r/BetaReaders • • 18d ago

Discussion [Discussion] r/BetaReaders check-in series! Share how your WIP is going, or how your beta reading is going, ask questions, and connect with more writers and readers!

4 Upvotes

Hello r/BetaReaders!

Who else can’t believe it’s November already? It’s basically 2027 now

Here’s this month’s prompt in the spirit of voting season: what happens/happened when you have/had split beta reader reactions? Do you ask for their reasonings before going with your gut decision or do you wait before implementing things? Or do you see if each beta view has a point and revise accordingly?


Welcome to our 11th monthly check-in thread!

These monthly pinned post aims to help the community connect with other writers and betas!

Share how your WIP is going, or how your current beta read is going, or other relatable beta reading topics in this thread!

This is a great thread to talk about writing, updates, accountability, trends, vents, and more.

It is not the right thread to post first pages as there’s another pinned thread for that, but you can link to your beta post if you wish.

Do NOT advertise any beta/editor services here, and no free samples to later ask for payment are allowed. You can try r/hireaneditor or r/freelance_forhire instead.

We also ask that self promotion of completed works do not contain links. Mentioning success is completely fine!

And we’d like to take this opportunity to remind people that works generated with AI, and AI-generated feedback is not allowed here, either. r/writingwithAI or r/betareadersforAI are better subreddits for that.

And because scammers are now targeting GDocs: please DM them and not leave them up on the sub publicly to avoid harassment

I’d also like to note that we have additional flairs available to help people know what specialty you have: traditional publishing, self-publishing, and fanfic. Please consider using them to help people match with you.

Also, it’s best to subscribe to our sub before commenting or posting to help avoid Reddit’s filters sending your content into the spam queue

Please ensure you comment in good faith and do not break any other r/betareaders rules.

Thank you, and happy writing/reading/editing/beta matching!


r/BetaReaders • • Oct 07 '26

Meta [Meta] Please review our subreddit’s resources on the sidebar and wiki to help with your posts here

15 Upvotes

For extra accessibility and convenience, r/betareaders is pinning this post with a link to the wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/wiki/index/

Additionally, you may find these comprehensive resources helpful in creating your own blurb or synopsis

If you are aiming for traditional publishing or self publishing, writing a query letter blurb will not only help tell potential betas what they can expect, but they also show you the core components of your story upfront and often helps with DIY revision

Many people prefer detailed information to help them decide on taking on a beta read, but the subreddit currently strictly enforces 2 key pieces of information in posts as some people want more privacy and will DM them to respondents

Please do take note of r/betareaders rules, which are found on the sidebar to the right, and are also expanded on in the wiki. The sidebar also has clickable links to templates that give suggestions for information beta readers would like to know before responding. The less you provide, the less enticing your post is. Conversely, extremely long posts also reduce likelihood in responses

And again, this is a fully free subreddit that does not permit services or requests for money in any form. It is also anti-AI generated works and pro-human

The wiki will have minor updates in future, and so will the comprehensive resources linked

Best wishes for your writing, revising, and beta reading!


r/BetaReaders • • 1h ago

Novella [Complete] [21K] [Horror] Willy's Wonderland fanfic

• Upvotes

Hi,

I've never asked for a beta reader from strangers before. Please let me know if I'm posting incorrectly. This is a fanfiction based off Willy's Wonderland. It has Liv and The Janitor, plus three original characters. I'd say it's a cross between the original and saw if the killer dude used possessed items to slash-mayem-murder. I need to do another edit so it's close to polished, but I'm sure you'll have to forgive some typos and grammars. Gotta get to the finer sandpaper to polish her up good!

Anywho, if anyone's interested, please hit me up in my DM. Let me know if you want a Google doc link or a PDF and where to send said PDF. It is rated R because being a horror, there is a lot of violence.

Summary: Months after Willy’s Wonderland, the silent Janitor and Liv hunt possessed objects. In Louisiana, they are lured into a serial killer’s “million-dollar maze” warehouse that traps victims, and must survive his the night against his possessed collection.


r/BetaReaders • • 5h ago

Short Story [In progress] [3400] [Techno-thriller] First chapter of my novel

2 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm looking for a few beta readers for the opening chapter of a techno-thriller / military-action novel. Honest reactions would be appreciated.

Blurb: Klaus Berger, a socially awkward scientist, is stuck at a secret research facility at 3 a.m. after a lab accident. When a power cut and some failing lights don't add up, he and the facility's aging security guard realize something is very wrong outside, and it's closing in.

Chapter 1 only, about 3400 words

- Does the opening hook you, or did you lose interest anywhere? Where?

- Was anything confusing, especially the logic of what's happening with the power and the radios?

- Do Klaus and Johann feel like real people?

- Does the ending land? Would you want to read chapter two?

Content note: gunfire, explosions, a graphic medical emergency, and strong language.

Contact me if you want to take a look!

Thanks so much for reading! EDIT: Swap your manuscripts with me in my DMs! I would like to read some too!


r/BetaReaders • • 9h ago

90k [Complete][99K][Urban Romantasy] Restoration

3 Upvotes

Hello,

I am seeking beta readers for my first novel. I am also open to writing swaps of similar genres (fantasy, romance, sci-fi, fiction, etc.). Overall, I hope to build long-term connections with my readers as I prepare this book for its final drafts (currently in 4th draft). I already have book 2 drafted as well, and book 3 is underway.

Furthermore, agreeing to be a beta reader or to swap manuscripts does not mean I expect you to read the entire book- I will start by sharing the first few chapters as a 'vibe check'. If you aren't feeling it or aren't engaged with the story, no worries! If you love it and are dying for more (or you see the potential), I can then provide the full manuscript.

Tropes/subjects: He falls first, witty banter, fated mates, werewolves (but not your usual werewolf lore.), found family, underlying mystery and intrigue.

Now for the quick and dirty summary:

Restoration is the first book in a three part urban-fantasy series that presents a reality living outside the bounds of science.
Our story follows Dr. Guinevere Cole, a surgeon who is struggling to break her cycle of grief after the death of her Fiancee. At least, that is the excuse she uses to justify the risk she is taking when she goes undercover at Lindhoff Laboratories to protect the secrets of her fiancee's people- The Voltaine.
The Voltaine, simply put, are a magical, wolven shape-shifters created by the goddess Morgana to serve as her warriors and agents of change upon earth.
With suspicious circumstances surrounding her Fiancee's death, as well as the reported disappearance of a young Voltaine woman, Guinevere tirelessly works to access the shadowed 'Valencia Project'.
Along the way, she meets Drake Callanach, a son of the Voltaine leader. Together, they work to destabilize the shadowed projects at Lindhoff Laboratories; all while working through past hurts and fighting the feelings that neither can bear to acknowledge.

If you are interested in giving this a read, please shoot me a DM and we can exchange email addresses.

- Please include if you have beta, alpha, or ARC reading experience.

- Please include if you are interested in a swap.

* I promise my actual writing is better than my silly lil' synopsis


r/BetaReaders • • 5h ago

60k [Complete] [64K] [Literary Espionage Thriller] Carry What Is Given

0 Upvotes

No Clay McCoy is a credit officer at a Boston bank, and for eight years he has been the most forgettable man in it. He is also a member of the Minutemen, a secret organization whose one rule was set in type by a Massachusetts printer on the night before Lexington: know one hand before you and one hand behind, and no more.

When the notice comes, Clay is sent to Miami under another name to enroll in the seminar of Professor Marisol Quintero, a warm, brilliant historian whose scholarship program has a pattern that nobody has been able to explain. His instructions are to watch, to learn, and to carry what he is given. What he finds is a trail of money that starts at a post office box in Florida and ends at a door in the United States Senate, and a group of students who trust him.

A slow-burn espionage novel in the tradition of le Carré, about institutions that last because their members never ask why, and what one honest man owes the people he uses.

Details
- Status: complete, revised draft
- Length: about 64,000 words (Prologue, 19 chapters, Epilogue)
- Genre: literary espionage thriller, contemporary setting, single close POV

Excerpt (Prologue, opening)

Nathaniel Thorne had been a printer for thirty-one years, and in that time he had learned two things about men who came to the door after dark. The first was that they never wanted what they said they wanted. The second was that they were always in a hurry, and that the hurry was usually the only honest thing about them.

The man who knocked a little before midnight said he wanted a ream of foolscap. He said it twice, the second time louder, as if the words had been given to him on a card and he feared the card was being read aloud. He was young, wet to the knees, and plainly frightened. Thorne let him in, shut the door, and waited for whatever he had really come for.

"The forme is locked," the young man said, and then, since Thorne said nothing, "The forme is locked and the type is cold."

It was not a good phrase. Thorne would remember afterwards that he had thought so at the time, that whoever devised it had never worked in a shop, because a forme was locked before it was inked and type was never cold, only clean or dirty.

Content warnings
Violence (the aftermath of a fatal shooting is shown, not the act), the death of a young character, grief, emotional manipulation and deception, and a brief moment of angry self-injury (a character punches a wall).

Feedback I'm looking for
- Whether the opening chapters hook you, and where you start to lose interest, if you do.
- Clarity: can you follow the money trail and who is working for whom without notes?
- Pacing and prose density. I am aiming for a le Carré-style register, and I want to know where it becomes heavy for a general reader.
- Characters: do you believe the relationship between Clay and the students, and does the ending land emotionally?

A full read is ideal, but notes on just the first few chapters would also help. Honest, specific criticism is more useful to me than encouragement.

Timeline
No hard deadline. Feedback within three to four weeks would be ideal.

Critique swap
Happy to swap if you would like to trade manuscripts. Please comment or message me with your genre and word count.

The manuscript is available as an EPUB or a Google Doc. Message me and I will send whichever you prefer.


r/BetaReaders • • 6h ago

70k [Complete] [72k] [YA Sci-Fi] "The Galaxy's Last Defenders"

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am once more looking for beta readers for my YA sci-fi novel! After working on and off of this book for three years, and a few rounds of beta readers, I am looking for more beta readers as I (hopefully) get closer to querying.

"The Galaxy's Last Defenders" is a novel about a group of humans stranded in space who get recruited by an alien to stop her father from conquering the galaxy.

Blurb: Emperor Vanof's reign spread through the galaxy like deadly vines. His army was the strongest in the galaxy and anyone who tried to resist was swiftly eliminated. After years of futile resistance, hope appeared in the form of five people: a soldier who escaped from Vanof, a once esteemed commander turned murderer, two space pirates with a messy history, and a girl oblivious to the danger Vanof poses. With the promise of money and a way home, this group of five is willing to defeat Vanof and save the galaxy.

"The Galaxy's Last Defenders" is a 72,776 word YA sci-fi novel inspired by Marvel's "Guardians of the Galaxy" and M.K. England's "The Disasters." Featuring a diverse cast of characters, the book focuses on themes of imperialism, rebellion, and found family.

I'd like help with:

-Story flow, plot holes, and attention grabbing (especially in the first 50 pages)

- Character development and relationships (if they're realistic or not, the romance between two of my characters, and anything I could do to improve them)

- Grammar and sentence structure

Deadline: Preferably before the end of the year or in the beginning of January

I would be open to a swap of a book around the same length as my novel. Please contact me if you are interested!


r/BetaReaders • • 6h ago

Novelette [In progress] [10k] [Cosy (might change later on)] Someone buys a blanket which then turns out to be sentient and can fold itself into anything.

1 Upvotes

Some details may be subject to change

Setting: UK (during or after Covid)

Introduction: 19 year old Callum Campbell, black/mixed race orphaned and questioning his religion, is at uni studying zoology to pursue his interest in wolves which originated from when he was given a stuffed toy wolf as a toddler who he named Wolfie. After he lost Wolfie on a school trip, he developed a craving for anything remotely soft and huggable like Wolfie as a coping mechanism, which leads us up to now.

Main story: Callum buys a massive throw blanket which he later discovers is alive and can fold itself into any shape or form, most commonly that of an anthropomorphic wolf in accordance with Callum's passions, hence its/his name, Blankanine (blanket + canine). The two bond over time as Blankanine gains/discovers new magical abilities of his, such as turning into a sofa or bed as well as trying out different human things such as taking a bath. Ideas for a main story include Callum introducing his girlfriend/closest human friend (who we'll call Imogen) to Blankanine, and Blankanine being hunted down by some nefarious secret organisation.

Ending: Blankanine turns Callum's dorm bed into a magical wolf-themed king-size bed as a thank you and goodbye present for graduation before the two separate to follow their own destinies.

Epilogue: Callum is now in his mid 20s or older and has since achieved his dream job of taking care of real wolves at a wildlife conservation centre. Blankanine manages to show up at Callum's house, meeting him for the first time since separating at graduation. There he presents Wolfie, Callum's long-lost cuddly toy wolf from his childhood, having been found miraculously spotless or with a bit of wear and tear or magically repaired by Blankanine beforehand to look good as new.

*What I'm looking for:*

  • Overall critique of concept and existing plot.
  • Additional ideas for main plots and how to flesh them and my existing ideas out.
  • How to accurately portray Callum as an orphan and/or someone questioning his faith plus other such characteristics (even if the aforementioned may be removed at some point).
  • (For UK betas) Corrections of any vocabulary, etc that's inaccurate for the UK (depending on region) such as if one of the characters said "couch" instead of "sofa" plus suggesting anything from your region you think is appropriate.

r/BetaReaders • • 10h ago

40k [Complete] [46000] [Nonfiction/Self Help] Shadow Mechanics: A Book About Self Awareness, Shadow Psychology, and Breaking Patterns — Seeking Beta Readers

1 Upvotes

I've spent a lot of time thinking about why people do things they know aren't good for them, why we repeat behaviors we swear we're done with, and why understanding our own bullshit doesn't necessarily stop us from participating in it.

That eventually turned into a book called Shadow Mechanics.

The idea started with a pretty simple question:

What happens when you understand exactly why you behave a certain way, but you keep doing it anyway?

We talk a lot about self-awareness, healing, personal growth, and becoming better versions of ourselves. But I've noticed something interesting: sometimes we become so good at explaining our behavior that those explanations become the very things protecting us from changing it.

We know why we're angry. We know why we push people away. We recognize our insecurities, our need for validation, and the patterns that keep showing up in our relationships.

And yet, there we are. Doing the same damn thing again.

Shadow Mechanics explores that uncomfortable space between understanding ourselves and actually changing our behavior.

It draws from shadow psychology, human behavior, emotional accountability, and the everyday contradictions that make us human.

But I didn't want to write another self-help book that reads like a psychology textbook or tells people to meditate, journal, and magically become enlightened.

I wanted to write something that feels like sitting across from someone having a conversation about the things we usually avoid admitting, including to ourselves.

Sometimes serious. Sometimes uncomfortable. Occasionally funny. And hopefully the kind of book that makes you stop reading for a second and think, "Well, shit. I do that."

The central philosophy is:

"Nothing within me is denied. Nothing within me rules me."

The manuscript is complete, and I'm looking for a handful of beta readers willing to give it an honest read before I move toward publication.

I'm not looking for people to tell me it's amazing. I'm looking for people who will tell me:

  • Did it actually hold your attention?
  • Were there moments where you recognized yourself?
  • Did anything feel repetitive, preachy, or unnecessarily complicated?
  • Were there sections you wanted to skip?
  • Did it challenge the way you think about your own behavior?
  • Most importantly, did you walk away with something you could actually use?

You don't need a psychology background. In fact, I'd really like perspectives from everyday readers who are interested in personal growth but are tired of self-help books that promise to fix their lives in five easy steps.

I'm particularly interested in whether this feels like a book you'd genuinely want to finish, rather than one you feel like you should finish.

If this sounds interesting, leave a comment or send me a message. I'd be happy to share more about the book and what beta reading would involve.

And even if you're not interested in beta reading, I'm curious:

Do you think understanding why you do something is enough to change it, or have we gotten really good at using self-awareness as another excuse?


r/BetaReaders • • 11h ago

40k [Complete] [40k] [Romance] The Weight of Small Wings

1 Upvotes

[Beta readers wanted] Sapphic age-gap romance novella (~40k)

Hi all — I'm working on my next novel, a sapphic romance novella called
The Weight of Small Wings (~40,000 words). Maggie is 67, a retired field
biologist (dragonflies) pushed out of her university job; Hallie is 37, and
their slow-burn relationship unfolds against wetland fieldwork, small-town
politics, and a legal fight in the back third. Hard-won HEA.

Full disclosure: I'm a bi-man writing my first sapphic romance, which is exactly
why I'm here before this goes anywhere — I want readers from the community to
tell me what rings true and what doesn't.

What I'm hoping you'll weigh in on: do Maggie and Hallie feel like a real
couple; does Maggie keep her agency (this matters a lot to me — no rescuing);
does the 30-year age gap and the power balance work; does the tenderness and
consent land; anything that rings false.

Heat level: sweet — tender rather than explicit. Content notes: grief (death
of parents), a courtroom/legal plotline, a health scare (AFib episode) in the
back third.

Timeline: ~40k words, hoping for feedback within 3 weeks. Happy to return the
favor on your manuscript. Word doc or PDF, your choice — DM ifinterested.

Thank you!

[Excerpt:]

The silence was replaced by a rhythmic, mechanical hum and the sharp, clinical tang of rubbing alcohol. Maggie opened her eyes to a ceiling of white tiles, one of which was slightly yellowed at the corner. She tried to sit up, but a hand—firm and unexpectedly warm—pressed gently against her shoulder. The sensation was an intrusion, a violation of the solitude she had spent months cultivating.

"Easy now, Dr. Kline. You've had quite a tumble."

Maggie blinked, her vision clearing to reveal a woman standing over her. The woman had warm, intelligent eyes and a face that Maggie struggled to categorize. It was the beard that stopped her—a thick, neatly trimmed auburn beard that followed the line of a strong jaw. It was soft-looking, well-maintained, and utterly incongruous with the white medical coat and the stethoscope draped around the woman's neck.

Maggie's mind, usually so quick to label and file, stuttered. "You're... the doctor?" Maggie asked, her voice cracking. She hated the sound of it, the way it betrayed her vulnerability.

The woman smiled, a small, pragmatic movement that made the hair of her beard shift. "I'm Dr. Hallie Roan. You're in my clinic. Some birdwatchers found you near the edge of the swamp and had enough sense to call for help. You were severely dehydrated, and your heart was doing some very creative things with its rhythm."

Maggie looked away, focusing on a poster on the wall detailing the symptoms of hypertension. The humiliation was a physical heat in her chest, sharper than the swamp sun. To be found like a specimen, tossed into the back of a vehicle, and brought to a struggling rural clinic was a sequence of events she found intolerable. And the doctor—the Bearded Angel, as she vaguely recalled hearing some of the locals whisper at the bait shop—was watching her with a level of scrutiny that made Maggie feel pinned to the exam table.

"I don't need a nursemaid," Maggie said, her voice regaining some of its academic steel. "I need my specimen bag. Where is it?"

"It's right here," Hallie said, gesturing to the floor where the bag sat, still stained with swamp mud. "Everything is intact. Though I suspect the insects you were looking for have better sense than to be out in a hundred-degree heat without water."

Maggie's eyes snapped back to the doctor. The comment was direct, almost dry, and it lacked the condescending pity Maggie had come to expect from people her own age. She looked at the doctor's boots—utilitarian leather caked with the same Georgia mud that now stained Maggie's field trousers. This doctor wasn't just a practitioner; she was someone who moved through the same landscape, someone who understood the physical cost of the swamp.


r/BetaReaders • • 13h ago

40k [Complete] [42k] [Upper MG / Literary Speculative] So Much Better

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone—I'm looking for 2–3 beta readers for my complete upper middle grade / literary speculative novel, So Much Better (~42,000 words, 14 chapters, fast read).
On an isolated island, everyone believes the underground Blaze takes away grief and makes people whole. After thirteen-year-old Wren’s mother goes down to the cavern, she comes back calm, smiling, and serene—just like the rest of the choir. Only Wren notices what is missing: the wrong words in an old song, her forgotten hatred of honey, her crooked stitches smoothed straight, and a memory of a bird they watched together that she can no longer find. With a failing boatmaker hiding an unfinished escape and the island counting down the days until Wren takes his own white robe, Wren has to decide what remembering is worth when everyone around him calls forgetting peace.
Vibe / comps: Quiet, atmospheric speculative fiction in the vein of The Giver and The Girl Who Drank the Moon—spare literary voice, slow-burn unease, zero gore.
Content notes: Grief, loss of a parent’s memory/identity, subtle cult-like conformity. No graphic violence or profanity.
What I'm looking for: Honest big-picture reader reactions (voice, pacing, clarity, and how the ending lands)—no copy-editing or grammar hunting needed. There are 7 short questions at the very back of the file to look at after you finish. Ideally looking for a 2-week turnaround, and happy to do a swap of similar length if you're looking for eyes on your draft too.
Comment or DM if interested and I'll send over a clean Word copy or Google Doc!


r/BetaReaders • • 13h ago

Novella [Complete] [24k][Memoir-Vignette] What You Make of Me NSFW

1 Upvotes

Hello Reddit.

I am looking for beta readers for a novella I have completed.

The story's of the lives lost in the sex work industry are plentiful. But, what if someone actually found life in the industry? What if they went in with that as the goal? This novella is an autobiographical memoir-vignette about a woman who, after years of denial, became her true self while working in the industry. While some stories center around glitz and glamour, or the horror and regret of being in the industry, this story has none. Instead this journey is filled with self-realizations about worth, navigating dark places, and coming out the other side with love for herself and others, regardless of what social narratives say.

Please be advised if you are looking for erotic writings and bedside thrills, this story has almost none of that. Although it does have scenes of internal experiences of rape.

The type of feedback I'm looking for is comprehension. I am dyslexic so, on top of resonance and digestibility, structure and grammar are things I am open to. This novella has been reviewed and edited by someone from my fringe social circle, who majored in English.

Ideal timeline: 5 weeks.

Please DM me if this seems like something you'd be willing to read.


r/BetaReaders • • 14h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [264] [Dark Fantasy] Looking for first impressions on a short excerpt

0 Upvotes

I'm looking for someone who enjoys fantasy and would be willing to read a short excerpt from my work in progress.

I'm mainly interested in your honest first impression.

Does the story sound interesting? Does it make you curious about what happens next? Would you want to keep reading?

I'm not looking for a detailed critique. Just a genuine reader's opinion would mean a lot to me.

If you're interested, please send me a DM, and I'll share the excerpt privately.

Thank you for your time!

M. H.


r/BetaReaders • • 21h ago

Short Story [Complete] [5000] [Short Story (Dark Fantasy/Speculative Fiction)] Trauma and Transformation

3 Upvotes

Hello, I'm seeking some beta readers for my short story: Trauma and Transformation.

Content Warning

Some graphic description of gore

Genre

Dark fantasy (fairy-tale retelling)/Speculative fiction

Format

Google Docs

Length

Nearly 5000 words

What it's About

It's a Little Red Riding Hood retelling about the destruction of her humanity after a violent attack by the wolf. I primarily want to explore the destruction of a person's humanity. I apologize if this premise sounds a bit vague, but I think it's easier to understand if you read the story.

Preferred Type of Feedback

I hope to find out about your thoughts on the general story and Red's actions throughout it. Mainly, I want to see if you think they make sense. Your thoughts on my prose would also be invaluable.

Preferred Timeline

Within 7 days of receiving the story.

Excerpt

The streets clamored, showcasing the most prosperous side of the village, Red’s village. Those were innocent times, times devoid of the taint of reality. A younger Red — often described by her relatives as a “cute little wanderer” — strode between the towering men and women, fingers pale from her tight grip on a basket containing some hot food and medicine. She had big brown eyes which always looked lost as they darted from one side to another. Her pale face was dotted with patches of light-gray freckles, and her physique was chubbier than other girls her age, making her look stronger and more mature. The overwhelming spectacles in the market exemplified the flourishing trade that took place there. Visually, pops of color interspersed the overall dull brown of the dirt road and the unassuming clothes of those who were walking on it. The chaotic cacophony wasn’t merely the hoarse shouting of the merchants, less noticeable sounds such as the clink of coins, the groan of the wagon’s axle, or the clack of hooves impacting the ground mixed with each other also contributed to the ruckus. Finally, being a place where people primarily traded food, alluring smells of perfume, flowers, and fresh meals blended with the fetid odor of raw meat from the butcher, leaving a weird, pungent aroma in your nose. Red was now in the square — arguably the most crowded area of the entire market, where the masses acted less like individual human beings, but more like a viscous human soup. With the sheer number of people here, those who went in the opposite direction of the crowds would soon find themselves nudged in the opposite direction of where they meant to go. The noise leading up to the square was merely a buildup, here was the final climax, the crescendo before everything would go silent. Technically, Red didn’t need to pass through the market and the square, but at least she felt safe here, although that was in exchange for a different kind of apprehension than if she were to take the short alleyways. At Red’s eye height, she normally only saw the browns, indigos, and grays of people’s legwear and their scuttling movements. So, when a pair of brilliant amber eyes flickered in between the moving crowd, Red immediately noticed. That pair of eyes, upon closer inspection, belonged to a large gray dog. Covered in grizzly rough fur over its thin limbs, it had also noticed Red, and in that moment, something clicked between them. A recognition, an understanding, an agreement, Red wasn’t so sure.

If you've read this far, thank you for considering my short story.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

>100k [Complete][121k][Epic Fantasy / Medieval Fantasy] The Ascendents

3 Upvotes

Hey! I'm looking for beta readers (honestly new to this idea, just heard of it this week by a publisher) for my debut fantasy novel (hopes for it to be a series). I'm hoping to get specific feedback over thoughts on pacing and attachment to characters, but also general thoughts and feelings! It's a book I had thoughts of writing for twelve years, but recently actually decided to go for it and grinded it out in four months. It has not been completely edited yet, but some parts have been checked over. (I know this community is likely safe, but do want to preface that I have an official copyright over this work via publishers, so legal action will be taken if this work is stolen... I doubt it happens, but I was told to preface!) Here is the story:
The story follows Aveline, a younger woman who finds herself in the town of Fairhaven with no recollection of her past or any memories tied to it. With little more than a name and people who quickly take her in, she has no idea how she ended up there or why. Despite knowing nothing about herself, though, she finds herself coming into a position of power and something she never could have expected - a home, friends, and some people who begin to become family.
The world beyond Fairhaven, however, had other plans.
That life, however, it just the beginning. As Aveline and others venture beyond those four walls to investigate ruins of ancient civilizations, she begins to experience memories of someone she never knew. She quickly becomes entangled inside the history of the Ascendents: divine and ancient beings whose influence shaped the world for years and years. Visions of a woman named Elowen, conflicting stories, and fragments of evidence start to raise questions about Aveline's own existence that she can't escape. Political conflict, supernatural threats, and the remnants of divine power draw her into a world where the responsibilities placed upon her are far greater than anything she imagined - and when someone she cares deeply about becomes trapped in a realm beyond their reach, finding a way to bring him home becomes one of the questions she refuses to leave unanswered. As Aveline's understanding of the world and herself changes, so does the complicated feelings between her and someone who has his own reasons to keep others at a distance.

At its heart, Ascendents is a story that highlights the idea of understanding who you are when you don't know where you came from, what you owe to those around you, and how much you can give without losing sight of who you aim to be.


r/BetaReaders • • 18h ago

70k [Complete] [76k] [Gothic Fantasy] The Winter Between Us, final round before release

1 Upvotes

Hi all, I posted here a while back, and the book’s come a long way since. It’s done now and I’m putting the ebook out soon, so I’m looking for a few readers for one last pass.

It’s four linked novellas that turn into one story. A weaver married off to a Fae lord, two rival scholars in a drowned city, a demon walking into hell to fetch a professor, and a vault that should’ve stayed shut. It’s gothic and slow-burn, with some dark humour.

Need to know:

  • anywhere you got bored or lost
  • characters you didn’t get
  • typos and clunky lines, honestly anything

Happy to swap if you’ve got something you need read. Timeline’s about 3–4 weeks but there’s no pressure. Just DM me.


r/BetaReaders • • 20h ago

90k [In Progress] [90k] [Romance] Are You Alone?

1 Upvotes

Hey hey!

I'm looking for a few readers willing to take a look at the first chapter of my novel, Are You Alone?, a character-driven romance with darker themes throughout.

A little about the story:

Sabrina spends most of her time with family or alone, and she's perfectly content with that. But after meeting two of her neighbours, the life she's grown comfortable with begins to change in ways she never could have anticipated.

I'm hoping to get some fresh eyes on Chapter 1 (1.8k words) and would really appreciate any honest impressions! I'm particularly interested in whether the opening draws you in, how you feel about the writing and characters, and, most importantly, whether you'd genuinely want to keep reading.

I'm not looking for line edits or proofreading at this stage, just your natural reactions as a reader. Constructive criticism is very welcome!

If anyone's interested, please leave a comment or send me a message, and I'll happily share the chapter.

Thank you!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

90k [Complete][96k][Adult Fantasy Romance] Queen of Spades

3 Upvotes

Hello Reddit!

I'm looking for a group of beta readers for Queen of Spades, a dual POV adult fantasy romance, complete at 96k words. It has undergone three revisions and needs a fresh set of eyes to strengthen it further. I'm open to both betas and swaps - see below for a blurb and details.

Blurb:

Bryn has lived his whole life defying the odds. Born in the slums and raised playing poker, he beats the fae at their own game, using magic he should not possess. When Bryn wins the Hymere, the city's biggest poker tournament, he finally has enough money to support himself and his ailing father.

But Serevine Riordane, heir to the throne, needs him to secure her crown. In light of his victory, she offers him a partnership – his secret to winning the Hymere in exchange for a life of wealth and comfort. Under the guise of an investigation, Serevine and Bryn uncover each other's secrets, but a plot for the crown is brewing within the castle. When murder strikes and Serevine’s allies start dying around her, she must work with Bryn to bring the killer to justice before they lose everything they’ve worked for.

Forced to navigate growing political strife and desire for one another, Bryn and Serevine must choose between his dream, her crown, and their loyalty to each other.

Born somewhere between ACOTAR and Molly’s Game, Queen of Spades will appeal to readers who enjoy a competitive romance, poker, murder mystery/investigation subplots, and political intrigue.

Note: This story is ADULT. It contains open-door romance, family illness, death, and violence.

What I'm looking for:

  • Pacing: Where were you bored? What scenes felt exciting?
  • Characters: Who are you rooting for and against? Are their choices believable?
  • Plot: Does the sequence of events make sense? Does anything feel rushed or too slow? Are there plot holes or inconsistencies?
  • General: What works for you in the story? What doesn't?
  • Other: Spur-of-the-moment reactions to the story (I enjoy reading in-line comments and thoughts, even if they aren't constructive)

I'm not looking for line edits or proofreading, but I appreciate being notified of anything that breaks your immersion in the story (Metaphores that don't work, confusing imagery, etc.).

If you use AI to beta read or write your manuscript for you, we're not going to be a good fit.

About me:

I'm a good fit for swaps with fantasy, romantasy, or romance novels. Queen of Spades is my seventh completed manuscript and is a standalone with series potential. Some recent reads of mine are Spark of the Everflame, The Priory of the Orange Tree, and Crown Me Dead.

If you're interested in beta reading or doing a swap, shoot me a DM, and I can send/trade my first 3 chapters to see if we'd be a good fit. If you'd like to continue reading, we can discuss a timeline and coordinate a full swap. I fully endorse constructive criticism on my work and the work of others.

Thank you!


r/BetaReaders • • 23h ago

Novella [Complete] [27K] [Philosophical Fantasy] Oh Death

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m super excited!

Here’s the short summary!

When Dante Simmons dies, he meets Death.

But Death is not what he expected.

Through a journey into the memories of his life, Dante is confronted with the choices he made, the people he loved, the suffering he endured, and questions about existence that may have no simple answers.
Oh, Death is a philosophical fantasy novella exploring mortality, consciousness, love, suffering, and what it means to have lived.

If interested, please comment below or send me a DM. Let me know what genres you typically enjoy reading.

Thank you!

Excerpt:

I died on a Friday. I died lying in a hospital bed, looking frail and weak. A shallow husk of the man I was. My wife sobbed beside me. My son did his best to be stoic. My daughter was too young to understand that her daddy wasn’t going to wake up from his rest.

I stood there in the hospital room watching the scene unfold. I felt awful.

Not physically, of course. That was the strange part. For the first time in a year, nothing hurt. No pounding headaches, no nausea, no aching joints. I could breathe without feeling as though someone had wrapped a belt around my chest and pulled it tight.

I felt better than I had in months.
Which seemed like a particularly cruel joke, considering the circumstances.
My wife held my hand against her cheek. She was saying something, but I couldn’t make out the words over the steady beeping of the machines. My son stood on the opposite side of the bed, his jaw clenched and his eyes fixed on the floor.
He was trying so hard not to cry.

I wanted to tell him it was okay. That he didn’t have to be strong for anyone.

Especially not for me.

I moved toward him and reached for his shoulder.

My hand passed straight through.

I stared at it.

“Well, that’s new.”


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

>100k [Complete] [160k] [Epic High Fantasy Romance] Queens of Chaos

1 Upvotes

Seeking Beta Readers for Epic/High Fantasy Romance and open to swaps!

Hey fantasy romance lovers!

I’m looking for beta readers for Queens of Chaos, the first book of the Slain Gods trilogy. Told through a dual, first-person POV, it features a completed romantic/character/thematic arc with partial story resolution. The series beats are already planned, and I'm currently drafting book two now.

Blurb:

Every Feln-born knows the queen’s voice travels only through death.

Lysaithe is Feln-born, one of the first mortals to inhabit a land crafted by a long--slain goddess. Solitude comes naturally to Lysaithe, only leaving her father’s house for the books that drift into her seaside town from the subsequent lands. But after an unfamiliar bookseller slips her a mysterious tome, a rush of divine magic severs Lysaithe from her safe, hermit’s existence and blesses her well of magic with a voice to compel mortals and the responsibilities of a godholme queen.

At the palace overlooking town, Guard Tiram fears Queen Sostra’s unexplained end means his hard-won peace is over. A soldier from the bloodied, war-torn human lands, Tiram can’t return home. And when one look into the new queen's eyes halts the world, he knows he can't leave. But as he strains to remain unaffected by Lysaithe, a pixie from his past leaves a foreboding warning that resurfaces choking memories he’d thought buried.

Drawn together by the secrets they harbor, Lysaithe and Tiram discover solace in one another. But as a neighboring queen's visit seems to coincide with a series of confounding events, including the spread of a devastating blood fever from the human lands, Lysaithe must decide if she's brave enough to stand up for not only her people, but perhaps all mortal kind.

Feedback I’m looking for:

Overall, I’m interested in reader reactions to the text, with a focus on whether it compels you to continue.

  • Which moments made you care most about Lysaithe and Tiram (individually or together)?
  • Were there places where the magic or world felt confusing? Did it make you stop reading?
  • Where were you flying through the pages, and did any part feel slow?
  • Did anything surprise you? Did you guess any twists? Did those twists feel earned by either the character development or world building?
  • Did the ending make you want to pick up book two? What are you curious about next?

Critique swapping:

I’m open to swap manuscripts, and read pretty much all genres of romance, from historical to fantasy, sci-fi, contemporary. I also enjoy fantasy without romance.

If you you are intersted, please send me a DM. I am happy to share the first three chapters (14,200 words) first to seal you decision!

Thanks for your consideration. :)


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

60k [Complete] [62k] [Psychological Thriller] The Fat Friend - opening chapters for beta readers

3 Upvotes

The first time Kirsty saves Chantelle, she gives her somewhere to sit. The last time, she makes her brother's body disappear.

Chantelle is pretty but insecure. Kirsty is dismissed as the fat friend. She's the one who fights Chantelle's corner, lends her money, sorts out her mess. Now she's hidden a body for her. There are reasons not to trust Kirsty, but worse reasons to keep her close.

THE FAT FRIEND is my completed psychological thriller, around 62,000 words. A dark, twisty slow burn about a friendship turning poisonous, messy families and working-class life in Exeter in the early 2000s, before smartphones. For readers of Gillian Flynn and Lisa Jewell.

Looking for thriller readers to try the opening chapters. If you're hooked, I'll send the rest. I'd love honest reactions: do you believe the friendship, and what keeps you reading or makes you stop?

Content notes: violence, drug use and references to sexual assault.

Comment if you're interested and I'll DM you.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

70k [Complete] [71k] [Contemporary Romance] Off the Books — Seeking Volunteer Readers

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm looking for 3–5 volunteer readers for my completed contemporary romance novel, Off the Books.

Premise: Anthony Russo is a successful musician attempting to prove himself in a summer production of Hamlet. Olivia Thompson is a theater intern who tells him something nobody else will: his performance is technically perfect, but emotionally empty.

Their secret, unpaid coaching arrangement becomes something neither anticipated.

Genre: Adult contemporary romance
Length: Approximately 71,000 words
POV: Dual third-person
Romance: Slow burn, moderate spice, guaranteed HEA
Content notes: Domestic abuse, family trauma, and emotional manipulation

Feedback requested: I'm primarily interested in character development, pacing, emotional engagement, romantic chemistry, and whether the ending feels earned. I'm not looking for proofreading or line editing.

Timeline: Four weeks from receiving the manuscript.

Format: PDF or EPUB.

This is an unpaid, voluntary beta-reading opportunity. I'm not seeking paid editorial or beta-reading services at this time.

If the premise interests you, please comment or send me a message with your preferred format and a contemporary romance you've enjoyed recently.

I also welcome Beta Swapping! Have a book you want read, I am in.

Thank you!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

60k [Complete] [60K] [Psychological Suspense] Loyalty Isn't Grey

1 Upvotes

Beta readers wanted: Loyalty Isn’t Grey — psychological suspense with supernatural elements, ~60,000 words

I’m looking for another round of beta readers for a completed novel that has already been through substantial revisions. At this stage, I’m primarily interested in the reader experience: pacing, character development, places where motivations or relationships don’t feel earned, continuity problems, confusing sections, and anything that simply doesn’t work. I’m not looking for line editing yet.

Content Warnings: organized crime, drug/alcohol use, violence, murder, sexual assault, references to childhood sexual abuse, coercive/abusive relationships, and other mature themes.

Blurb

Eighteen-year-old Cameron Weiler has no idea what he's doing after high school. Then he dreams about a mysterious woman who tells him to find her. The search leads him and his twin brother, Caleb, to Miami. There, Cameron finally finds her—and the powerful man she works for.

Saint Jude offers Cameron money, influence, and a place in his world. At first, Cameron believes he can have everything: the life Jude offers, the woman who brought him there, and the brother who has always stood beside him.

As Cameron is drawn deeper into Saint Jude's world, he is forced to decide whether loyalty can be divided—or whether choosing one person means betraying another.

Excerpt

“I see.” Rei set their bowl down. “Cam, I’ve had fun also, but I’m not going to wait around to see if you ever pick anything over him. If you leave now, don’t ask me out again.”

Cameron just stood there. He really liked Rei, but also felt that he had an obligation to Saint Jude. He set his bowl down next to Rei’s and gave them a hug. He picked up his phone and left.

He practically ran to his dorm to change into a clean suit. 

Cameron spent the ride wondering if he’d made the right choice. They said not to ask them out again, but maybe he could do something to apologize. 

The car stopped in front of the club at 6:24

Cameron tipped the driver and hurried inside. The club was dead at this hour aside from a few people preparing for the evening. Nobody stopped him as he took the stairs to Saint Jude’s lounge.

Carlos met Cameron at the entrance. “How was your date with Rei?”

“How did you—”

Carlos grinned. “I am the head of security.”

Cameron’s stomach dropped as he considered what else Carlos might know.

Saint Jude’s voice pulled Cameron from his thoughts.

“There he is. Right on time.”

Saint Jude was standing by the bar. A small metal case sat on the bar, his hand on the top.

Cameron straightened his jacket, pleased that he had made it on time.

“Come here. I want you to see something.”

Saint Jude opened the case and pulled out a pistol. He verified that the chamber was empty and handed it to Cameron.

“Woah, man! I don't want that!” Cameron objected sharply, hoping Carlos would intervene.

“Just hold it,” Saint Jude said. He seemed unsurprised by Cameron’s reaction.

“Just hold it?” Cameron asked.

Saint Jude stepped closer, a slight grin crossing his face. “Yes. I don’t let just anybody touch it.”

For a moment, Cameron didn’t move, unsure if he was joking. Then he slowly reached out.

The cold metal of the pistol surprised him. He was used to the warm, wooden stock of a shotgun. He looked back up at Saint Jude. 

“You’ll get used to it. I promise. Can you shoot?” Saint Jude asked.

“I’ve shot one before, but I’m not very good,” Cameron replied.

“That’s fine. Carlos will teach you.”

Carlos walked over to Cameron and took the pistol from him. “Come with me,” Carlos said, then walked to the bar.

“I’m nobody’s babysitter,” Carlos said with resentment in his voice. He reached under the bar and pulled out a shoulder holster. Cameron took off his jacket and Carlos helped him put the holster on. 

“We start practice tomorrow. In the meantime, just get used to wearing this.” He handed Cameron the jacket and abruptly walked away, keeping the gun. 

Cameron wasn’t used to wearing a suit and could feel the slight tug of the holster under the jacket. It was uncomfortable, but he felt he didn’t have a choice.

“Nice to see you again,” Gabriel began, approaching. “I see you’ve been promoted.”

“I guess you could call it that,” Cameron said with a sigh.

“Man, he gave you a gun and a suit. You skyrocketed up.”

Cameron leaned over the bar. “You saw the gun?” he whispered.

“Saint Jude wasn’t exactly subtle about it,” Gabriel chuckled. 

“I didn’t really agree to carry it. It seems Saint Jude just wants me to practice. Carlos is going to teach me tomorrow.”

“If you say so, kid. Here’s his drink.” Gabriel handed Cameron a tumbler. “You want something stronger tonight, or you good?”

“I’m not old enough for that,” Cameron said.

“This is Saint Jude’s bar. It doesn’t matter how old you are. It didn't stop him from putting that gun in your hand, did it?”


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novelette [Complete] [10,000] [Narrative Nonfiction] Flowers from the Devil — one chapter on America's first opioid epidemic. Looking for a gut read, not line edits. Swap available.

1 Upvotes

I'm looking for one or two beta readers for a single chapter of a narrative history book.

The book: How the nineteenth-century morphine epidemic built the machinery of the American drug war — the laws, the bureaucracies, and the blame — decades before Nixon gave it a name. This chapter (1870–1905) follows Ella Henderson, a Seattle woman whose morphine addiction was reported in newspapers across the country, and traces how doctors who created addicts with the new hypodermic needle became the villains of the story.

If your shelf runs to Dreamland, Empire of Pain, Dopesick, or Chasing the Scream, this is the prequel to that shelf — and you're exactly the reader I need.

What I'm asking for — three questions only:

  1. Where did you get bored?
  2. Where did you get confused?
  3. Would you keep reading?

No line edits, no craft notes, no summary. Gut reaction from a reader of the genre is the whole point. I'm deliberately not sharing anything about myself — the pages have to stand on their own.

Timeline: Feedback by mid-December if possible (two to three weeks).

Swap: Happy to beta read a comparable amount of your work — nonfiction or fiction — on the same terms.

Content notes: Addiction and drug use throughout; a suicide and period newspaper accounts of violence; quoted historical sources contain period language, including racial terms, reproduced as written.

Comment or DM if you're interested — and tell me the last narrative nonfiction book you loved.


Excerpt — the opening of the chapter:

After the death of her father, a prominent Seattle hotel owner, Ella Henderson started taking morphine to ease her grief. She was thirty-three years old and, because of her education and intellect, frequented social circles "most exalted by her sex."

It was her "thirst for morphine," however, that "dragged her down to the verge of debauchery." Ella's story, first told by Seattle's The Daily Intelligencer in an 1877 article entitled "A Beautiful Opium Eater," circulated through the American and European press and exemplified the kind of story of addiction that pulled at the heartstrings of the average American.

Ella's doctor's wife, Mrs. Stone, took her into their home in hopes of "restoring her once more to her proper sphere." All efforts at rehabilitation failed, however, and Ella's concerned friends took her kids away from her. When deprived of her drugs, Ella would say "give me morphine, give me something that I may quench this terrible thirst, or let me die!"

The Intelligencer surmised that only the coldest of hearts could endure such suffering, which it claimed was so severe it could make an angel cry. Towards the end of her addiction, Ella secluded herself in her room and took morphine until she poisoned herself to death.

Ella Henderson was the kind of addict most often reported about in the late-nineteenth century press. She had been prescribed morphine by a trusted physician, enabled to continue its use by that same doctor, and then developed an addiction that ultimately led to her death.

That narrative captured the public's imagination. Not only did it highlight a threat to the middle-class home — one aimed at daughters, mothers, and grandmothers — but it also indicted the medical and pharmaceutical communities as culprits. Those professionals were increasingly portrayed as reckless by enterprising newspaper men. The publicizing of addicts such as Ella Henderson and the allegedly unscrupulous doctors that enabled her addiction pointed to a dramatic change in America's relationship with drugs.

The social and political reality of the period — and one that nurtured a widespread epidemic — is that in 1877 you could buy morphine over the counter at any druggist, order it by mail, find it in patent medicines on a general-store shelf — no prescription, no registry, no questions. The hypodermic syringe was sold just as freely, marketed to doctors and laypeople alike as modern self-care. The most powerful drug of the century had fewer controls on it than aspirin does now.

Ella's death from morphine addiction came at a watershed moment in the drug reform movement, which was gaining steam at the city and state level. It would still be twelve years after Ella's death before the first prescription-only law would pass — in San Francisco, 1889. That law, the most vigorous the nation had seen, only stated that the sale of opium, morphine, and cocaine would be banned except by pharmacies on doctor's orders. Oakland followed in 1890 with the same rule. It was newspaper accounts of deaths like Ella Henderson's that fed red meat to the grassroots drug reform movement.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

80k [Complete] [86.4k] [Urban Fantasy] Heart of Magic: Adrift at Night

3 Upvotes

A bit about my work:

Some form of this series has been lurking in my mind as early as 2012, with character ideas and plot moments floating around, but it wasn't until 2017/2018 that I really sat down and wrote out the first draft of Adrift at Night, usually while in between classes or waiting for my creative writing club to start. Since then I've written rough drafts for the first six books the series and I've decided to try and share my attempts to capture the lives of these crazy people living in my head. From slice of life moments and romance, to scheming crime syndicates and bloodthirsty vampires. In terms of content, they are roughly comparable to Illona Andrew's Kate Daniels books, or earlier seasons of Buffy, with the later novels growing to be more adult, perhaps closer to Leigh Bardugo's Ninth House or Patricia Brigg's Mercy Thompson (none of that book 3 stuff though, waay too much for me).

Before I start rambling too much, here's the blurb for Heart of Magic: Rosebriar: Adrift at Night

As a child, Kasey Chase dreamed of being a veterinarian or a doctor. Or, if she was really lucky she’d meet a prince or princess charming and be swept off her feet to live a dream fairytale life where everything was perfect.

She never thought her mother would become a part of the Dermail Syndicate and smuggle and distribute drugs. She never thought her father would became nothing more than an addict. And she never thought she’d come home one day to find them murdered—or that she might be adopted.

While on the run from the Dermail Syndicate, Kasey’s search for answers will reveal more to the world than she ever thought possible, that dark and dangerous things lurk in the night, that magic and monsters are real. And to get the answers she seeks, she’ll have to step foot into a conflict between forces she scarcely can believe are real, and wished they weren’t.

Content Warnings: Brief Addiction, Brief Drug Use, Graphic Death, Graphic Injury, Graphic Kidnapping, Mentions of Pregnancy, Childbirth, and Child Death, Brief Sexual Assault/Harassment, Mentions of Sexual Content.

Who I'm looking for:

First and foremost, someone that loves urban fantasy! Vampires, shifters, witches, fae, and demons are at the heart of this series. Religions and Mythologies with lots of liberties taken are also an important component to the series, the general idea here is that there is some truth to every religion/mythology but a lot has been distorted over time.

Another thing to keep in mind is that this is an LGBTQ+ friendly series with several characters *eventually* ending up in queer relationships, however romance is not the main driving focus of the series, and nothing really starts happening in the first few books.

What I'm looking for:

Big picture things such as characterization, overall plot, confusing moments, things you enjoyed. I am not looking for line edits or proofreading, (although if you find something that bugs you feel free to mark it!).

I'm looking for 2-3 people, and I'm happy to do a swap. As for time frame, I'd prefer 4-8 weeks, although with it being holiday season I understand if someone might need more time. I'd like to start with the first three chapters to make sure we're a good match. Anyways, thank you for taking the time to read all this gibberish!