.

While on the run from the Dermail Syndicate, Kasey’s search for answers will reveal more to the world than she ever thought possible, that dark and dangerous things lurk in the night, that magic and monsters are real. And to get the answers she seeks, she’ll have to step foot into a conflict between forces she scarcely can believe are real, and wished they weren’t.

Content Warnings: Brief Addiction, Brief Drug Use, Graphic Death, Graphic Injury, Graphic Kidnapping, Mentions of Pregnancy, Childbirth, and Child Death, Brief Sexual Assault/Harassment, Mentions of Sexual Content.

Who I'm looking for:

First and foremost, someone that loves urban fantasy! Vampires, shifters, witches, fae, and demons are at the heart of this series. Religions and Mythologies with lots of liberties taken are also an important component to the series, the general idea here is that there is some truth to every religion/mythology but a lot has been distorted over time.

Another thing to keep in mind is that this is an LGBTQ+ friendly series with several characters *eventually* ending up in queer relationships, however romance is not the main driving focus of the series, and nothing really starts happening in the first few books.

What I'm looking for:

Big picture things such as characterization, overall plot, confusing moments, things you enjoyed. I am not looking for line edits or proofreading, (although if you find something that bugs you feel free to mark it!).

I'm looking for 2-3 people, and I'm happy to do a swap. As for time frame, I'd prefer 4-8 weeks, although with it being holiday season I understand if someone might need more time. I'd like to start with the first three chapters to make sure we're a good match. Anyways, thank you for taking the time to read all this gibberish!


r/BetaReaders • • 3h ago

>100k [Complete][180k][Historical Fantasy] Runemaster

2 Upvotes

I've nearly complete my first revision of a historical fantasy I've been writing for the past two years.

Runemaster is a historical high fantasy fiction. I wanted to blend my two favorite subjects, High Fantasy magic and World War Two into an alternative world with an emphasis on some of my favorite things, namely: religion, wizards, guns, tanks and old warbirds from the perspective of a common man overcome by the events taking place around him.

The stable zone is a place of relative calm on a primordial world embroiled by magical(ley) energy. An ancient race of powerful mages known as the Methilim once ruled the world, the discovery of runes -magically drawn symbols which dissipate ley energy- led to the defeat of the Methilim and the establishment of the Stable Zone. Now, a thousand cycles later, tyranny threatens the stable zone again as scarcity drives common men to War with one another again.

Disclaimer: I understand that there are some themes centered around this time that are difficult to discuss. I wanted to use this story as an opportunity to explore them and maybe learn something from them. I have studied World War 2 and the Holocaust most of my life. While I am no expert, I find people using the inflammatory terms of the time very loosely in our modern world troubling. Some even go so far as to identify with these evil people from our own history.

To that end, I am trying to frame that history into a fantastic story that helps modern readers understand this difficult time a little better. I want to describe the events that led up to it, how we can identify them by knowing what patterns to look for in our own society, and maybe posit some solutions that might help us resist taking a similar path again.

Feel free to comment if interested, I can provide either the full text so far, or specific chapters depending on what you are looking for.

Thanks!

EXCERPT:

The Divisionaire looked around in disgust at the mounded piles of bodies. With Hadenstein’s grip on them released, several had reverted halfway between their monstrous bodies and original forms. The transformed Lauten too now lay in some purgative stasis between man and beast. The abominations lay in mangled, burning piles amidst the wreckage of the battle. “Then what do you call all of this?” He motioned to the spectacle.

“Nothing more than a battle with monsters, their faces have changed. They do not possess the humanity they once did.”

“That may be.” Replied the Divisionaire. “Yet that is exactly what makes this a war.” He turned to address the Lauten representative. “War makes monsters of us all, and none come out wearing the same faces.” His face was somber as he gazed into the fire, mind turning behind his eyes in an unfathomable stupor. “Especially the survivors.”


r/BetaReaders • • 11m ago

>100k [Complete] [101k] [Contemporary Romance] The Shape of the Room — Exploring honesty and boundaries in a long-term marriage

1 Upvotes

I am seeking 5-7 beta readers for my debut novel.

Title: The Shape of the Room

Genre: Contemporary Relationship Fiction
Word Count: ~101,000 words | 26 chapters
Formats: PDF, EPUB, or Word (.docx) — your choice

Blurb
What does honesty look like when a marriage opens up?

Liz and Dave have been married twenty years. They have three children, a home on the Lancashire coast, and a quiet question neither of them has dared ask out loud: what if love didn't have to be quite so neat?

This isn't a story about leaving. It's a story about staying, and finding out there's more room inside a life — and a marriage — than you thought.

Content Notes
• Themes: Ethical non-monogamy, bisexuality (M/M & F/F), explicit intimacy, honest marital conflict
• Characters make mistakes — no one is purely "right" or "wrong"
• Adult content — please ensure this is within your comfort zone before requesting

Details
• Reading window: 4 weeks — happy to extend if you need more time
• Feedback: A 30–40 question questionnaire via Google Forms at the end — covers pacing, characters, emotional beats, and your overall thoughts
• No prior experience needed — just your honest reaction as a reader

About Me
I'm Alex Lune, a debut author from the North West. This is my first novel, and I'm looking for thoughtful readers to help me polish it before publication. Your feedback will directly shape the final draft.

How to Join
Send me a quick message — just say hello and your preferred file format. I'll send your copy and the link to the form once you've finished reading. No pressure, no deadlines beyond the 4-week window — I'm just grateful for your time.

Thanks for considering!


r/BetaReaders • • 58m ago

>100k [Complete][128k][Urban Fantasy, Neo-Noir, Psychological Thriller] Playback Requiem - A mercenary seeks to save her wife with one last job NSFW

1 Upvotes

Looking for Beta Readers to give any and all feedback, DM if Interested. Currently on Draft 3 so plenty of room for improvement to go.

Base details: A sapphic love story that explores self definition, the price of violence and internalized trauma in a setting built to push a mercenary beyond her limits to retrieve the only happiness she has in her life.

Logline: In the fictional city of New Paris, Michigan a race of humanimals known as Ferren struggle with the Americanization of their historically French city after decades of squalor, economic decay, and cultural redefinition. In the midst of this city, A criminal mercenary is on the verge of retiring to the civilian life when everything about her final job goes wrong. Her wife is kidnapped by a mysterious client and now she is guided by a mysterious cassette player and its tapes. She has one night to do one last job, get her wife back, while saving what matters most to her, preserving what she is defined by, and maintaining her desire for a peaceful life against a necessity for violence.

[CONTENT WARNING] - Graphic and Pervasive Violence, Gore and Body Horror, Intense Grief and Unexpected Deaths, Psychological Distress and Trauma, Familial Abuse, Extreme Criminal Exploitation, Sex, Sexualized Violence, Self-Harm Imagery, Medical Gore, & Political Exploration

Inspiration: John Wick, Signalis, & Disco Elysium


r/BetaReaders • • 4h ago

Discussion [Discussion] I’m looking for Beta Readers!

2 Upvotes

I started writing fanfics recently and I’m writing my second & third one currently. I heard it’s good to have beta readers, and I think it’d help me a lot to have genuine feedback.

I’ll mostly write Genshin Impact fanfics, but might write about other fandoms as well. Most of the fanfics will be 18+ as well.

Two or three beta readers would be amazing, and warning, I’m kinda writing for fun—not to become some famous writer and get recognition. I just wish for other people to be able to enjoy what I write too!


r/BetaReaders • • 2h ago

>100k [Complete] [128k] [Progression Fantasy] Coding Cultivation: Refactoring QI

1 Upvotes

Hi all

Looking for beta readers for my first (of a planned trilogy) complete book ~128,000-word LitRPG / cultivation (written from a western perspective) / progression novel.

Blurb:

To the Great Sects, Qi is a divine mystery. To Mike Lee, it’s bad code.

Waking up in a younger body in a brutal, underground cultivation world, Mike Lee is a long way from his corporate desk job. He doesn't have a golden root or a legendary lineage. What he does have is QiOS: a deeply passive-aggressive operating system that translates the laws of the universe into something he understands. Code.

While cultivators spend centuries meditating to grasp the "intent" of the Dao, Mike is busy refactoring his meridians and patching the vulnerabilities in his spiritual pathways.

Unfortunately, his new body is low-spec hardware, and QiOS has the personality of an edgelord teenager. Starting at the rock bottom of Voidweave Pavilion, Mike has to survive monster-infested tunnels, cutthroat disciples, an annoying goat, and lethal system crashes just to see tomorrow. If he can't patch his way to power, he'll be permanently deleted.

What I'm asking: structural feedback, not line edits. Does the opening hook? Does the progression feel earned? Where do you want to stop reading? Pacing issues?

Length: 64 chapters, ~128k words.

Timeline: 4–6 weeks.

No obligation to finish — honestly, "I stopped at ch X because Y" is the most useful thing you can send me. Format: Google Doc. (I'll try to export to epub if requested)

Comps: Beware of Chicken, He Who Fights With Monsters, Dungeon Crawler Carl.

Unfortunately, due to juggling a full-time job, taking care of 3 younglings, and writing when I get a chance, I may not have time for swaps, however I am open to a few chapters. No guarantees.

If you're interested, reply or DM — I'll send the first 10 chapters first so you can bail early if it's not for you.


r/BetaReaders • • 2h ago

Novella [complete][20000][lgbtq horror] The Violin NSFW

1 Upvotes

I have a horror smut audiobook I’m looking to have critiqued.

20k words. Little less than 2 hour runtime.

Interesting stylistically— got that dogme 95 vibe.

\*Carrie\* by Stephen King meets \*Party Monster\* by James St. James. With a lot more smut and a real messed up first person present pov.

Pretty gay 🏳️‍🌈.

Darryl is a successful and renowned violinist and luthier who stars in a popular tourist attraction called Gay for a Day in Boystown, Chicago. When his long time friend-with-benefits kills himself, he inherits a broken violin that isolates him from his world in a seemingly consensual possession.

It’s a published book but the audio, recorded by me, is in its final stages.

Hope this is allowed here!

TIA. DMs open


r/BetaReaders • • 2h ago

50k [In Progress] [55k] [Dark academia romance] Coded Ruin

1 Upvotes

My book is about this girl who’s been wanting to get into a prestigious secret society for a while now. Coincidentally her academic rival is a member of this society. He has to help her get into the society and also helps her uncover a big family secret.

If you’d like to apply to be a beta reader, please fill out this form: https://forms.gle/pbNKq1Vt96VRin1y5

I’ve seen a lot of AI bots filling out my form and DM-ing me on TikTok. Please refrain from using AI as I do not support its usage for writing/reading.


r/BetaReaders • • 3h ago

>100k [In Progress][180k][Historical Fantasy] Runemaster

1 Upvotes

I've nearly complete my first revision of a historical fantasy I've been writing for the past two years.

Runemaster is a historical high fantasy fiction. I wanted to blend my two favorite subjects, High Fantasy magic and World War Two into an alternative world with an emphasis on some of my favorite things, namely: religion, wizards, guns, tanks and old warbirds from the perspective of a common man overcome by the events taking place around him.

The stable zone is a place of relative calm on a primordial world embroiled by magical(ley) energy. An ancient race of powerful mages known as the Methilim once ruled the world, the discovery of runes -magically drawn symbols which dissipate ley energy- led to the defeat of the Methilim and the establishment of the Stable Zone. Now, a thousand cycles later, tyranny threatens the stable zone again as scarcity drives common men to War with one another again.

Disclaimer: I understand that there are some themes centered around this time that are difficult to discuss. I wanted to use this story as an opportunity to explore them and maybe learn something from them. I have studied World War 2 and the Holocaust most of my life. While I am no expert, I find people using the inflammatory terms of the time very loosely in our modern world troubling. Some even go so far as to identify with these evil people from our own history.

To that end, I am trying to frame that history into a fantastic story that helps modern readers understand this difficult time a little better. I want to describe the events that led up to it, how we can identify them by knowing what patterns to look for in our own society, and maybe posit some solutions that might help us resist taking a similar path again.

Feel free to comment if interested, I can provide either the full text so far, or specific chapters depending on what you are looking for.

Thanks!


r/BetaReaders • • 6h ago

>100k [Complete] [106,262] [Fantasy] Curse of the Hollow God

0 Upvotes

The gods are dead. Their bones are the city.

Two hundred years after the Godsfall, Drevarn is built inside the corpse of Rhaelor, the Iron Vow. Its streets run between his ribs, and the damp that seeps from the walls every morning is rust-red. Beneath the city, Rifts tear down into the dark. They are wounds in the world, thick with Ichor, the blood of dead gods, and divers who go down to harvest it come back changed, or not at all. Every diver is watched by the Register, a cold voice at the base of the skull that grades, measures and files them, and counts how much of the divine has crept into their flesh.

Vael Ashcroft was a brother of the Order of the Cracked Chalice, sworn to keep the dead gods dead. Then his sister stopped breathing. He went down to a seep with a basin and a lamp and put a god's blood into her to save her. The Order cast him out for it. And in front of every brother in the hall, the Register spoke inside his head and gave him a name it had never given anyone: Oathbreaker. Then, as its charter required, it offered him congratulations. Please DM for a Copy for review or opinions.


r/BetaReaders • • 6h ago

90k [Complete] [95k] [Upper YA / Dark Mythological & Dystopian Fantasy] Looking for thoughtful beta readers for Vol. 1 of a deeply character-driven F/F found-family series!

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Grab a cup of tea and let me tell you a little about the world I’ve been living in for the past 3 years.

I’m looking for 2–3 kind, thoughtful beta readers for my completed 95,000-word Upper YA / Dark dystopian and mythological fantasy (which includes a glossary and a "people of interest" guide at the back). This is a multi-POV, heavily character-driven story and Volume 1 of a planned 4-arc saga, written to have a complete, satisfying arc of its own while setting up a larger journey.

The heart behind the book: This story was originally written as a mending letter to my younger self. While I am aiming to self-publish it, my biggest hope has always been that this particular journey might reach someone out there who needs to feel safe alongside these characters as they heal, endure, and build a home with one another.

What it’s about: The story spans two starkly divided worlds on an island: starved mortals who survive by hunting skyward offerings; divine wielders who inhabit a secret ancient city created by the Endless and are protected by a frightening High Master. Through multiple perspectives, two women (15yo/immortal) forge an unexpected bond—and a fierce found family—against the brutal realities dividing their worlds.

Here's a quick blurb:

In the starved, sun-depraved foothills of Davinium, fifteen-year-old ranger Karieah survives day to day by harboring her dreams in the dark caves of her people's commune. Tasked with patrolling the forests for malevolent, malleable shadows, she must obey one strict rule: never interact with other hunters. But Karieah harbors a dangerous, forbidden secret—a plan to escape across the treacherous mountains with a fellow huntress, Naomi. Time is running out before she is forced to face the deadly judgment of the righteous bonfire, or turn the blade against someone else. Far beyond those very mountains, an ancient civilization withers in the frozen North. Victoria, the right hand of the Endless known as the immortal High Master, struggles to ward the fading city of Arkkadine from the creeping season of wintersmourn that has been slowly diminishing sacred harvests over centuries of a deadly invasion from one Exiled Endless. For centuries, she has anchored the secret city under a charming spell and the well of the Sacred Tree whose tears power the city, all while drowning in the agonizing memories of a tragic past. But when her nights are shattered by a strange commotion within the city’s magical roots, Victoria must make a choice: unearth a dark truth, or live another century forgetting a fate she failed to protect.
One hunts for seconds to survive; the other is haunted by them. When a fatal calamity threatens to collapse the ancient cycles of nature and time, these two separate bloodlines are forced into an unlikely union.

Vibes & Tropes you’ll find inside: ✅Heavily character-driven emotional depth and healing arcs ✅Two contrasting worlds (desperate mortal survival vs. divine/ancient mythology) ✅Multi-POVs intertwining throughout a larger 4-arc saga that include subplots of queer romance and self-discovery ✅A reaaally slow-burn F/F master/apprentice dynamic built on earned trust ✅Character that feel like pure chaos sometimes, ✅Deep found family energy (quiet, tender safety balanced against a harsh, unforgiving world) ✅A glossary and character list—I’d love to know if you actually needed them or if the story stood on its own!

Content Warnings (Please Read): Because this story walks honestly through pain on its way toward healing, there are heavy sections depicting or mentioning sexual assault/rape, abuse, graphic violence, blood and torture, suicide/self-harm, and intense grief. Please take care of yourself and only reach out if you are comfortable reading these themes!

What I’m looking for: Mostly big-picture reader reactions! Did the dual-world lore and multi-POV shifts feel clear early on? Did the character arcs and relationships spike interest? And most importantly, did the ending feel satisfying for a setting volume? No line-editing needed—just your honest thoughts as a reader.

Timeline & Sample: I’d love to start with a 3-chapter sample (16-17k words) to make sure our reading vibes match before sending the full manuscript. My ideal timeline is around [4–6 weeks], though I’m flexible!

I’m also very happy to do a beta swap if you have a dark fantasy, YA, or sapphic manuscript in a similar word-count range! If this sounds like a journey you’d like to take, drop a comment or send me a DM.

Thank you so much for reading!


r/BetaReaders • • 13h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Newbie!

4 Upvotes

Hi! I have been reading for quite a while now, and have started being interested on being a beta reader, mostly for fun! I have no clue how this works or if my critique would even be valid, tho i do think i have a good eye for engaging writing (not that i can do it myself), i wanted to ask for tips on how to not sound super biased without meaning to and how to improve on it!


r/BetaReaders • • 7h ago

>100k [Complete] [105k] [Contemporary / Coming-of-Age] Idiots Stuck in the Middle...

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m looking for a few beta readers for my 105k-word contemporary coming-of-age novel, Idiots Stuck in the Middle...

Blurb: Long before corporate jobs, failed Wi-Fi routers, clothing brands, and glossy literature fests, Aryan, Surya, Sukhdeep and Haris were just terrified 11th-grade PCM students trying to decode physics, dodge strict teachers, and survive the sheer exhaustion of teenage expectations. They called themselves the "Functional Idiots"—a ragged group floating through classrooms under grey skies, awkwardly navigating crushes, minor school disasters, and the constant fear of not measuring up.

Fast forward a decade later. The high school hallways are a distant memory, replaced by the crushing realities of adult life, career stress, and unexpected reunions. When an invitation to a school reunion drags them back together, the old chemistry ignites instantly. Between awkward apologies, old flames like Rhea and Isha, and a whole lot of chai, the old crew realizes that while life turned them into software engineers, businessmen, and writers, they are still fundamentally the same chaotic, inseparable bunch of fools.

Heartwarming, deeply nostalgic, and laugh-out-loud funny, Idiots Stuck in the Middle... is a tribute to messy youth, lifelong friendships, and the beautiful realization that life isn't a race—even if you spent half of it stuck in the middle.

Content Warnings: Mild language, Mild Emotional Anguish & Stress, Interpersonal Conflict

What I’m looking for:

  • Big-picture feedback: Pacing (especially how the past and present timelines balance out), character chemistry, and whether the humor and emotional beats land.
  • Cultural accessibility: For non-Indian readers, do the school and cultural references (like the PCM stream) still feel easy to follow and relatable?
  • Timeline: Ideally, I’d love to get feedback within [e.g., 3–4 weeks].

Format: I can share the manuscript via PDF. I also have the first 3 chapters ready as a sample if you'd like to test the vibe first!

If you're interested, please comment below or send me a DM. Thanks so much for checking this out!


r/BetaReaders • • 15h ago

80k [Complete] [80k] [Science Fantasy / Space Opera] Legend of Circé: The Anomaly

2 Upvotes

Looking for beta readers for my completed 80k science fantasy novel.

Blurb:

Zerya, a high-ranking noble fleeing her own trial, crashes onto a scrapyard planet at the galaxy’s edge. There, she encounters Kael, a Wielder with unconventional powers and the last survivor of a planetary massacre orchestrated by the Order of Conquista.

Forced into an unlikely alliance, Kael and Zerya must escape the planet before they can even think of striking back. Their only hope lies in mastering the Æther.

But survival is only the first step.

To defeat the Order, their quest will take them across the Seven Kingdoms—worlds shaped by raw elemental power. Yet, these nations are already falling under the shadow of the Conquista, which relentlessly hunts down the last remaining Wielders of the universe.

DM me or comment if interested 🙏.


r/BetaReaders • • 14h ago

70k [Complete][78k][Fantasy]Ragnarok Interrupted

1 Upvotes

An adult contemporary fantasy. Combining the dry humor and practical, older protagonist of T. Kingfisher’s Hemlock & Silver with the mythological family drama of Genevieve Gornichec’s The Witch’s Heart, it will appeal to readers who enjoy voice-driven urban fantasy with high apocalyptic stakes.


r/BetaReaders • • 16h ago

>100k [Complete] [112k] [Historical Fiction] Ballyclavas: An Oath of Blood and Canvas

1 Upvotes

Hello, fellow readers!

I'm K.M. Roy, author of The Shadow of London series, and I'm seeking beta readers for my completed novel, Ballyclavas: An Oath of Blood and Canvas, the first book in a new historical family saga.

About the book:

Set in late Victorian Ireland and England, the novel follows Brian Kavanagh, an Irish solicitor with a dangerous past, and his wife, Lady Kamie Kavanagh, as they navigate marriage, family, loyalty, and the secrets of a powerful Irish brotherhood.

When Brian's past threatens the family they have built together, Kamie finds herself confronting a world she never expected to enter—and challenging the traditions that have governed it for generations.

The story combines historical fiction, romance, family drama, suspense, and humor.

Manuscript details:

  • Approximately 112,000 words
  • Completed manuscript
  • Adult historical fiction with strong romantic elements
  • Set primarily in Ireland during the 1890s

Content warnings: Domestic violence, violence, mature themes, strong language, and non-explicit adult content.

Feedback requested:

  • Character development and relationships
  • Pacing and engagement
  • Emotional impact
  • Whether the story works as a standalone novel
  • Overall enjoyment and interest in continuing the series

Previous knowledge of The Shadow of London is not necessary. In fact, I would particularly welcome readers who are new to the Kavanagh family.

I would ideally like feedback within four to six weeks.

If you're interested, please comment below and send me a DM. I will share the manuscript privately with selected beta readers.

Thank you for your time and consideration!

K.M. Roy


r/BetaReaders • • 21h ago

40k [In Progress] [40,000] [satire, comedic fantasy ] A Brief History of Old Man McGunderson

2 Upvotes

Hi, I’m a aspiring author who has been working due diligently on a comedic historical fiction novel about an immortal old man named McGunderson who is older than the big bang (which he created) and is responsible for major disasters and grievances in all of history, by trying to help make things better despite his lack of self awareness or understanding of how things work and his out of touch and out of place demeanor and forgetfulness and self interests get the best of him.

This also leads to McGunderson unintentionally creating a secret society with the goal of stopping him from helping any further by the victims and their descendants of his many mistakes and of the problems he’s caused.

This book is inspired by Douglas Adam’s and Terry Pratchett as well as Christopher Moore and Kurt Vonnegut.

If anyone wants to read it just dm me on Reddit and I’ll share you a copy!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

90k [Complete] [91k] [Gothic Fantasy] What Grew There

2 Upvotes

Blurb: A young woman takes a job looking after a little girl in an isolated house in a northern valley. Then the number seven starts turning up everywhere, and something outside starts knocking.

Content warnings: 18+. Two explicit scenes, sexual content, child in peril, violence, blood, death.

Feedback I’m looking for: pacing, characters, how the tension builds, whether the ending lands, and anything else you notice.

Timeline: about 4 weeks.

Critique swap: happy to swap. I read fantasy, romance and horror.

Comment or DM me if you’re interested!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

[COMPLETE] [60.0000] [YA FANTASY] Ingebeeld en Ingesloten (DUTCH)

4 Upvotes

Lijkt het je leuk een YA Fantasy proef te lezen?

Zonder ‘De Kracht’ telt Eloise niet mee. Als haar machtige familie weesmeisje Vivienne adopteert om hun plek in de regerende Raad te redden, staat alles op scherp. Terwijl de beruchte Derde Week dreigend dichterbij komt, slaat jaloezie om in obsessie – en blijkt alles een duistere prijs te hebben.

Vier van mijn boeken zijn al gepubliceerd dus ik heb al schrijfervaring! Ik zou het heel leuk vinden als een aantal van jullie wil proeflezen.

Als je wilt proeflezen kun je me hier een berichtje sturen of een DM sturen (@paris_duivenvoorden)


r/BetaReaders • • 22h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [4k] [Dark Fantasy] The Beacon — Prologue and First Two Chapters

1 Upvotes

About a month ago, I posted the 40K-word first part of a dark fantasy novel I was working on. The reviews were not good. It was long-winded and, frankly, boring. I took the critiques to heart, listened to the feedback, and decided to start over.

I'm coming back now with something new. I don't want to spend months writing again only to discover that my story is overwhelmingly dull or simply not enjoyable.

This is a short read of approximately 4,000 words, consisting of the prologue and the first two chapters. You will meet the protagonist and two of the main characters.

I'm interested in hearing what readers think.

  • Are the characters interesting?
  • How is the pacing?
  • Are the fight scenes enjoyable to read?
  • Does the worldbuilding intrigue you?
  • Would you want to read more?

Please feel free to provide any additional feedback. Constructive criticism is absolutely welcome.

I can share the manuscript through Google Docs.

About the novel:

The Beacon is a dark fantasy adventure featuring ancient magic, unlikely companions, brutal combat, dark humor, and a world filled with dangerous creatures.

Content warning: Graphic violence, strong language, and threats of sexual violence.

Thanks in advance, friends!

Nick


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

90k [COMPLETE] [93,000] [Crossover Fantasy With Queer Themes] Behemoth of the Inverted Sun

1 Upvotes

Hello! I have just completed the third draft of my fantasy novel, Behemoth of the Inverted Sun, and I'm currently looking for beta readers to let me know whether the novel is working and how close you think it is to being publishable.

Behemoth of the Inverted Sun is a fantasy novel about a young man named Oliver who bonds with a powerful creature known as a titan. Though Oliver's titan gives him a path out of his dead-end life of poverty, it also represents a great danger. Titans are strictly the military's property, meaning that if Oliver's bond with his titan is discovered, he will be killed. With titan hunters lurking around Oliver's sleepy town of Eastisle, raising a titan in secret is far from easy.

As if that weren't enough, Oliver is also trying to sort out his feelings for the mysterious stranger, Raine, who gave him his titan.

The novel is a creature-bonding fantasy with a slow-burn M/M romance.

Please reach out to me if you're interested! I'm totally down for chapter swaps.