Hey everyone!
Hoping to pick a few brains here!
A friend and I run a D&D podcast called Welcome 2 Rule of Cool. We chat about D&D, geek culture, nostalgia and generally try to show that D&D players come from all walks of life.
At the end of each episode, we do a little segment called Rule of Cool Rule of the Week, where we share a homebrew rule we've either stumbled across online or used at our own tables. It's actually become quite a popular part of the show amongst our listeners.
We're now thinking about introducing another segment, a bit like AITA, but for D&D!
Basically, those moments at the table where everyone has a different opinion on what should happen, who's in the right, or whether the DM made the correct call.
For example, we've got a long-running debate at our table involving two Tortles. One retreats into his shell, and the other launches him from a height, Super Mario style, straight at an enemy.
The question: Who gets credit for the kill? The Tortle who launched him, or the one who became a living cannonball?
It's the sort of ridiculous argument we absolutely love getting into, especially when neither of us is willing to back down!
So I thought I'd ask, what are some of the funniest, most controversial or downright ridiculous rulings you've had at your tables?
Would anyone be interested in a segment where we debate these sorts of situations and give our completely unofficial verdicts?
And if you've got a good story you'd be happy for us to discuss on the podcast, please share it! We'd obviously give you a shoutout if we featured it.